Indiana Case Commentaries

Kelly v. State: Amendments to Successive Post-Conviction Petitions & Juvenile Sentencing Standards

Date: May 1, 2025

Kelly v. State: Amendments to Successive Post-Conviction Petitions & Juvenile Sentencing Standards Introduction McKinley Kelly v. State of Indiana is a 2025 Indiana Supreme Court decision that...

Per Se Justification of a Property Owner’s Right to Exclude in Tortious Interference Claims

Date: Apr 25, 2025

Per Se Justification of a Property Owner’s Right to Exclude in Tortious Interference Claims Introduction In In the Matter of the Certified Question: Diamond Quality, Inc. v. Dana Light Axle Products,...

Crossland v. Indiana: Refining Standards for Impartial Juries, Venue Transfers, Peremptory Challenges, and Defense Rights

Date: Apr 24, 2025

Crossland v. Indiana: Refining Standards for Impartial Juries, Venue Transfers, Peremptory Challenges, and Defense Rights Introduction In Chelsea L. Crossland v. State of Indiana (Ind. 2025), the...

Defining “Intra-Agency Deliberative Material” Under Indiana’s APRA

Date: Apr 24, 2025

Defining “Intra-Agency Deliberative Material” Under Indiana’s APRA 1. Introduction Family & Social Services Administration v. Robert E. Saint (No. 25S-MI-101, decided April 23, 2025) is a landmark...

Res Ipsa Loquitur for Fixture-Based Premises Liability: Indiana’s New Frontier

Date: Apr 23, 2025

Res Ipsa Loquitur for Fixture-Based Premises Liability: Indiana’s New Frontier Introduction In Kiera Isgrig v. Trustees of Indiana University (Ind. 2025), the Indiana Supreme Court for the first time...

Clarifying the Eggshell Skull Doctrine in Homicide: Establishing Its Role in Causation, Not Mens Rea

Date: Mar 15, 2025

Clarifying the Eggshell Skull Doctrine in Homicide: Establishing Its Role in Causation, Not Mens Rea Introduction In the case of Zachariah David Konkle v. State of Indiana, the Indiana Supreme Court...

New Precedent: Recognizing Parental Criminal Conduct as an Adverse Interest in Juvenile Waivers

Date: Mar 15, 2025

New Precedent: Recognizing Parental Criminal Conduct as an Adverse Interest in Juvenile Waivers Introduction The case of J.Q.R., Appellant v. State of Indiana, Appellee, decided on March 12, 2025, by...

“Hindsight as a Justificatory Lens”: A New Precedent on Self‐Defense under Indiana Law

Date: Mar 15, 2025

“Hindsight as a Justificatory Lens”: A New Precedent on Self‐Defense under Indiana Law Introduction The case of Antonio Turner v. State of Indiana introduces a groundbreaking twist to Indiana’s...

Judicial Accountability and Integrity: Enforcing Sanctions for Sexual Harassment

Date: Mar 2, 2025

Judicial Accountability and Integrity: Enforcing Sanctions for Sexual Harassment Introduction This commentary examines the Supreme Court of Indiana’s decision in the disciplinary case involving the...

New Precedent Affirming Indiana Courts’ Subject-Matter Jurisdiction over Multistate Trust Disputes

Date: Mar 1, 2025

New Precedent Affirming Indiana Courts’ Subject-Matter Jurisdiction over Multistate Trust Disputes Introduction The recent Supreme Court of Indiana Judgment in Emily Tingley v. First Financial Bank,...

Prospective-Only Application and the Jurisdictional Gap in Juvenile-to-Adult Waiver Cases

Date: Mar 1, 2025

Prospective-Only Application and the Jurisdictional Gap in Juvenile-to-Adult Waiver Cases Introduction The Judgment in Johnny Webster Brown v. State of Indiana addresses a critical legal lacuna that...

Recalibrating Nuisance Claims: Exhaustion, Zoning, and the UDO’s Integration of State and Federal Law

Date: Feb 22, 2025

Recalibrating Nuisance Claims: Exhaustion, Zoning, and the UDO’s Integration of State and Federal Law Introduction The case of Willow Haven on 106th Street, LLC v. Hari Nagireddy and Saranya...

New Precedent in Attorney Misconduct: Disbarment for Exploitation of Vulnerable Clients

Date: Feb 20, 2025

New Precedent in Attorney Misconduct: Disbarment for Exploitation of Vulnerable Clients Introduction The Judgment in the matter of Nathan Pearson, Respondent, delivered by the Supreme Court of...

Expansive Interpretation of Church Premises under Indiana’s Limited Liability Statute

Date: Feb 12, 2025

Expansive Interpretation of Church Premises under Indiana’s Limited Liability Statute Introduction In the case of Calvary Temple Church of Evansville, Inc. v. Gerard A. Kirsch, the Supreme Court of...

Jennings v. Smiley: Indiana Supreme Court Establishes Balanced Standard for Smartphone Data in Civil Discovery

Date: Jan 31, 2025

Jennings v. Smiley: Indiana Supreme Court Establishes Balanced Standard for Smartphone Data in Civil Discovery Introduction The case of Charles Jennings Appellant v. Jessica A. Smiley and Progressive...

Limiting Improper Use of Judicial Notice and Issue Preclusion in Suppression Motions: Analysis of Vlietstra v. State Of Indiana

Date: Jan 25, 2025

Limiting Improper Use of Judicial Notice and Issue Preclusion in Suppression Motions: Analysis of Vlietstra v. State Of Indiana Introduction The case of Jeffery Alan Vlietstra v. State Of Indiana...

Automotive Finance Corp. v. Liu: Indiana Sets Strict Standards for Relief Under Trial Rule 60(B)(3)

Date: Jan 24, 2025

Automotive Finance Corp. v. Liu: Indiana Sets Strict Standards for Relief Under Trial Rule 60(B)(3) Introduction The case of Automotive Finance Corporation (AFC) v. Meng Liu serves as a pivotal...

Indiana Supreme Court Expands Medical Malpractice Act to Include Emotional Distress Claims in Class Actions

Date: Jan 14, 2025

Indiana Supreme Court Expands Medical Malpractice Act to Include Emotional Distress Claims in Class Actions Introduction In the landmark case of Linda Gierek and Stephen Gierek, et al. v. Anonymous...

Advanced Age Considerations in Adoption: Supreme Court of Indiana Establishes New Precedent

Date: Jan 14, 2025

Advanced Age Considerations in Adoption: Supreme Court of Indiana Establishes New Precedent Introduction The case of In Re: The Adoption of P.J.W. v. R.W. adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Indiana...

Indiana Supreme Court Upholds Judicial Impartiality in Unjust Enrichment Cases: Reprimand of Judge Charles D. Bridges

Date: Jan 13, 2025

Indiana Supreme Court Upholds Judicial Impartiality in Unjust Enrichment Cases: Reprimand of Judge Charles D. Bridges Introduction The recent decision by the Supreme Court of Indiana marks a...