7th Circuit Case Commentaries

Loeb Industries v. Sumitomo: New Precedents on Direct Purchaser Standing in Antitrust Market Manipulation Cases

Date: Sep 21, 2002

Loeb Industries v. Sumitomo: New Precedents on Direct Purchaser Standing in Antitrust Market Manipulation Cases Introduction The case of Loeb Industries, Inc., et al. v. Sumitomo Corporation and...

Affirming Retaliation Protections Under Title VII: Fine v. Ryan International Airlines

Date: Sep 20, 2002

Affirming Retaliation Protections Under Title VII: Fine v. Ryan International Airlines Introduction The case of Lisa S. Fine v. Ryan International Airlines (305 F.3d 746) represents a pivotal moment...

Seventh Circuit Upholds Dismissal of Retaliation Claims and Sanctions for Frivolous 42 U.S.C. §1983 Suit in Tierney v. Vahle and Olson

Date: Sep 19, 2002

Seventh Circuit Upholds Dismissal of Retaliation Claims and Sanctions for Frivolous 42 U.S.C. §1983 Suit in Tierney v. Vahle and Olson Introduction The case of J. Robert Tierney et al. v. Chet W....

Enforceability of Arbitral Agreements in At-Will Employment: Insights from Tinder v. Pinkerton Security

Date: Sep 18, 2002

Enforceability of Arbitral Agreements in At-Will Employment: Insights from Tinder v. Pinkerton Security Introduction The case of Ilah M. Tinder v. Pinkerton Security, decided by the United States...

Seventh Circuit Expands Rooker-Feldman Doctrine: Independent § 1983 Claims in Child Custody Removals

Date: Sep 14, 2002

Seventh Circuit Expands Rooker-Feldman Doctrine: Independent § 1983 Claims in Child Custody Removals Introduction The case of A.D. Brokaw v. Karen Weaver, Mercer County, State of Illinois, et al....

Sonnleitner v. York: Establishing Procedural Due Process in Employment Demotions

Date: Sep 13, 2002

Sonnleitner v. York: Establishing Procedural Due Process in Employment Demotions Introduction Parties Involved: Harold E. Sonnleitner (Plaintiff-Appellant) vs. Stanley York, Joann O'Connor, Kathleen...

Voluntariness of Juvenile Confessions Under Totality of Circumstances: The Hardaway Decision

Date: Sep 12, 2002

Voluntariness of Juvenile Confessions Under Totality of Circumstances: The Hardaway Decision Introduction The case of Derrick Hardaway v. Donald S. Young (302 F.3d 757) presents a pivotal examination...

Reaffirming Summary Judgment Standards in Employment Discrimination: Insights from Jones v. Union Pacific Railroad Co.

Date: Sep 11, 2002

Reaffirming Summary Judgment Standards in Employment Discrimination: Insights from Jones v. Union Pacific Railroad Co. Introduction The case of Glenn E. Jones v. Union Pacific Railroad Company,...

ERISA Preemption Does Not Bar State Common Law Fraud Claims Against Plan Participants: Analysis of Trustees of AFTRA Health Fund v. Richard Biondi

Date: Sep 7, 2002

ERISA Preemption Does Not Bar State Common Law Fraud Claims Against Plan Participants: Analysis of Trustees of AFTRA Health Fund v. Richard Biondi Introduction The case of Trustees of the AFTRA...

Reasonable Accommodation Under the Rehabilitation Act: Insights from Maxcene MAYS v. Principi

Date: Sep 6, 2002

Reasonable Accommodation Under the Rehabilitation Act: Insights from Maxcene MAYS v. Principi Introduction The case of Maxcene MAYS v. Anthony J. PRINCIPI, Secretary of Veterans Affairs, 301 F.3d 866...

Hyatt International Corp. v. Gerardo Coco: Expanding Personal Jurisdiction Over Foreign Entities in International Business Transactions

Date: Sep 4, 2002

Hyatt International Corp. v. Gerardo Coco: Expanding Personal Jurisdiction Over Foreign Entities in International Business Transactions Introduction In Hyatt International Corp., et al. v. Gerardo...

Del v. Payton: Affirming the Juridical Link Doctrine in Class Action Suits Against Multiple Counties

Date: Sep 4, 2002

Del v. Payton: Affirming the Juridical Link Doctrine in Class Action Suits Against Multiple Counties Introduction In the landmark case Del v. Payton, et al., decided by the United States Court of...

Affirmation of Qualified and Absolute Immunity in DCFS Due Process Claims

Date: Aug 31, 2002

Affirmation of Qualified and Absolute Immunity in DCFS Due Process Claims Introduction Elizabeth Doyle v. Camelot Care Centers, Incorporated is a landmark case adjudicated by the United States Court...

Restricting the Scope of Arbitration Clauses: Insights from Welborn Clinic v. MedQuist, Inc.

Date: Aug 30, 2002

Restricting the Scope of Arbitration Clauses: Insights from Welborn Clinic v. MedQuist, Inc. Introduction The case of Welborn Clinic v. MedQuist, Inc. (301 F.3d 634, Seventh Circuit, 2002) presents a...

United States v. Mansoori et al.: Affirming Conspiracy Convictions Amid Sentencing Reforms on Wiretap Minimization and Jury Anonymity

Date: Aug 30, 2002

United States v. Mansoori et al.: Affirming Conspiracy Convictions Amid Sentencing Reforms on Wiretap Minimization and Jury Anonymity Introduction In the case of United States of America v. Bahman...

Seventh Circuit Sets New Precedent on Sentencing Guidelines §3B1.4 and §851(a) Non-Jurisdictional Status in Drug Conspiracy Cases

Date: Aug 28, 2002

Seventh Circuit Sets New Precedent on Sentencing Guidelines §3B1.4 and §851(a) Non-Jurisdictional Status in Drug Conspiracy Cases Introduction In the landmark case United States of America v. Alfredo...

Employee Threshold Requirements for Title VII Claims: Insights from Stinnett v. Executive Health Spa

Date: Aug 27, 2002

Employee Threshold Requirements for Title VII Claims: Insights from Stinnett v. Executive Health Spa Introduction Stinnett v. Iron Works Gym/Executive Health Spa, Inc., 301 F.3d 610 (7th Cir. 2002),...

Eleventh Amendment Protections: State Sovereign Immunity in Bankruptcy Adversary Proceedings – In re Coralynn F. Nelson

Date: Aug 24, 2002

Eleventh Amendment Protections: State Sovereign Immunity in Bankruptcy Adversary Proceedings – In re Coralynn F. Nelson Introduction The case of In re Coralynn F. Nelson addresses the pivotal issue...

Fritcher v. Health Care Service Corporation: Affirming Plenary Judicial Review under ERISA

Date: Aug 24, 2002

Fritcher v. Health Care Service Corporation: Affirming Plenary Judicial Review under ERISA Introduction In the landmark case of Mark Fritcher and Country Trust Bank v. Health Care Service...

Establishing Jurisdictional Standards for Removal and the Enforceability of Arbitration Awards in Diversity Cases

Date: Aug 21, 2002

Establishing Jurisdictional Standards for Removal and the Enforceability of Arbitration Awards in Diversity Cases Introduction The case of BEM I, L.L.C. v. Anthropologie, Inc., 301 F.3d 548 (7th Cir....