Florida Case Commentaries

Florida Supreme Court Upholds Insurer’s Duty of Good Faith in Settling Minor Claims Without Court Approval

Date: Mar 1, 2005

Florida Supreme Court Upholds Insurer’s Duty of Good Faith in Settling Minor Claims Without Court Approval Introduction The case of Barry Berges v. Infinity Insurance Company addresses a critical...

Waiver of Arbitration Rights Without Proof of Prejudice: Raymond James Financial Services, Inc. v. Saldukas

Date: Feb 25, 2005

Waiver of Arbitration Rights Without Proof of Prejudice: Raymond James Financial Services, Inc. v. Saldukas Introduction The case of Raymond James Financial Services, Inc., et al. v. Steven W....

Florida Supreme Court Upholds Dual Convictions for Attempted Second-Degree Murder and Aggravated Battery on a Law Enforcement Officer Without Violating Double Jeopardy

Date: Feb 18, 2005

Florida Supreme Court Upholds Dual Convictions for Attempted Second-Degree Murder and Aggravated Battery on a Law Enforcement Officer Without Violating Double Jeopardy Introduction In the landmark...

Preservation Requirements for Withdrawal of Plea Motions: HARRELL v. STATE Sets New Precedent

Date: Feb 11, 2005

Preservation Requirements for Withdrawal of Plea Motions: HARRELL v. STATE Sets New Precedent Introduction The case of Dwayne Lamont HARRELL v. STATE of Florida, adjudicated by the Supreme Court of...

Expansion of Declaratory Judgment Authority in Insurance Coverage Disputes: State Farm Fire Cas. Co. v. Higgins

Date: Feb 1, 2005

Expansion of Declaratory Judgment Authority in Insurance Coverage Disputes: State Farm Fire Cas. Co. v. Higgins Introduction State Farm Fire and Casualty Company v. Higgins is a landmark decision by...

Affirmation of Felony Murder Conviction Amid Partial Reduction of Underlying Felony in Willie Seth Crain v. State of Florida

Date: Jan 26, 2005

Affirmation of Felony Murder Conviction Amid Partial Reduction of Underlying Felony in Willie Seth Crain v. State of Florida Introduction Case: Willie Seth Crain, Appellant, v. STATE of Florida,...

Supreme Court of Florida Clarifies Economic Loss Doctrine in Negligence Actions

Date: Dec 24, 2004

Supreme Court of Florida Clarifies Economic Loss Doctrine in Negligence Actions Introduction In the landmark case of Indemnity Insurance Company of North America, et al. v. American Aviation, Inc.,...

Florida Supreme Court Rules Tripp Credit Inapplicable to Habitual Felony Offender Sentences

Date: Dec 24, 2004

Florida Supreme Court Rules Tripp Credit Inapplicable to Habitual Felony Offender Sentences Introduction In the landmark case of State of Florida v. Gary Matthews (891 So.2d 479, 2004), the Supreme...

Limiting Dismissal with Prejudice for Discovery Violations: Insights from HAM v. DUNMIRE

Date: Dec 24, 2004

Limiting Dismissal with Prejudice for Discovery Violations: Insights from HAM v. DUNMIRE Introduction The case of Suzanne S. Ham v. Scott Ryan Dunmire, et al. adjudicated by the Supreme Court of...

Strict Limitations on Appellate Review of Nonfinal Orders Denying Workers' Compensation Immunity

Date: Dec 17, 2004

Strict Limitations on Appellate Review of Nonfinal Orders Denying Workers' Compensation Immunity Introduction The case of Reeves v. Fleetwood Homes of Florida, Inc., 889 So. 2d 812 (Fla. 2004),...

Florida Supreme Court Affirms Insurance Coverage for Objectively Substantial Intentional Torts under Workers' Compensation Law

Date: Dec 10, 2004

Florida Supreme Court Affirms Insurance Coverage for Objectively Substantial Intentional Torts under Workers' Compensation Law Introduction The case of Travelers Indemnity Company v. PCR Incorporated...

Enforcement of Franchise Fees Post-Agreement Expiration: Florida Power Corp. v. City of Winter Park

Date: Oct 29, 2004

Enforcement of Franchise Fees Post-Agreement Expiration: Florida Power Corp. v. City of Winter Park Introduction Florida Power Corporation ("FPC") appealed a decision by the Supreme Court of Florida...

Balancing Customer Preference and Historical Presence in Utility Territorial Disputes: A Comprehensive Analysis of West Florida Electric Cooperative Association v. E. Leon Jacobs, Jr.

Date: Oct 22, 2004

Balancing Customer Preference and Historical Presence in Utility Territorial Disputes Introduction The case of West Florida Electric Cooperative Association, Inc. v. E. Leon Jacobs, Jr., et al.,...

Affirmation of Denial of Postconviction Relief in Dennis SOCHOR v. STATE of Florida

Date: Sep 22, 2004

Affirmation of Denial of Postconviction Relief in Dennis SOCHOR v. STATE of Florida Introduction In Dennis SOCHOR v. STATE of Florida, reported at 883 So. 2d 766, the Supreme Court of Florida...

Res Judicata and Successive Foreclosure Actions: Florida Supreme Court's Decision in SINGLETON v. GREYMAR ASSOCiates

Date: Sep 16, 2004

Res Judicata and Successive Foreclosure Actions: Florida Supreme Court's Decision in SINGLETON v. GREYMAR ASSOCiates Introduction The legal landscape surrounding foreclosure actions in Florida...

Clarifying Jurisdictional Boundaries: R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co. v. Kenyon

Date: Sep 3, 2004

Clarifying Jurisdictional Boundaries: R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Co. v. Kenyon Introduction In the landmark case of R.J. Reynolds Tobacco Company v. Florence Kenyon, 882 So.2d 986 (Fla. 2004), the Supreme...

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Felony Murder with Multiple Aggravating Factors: Chamberlain v. State

Date: Sep 2, 2004

Affirmation of Death Sentence in Felony Murder with Multiple Aggravating Factors: Chamberlain v. State Introduction In the case of John Chamberlain v. State of Florida (881 So. 2d 1087), the Supreme...

Strict Construction of 'Unrelated Works' Exception in Florida Workers' Compensation Law: Taylor v. School Board of Brevard County

Date: Aug 20, 2004

Strict Construction of 'Unrelated Works' Exception in Florida Workers' Compensation Law: Taylor v. School Board of Brevard County Introduction Lawrence Taylor v. School Board of Brevard County is a...

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Rule: Habeas Corpus Petitions by Noncapital Defendants Must Comply with Rule 3.850

Date: Jul 16, 2004

Florida Supreme Court Establishes Rule: Habeas Corpus Petitions by Noncapital Defendants Must Comply with Rule 3.850 Introduction The case of DARRELL BAKER, Petitioner, v. STATE OF FLORIDA,...

Classification of Writ Petitions as Collateral Criminal Proceedings under Florida's Prisoner Indigency Statute: Schmidt v. Crusoe

Date: Jul 15, 2004

Classification of Writ Petitions as Collateral Criminal Proceedings under Florida's Prisoner Indigency Statute: Schmidt v. Crusoe Introduction In the landmark case of Schmidt v. Crusoe, the Supreme...