Florida Case Commentaries

Establishing a Totality of Circumstances Approach to Presume Judicial Vindictiveness in Florida

Date: Apr 11, 2003

Establishing a Totality of Circumstances Approach to Presume Judicial Vindictiveness in Florida Introduction The Supreme Court of Florida, in the landmark decision of Omar Wilson, Petitioner, v....

Florida Supreme Court Defines Scope of Design Defect Exclusion and Sue and Labor Clause in Builder’s Risk Insurance

Date: Apr 11, 2003

Florida Supreme Court Defines Scope of Design Defect Exclusion and Sue and Labor Clause in Builder’s Risk Insurance Introduction In Swire Pacific Holdings, Inc. v. Zurich Insurance Company, the...

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Insured’s Right to Suing Insurers for PIP Benefits Without Preexisting Medical Liability

Date: Apr 4, 2003

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Insured’s Right to Suing Insurers for PIP Benefits Without Preexisting Medical Liability Introduction The Florida Supreme Court, in the landmark decision of Allstate...

Supreme Court of Florida Rules Out Anders Procedures for Termination of Parental Rights Cases

Date: Apr 4, 2003

Supreme Court of Florida Rules Out Anders Procedures for Termination of Parental Rights Cases Introduction The case of N.S.H. v. Florida Department of Children and Family Services, decided by the...

ERISA Preemption and Vicarious Liability: Insights from VILLAZON v. PRUDENTIAL HEALTH CARE Plan, Inc.

Date: Mar 28, 2003

ERISA Preemption and Vicarious Liability: Insights from VILLAZON v. PRUDENTIAL HEALTH CARE Plan, Inc. Introduction The case of Rolando Villazon, et al. v. Prudential Health Care Plan, Inc. (843 So....

FDUTPA Applies to Single Acts: PNR, Inc. v. Beacon Property Management, Inc. - Comprehensive Legal Commentary

Date: Mar 14, 2003

FDUTPA Applies to Single Acts: PNR, Inc. v. Beacon Property Management, Inc. Author: Legal Expert Commentary Date: October 2023 Introduction The case of PNR, Inc. v. Beacon Property Management, Inc....

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Rigorous Standards for Ineffective Assistance Claims and Penalty Phase Proceedings in Coney Case

Date: Mar 7, 2003

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Rigorous Standards for Ineffective Assistance Claims and Penalty Phase Proceedings in Coney Case Introduction In the landmark case of State of Florida v. Jimmie Lee...

Establishing Enhanced RICO Standards in Capital Sentencing: The Lugo v. State of Florida Judgment

Date: Feb 21, 2003

Establishing Enhanced RICO Standards in Capital Sentencing: The Lugo v. State of Florida Judgment Introduction The case of Daniel Lugo v. State of Florida (No. SC93994, 845 So.2d 74) represents a...

Reaffirmation of the Standards for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel and Procedural Barriers: Supreme Court of Florida Upholds Denial of Randall Scott Jones's Postconviction Relief and Habeas Corpus

Date: Feb 14, 2003

Reaffirmation of the Standards for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel and Procedural Barriers: Supreme Court of Florida Upholds Denial of Randall Scott Jones's Postconviction Relief and Habeas Corpus...

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Doorbal v. State of Florida: Upholding Aggravating Factors and Probable Cause Standards

Date: Jan 31, 2003

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Doorbal v. State of Florida: Upholding Aggravating Factors and Probable Cause Standards Introduction In the landmark case of Noel Doorbal v. State of Florida, the...

Florida Supreme Court Clarifies Jurisdictional Limits on Extraordinary Writs for Per Curiam Decisions

Date: Jan 24, 2003

Florida Supreme Court Clarifies Jurisdictional Limits on Extraordinary Writs for Per Curiam Decisions Introduction In the landmark decision Floyd Persaud, Petitioner, v. State of Florida, Respondent...

Credit for Time Served in Multiple Jurisdictions: GETHERS v. STATE

Date: Jan 17, 2003

Credit for Time Served in Multiple Jurisdictions: GETHERS v. STATE 1. Introduction Antonio GETHERS v. STATE (838 So. 2d 504) is a pivotal case decided by the Supreme Court of Florida on January 16,...

Affirmation of Death Penalty: Use of Prior Violent Felony as Aggravating Circumstance in First-Degree Murder

Date: Jan 17, 2003

Affirmation of Death Penalty: Use of Prior Violent Felony as Aggravating Circumstance in First-Degree Murder 1. Introduction The case of Charles Anderson v. State of Florida (841 So. 2d 390, Supreme...

Affirming Procedural Barriers and Standards for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel in Postconviction and Habeas Procedures: Spencer v. Florida

Date: Jan 10, 2003

Affirming Procedural Barriers and Standards for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel in Postconviction and Habeas Procedures: Spencer v. Florida Introduction In the landmark case of SPENCER v. STATE of...

Clarifying Heinousness and Calculated Premeditation as Aggravators in Capital Sentencing: Lynch v. State

Date: Jan 10, 2003

Clarifying Heinousness and Calculated Premeditation as Aggravators in Capital Sentencing: Lynch v. State Introduction RICHARD LYNCH, Appellant, v. STATE OF FLORIDA, Appellee is a landmark decision by...

Double Jeopardy and Resentencing: Insights from ASHLEY v. STATE

Date: Jan 10, 2003

Double Jeopardy and Resentencing: Insights from ASHLEY v. STATE Introduction The case of Columbus R. ASHLEY v. STATE of Florida (850 So. 2d 1265) adjudicated by the Supreme Court of Florida on...

Florida Supreme Court Expands Appellate Review and Attorney's Fee Claims in CAUFIELD v. CANTELE

Date: Dec 20, 2002

Florida Supreme Court Expands Appellate Review and Attorney's Fee Claims in CAUFIELD v. CANTELE Introduction The case of Edward B. Caufield, et al. v. Gino Cantele, et al. (837 So. 2d 371) presented...

Standard Jury Instructions and Fundamental Error: Reeves v. State of Florida

Date: Dec 20, 2002

Standard Jury Instructions and Fundamental Error: Reed v. State of Florida Introduction In the landmark case of Reed v. State of Florida, 837 So. 2d 366 (Fla. 2002), the Supreme Court of Florida...

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Exception to the Impact Rule in Cases of Statutory Confidentiality Breaches by Psychotherapists

Date: Dec 20, 2002

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Exception to the Impact Rule in Cases of Statutory Confidentiality Breaches by Psychotherapists Introduction In the landmark case of GRACEY v. EAKER, decided on...

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Flexible Standards for Probation Revocation Due to Failure to File Reports

Date: Dec 6, 2002

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Flexible Standards for Probation Revocation Due to Failure to File Reports Introduction In State of Florida v. John H. Carter (835 So. 2d 259), the Supreme Court of...