Illinois Case Commentaries

Colorable Actual Innocence Claims Necessary for Successive Postconviction Petitions: Insights from People v. Edwards

Date: May 30, 2012

Colorable Actual Innocence Claims Necessary for Successive Postconviction Petitions: Insights from People v. Edwards Introduction People of the State of Illinois v. Walter Edwards (360 Ill. Dec. 784,...

Reinforcing the Waiver Rule and Limiting Fraudulent Misrepresentation to Commercial Contexts – BONHOMME v. ST. JAMES

Date: May 25, 2012

Reinforcing the Waiver Rule and Limiting Fraudulent Misrepresentation to Commercial Contexts – BONHOMME v. ST. JAMES Introduction In the landmark case of Paula Bonhomme v. Janna St. James, decided by...

Rigorous Compliance with Appellate Brief Requirements: The Hall v. Naper Gold Hospitality LLC Decision

Date: May 15, 2012

Rigorous Compliance with Appellate Brief Requirements: The Hall v. Naper Gold Hospitality LLC Decision Introduction The case of Peggy Lee Hall v. Naper Gold Hospitality LLC, adjudicated by the...

Affirmation of the Identical Elements Test in Illinois Sentencing: PEOPLE v. CLEMONS

Date: Apr 20, 2012

Affirmation of the Identical Elements Test in Illinois Sentencing: PEOPLE v. CLEMONS Introduction In the landmark case of The People of the State of Illinois v. Corey D. Clemons, decided on April 19,...

Cook County's Assault Weapons Ban Partially Upheld; Second Amendment Claims Remanded

Date: Apr 6, 2012

Cook County's Assault Weapons Ban Partially Upheld; Second Amendment Claims Remanded Introduction The case of Matthew D. Wilson et al. v. The County of Cook et al. challenges the constitutionality of...

Duty of Care in 'Take-Home Asbestos' Cases: CSX Transportation, Inc. v. Simpkins

Date: Mar 23, 2012

Duty of Care in 'Take-Home Asbestos' Cases: CSX Transportation, Inc. v. Simpkins Introduction The case of Cynthia Simpkins v. CSX Transportation, Inc. (2012 IL 110662) addresses the pivotal issue of...

Admissibility of Prior Domestic Battery Convictions as Propensity Evidence in Murder Trials: Insights from The People v. Chapman (2012)

Date: Mar 23, 2012

Admissibility of Prior Domestic Battery Convictions as Propensity Evidence in Murder Trials: Insights from The People v. Chapman (2012) Introduction The People of the State of Illinois v. Robert J....

Enhancing Standards for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel in Post-Conviction Reviews: A Comprehensive Analysis of PEOPLE v. CATHEY

Date: Mar 23, 2012

Enhancing Standards for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel in Post-Conviction Reviews: A Comprehensive Analysis of PEOPLE v. CATHEY Introduction People v. Elron Cathey (965 N.E.2d 1109), adjudicated...

Clarifying Cause and Prejudice Requirements for Successive Postconviction Petitions: Insights from People v. Guerrero

Date: Feb 18, 2012

Clarifying Cause and Prejudice Requirements for Successive Postconviction Petitions: Insights from People v. Guerrero Introduction In the realm of criminal law, postconviction relief serves as a...

People v. Baskerville: Affirming False Statements as Obstruction of a Peace Officer Under Section 31-1(a)

Date: Feb 18, 2012

People v. Baskerville: Affirming False Statements as Obstruction of a Peace Officer Under Section 31-1(a) Introduction In the landmark case of The People of the State of Illinois v. Joseph...

Clarifying Citizen Suit Limitations Under Section 8.05(a) of the Surface Coal Mining Act

Date: Feb 3, 2012

Clarifying Citizen Suit Limitations Under Section 8.05(a) of the Surface Coal Mining Act Introduction In the landmark case CITIZENS OPPOSING POLLUTION v. EXXONMOBIL COAL U.S.A., the Supreme Court of...

Illinois Supreme Court Affirms 'No Harmless Error' Rule for Physically Coerced Confessions in Successive Postconviction Petitions

Date: Feb 3, 2012

Illinois Supreme Court Affirms 'No Harmless Error' Rule for Physically Coerced Confessions in Successive Postconviction Petitions Introduction In the landmark decision of The PEOPLE of the State of...

Mandatory Second Degree Murder Instructions in Self-Defense Cases: An Analysis of People v. Mal

Date: Jan 21, 2012

Mandatory Second Degree Murder Instructions in Self-Defense Cases: An Analysis of People v. Mal Introduction The case of The People of the State of Illinois v. Malvin Washington (357 Ill. Dec. 1)...

Vacuating Improperly Imposed Public Defender Fees by Circuit Clerks

Date: Jan 21, 2012

Vacuating Improperly Imposed Public Defender Fees by Circuit Clerks Introduction The case of The People of the State of Illinois v. Elias Gutierrez, decided by the Supreme Court of Illinois on...

Indeterminate Mandatory Supervised Release Terms in Criminal Sexual Assault Cases: A Comprehensive Analysis

Date: Jan 21, 2012

Indeterminate Mandatory Supervised Release Terms in Criminal Sexual Assault Cases: A Comprehensive Analysis Introduction The landmark decision in The PEOPLE of the State of Illinois v. Thomas S....

Prosecutorial Limitations on Arguing Law Enforcement Credibility: Insights from People v. Romney Adams

Date: Jan 21, 2012

Prosecutorial Limitations on Arguing Law Enforcement Credibility: Insights from People v. Romney Adams Introduction People v. Romney Adams is a pivotal judgment delivered by the Supreme Court of...

Reaffirming the Scope of the Illinois Citizen Participation Act: Limiting Anti-SLAPP Protections to Meritless Litigation

Date: Jan 21, 2012

Reaffirming the Scope of the Illinois Citizen Participation Act: Limiting Anti-SLAPP Protections to Meritless Litigation Introduction The case of Ste v. Sandholm, decided on January 20, 2012, by the...

Preliminary Inquiry Mandate for Pro Se Ineffective Assistance Claims in Illinois

Date: Dec 31, 2011

Preliminary Inquiry Mandate for Pro Se Ineffective Assistance Claims in Illinois Introduction The case of The PEOPLE of the State of Illinois v. Tyron L. Patrick (355 Ill. Dec. 943, 2011) addresses...

Illinois Supreme Court Establishes Right to Withdraw Plea Following Incomplete Admonishments on Restitution

Date: Dec 2, 2011

Illinois Supreme Court Establishes Right to Withdraw Plea Following Incomplete Admonishments on Restitution Introduction The case of The People of the State of Illinois v. Deandra Snyder, decided by...

Ensuring Procedural Due Process in Terminating Parental Rights: IN RE HALEY D.

Date: Dec 2, 2011

Ensuring Procedural Due Process in Terminating Parental Rights: IN RE HALEY D. Introduction IN RE HALEY D. is a seminal decision by the Supreme Court of Illinois that addresses the critical issue of...