Florida Case Commentaries

Safeguarding Jury Integrity: Insights from THOMAS v. STATE of Florida

Date: Oct 1, 1999

Safeguarding Jury Integrity: Insights from THOMAS v. STATE of Florida Introduction THOMAS v. STATE of Florida, 748 So. 2d 970 (1999), adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Florida, serves as a pivotal...

Electric Chair Execution Upheld as Constitutional in Provenzano v. Moore, 744 So. 2d 413 (Fla. 1999)

Date: Sep 25, 1999

Electric Chair Execution Upheld as Constitutional in Provenzano v. Moore 744 So. 2d 413 (Fla. 1999) Introduction Thomas H. Provenzano, a defendant under a death warrant, challenged the...

Unconscionability of Arbitration Clauses in Consumer Contracts: Powertel v. Bexley

Date: Sep 2, 1999

Unconscionability of Arbitration Clauses in Consumer Contracts: Powertel v. Bexley Introduction The case of Powertel, Inc. and Powertel/Jacksonville, Inc. v. Dana C. Bexley serves as a pivotal...

Broad Discretion Standard Affirmed in Estate of STUCKEY v. BROWN

Date: Aug 27, 1999

Broad Discretion Standard Affirmed in Estate of STUCKEY v. BROWN Introduction The case of Estate of A.P. Stuckey, Sr. v. Rupert B. Brown et ux., decided by the Supreme Court of Florida on August 26,...

Clarifying Evidentiary Hearing Standards in Brady and Ineffective Assistance Claims: PEEDE v. STATE of Florida

Date: Aug 20, 1999

Clarifying Evidentiary Hearing Standards in Brady and Ineffective Assistance Claims: PEEDE v. STATE of Florida Introduction In Robert Ira PEEDE v. STATE of Florida, 748 So. 2d 253 (Fla. 1999), the...

Miranda Compliance and Juvenile Rights in NATHAN JOE RAMIREZ v. STATE OF FLORIDA

Date: Jul 9, 1999

Miranda Compliance and Juvenile Rights in NATHAN JOE RAMIREZ v. STATE OF FLORIDA Introduction NATHAN JOE RAMIREZ v. STATE OF FLORIDA (739 So. 2d 568), adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Florida on...

Proportionality in Death Penalty Sentencing: Analysis of ROBERT LARKINS v. STATE OF FLORIDA

Date: Jul 9, 1999

Proportionality in Death Penalty Sentencing: Analysis of ROBERT LARKINS v. STATE OF FLORIDA Introduction ROBERT LARKINS v. STATE OF FLORIDA is a pivotal case adjudicated by the Supreme Court of...

Affirmation and Remand in Postconviction Relief: GASKIN v. STATE of Florida

Date: Jul 2, 1999

A Comprehensive Analysis of GASKIN v. STATE of Florida: Establishing the Need for Evidentiary Hearings in Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claims Introduction GASKIN v. STATE of Florida (737 So. 2d...

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Liability Beyond Economic Loss Rule in Professional Negligence Cases

Date: Jul 2, 1999

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Liability Beyond Economic Loss Rule in Professional Negligence Cases Introduction In the landmark case of MORANSAIS v. HEATHMAN, 744 So.2d 973 (Fla. 1999), the...

Affirmation of Procedural Bars and Standards for Effective Counsel in TEFFETELLER v. DUGGER

Date: Jun 18, 1999

Affirmation of Procedural Bars and Standards for Effective Counsel in TEFFETELLER v. DUGGER Introduction TEFFETELLER v. DUGGER, 734 So. 2d 1009 (Fla. Supreme Court, 1999), is a pivotal case that...

Recognition of Intentional Interference with Custodial Parent-Child Relationships in Florida: STONE v. WALL (1999)

Date: Jun 18, 1999

Recognition of Intentional Interference with Custodial Parent-Child Relationships in Florida: STONE v. WALL (1999) Introduction STONE v. WALL is a landmark case decided by the Supreme Court of...

Belated Postconviction Relief and Legal Malpractice in STEELE v. KEHOE

Date: May 28, 1999

Belated Postconviction Relief and Legal Malpractice in STEELE v. KEHOE Introduction STEELE v. KEHOE (747 So. 2d 931, Supreme Court of Florida, 1999) addresses critical issues concerning legal...

Limiting Writ of Error Coram Nobis to Florida Rule 3.850 Timeframes: WOOD v. STATE

Date: May 28, 1999

Limiting Writ of Error Coram Nobis to Florida Rule 3.850 Timeframes: WOOD v. STATE Introduction Robert Earl WOOD v. STATE of Florida is a pivotal case decided by the Supreme Court of Florida on May...

Clarifying Procedural Barriers in Postconviction Relief: DOWNS v. STATE of Florida

Date: May 21, 1999

Clarifying Procedural Barriers in Postconviction Relief: DOWNS v. STATE of Florida Introduction DOWNS v. STATE of Florida, 740 So. 2d 506 (Fla. 1999), is a pivotal decision by the Supreme Court of...

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Discretionary Jurisdiction Protocol for Habeas Corpus Petitions

Date: May 7, 1999

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Discretionary Jurisdiction Protocol for Habeas Corpus Petitions Introduction In the case of William Gary Harvard a/k/a Darrell Small vs. Harry K. Singletary, etc.,...

Disbarment Upheld: Continuing Disciplinary Jurisdiction and Ethical Obligations of Suspended Attorneys

Date: May 7, 1999

Disbarment Upheld: Continuing Disciplinary Jurisdiction and Ethical Obligations of Suspended Attorneys Introduction The case of The Florida Bar, Complainant, v. Alec Joseph Ross, 732 So. 2d 1037...

ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO. v. BOECHER: Supreme Court of Florida Permits Discovery of Party’s Relationship with Expert Witnesses

Date: Apr 23, 1999

ALLSTATE INSURANCE CO. v. BOECHER: Supreme Court of Florida Permits Discovery of Party’s Relationship with Expert Witnesses Introduction The Supreme Court of Florida, in the landmark case Allstate...

Proportionality in Capital Sentencing: Insights from Woods v. State of Florida

Date: Apr 16, 1999

Proportionality in Capital Sentencing: Insights from Woods v. State of Florida Introduction Woods v. State of Florida (733 So. 2d 980, 1999) is a landmark decision by the Supreme Court of Florida...

Restitution Over Imprisonment: Analysis of STATE v. BANKS Establishing the Weight of Restitution in Sentencing Departures

Date: Apr 16, 1999

Restitution Over Imprisonment: Analysis of STATE v. BANKS Establishing the Weight of Restitution in Sentencing Departures Introduction STATE v. BANKS, 732 So.2d 1065 (Fla. 1999), adjudicated by the...

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Standard for Ineffective Assistance Claims Concerning Plea Offers, Rejecting Requirement to Prove Court Acceptance

Date: Apr 9, 1999

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Standard for Ineffective Assistance Claims Concerning Plea Offers, Rejecting Requirement to Prove Court Acceptance Introduction The case of James L. Cottle vs. State...