Iowa Case Commentaries

Reaffirming the Boundaries of Transitional and Rehabilitative Spousal Support: In re Marriage of Sokol

Date: Jan 28, 2023

Reaffirming the Boundaries of Transitional and Rehabilitative Spousal Support: In re Marriage of Sokol Introduction The Supreme Court of Iowa recently delivered a pivotal judgment in the case of In...

Preserving Public Trial Rights During a Pandemic: The Iowa Supreme Court's Decision in State v. Brimmer

Date: Dec 23, 2022

Preserving Public Trial Rights During a Pandemic: The Iowa Supreme Court's Decision in State v. Brimmer Introduction In the landmark case of State of Iowa v. Ronald James Brimmer, the Iowa Supreme...

Iowa Supreme Court Establishes Reasonable Efforts Standard for Implied Consent Advisory in Cases of Language Barriers

Date: Nov 11, 2022

Iowa Supreme Court Establishes Reasonable Efforts Standard for Implied Consent Advisory in Cases of Language Barriers Introduction In the landmark case of State of Iowa v. Fethe Feshaye Baraki, the...

Reversing No-Contact Order Extensions: The Petro Decision

Date: Nov 11, 2022

Reversing No-Contact Order Extensions: The Petro Decision Introduction In the landmark case State of Iowa v. Rick D. Petro (981 N.W.2d 686), the Supreme Court of Iowa addressed the standards for...

Strict Compliance with Plea Agreements: Iowa Supreme Court Reaffirms Resentencing Requirements in State v. Patten

Date: Oct 22, 2022

Strict Compliance with Plea Agreements: Iowa Supreme Court Reaffirms Resentencing Requirements in State v. Patten Introduction In State of Iowa v. Mychael Richard Patten (981 N.W.2d 126), the Supreme...

Supreme Court of Iowa Overrules Gacke and Applies Rational Basis Review to Nuisance Immunity Statute

Date: Jul 1, 2022

Supreme Court of Iowa Overrules Gacke and Applies Rational Basis Review to Nuisance Immunity Statute Introduction In the landmark case of Gordon Berg Garrison v. New Fashion Pork LLP and BWT Holdings...

Broad Interpretation of "In Connection With" Under Iowa Code § 322.3(12): Carreras v. Iowa Department of Transportation

Date: Jun 18, 2022

Broad Interpretation of "In Connection With" Under Iowa Code § 322.3(12): Carreras v. Iowa Department of Transportation 1. Introduction In the landmark case of Carreras v. Iowa Department of...

Affirmation of General Verdicts Under Iowa Code §814.28: STATE OF IOWA v. ERICA LYNE WEST VANGEN

Date: Jun 11, 2022

Affirmation of General Verdicts Under Iowa Code §814.28: State of Iowa v. Erica Lyne West Vangen Introduction The case of State of Iowa v. Erica Lyne West Vangen (975 N.W.2d 344) adjudicated by the...

Clarifying the 'Continuing Basis' in Ongoing Criminal Conduct: Iowa Supreme Court Sets New Precedent in State v. Crawford

Date: May 21, 2022

Clarifying the 'Continuing Basis' in Ongoing Criminal Conduct: Iowa Supreme Court Sets New Precedent in State v. Crawford Introduction In State of Iowa v. Jordan McKim Crawford (974 N.W.2d 510,...

Resentencing Entitlements in the Presence of Sentencing Errors: The Wilbourn Case

Date: May 7, 2022

Resentencing Entitlements in the Presence of Sentencing Errors: The Wilbourn Case Introduction The case of State of Iowa v. Korki Ricoh Wilbourn (974 N.W.2d 58) adjudicated by the Supreme Court of...

Iowa Supreme Court Affirms Mandatory Certificate of Merit in Medical Malpractice Actions: Struck v. Mercy Health Services

Date: Apr 23, 2022

Iowa Supreme Court Affirms Mandatory Certificate of Merit in Medical Malpractice Actions: Struck v. Mercy Health Services Introduction The case of Jacqueline Struck v. Mercy Health Services-Iowa...

Definition of "Indian Child" Under ICWA Affirmed in Z.K. Termination of Parental Rights Case

Date: Apr 9, 2022

Definition of "Indian Child" Under ICWA Affirmed in Z.K. Termination of Parental Rights Case Introduction The case of In the Interest of Z.K., Minor Child (973 N.W.2d 27) adjudicated by the Supreme...

Iowa Supreme Court Affirms Discretionary Sentencing Rights in Restitution and Incarceration for Habitual Offenders

Date: Apr 2, 2022

Iowa Supreme Court Affirms Discretionary Sentencing Rights in Restitution and Incarceration for Habitual Offenders Introduction In State of Iowa v. Tiffany Sue McCalley, the Supreme Court of Iowa...

Clarifying Brady Obligations and Due Process in Long-Delayed Prosecutions: Cahill v. State

Date: Mar 26, 2022

Clarifying Brady Obligations and Due Process in Long-Delayed Prosecutions: Cahill v. State Introduction In the landmark decision of State of Iowa v. Annette Dee Cahill, 972 N.W.2d 19 (Iowa 2022), the...

Supreme Court of Iowa Recognizes Transitional Alimony: A New Era in Spousal Support

Date: Mar 19, 2022

Supreme Court of Iowa Recognizes Transitional Alimony: A New Era in Spousal Support Introduction In the landmark case In re the Marriage of Suraj George Pazhoor and Hancy Chennikkara Pazhoor (971...

Enforcing Plea Agreements: Iowa Supreme Court Reinforces Prosecutor's Duty to Honor Sentencing Recommendations

Date: Mar 19, 2022

Enforcing Plea Agreements: Iowa Supreme Court Reinforces Prosecutor's Duty to Honor Sentencing Recommendations Introduction The Supreme Court of Iowa, in the case of State of Iowa v. Shane Michael...

Impact of Improper Jury Instructions on Sexual Abuse Convictions: STATE OF IOWA v. JUSTICE MATHIS

Date: Mar 19, 2022

Impact of Improper Jury Instructions on Sexual Abuse Convictions: STATE OF IOWA v. JUSTICE MATHIS Introduction In the landmark case of STATE OF IOWA, Appellee, v. JUSTICE MATHIS, Appellant (971...

Direct Appellate Review of Sufficiency of Evidence: State of Iowa v. Crawford

Date: Mar 19, 2022

Direct Appellate Review of Sufficiency of Evidence: State of Iowa v. Crawford Introduction In State of Iowa v. Randy Allen Crawford, 972 N.W.2d 189 (Iowa Supreme Court, 2022), the Iowa Supreme Court...

New Precedent on Delayed Appeals and Competency Hearings in Iowa

Date: Mar 5, 2022

New Precedent on Delayed Appeals and Competency Hearings in Iowa Introduction The case of State of Iowa v. Dantreyon Levon Newman (970 N.W.2d 866) adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Iowa on March 4,...

Admissibility of Prior Bad Acts Evidence in Sexual Abuse Cases: Insights from State v. Thoren

Date: Feb 26, 2022

Admissibility of Prior Bad Acts Evidence in Sexual Abuse Cases: Insights from State of Iowa v. Kevin Jon Thoren Introduction In the significant case of State of Iowa v. Kevin Jon Thoren, the Supreme...