Indiana Case Commentaries

Indiana Supreme Court Reinforces Political Speech Protections under State Constitution in Colleen Price Case

Date: Nov 2, 1993

Indiana Supreme Court Reinforces Political Speech Protections under State Constitution in Colleen Price Case Introduction The Colleen PRICE v. STATE of Indiana case represents a significant...

Affirming Discretion in Custody Modification under Joint Legal Custody: Analysis of RICHARDSON v. MORGAN

Date: Oct 28, 1993

Affirming Discretion in Custody Modification under Joint Legal Custody: Analysis of RICHARDSON v. MORGAN Introduction In Re the Marriage of Ranaye (Morgan) Richardson, Appellant, and Daniel G....

Establishing Tort Liability for Bad Faith in Insurance Claims: Erie Insurance Co. v. Hickman

Date: Oct 28, 1993

Establishing Tort Liability for Bad Faith in Insurance Claims: Erie Insurance Co. v. Hickman Introduction In the landmark case of Erie Insurance Company v. Ramona Hickman, the Supreme Court of...

Burden of Proof in Post-Conviction Relief for Habitual Offender Status: WEATHERFORD v. STATE

Date: Oct 26, 1993

Burden of Proof in Post-Conviction Relief for Habitual Offender Status: WEATHERFORD v. STATE Introduction The case of Michael WEATHERFORD v. STATE of Indiana (619 N.E.2d 915) presents a pivotal...

Indiana Supreme Court Sets New Precedent on Jury Deliberation Fatigue: FARRELL v. STATE of Indiana

Date: Oct 23, 1993

Indiana Supreme Court Sets New Precedent on Jury Deliberation Fatigue: FARRELL v. STATE of Indiana Introduction In the landmark case of FARRELL v. STATE of Indiana, 622 N.E.2d 488 (Ind. 1993), the...

Sanford Marshall v. State of Indiana: Affirmation of Accomplice Liability and Application of Capital Sentencing Standards

Date: Sep 1, 1993

Sanford Marshall v. State of Indiana Affirmation of Accomplice Liability and Application of Capital Sentencing Standards Introduction The case of Sanford Marshall v. State of Indiana (621 N.E.2d 308)...

Enforceability of Designated Evidentiary Material under Indiana Trial Rule 56(C): Insights from ROSI v. BUSINESS FURNITURE CORP.

Date: Jun 19, 1993

Enforceability of Designated Evidentiary Material under Indiana Trial Rule 56(C): Insights from ROSI v. BUSINESS FURNITURE CORP. Introduction The case of RICHARD A. ROSI, APPELLANT (PLAINTIFF BELOW)...

Right to Expert Testimony in Capital Sentencing: Indiana Supreme Court's Decision in James v. State

Date: May 14, 1993

Right to Expert Testimony in Capital Sentencing: Indiana Supreme Court's Decision in James v. State Introduction In the landmark case of Vincent James a/k/a Victor James v. State of Indiana, the...

Kenneth Hinshaw v. Jay County: Refining Governmental Immunity under Subsection 9 of the Indiana Tort Claims Act

Date: Apr 8, 1993

Kenneth Hinshaw v. Jay County: Refining Governmental Immunity under Subsection 9 of the Indiana Tort Claims Act Introduction In the landmark case of Kenneth Hinshaw, Melissa Hinshaw, and Natasha...

Adoption of Federal Rules of Evidence 404(b) and 403 by the Indiana Supreme Court: Implications for Admissibility of Prior Uncharged Misconduct

Date: Mar 30, 1993

Adoption of Federal Rules of Evidence 404(b) and 403 by the Indiana Supreme Court: Implications for Admissibility of Prior Uncharged Misconduct Introduction The case of Derrick HARDIN v. STATE of...

Reaffirmation of Established Standards for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel: Fugate v. State of Indiana

Date: Feb 13, 1993

Reaffirmation of Established Standards for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel: Fugate v. State of Indiana Introduction Fugate v. State of Indiana is a seminal decision by the Supreme Court of Indiana,...

Clarifying 'Forcible Resistance' under Indiana's Resisting Law Enforcement Statute: Gary Spangler v. State of Indiana

Date: Jan 23, 1993

Clarifying 'Forcible Resistance' under Indiana's Resisting Law Enforcement Statute: Gary Spangler v. State of Indiana Introduction The Supreme Court of Indiana's decision in Gary Spangler v. State of...

Obligation to Disclose Rebuttal Expert Witnesses: Indiana Supreme Court Establishes Clear Rule

Date: Jan 7, 1993

Obligation to Disclose Rebuttal Expert Witnesses: Indiana Supreme Court Establishes Clear Rule Introduction The case of Bertha McCULLOUGH v. ARCHBOLD LADDER CO. and The Sherwin-Williams Co. (605...

Indiana Supreme Court Abolishes Mutuality and Identity Requirements for Defensive Collateral Estoppel in Uninsured Motorist Litigation

Date: Dec 23, 1992

Indiana Supreme Court Abolishes Mutuality and Identity Requirements for Defensive Collateral Estoppel in Uninsured Motorist Litigation Introduction The Supreme Court of Indiana delivered a pivotal...

Use of Non-Statutory Aggravators in Capital Sentencing: Indiana Supreme Court Sets New Precedent

Date: Oct 30, 1992

Use of Non-Statutory Aggravators in Capital Sentencing: Indiana Supreme Court Sets New Precedent Introduction The case of Larry Bellmore v. State of Indiana (602 N.E.2d 111) adjudicated by the...

Indiana Supreme Court Abolishes "Depraved Sexual Instinct" Exception, Adopts Federal Rule 404(b) in Sexual Offense Cases

Date: Oct 17, 1992

Indiana Supreme Court Abolishes "Depraved Sexual Instinct" Exception, Adopts Federal Rule 404(b) in Sexual Offense Cases Introduction In the landmark case of Donald G. Lannan v. State of Indiana, the...

Limits of Driver's Duty of Care for Intoxicated Passengers: STEPHENSON v. LEDBETTER Analysis

Date: Aug 7, 1992

Limits of Driver's Duty of Care for Intoxicated Passengers: STEPHENSON v. LEDBETTER Analysis Introduction The case of STEPHENSON v. LEDBETTER (1992) brought before the Supreme Court of Indiana...

Establishing the Standard of Care in Medical Malpractice Summary Judgments: Insights from OELLING v. RAO

Date: Jun 9, 1992

Establishing the Standard of Care in Medical Malpractice Summary Judgments: Insights from OELLING v. RAO Introduction The case of Howard A. Oelling and Margaret Oelling v. Satya M. Rao, M.D.; Jorge...

Egly v. Blackford County: Establishing Correct Standard for Terminating Parental Rights in Indiana

Date: Jun 5, 1992

Egly v. Blackford County: Establishing Correct Standard for Terminating Parental Rights in Indiana Introduction The case of Walter Egly and Diana Egly v. Blackford County Department of Public Welfare...

Nichols v. State of Indiana: Defining the Boundaries of Circumstantial Evidence in Criminal Convictions

Date: Apr 28, 1992

Nichols v. State of Indiana: Defining the Boundaries of Circumstantial Evidence in Criminal Convictions Introduction Roy D. Nichols, the appellant, was convicted by the Superior Court of St. Joseph...