Illinois Case Commentaries

People v. Brown (2026 IL 130930) Commentary

Date: Jan 31, 2026

Prospective-Only Operation of the 2021 Habitual Criminal Age-21 Requirement (and Limits on “Clarification”) Case: People v. Brown, 2026 IL 130930 (Ill. Jan. 28, 2026) Court: Supreme Court of Illinois...

Permitted Emissions Are Irrelevant to CGL Pollution Exclusions (Overruling Imperial Marble and Bible Pork)

Date: Jan 27, 2026

Permitted Emissions Are Irrelevant to CGL Pollution Exclusions (Overruling Imperial Marble and Bible Pork) I. Introduction In Griffith Foods International Inc. v. National Union Fire Insurance...

People v. Chambliss (2026 IL 130585) Commentary

Date: Jan 27, 2026

Post-Conviction Review of Missing Preliminary Hearings: No Second-Prong Plain Error Where the Defendant Forfeits and the Trial Remains Fair Introduction People v. Chambliss, 2026 IL 130585, presented...

People v. Vesey: Self-Defense Instruction Against Police Requires “Some Evidence” of All Jeffries Elements—Excessive Force Is Factored Into (Not a Substitute for) the Unlawful-Force Element

Date: Jan 27, 2026

People v. Vesey: Self-Defense Instruction Against Police Requires “Some Evidence” of All Jeffries Elements—Excessive Force Is Factored Into (Not a Substitute for) the Unlawful-Force Element Court:...

Schilling v. Quincy Physicians: A Juror “Surrender Note” Does Not Mandate Mistrial; Prim Instruction and Standard Polling Suffice Absent Dissent or Ambiguity

Date: Jan 27, 2026

Schilling v. Quincy Physicians: A Juror “Surrender Note” Does Not Mandate Mistrial; Prim Instruction and Standard Polling Suffice Absent Dissent or Ambiguity 1. Introduction In Schilling v. Quincy...

“Capable of Financing” Under § 8-406.1(f)(3) Is Forward-Looking: No Present-Funding Condition Precedent for CPCNs

Date: Jan 27, 2026

“Capable of Financing” Under § 8-406.1(f)(3) Is Forward-Looking: No Present-Funding Condition Precedent for CPCNs Case: Concerned Citizens & Property Owners v. Illinois Commerce Comm'n, 2026 IL...

People v. Dobbins: Certificate of Innocence Petitions Abate at Death Because a COI Is Not an “Action to Recover Damages” Under the Survival Act

Date: Jan 27, 2026

People v. Dobbins: Certificate of Innocence Petitions Abate at Death Because a COI Is Not an “Action to Recover Damages” Under the Survival Act Introduction People v. Dobbins (2026 IL 131187)...

Pretrial Jail Sanctions, Finality, and County Jail Good-Behavior Credit: Commentary on People v. Seymore

Date: Dec 6, 2025

Pretrial Jail Sanctions, Finality, and County Jail Good-Behavior Credit: Commentary on People v. Seymore, 2025 IL 131564 I. Introduction The Illinois Supreme Court’s decision in People v. Seymore,...

Concrete Injury as a Prerequisite for Federal Statutory Claims in Illinois Courts: Standing and FACTA After Fausett v. Walgreen Co.

Date: Nov 22, 2025

Concrete Injury as a Prerequisite for Federal Statutory Claims in Illinois Courts: Standing and FACTA After Fausett v. Walgreen Co. I. Introduction The Supreme Court of Illinois’ decision in Fausett...

Haase v. Kankakee School District 111: Reaffirming Broad Immunity for Negligent School Supervision Under Section 3‑108 of the Tort Immunity Act

Date: Nov 22, 2025

Haase v. Kankakee School District 111: Reaffirming Broad Immunity for Negligent School Supervision Under Section 3‑108 of the Tort Immunity Act I. Introduction In Haase v. Kankakee School District...

