Iowa Case Commentaries

Requirement for Explicit Reasoning in Consecutive Sentencing: Insights from STATE of Iowa v. Donald James Hill

Date: Apr 23, 2016

Requirement for Explicit Reasoning in Consecutive Sentencing: Insights from STATE of Iowa v. Donald James Hill Introduction The Supreme Court of Iowa, in STATE of Iowa v. Donald James Hill (878...

Guilty Pleas and Wrongful Imprisonment: The Rhoades v. State Decision

Date: Apr 16, 2016

Guilty Pleas and Wrongful Imprisonment: The Rhoades v. State Decision Introduction Rhoades v. State, 880 N.W.2d 431, is a landmark case adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Iowa on April 15, 2016. The...

Right to Be Informed of Automatic License Revocation and Fine Surcharges in Guilty Pleas: Analysis of STATE of Iowa v. Fisher

Date: Apr 9, 2016

Right to Be Informed of Automatic License Revocation and Fine Surcharges in Guilty Pleas: Analysis of STATE of Iowa v. Fisher Introduction STATE of Iowa v. Kevin Duane Fisher II (877 N.W.2d 676) is a...

Iowa Supreme Court Clarifies Standards for Jury Impartiality and New Trials on Weight of Evidence

Date: Apr 9, 2016

Iowa Supreme Court Clarifies Standards for Jury Impartiality and New Trials on Weight of Evidence Introduction The case of STATE of Iowa, Appellee, v. Kenneth Osborne Ary, Appellant presents...

Nonretroactive Application of Heemstra in Nguyen v. State: Establishing Limits on Felony-Murder Doctrine

Date: Mar 12, 2016

Nonretroactive Application of Heemstra in Nguyen v. State: Establishing Limits on Felony-Murder Doctrine 1. Introduction In the landmark case of Phuoc Nguyen v. State of Iowa, decided by the Supreme...

Supreme Court Upholds Termination of Parental Rights Under Iowa Code § 232.116(1)(h)

Date: Mar 5, 2016

Supreme Court Upholds Termination of Parental Rights Under Iowa Code § 232.116(1)(h) Introduction The case of In the Interest of M.W. and Z.W., Minor Children, R.W., Mother addresses the complex and...

Admissibility of Flight Evidence as Consciousness of Guilt: State v. Wilson

Date: Feb 20, 2016

Admissibility of Flight Evidence as Consciousness of Guilt: State v. Wilson Introduction In State of Iowa v. John Arthur Wilson, 878 N.W.2d 203 (Iowa 2016), the Supreme Court of Iowa examined the...

Supreme Court of Iowa Reaffirms Statutory Factors Over External Guidelines in Spousal Support Determinations

Date: Jan 30, 2016

Supreme Court of Iowa Reaffirms Statutory Factors Over External Guidelines in Spousal Support Determinations Introduction The case of In re the Marriage of Richard C. Mauer and Carol K. Mauer (874...

Prosecutorial Obligations in Plea Agreements: Upholding Letter and Spirit in State v. Lopez

Date: Dec 5, 2015

Prosecutorial Obligations in Plea Agreements: Upholding Letter and Spirit in State v. Lopez Introduction State of Iowa v. Andrew James Lopez, 872 N.W.2d 159 (Iowa 2015), is a landmark case addressing...

Establishing the Limits of Medical Examiner Testimony: Reliance on Defendant Statements in State v. Tyler

Date: Jul 1, 2015

Establishing the Limits of Medical Examiner Testimony: Reliance on Defendant Statements in State of Iowa v. Tyler Introduction In the landmark case of State of Iowa v. Hillary Lee Tyler (867 N.W.2d...

Juvenile Sentencing Guidelines: Iowa Supreme Court's Landmark Decision in State v. Seats

Date: Jun 27, 2015

Juvenile Sentencing Guidelines: Iowa Supreme Court's Landmark Decision in State v. Seats Introduction In the seminal case of State of Iowa, Appellee, v. Damion John Seats, Appellant (865 N.W.2d 545,...

Hoffman v. Hoffman: Custody Modification and the Threshold for Substantial Change in Residence

Date: May 9, 2015

Hoffman v. Hoffman: Custody Modification and the Threshold for Substantial Change in Residence Introduction Parties Involved: Tracy Lynn Hoffman (Appellant) and Ernst Franklin Hoffman (Appellee)...

Balancing Privacy and Discovery: New Protocol for Mental Health Records in Tort Actions Established by Cameron Fagen v. Grand View University

Date: Apr 4, 2015

Balancing Privacy and Discovery: New Protocol for Mental Health Records in Tort Actions Established by Cameron Fagen v. Grand View University Introduction Cameron Fagen v. Grand View University, NPI...

Affirmation of Jury Instruction on Lascivious Acts: Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claim Denied

Date: Feb 28, 2015

Affirmation of Jury Instruction on Lascivious Acts: Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claim Denied Introduction In the landmark case STATE of Iowa v. Max V. THORNDIKE (860 N.W.2d 316, 2015), the...

Affirmation of Automated Traffic Enforcement Ordinances Against Due Process and Preemption Claims: City of Sioux City v. Jacobsma

Date: Feb 21, 2015

Affirmation of Automated Traffic Enforcement Ordinances Against Due Process and Preemption Claims: City of Sioux City v. Jacobsma Introduction In the landmark case City of Sioux City v. Michael Jon...

Affirmation of Indefinite Traditional Spousal Support in Iowa: In re The Marriage of Gust

Date: Jan 17, 2015

Affirmation of Indefinite Traditional Spousal Support in Iowa: In re The Marriage of Gust Introduction The case of In re The Marriage of Steven Michael Gust and Linda Leann Gust (858 N.W.2d 402)...

STATE of Iowa v. Ambrose: Upholding Acquittal-First Instructions and Malice Inferences

Date: Jan 3, 2015

STATE of Iowa v. Ambrose: Upholding Acquittal-First Instructions and Malice Inferences Case: STATE of Iowa, Appellee, v. Kevin Deshay Ambrose Citation: 861 N.W.2d 550 Court: Supreme Court of Iowa...

Affirmation of Statutory Definitions in Juvenile Proceedings: In the Interest of J.C. v. D.C.

Date: Dec 27, 2014

Affirmation of Statutory Definitions in Juvenile Proceedings: In the Interest of J.C. v. D.C. Introduction The case of In the Interest of J.C., Minor Child. D.C., Father, Appellant. (857 N.W.2d 495)...

Mandatory Sentencing Reason Statements: Overruling Mudra and Alloway in Iowa Supreme Court's Decision in State v. Thompson

Date: Dec 13, 2014

Mandatory Sentencing Reason Statements: Overruling Mudra and Alloway in Iowa Supreme Court's Decision in State v. Thompson Introduction State of Iowa v. Mark Aaron Thompson, 856 N.W.2d 915 (Iowa...

State v. Dudley: Restricting Expert Testimony on Victim Credibility in Child Sexual Abuse Cases

Date: Dec 6, 2014

State v. Dudley: Restricting Expert Testimony on Victim Credibility in Child Sexual Abuse Cases Introduction State of Iowa v. Patrick Michael Dudley (856 N.W.2d 668, 2014) is a landmark decision by...