8th Circuit Case Commentaries

Exclusion of Unlawfully Present Aliens from Second Amendment Protections: Analysis of United States v. Sitladeen

Date: Apr 5, 2023

Exclusion of Unlawfully Present Aliens from Second Amendment Protections: Analysis of United States v. Sitladeen Introduction United States v. Sitladeen, 64 F.4th 978 (8th Cir. 2023), is a pivotal...

Affirmation of Remand in Minnesota v. Energy Companies: Jurisdictional Boundaries in Climate Litigation

Date: Mar 24, 2023

Affirmation of Remand in Minnesota v. Energy Companies: Jurisdictional Boundaries in Climate Litigation Introduction The case of State of Minnesota, by its Attorney General Keith Ellison v. American...

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Age Discrimination Case under ICRA and ADEA

Date: Mar 24, 2023

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Age Discrimination Case under ICRA and ADEA Introduction The case of Inge Smothers v. Rowley Masonic Assisted Living Community, LLC, adjudicated by the United...

Strict Supervision Maintained: Eighth Circuit Upholds Denial to Modify Internet Usage Conditions in Supervised Release

Date: Mar 14, 2023

Strict Supervision Maintained: Eighth Circuit Upholds Denial to Modify Internet Usage Conditions in Supervised Release Introduction In the appellate case United States of America v. James B. Norris,...

Dahle v. Kijakazi: Clarifying the Scope of the Federal Vacancies Reform Act in SSA Leadership Appointments

Date: Mar 8, 2023

Dahle v. Kijakazi: Clarifying the Scope of the Federal Vacancies Reform Act in SSA Leadership Appointments Introduction In the landmark case Brian T. Dahle Plaintiff - Appellee v. Kilolo Kijakazi,...

Affirming Objective Reasonableness in Traffic Stops and Extensions: United States v. Rutledge

Date: Mar 4, 2023

Affirming Objective Reasonableness in Traffic Stops and Extensions: United States v. Rutledge Introduction The case of United States of America Plaintiff - Appellee v. James Rutledge...

Noncompetition Agreements and Employment Contracts: Eighth Circuit Clarifies Integration Clause Scope in Core and Main, LP v. McCabe

Date: Mar 2, 2023

Noncompetition Agreements and Employment Contracts: Eighth Circuit Clarifies Integration Clause Scope in Core and Main, LP v. McCabe Introduction In Core and Main, LP Plaintiff - Appellant v. Ron...

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Bell v. Baptist Health: Implications for Sex Discrimination and Hostile Work Environment Claims

Date: Mar 1, 2023

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Bell v. Baptist Health: Implications for Sex Discrimination and Hostile Work Environment Claims Introduction In the case of Courtnay Bell Plaintiff - Appellant v....

Permissibility of Information and Belief Pleadings in Trade Secret Misappropriation: Ahern Rentals v. EquipmentShare

Date: Feb 8, 2023

Permissibility of Information and Belief Pleadings in Trade Secret Misappropriation: Ahern Rentals v. EquipmentShare Introduction In the landmark case of Ahern Rentals, Inc. v. EquipmentShare.com,...

FECA Does Not Preempt State Consumer Protection Investigations of PAC Fundraising Practices

Date: Feb 8, 2023

FECA Does Not Preempt State Consumer Protection Investigations of PAC Fundraising Practices Introduction The case of WinRed, Inc. v. Keith M. Ellison addresses the intersection of federal election...

Qualified Immunity Affirmed for Law Enforcement and Correctional Staff in Use of Force and Medical Neglect Cases

Date: Feb 4, 2023

Qualified Immunity Affirmed for Law Enforcement and Correctional Staff in Use of Force and Medical Neglect Cases Introduction The case of Jamie Leonard Plaintiff - Appellant v. St. Charles County...

Affirmation of Rule 410 Waiver and Evidentiary Standards in Enticement of a Minor: United States v. Hahn

Date: Jan 27, 2023

Affirmation of Rule 410 Waiver and Evidentiary Standards in Enticement of a Minor: United States v. Hahn Introduction In the landmark case United States of America v. Jeremy Spencer Hahn, adjudicated...

Strengthened Standards for Qualified Immunity in Probation-Related Searches: Dennis Ryno v. City of Waynesville

Date: Jan 27, 2023

Strengthened Standards for Qualified Immunity in Probation-Related Searches: Dennis Ryno v. City of Waynesville Introduction In the landmark case of Dennis Ryno v. City of Waynesville, decided by the...

8th Circuit Reverses Preliminary Injunction in H&R Block v. Block Inc., Emphasizing Burden of Proof for Likelihood of Confusion

Date: Jan 25, 2023

8th Circuit Reverses Preliminary Injunction in H&R Block v. Block Inc., Emphasizing Burden of Proof for Likelihood of Confusion Introduction In the landmark case H&R Block, Inc.; HRB Innovations,...

Affirmation of Qualified Immunity in Police Use of Pepper Spray During Protests: Laney v. City of St. Louis

Date: Jan 7, 2023

Affirmation of Qualified Immunity in Police Use of Pepper Spray During Protests: Laney v. City of St. Louis Introduction Derek Laney v. City of St. Louis, Missouri is a significant case adjudicated...

Eighth Circuit Affirms RFRA Protections for Religious Healthcare Providers under ACA's Section 1557, Limits Associational Standing

Date: Dec 10, 2022

Eighth Circuit Affirms RFRA Protections for Religious Healthcare Providers under ACA's Section 1557, Limits Associational Standing Introduction In the landmark case The Religious Sisters of Mercy;...

Functionality Doctrine Strengthened in Trade Dress Infringement: Pocket Plus, LLC v. Pike Brands, LLC

Date: Nov 16, 2022

Functionality Doctrine Strengthened in Trade Dress Infringement: Pocket Plus, LLC v. Pike Brands, LLC Introduction The case of Pocket Plus, LLC v. Pike Brands, LLC, decided on November 15, 2022, by...

Establishing the Persuasiveness Standard for Medical Opinions in Social Security Disability Appeals: Austin v. Kijakazi

Date: Nov 2, 2022

Establishing the Persuasiveness Standard for Medical Opinions in Social Security Disability Appeals: Austin v. Kijakazi Introduction Austin v. Kijakazi (52 F.4th 723, 2022) is a significant appellate...

Necessity of Meaningful Benchmarks in Fiduciary Duty Claims: 8th Circuit Affirms Dismissal in MidAmerican Energy Case

Date: Oct 13, 2022

Necessity of Meaningful Benchmarks in Fiduciary Duty Claims: 8th Circuit Affirms Dismissal in MidAmerican Energy Case Introduction In the case of Daniel C. Matousek, individually and on behalf of all...

Constructive Possession Standards Clarified in United States v. Spencer

Date: Oct 7, 2022

Constructive Possession Standards Clarified in United States v. Spencer Introduction United States of America Plaintiff - Appellee v. Donnie Spencer Defendant-Appellant, adjudicated by the United...