Board-Appointed Physicians Do Not Control Disability Determinations Under Section 5‑156: Commentary on Moreland v. Retirement Board of the Policemen’s Annuity and Benefit Fund of Chicago

Date: Nov 22, 2025

Board-Appointed Physicians Do Not Control Disability Determinations Under Section 5‑156: Commentary on Moreland v. Retirement Board of the Policemen’s Annuity and Benefit Fund of the City of Chicago,...

People v. Butler: Availability for Cross‑Examination, Not In‑Court Accusation, Satisfies §115‑10 and the Confrontation Clause

Date: Nov 22, 2025

People v. Butler: Availability for Cross‑Examination, Not In‑Court Accusation, Satisfies §115‑10 and the Confrontation Clause I. Introduction In People v. Butler, 2025 IL 130988 (Ill. Nov. 20, 2025),...

People v. Hietschold: Substantial Compliance with Section 113‑4(e) Where the Court Warns Only of Trial in Absentia

Date: Nov 22, 2025

People v. Hietschold: Substantial Compliance with Section 113‑4(e) Where the Court Warns Only of Trial in Absentia I. Introduction In People v. Hietschold, 2025 IL 130716 (Ill. Nov. 20, 2025), the...

People v. Williams: Definitional vs. Mandatory Jury Instructions and the Partial Overruling of Warrington

Date: Nov 22, 2025

People v. Williams: Definitional vs. Mandatory Jury Instructions and the Partial Overruling of People v. Warrington I. Introduction In People v. Williams, 2025 IL 130779 (Ill. Nov. 20, 2025), the...

Fee-Shifting in Police Disability Benefit Termination Cases: Commentary on Rainey v. Retirement Board of the Policemen's Annuity and Benefit Fund of the City of Chicago

Date: Nov 22, 2025

Fee-Shifting in Police Disability Benefit Termination Cases: Commentary on Rainey v. Retirement Board of the Policemen's Annuity and Benefit Fund of the City of Chicago I. Introduction The Illinois...

Illinois Supreme Court Requires Midtrial Directed‑Verdict Rulings Before the Defense Presents Evidence: People v. Johnson, 2025 IL 130447

Date: Nov 4, 2025

Illinois Supreme Court Requires Midtrial Directed‑Verdict Rulings Before the Defense Presents Evidence: People v. Johnson, 2025 IL 130447 Introduction In People v. Johnson, 2025 IL 130447, the...

Illinois Supreme Court Clarifies: A Certificate of Innocence Requires Proving Innocence of Every Offense Charged—Including Nol-Prossed Counts from Plea Deals

Date: Oct 25, 2025

Certificates of Innocence Now Require Proof of Innocence of Every Offense Charged—even Nol-Prossed Counts Executive Summary In People v. Reed, 2025 IL 130595 (Ill. Oct. 23, 2025), the Illinois...

No Public-Trial Violation from Sequestration of a Potential Witness: People v. Smith (Ill. 2025)

Date: Oct 3, 2025

No Public-Trial Violation from Sequestration of a Potential Witness: People v. Smith (Ill. 2025) Introduction In People v. Smith, 2025 IL 130067, the Supreme Court of Illinois resolved multiple...

People v. Class (2025): Appellate Reassignment on Remand in Postconviction Cases Limited to Bias or Probability of Bias; Rule 615(b)(2) Authority Clarified and Serrano Overruled

Date: Aug 31, 2025

People v. Class (2025): Appellate Reassignment on Remand in Postconviction Cases Limited to Bias or Probability of Bias; Rule 615(b)(2) Authority Clarified and Serrano Overruled Introduction In...

People v. Muhammad (2025): Redefining “Tortured Confession” under the TIRC Act and Establishing the “Actual-Conflict” Standard for Rescinding a Special Prosecutor in Illinois

Date: Jul 13, 2025

People v. Muhammad (2025 IL 130470) Redefining “Tortured Confession” under the Illinois TIRC Act & Clarifying the Evidence Required to Remove a Special Prosecutor under § 3-9008(a-10)...