7th Circuit Case Commentaries

Seventh Circuit Upholds Strict Criteria for Compassionate Release: United States v. Hanson

Date: Dec 19, 2024

Seventh Circuit Upholds Strict Criteria for Compassionate Release: United States v. Hanson Introduction In United States of America v. James B. Hanson, the United States Court of Appeals for the...

Corcoran v. Neal: Affirmation of Denial of Habeas Petition and Stay of Execution

Date: Dec 19, 2024

Corcoran v. Neal: Affirmation of Denial of Habeas Petition and Stay of Execution Introduction Corcoran v. Neal is a pivotal case adjudicated by the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh...

Affirmation of Substantial Evidence Standard in Disability Determinations: Schmitz v. Colvin

Date: Dec 19, 2024

Affirmation of Substantial Evidence Standard in Disability Determinations: Schmitz v. Colvin Introduction In the case of Amra E. Schmitz v. Carolyn W. Colvin, the Plaintiff-Appellant, Amra Schmitz,...

Clarifying Deliberate Indifference in Prison Medical Care: The Bean v. Marthakis Decision

Date: Dec 19, 2024

Clarifying Deliberate Indifference in Prison Medical Care: The Bean v. Marthakis Decision Introduction The case of Joshua Bean v. Nancy Marthakis et al. presents a significant examination of the...

Probable Cause as an Absolute Bar in False Arrest and Malicious Prosecution Claims: Insights from Lynch v. United States of America

Date: Dec 9, 2024

Probable Cause as an Absolute Bar in False Arrest and Malicious Prosecution Claims: Insights from Lynch v. United States of America Introduction In the case of Kathy L. Lynch v. United States of...

Upholding Rule 11: Sanctioning Frivolous and Harassing Litigation in Eberhardt v. Walsh

Date: Dec 9, 2024

Upholding Rule 11: Sanctioning Frivolous and Harassing Litigation in Eberhardt v. Walsh Introduction Stephen E. Eberhardt, an attorney with a history of litigating against the Village of Tinley Park...

Retroactive Transformation of Preliminary Injunctions Unauthorised Under PLRA: Monroe v. Bowman

Date: Dec 9, 2024

Retroactive Transformation of Preliminary Injunctions Unauthorised Under PLRA: Monroe v. Bowman Introduction Monroe, et al. v. Bowman, et al. is a significant appellate decision from the United...

Seventh Circuit Upholds Rooker-Feldman Doctrine in Ruling Against §1983 Claims

Date: Dec 9, 2024

Seventh Circuit Upholds Rooker-Feldman Doctrine in Ruling Against §1983 Claims Introduction In the case of Ali R. Muhammad v. Lone Star Funds, et al., the United States Court of Appeals for the...

Strict FTCA Pre‑Suit Presentment Reaffirmed: DOJ/OIG or Attorney General Contacts Do Not Satisfy § 2675; Pro Se Hardship Is Not an Excuse

Date: Dec 5, 2024

Strict FTCA Pre‑Suit Presentment Reaffirmed: DOJ/OIG or Attorney General Contacts Do Not Satisfy § 2675; Pro Se Hardship Is Not an Excuse Introduction In a nonprecedential disposition issued on...

Compassionate Release Is Not a Vehicle to Challenge Sentence Validity: Seventh Circuit Affirms Denial and Highlights the 10‑Year Gate in U.S.S.G. § 1B1.13(b)(6)

Date: Dec 5, 2024

Compassionate Release Is Not a Vehicle to Challenge Sentence Validity: Seventh Circuit Affirms Denial and Highlights the 10‑Year Gate in U.S.S.G. § 1B1.13(b)(6) Introduction In United States v....

No Rule 56(f) Notice When Issues Are Teed Up; Civil Detainee Privilege Limits Survive Under Both Sandin and Youngberg; Medical-Care Claims Require Objective Unreasonableness

Date: Dec 4, 2024

No Rule 56(f) Notice When Issues Are Teed Up; Civil Detainee Privilege Limits Survive Under Both Sandin and Youngberg; Medical-Care Claims Require Objective Unreasonableness Introduction This...

“Same Claim” Under 29 C.F.R. § 1614.107 Requires More Than the Same Employment Practice; Premature Federal-Employee Title VII Suits Are Cured by Later Right-to-Sue Notices

Date: Dec 4, 2024

“Same Claim” Under 29 C.F.R. § 1614.107 Requires More Than the Same Employment Practice; Premature Federal-Employee Title VII Suits Are Cured by Later Right-to-Sue Notices Introduction In Mary F....

Appeal Waivers Control: Seventh Circuit Dismisses Anders Appeal, Upholds Upward Variance, and Treats Declined Continuance as Waiver of Late Victim-Impact Notice Objections

Date: Dec 4, 2024

Appeal Waivers Control: Seventh Circuit Dismisses Anders Appeal, Upholds Upward Variance, and Treats Declined Continuance as Waiver of Late Victim-Impact Notice Objections Introduction In a...

Unsanitary Cells and John Doe Defendants: Seventh Circuit Clarifies Pleading Standards and Relation-Back in Prison Conditions Cases

Date: Dec 4, 2024

Unsanitary Cells and John Doe Defendants: Seventh Circuit Clarifies Pleading Standards and Relation-Back in Prison Conditions Cases Case: Titus v. Gomez, No. 24-1714 (7th Cir. Dec. 3, 2024)...

Deference to Medical Judgment in Prison Healthcare: Denial of Plastic‑Surgery Referral and Gabapentin for Pseudo‑Gynecomastia Is Not Deliberate Indifference

Date: Dec 4, 2024

Deference to Medical Judgment in Prison Healthcare: Denial of Plastic‑Surgery Referral and Gabapentin for Pseudo‑Gynecomastia Is Not Deliberate Indifference Case: Joe’vone M. Jordan v. Laura Sukowaty...

Totality-of-Care Defeats Deliberate Indifference; Post-Transfer Claims Must Be Grieved Through Facility Counselor (Buck v. Connors-Johnson)

Date: Dec 4, 2024

Totality-of-Care Defeats Deliberate Indifference; Post-Transfer Claims Must Be Grieved Through Facility Counselor Case: Buck v. Connors-Johnson, et al., No. 23-3128 (7th Cir. Dec. 3, 2024)...

Affirmation of Within-Guidelines Sentencing in United States v. Logeman

Date: Nov 28, 2024

Affirmation of Within-Guidelines Sentencing in United States v. Logeman Introduction In the case of United States of America v. Jonathan Alexander L. Logeman, the United States Court of Appeals for...

Limits on Successive 28 U.S.C. § 2255 Petitions: Insights from United States v. McGee

Date: Nov 25, 2024

Limits on Successive 28 U.S.C. § 2255 Petitions: Insights from United States v. McGee Introduction The case of United States of America v. Terrell McGee addresses crucial aspects of postconviction...

Comparable Evidence Sufficiency in Prison Disciplinary Proceedings: An Analysis of Downey v. Garza

Date: Nov 25, 2024

Comparable Evidence Sufficiency in Prison Disciplinary Proceedings: An Analysis of Downey v. Garza Introduction The case of Tyrenace D. Downey v. Fernando Garza presents a pivotal examination of due...

Affirmation of Standing Requirements in Bankruptcy Appeals: Young v. Lake County Treasurer

Date: Nov 25, 2024

Affirmation of Standing Requirements in Bankruptcy Appeals: Young v. Lake County Treasurer A Comprehensive Commentary on the Seventh Circuit's Decision Introduction In the case of Andrew L. Young v....