Illinois Case Commentaries

Transition from Reasonable Hypothesis of Innocence to Reasonable Doubt Standard in Illinois Criminal Cases: Analysis of PEOPLE v. PINTOS

Date: Dec 22, 1989

Transition from Reasonable Hypothesis of Innocence to Reasonable Doubt Standard in Illinois Criminal Cases: Analysis of PEOPLE v. PINTOS Introduction The case of The People of the State of Illinois...

People v. Lucas: Clarifying 'Exceptionally Brutal or Heinous' for Death Penalty in Illinois

Date: Dec 22, 1989

People v. Lucas: Clarifying 'Exceptionally Brutal or Heinous' for Death Penalty in Illinois Introduction People of the State of Illinois v. John W. Lucas, 132 Ill.2d 399 (1989), adjudicated by the...

Refining Defamation and Tortious Interference Standards: Analysis of MITTELMAN v. WITOUS

Date: Dec 22, 1989

Refining Defamation and Tortious Interference Standards: Analysis of MITTELMAN v. WITOUS Introduction MITTELMAN v. WITOUS, 135 Ill. 2d 220 (1989), adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Illinois,...

Affirming Batson: Illinois Supreme Court Strengthens Protections Against Racial Bias in Jury Selection

Date: Dec 22, 1989

Affirming Batson: Illinois Supreme Court Strengthens Protections Against Racial Bias in Jury Selection Introduction In the landmark case of The People of the State of Illinois v. Lawrence Andrews...

Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies: Illinois Supreme Court Affirms Mandatory Rehearing Requirement in Castaneda v. Illinois Human Rights Commission

Date: Nov 23, 1989

Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies: Illinois Supreme Court Affirms Mandatory Rehearing Requirement in Castaneda v. Illinois Human Rights Commission Introduction In Raul Castaneda v. The Illinois...

Reversal of Murder Conviction Due to Insufficient Evidence of Mutual Combat in Peggy Austin Case

Date: Nov 23, 1989

Reversal of Murder Conviction Due to Insufficient Evidence of Mutual Combat in Peggy Austin Case Introduction The case of The People of the State of Illinois v. Peggy Austin, 133 Ill. 2d 118,...

Eyler v. The People of Illinois: Affirmation of Aggravated Kidnapping and Murder Convictions

Date: Oct 26, 1989

Eyler v. The People of Illinois: Affirmation of Aggravated Kidnapping and Murder Convictions Introduction Case Overview: In The People of the State of Illinois v. Larry Eyler (133 Ill. 2d 173, 1989),...

Restrictions on Victim Impact Statements in Bench Proceedings for Death Penalty Sentencing: People v. Terrell

Date: Oct 26, 1989

Restrictions on Victim Impact Statements in Bench Proceedings for Death Penalty Sentencing: People v. Terrell Introduction Case: The People of the State of Illinois v. Drew Terrell Court: Supreme...

Establishing Probable Cause for Warrantless Arrests: The PEOPLE v. ADAMS

Date: Oct 26, 1989

Establishing Probable Cause for Warrantless Arrests: The PEOPLE v. ADAMS Introduction The People of the State of Illinois v. Romney Adams (131 Ill. 2d 387) is a landmark case adjudicated by the...

Effective Assistance of Counsel and Procedural Adherence in Death Penalty Sentencing: An Analysis of People v. Barrow

Date: Oct 26, 1989

Effective Assistance of Counsel and Procedural Adherence in Death Penalty Sentencing: An Analysis of People v. Barrow Introduction People v. Ronald Barrow (133 Ill. 2d 226, 1989) is a landmark...

Establishing Tort Liability for Asbestos-Related Property Damage in Educational Institutions

Date: Oct 26, 1989

Establishing Tort Liability for Asbestos-Related Property Damage in Educational Institutions Introduction In The Board of Education of City of Chicago et al. v. A, C and S, Inc., et al. (131 Ill. 2d...

Good-Faith Settlements and Setoff of Workers' Compensation Liens under the Illinois Contribution Act

Date: Oct 26, 1989

Good-Faith Settlements and Setoff of Workers' Compensation Liens under the Illinois Contribution Act Introduction In the seminal case of Scott Wilson v. The Hoffman Group, Inc. (131 Ill. 2d 308), the...

Clarifying the Burden of Proof in Intentional Interference with Contract: Insights from HPI Health Care Services, Inc. v. Mt. Vernon Hospital, Inc.

Date: Sep 28, 1989

Clarifying the Burden of Proof in Intentional Interference with Contract: Insights from HPI Health Care Services, Inc. v. Mt. Vernon Hospital, Inc. Introduction The case of HPI Health Care Services,...

Affirmation of Legitimate Employment Practices in Age Discrimination Cases: Zaderaka v. Illinois Human Rights Commission

Date: Sep 28, 1989

Affirmation of Legitimate Employment Practices in Age Discrimination Cases: Zaderaka v. Illinois Human Rights Commission Introduction In Zaderaka v. Illinois Human Rights Commission et al., 131 Ill....

Admissibility of Victim Impact Statements in Non-Capital Felony Sentencing: People v. Felella

Date: Sep 21, 1989

Admissibility of Victim Impact Statements in Non-Capital Felony Sentencing: People v. Felella Introduction People of the State of Illinois v. Lee C. Felella (131 Ill. 2d 525) is a pivotal case...

Judicial Non-Interference in Private Hospital Staff Privilege Decisions: Adkins v. Sarah Bush Lincoln Health Center

Date: Sep 21, 1989

Judicial Non-Interference in Private Hospital Staff Privilege Decisions: Adkins v. Sarah Bush Lincoln Health Center Introduction Adkins v. Sarah Bush Lincoln Health Center is a pivotal case...

Affirmation of Triable Issue on Scope of Employment in Respondeat Superior: PYNE v. WITMER

Date: Jun 20, 1989

Affirmation of Triable Issue on Scope of Employment in Respondeat Superior: PYNE v. WITMER Introduction The case of Keith L. Pyne, Appellee, v. William E. Witmer et al. (D.R.W. Enterprises, Inc.,...

Schaffner v. Chicago North Western Transportation Co.: Admissibility of Subsequent Remedial Measures and Evidentiary Challenges in Negligence and Product Liability

Date: Jun 20, 1989

Schaffner v. Chicago North Western Transportation Co.: Admissibility of Subsequent Remedial Measures and Evidentiary Challenges in Negligence and Product Liability Introduction Schaffner v. Chicago...

Enhancing Fairness in Death Penalty Sentencing: Key Insights from People v. Harris

Date: Jun 20, 1989

Enhancing Fairness in Death Penalty Sentencing: Key Insights from People v. Harris Introduction People of the State of Illinois v. James Harris, decided by the Supreme Court of Illinois on June 19,...

Effective Assistance of Counsel and Statutory Interpretation in People v. Chandler

Date: Jun 20, 1989

Effective Assistance of Counsel and Statutory Interpretation in People v. Chandler Introduction People of the State of Illinois v. Mark F. Chandler, 129 Ill. 2d 233 (1989), is a pivotal case...