7th Circuit Case Commentaries

Strict Adherence to Diversity Jurisdiction Requirements in Tylka v. Gerber Products

Date: May 2, 2000

Strict Adherence to Diversity Jurisdiction Requirements in Tylka v. Gerber Products Company Introduction Tylka J. Tylka, H. Joshua Chaet, Cheryl Keller, et al., Plaintiffs-Appellants, v. Gerber...

Refining Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Under 28 U.S.C. §2255: Insights from Fountain v. United States

Date: May 2, 2000

Refining Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Under 28 U.S.C. §2255: Insights from Fountain v. United States Introduction Fountain v. United States, 211 F.3d 429 (7th Cir. 2000), presents a nuanced...

Limitations on Title VII Sexual Harassment Claims: The Equal Opportunity Harasser Doctrine Established in Holman v. Indiana Department of Transportation

Date: May 2, 2000

Limitations on Title VII Sexual Harassment Claims: The Equal Opportunity Harasser Doctrine Established in Holman v. Indiana Department of Transportation Introduction Holman v. State of Indiana and...

Ensuring Complete Diversity and Fee-Shifting Compliance: Insights from Garbie v. DaimlerChrysler Corp.

Date: May 2, 2000

Ensuring Complete Diversity and Fee-Shifting Compliance: Insights from Garbie v. DaimlerChrysler Corp. Introduction The case of Craig GARBIE, et al., Plaintiffs-Appellees, v. DAIMLERCHRYSLER CORP.,...

Discrimination Claims Require Similarly Situated Employees: Spath v. Hayes Wheels International

Date: May 2, 2000

Discrimination Claims Require Similarly Situated Employees: Spath v. Hayes Wheels International Introduction Spath v. Hayes Wheels International-Indiana, Inc., 211 F.3d 392 (7th Cir. 2000), is a...

Abuse of Discretion Standard Established for Remand in Social Security Disability Cases

Date: Apr 28, 2000

Abuse of Discretion Standard Established for Remand in Social Security Disability Cases Introduction Case: Linnie Nelson, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Kenneth S. Apfel, Commissioner of Social Security,...

Estoppel and Administrative Exhaustion in ERISA Claims: Gallegos v. Mt. Sinai Medical Center

Date: Apr 28, 2000

Estoppel and Administrative Exhaustion in ERISA Claims: Gallegos v. Mt. Sinai Medical Center Introduction Rita Moreno Gallegos v. Mt. Sinai Medical Center and Unum Life Insurance Company of America...

Arbitration Clauses in Commodity Contracts: Insights from Harter v. Iowa Grain Co.

Date: Apr 22, 2000

Arbitration Clauses in Commodity Contracts: Insights from Harter v. Iowa Grain Co. Introduction The case of Lowell E. Harter and Doretta Harter v. Iowa Grain Co., et al. (220 F.3d 544) adjudicated by...

Equal Protection and the Right to Petition: Insights from Hilton v. City of Wheeling

Date: Apr 21, 2000

Equal Protection and the Right to Petition: Insights from Hilton v. City of Wheeling Introduction Hilton v. City of Wheeling, 209 F.3d 1005 (7th Cir. 2000), serves as a significant case in...

Effective Remedial Action under Title VII: Analysis of Tutman v. WBBM-TV, Inc./CBS, Inc.

Date: Apr 21, 2000

Effective Remedial Action under Title VII: Analysis of Tutman v. WBBM-TV, Inc./CBS, Inc. Introduction Tutman v. WBBM-TV, Inc./CBS, Inc., 209 F.3d 1044 (7th Cir. 2000), is a pivotal case addressing...

Interpreting 'Net Worth' under FDCPA: Book Value vs. Fair Market Value

Date: Apr 21, 2000

Interpreting 'Net Worth' under FDCPA: Book Value vs. Fair Market Value Introduction The case of Michelle Sanders v. Universal Fidelity Corporation addresses a pivotal issue under the Fair Debt...

Seventh Circuit Affirms Dismissal of Section 1983 Conspiracy Claims in Cefalu v. Village of Elk Grove

Date: Apr 14, 2000

Seventh Circuit Affirms Dismissal of Section 1983 Conspiracy Claims in Cefalu v. Village of Elk Grove Introduction In the landmark case of Cefalu v. Village of Elk Grove, decided on April 13, 2000,...

Eleventh Amendment Immunity and County Officers: Insights from DeGenova v. Sheriff of DuPage County

Date: Apr 14, 2000

Eleventh Amendment Immunity and County Officers: Insights from DeGenova v. Sheriff of DuPage County Introduction The case of Mario DeGenova v. Sheriff of DuPage County, 209 F.3d 973 (7th Cir. 2000),...

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Title VII Discrimination and Retaliation Claims: Maarouf v. Walker Manufacturing Company

Date: Apr 13, 2000

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Title VII Discrimination and Retaliation Claims: Maarouf v. Walker Manufacturing Company Introduction Jamal M. Maarouf, the Plaintiff-Appellant, brought forth a...

Limits on Public Employment Conditions and the Protection of Attorney-Client Privilege: Denious v. Dunlap

Date: Apr 12, 2000

Limits on Public Employment Conditions and the Protection of Attorney-Client Privilege: Denious v. Dunlap Introduction In the case of Ronald C. Denious v. Wayne Dunlap and Gary Sadler, decided by the...

Eleventh Amendment Immunity Reinforced for State Entities under the ADA: Insights from Stevens v. Illinois Department of Transportation

Date: Apr 12, 2000

Eleventh Amendment Immunity Reinforced for State Entities under the ADA: Insights from Stevens v. Illinois Department of Transportation Introduction The case of Georgeen Stevens v. Illinois...

Reallocation of Burden of Proof in FMLA Termination Cases: Rice v. Sunrise Express

Date: Apr 8, 2000

Reallocation of Burden of Proof in FMLA Termination Cases: Rice v. Sunrise Express Introduction Rice v. Sunrise Express, Incorporated, Gainey Corporation, and Sunrise U.S.A., Incorporated, 209 F.3d...

Specific Phobia and ADA Disability Status: Comprehensive Analysis of Sinkler v. Midwest Property Management LLC

Date: Apr 7, 2000

Specific Phobia and ADA Disability Status: Comprehensive Analysis of Sinkler v. Midwest Property Management LLC Introduction The case of Staceen M. Sinkler v. Midwest Property Management Limited...

Age Discrimination in Reductions in Force: Insights from Michas v. Health Cost Controls of Illinois

Date: Apr 7, 2000

Age Discrimination in Reductions in Force: Insights from Michas v. Health Cost Controls of Illinois Introduction The case of Christopher J. Michas v. Health Cost Controls of Illinois, Inc., decided...

Exigent Circumstances in Warrantless Home Searches: Analysis of United States v. Richardson

Date: Apr 4, 2000

Exigent Circumstances in Warrantless Home Searches: Analysis of United States v. Richardson Introduction In United States of America v. Clarence Richardson, Jr., 208 F.3d 626 (7th Cir. 2000), the...