8th Circuit Case Commentaries

ERISA Exhaustion Requirement Excused by Prudential’s Failure to Provide Adequate Information: Brown v. J.B. Hunt Transport Services, Inc.

Date: Nov 18, 2009

ERISA Exhaustion Requirement Excused by Prudential’s Failure to Provide Adequate Information: Brown v. J.B. Hunt Transport Services, Inc. Introduction In the landmark case of Barbara Brown v. J.B....

Affirmation of District Court's Interpretation of Anti-Forfeiture Provisions in NFL Antitrust Settlement

Date: Nov 11, 2009

Affirmation of District Court's Interpretation of Anti-Forfeiture Provisions in NFL Antitrust Settlement Introduction The case of Reggie White, Michael Buck, Hardy Hardy Nickerson, Vann McElroy, Dave...

Eighth Circuit Upholds Missouri’s Lethal Injection Protocol Amid Eighth Amendment Challenges

Date: Nov 11, 2009

Eighth Circuit Upholds Missouri’s Lethal Injection Protocol Amid Eighth Amendment Challenges Introduction The case of Reginald Clemons et al. v. Larry Crawford et al. (2009) presented a critical...

Clarifying Police Obligations and Qualified Immunity: Nance v. Sammis

Date: Nov 11, 2009

Clarifying Police Obligations and Qualified Immunity: Nance v. Sammis Introduction The case of Unseld NANCE, Sr., individually and as the natural father and next friend of Unseld Nance, Jr.; Pamela...

Procedural Default in Federal Habeas Review of Civil Commitment on Indian Reservations

Date: Oct 9, 2009

Procedural Default in Federal Habeas Review of Civil Commitment on Indian Reservations Introduction The case of Wallace James Beaulieu v. State of Minnesota (583 F.3d 570) delves into the...

Affirmation of Sentencing Enhancements and Strict Criteria for Withdrawing Guilty Pleas in Davis v. United States

Date: Oct 9, 2009

Affirmation of Sentencing Enhancements and Strict Criteria for Withdrawing Guilty Pleas in Davis v. United States Introduction Davis v. United States (583 F.3d 1081) is a significant appellate case...

Defining Qualified Immunity and Duty to Intervene in Excessive Force Cases: Krout v. Estate of Rylee

Date: Oct 7, 2009

Defining Qualified Immunity and Duty to Intervene in Excessive Force Cases: Krout v. Estate of Rylee Introduction The case of Sandy Krout v. Dually and as Administratrix of the Estate of Bobby Joe...

Affirmation of Arbitration Agreements in Consumer Contracts Under the Federal Arbitration Act: Cicle v. Chase Bank USA

Date: Oct 7, 2009

Affirmation of Arbitration Agreements in Consumer Contracts Under the Federal Arbitration Act: Cicle v. Chase Bank USA Introduction In Cicle v. Chase Bank USA, 583 F.3d 549 (8th Cir. 2009), the...

Use of Restraints on Pregnant Inmates During Labor: Eighth Amendment Implications

Date: Oct 3, 2009

Use of Restraints on Pregnant Inmates During Labor: Eighth Amendment Implications Introduction The case of Shawanna NELSON v. CORRECTIONAL Medical Services addresses the critical issue of whether the...

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Cook v. City of Bella Villa: Standards for Excessive Force Claims

Date: Oct 3, 2009

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Cook v. City of Bella Villa: Standards for Excessive Force Claims Introduction Cooks v. City of Bella Villa is a significant appellate decision from the United...

United States v. Stymiest: Clarifying Indian Status Determination under the Indian Major Crimes Act

Date: Sep 23, 2009

United States v. Stymiest: Clarifying Indian Status Determination under the Indian Major Crimes Act Introduction United States v. Matthew David Stymiest (581 F.3d 759, 8th Cir. 2009) is a pivotal...

Amendment 706's Inapplicability to Career Offenders under USSG §4B1.1: United States v. Collier

Date: Sep 22, 2009

Amendment 706's Inapplicability to Career Offenders under USSG §4B1.1: United States v. Collier Introduction In the landmark case of United States of America v. Robert E. Collier, 581 F.3d 755 (8th...

Establishing the Duty of FAA Flight Service Specialists in Weather Briefings: GLORVIGEN v. CIRRUS DESIGN CORPORATION

Date: Sep 17, 2009

Establishing the Duty of FAA Flight Service Specialists in Weather Briefings: GLORVIGEN v. CIRRUS DESIGN CORPORATION Introduction The case of Rick Glorvigen, as Trustee for the Next of Kin of...

Enforcement of Arbitration Clauses by Nonsignatories: The Donaldson Company v. Burroughs Diesel Decision

Date: Sep 17, 2009

Enforcement of Arbitration Clauses by Nonsignatories: The Donaldson Company v. Burroughs Diesel Decision Introduction The case of Donaldson Company, Inc. v. Burroughs Diesel, Inc., reported at 581...

Ke v. Williams: Section 301 Preemption in NFL Drug Policy Enforcement

Date: Sep 12, 2009

Ke v. Williams: Section 301 Preemption in NFL Drug Policy Enforcement Introduction The case Ke v. Williams (582 F.3d 863, United States Court of Appeals, Eighth Circuit, 2009) addresses significant...

Eighth Circuit Establishes Boundaries of RLUIPA and State Sovereign Immunity in Inmate Religious Rights Claims

Date: Sep 11, 2009

Eighth Circuit Establishes Boundaries of RLUIPA and State Sovereign Immunity in Inmate Religious Rights Claims Introduction In the landmark case of James Dean Van Wyhe v. Tim Reisch et al. (581 F.3d...

Reconciling Affirmative Action Policies and Title VII: Insights from Humphries v. Pulaski County Special School District

Date: Sep 4, 2009

Reconciling Affirmative Action Policies and Title VII: Insights from Humphries v. Pulaski County Special School District Introduction Humphries v. Pulaski County Special School District is a pivotal...

Eighth Circuit Reinforces Weight of Treating Physician’s Opinion in Disability Claims

Date: Sep 2, 2009

Eighth Circuit Reinforces Weight of Treating Physician’s Opinion in Disability Claims Introduction The case of Jill Tilley v. Michael J. Astrue, Commissioner of Social Security Administration...

Eighth Circuit Affirms Enhanced PSLRA Pleading Requirements for Securities Fraud Litigation in In re 2007 Novastar Financial Inc.

Date: Sep 2, 2009

Eighth Circuit Affirms Enhanced PSLRA Pleading Requirements for Securities Fraud Litigation in In re 2007 Novastar Financial Inc. Introduction The case of In re 2007 Novastar Financial Inc.,...

Strict Adherence to Prescribed Treatment as a Prerequisite for Disability Benefits: Brace v. Astrue

Date: Aug 28, 2009

Strict Adherence to Prescribed Treatment as a Prerequisite for Disability Benefits: Brace v. Astrue Introduction The case of Larry A. Brace v. Michael J. Astrue, decided by the United States Court of...