7th Circuit Case Commentaries

Reassessment of Excessive Force Claims under Eighth Amendment in Federal Prison Transfers

Date: Feb 19, 2004

Reassessment of Excessive Force Claims under Eighth Amendment in Federal Prison Transfers Introduction The case of Aaron Fillmore v. Thomas F. Page et al., adjudicated by the United States Court of...

Equitable Tolling Unavailable for § 2255 Motions: Nolan v. United States

Date: Feb 19, 2004

Equitable Tolling Unavailable for § 2255 Motions: Nolan v. United States Introduction Case: Leroy Nolan, Petitioner-Appellant, v. United States of America, Respondent-Appellee. Court: United States...

Summary Judgment Affirmed in Hrobowski v. Worthington Steel: Hostile Work Environment Claims Under Title VII and 42 U.S.C. § 1981

Date: Feb 18, 2004

Summary Judgment Affirmed in Hrobowski v. Worthington Steel: Hostile Work Environment Claims Under Title VII and 42 U.S.C. § 1981 Introduction In the case of William R. Hrobowski v. Worthington Steel...

AEDPA Reinforces Strict Limitations on Successive Collateral Attacks: Insights from Melton v. United States

Date: Feb 14, 2004

AEDPA Reinforces Strict Limitations on Successive Collateral Attacks: Insights from Melton v. United States Introduction The case of Timothy Melton v. United States, decided by the United States...

Substantial Evidence Upholds ALJ's Determination in Disability Claims: Scheck v. Barnhart

Date: Feb 6, 2004

Substantial Evidence Upholds ALJ's Determination in Disability Claims: Scheck v. Barnhart Introduction The case of Kenneth Scheck v. Jo Anne B. Barnhart, Commissioner of Social Security (357 F.3d...

Preemption and Labor Representation in RICO Claims: Baker & Enyeart v. IBP, Inc.

Date: Feb 5, 2004

Preemption and Labor Representation in RICO Claims: Baker & Enyeart v. IBP, Inc. Introduction In the case of Deborah Baker and Richard Enyeart v. IBP, Inc., decided by the United States Court of...

Defining Material Adversity in Age Discrimination and Retaliation Claims: Griffin v. Potter

Date: Feb 4, 2004

Defining Material Adversity in Age Discrimination and Retaliation Claims: Griffin v. Potter Introduction Griffin v. Potter, 356 F.3d 824 (7th Cir. 2004), is a pivotal case addressing the intricacies...

Impact of Competency Assessments and Effective Counsel in Death Penalty Sentencing: Analysis of Benefiel v. Davis

Date: Jan 31, 2004

Impact of Competency Assessments and Effective Counsel in Death Penalty Sentencing: Analysis of Benefiel v. Davis Introduction The case of Bill J. Benefiel v. Cecil Davis (357 F.3d 655) represents a...

Ma v. MIRFASIHI: Rejection of Class Action Settlement Excluding Information-Sharing Class

Date: Jan 30, 2004

Ma v. MIRFASIHI: Rejection of Class Action Settlement Excluding Information-Sharing Class Introduction The case of Ma v. MIRFASIHI, decided by the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh...

Strict Adherence to Rule 26(a)(2): Implications from Musser v. Gentiva Health Services on Expert Testimony in Medical Malpractice

Date: Jan 29, 2004

Strict Adherence to Rule 26(a)(2): Implications from Musser v. Gentiva Health Services on Expert Testimony in Medical Malpractice Introduction The case of Mischelle MUSSER and Michael Musser v....

Reversal of ALJ Decision: Proper Evaluation of Treating Physician's Opinions and Credibility in Social Security Disability Claims

Date: Jan 27, 2004

Reversal of ALJ Decision: Proper Evaluation of Treating Physician's Opinions and Credibility in Social Security Disability Claims Introduction The case of Andra Brown v. JoAnne Barnhart, adjudicated...

Capric v. Ashcroft: Reinforcing Credibility Assessments and Evidence Corroboration in Asylum Proceedings

Date: Jan 24, 2004

Capric v. Ashcroft: Reinforcing Credibility Assessments and Evidence Corroboration in Asylum Proceedings Introduction Capric v. Ashcroft, decided on January 23, 2004, by the United States Court of...

Separation and Responsibility: Equitable Doctrine of Piercing the Corporate Veil in International Financial Services Corp. v. Chromas Technologies Canada, Inc.

Date: Jan 24, 2004

Separation and Responsibility: Equitable Doctrine of Piercing the Corporate Veil in International Financial Services Corp. v. Chromas Technologies Canada, Inc. Introduction The case of International...

Seventh Circuit Upholds Reasonableness of Detentions in §1983 Claims for Minor Offenses

Date: Jan 24, 2004

Seventh Circuit Upholds Reasonableness of Detentions in §1983 Claims for Minor Offenses Introduction In Ste v. n CHORTEK et al., 356 F.3d 740 (7th Cir. 2004), the United States Court of Appeals for...

Reevaluation of Disability Determination Procedures: Barrett v. Barnhart

Date: Jan 23, 2004

Reevaluation of Disability Determination Procedures: Barrett v. Barnhart Introduction The case of Linda P. Barrett v. Jo Anne B. Barnhart, decided by the United States Court of Appeals for the...

7th Circuit Upholds Minors' First Amendment Rights by Striking Down Indiana's Curfew Law

Date: Jan 23, 2004

7th Circuit Upholds Minors' First Amendment Rights by Striking Down Indiana's Curfew Law Introduction In Hodgkins v. Peterson, 355 F.3d 1048 (7th Cir. 2004), the United States Court of Appeals for...

Seventh Circuit Upholds Mandatory Detention Under INA § 236(c) Despite Probationary Dispositions

Date: Jan 22, 2004

Seventh Circuit Upholds Mandatory Detention Under INA § 236(c) Despite Probationary Dispositions Introduction In the landmark case Carlos Gonzalez v. Cynthia J. O'Connell et al., 355 F.3d 1010 (7th...

Establishing the Standard for Legal Malpractice Damages in Bankruptcy Proceedings: Mungo v. Taylor

Date: Jan 21, 2004

Establishing the Standard for Legal Malpractice Damages in Bankruptcy Proceedings: Mungo v. Taylor Introduction The case of Marjorie L. Mungo v. Maureen Sullivan Taylor (355 F.3d 969) presents a...

Limitations on Remedies for ADA Retaliation Claims: Kramer v. Banc of America Securities

Date: Jan 21, 2004

Limitations on Remedies for ADA Retaliation Claims: Kramer v. Banc of America Securities Introduction In the case of Colleen P. Kramer v. Banc of America Securities, LLC, decided by the United States...

Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies in ERISA Plans: Stark v. PPM America

Date: Jan 10, 2004

Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies in ERISA Plans: Stark v. PPM America Introduction The case of F. John Stark III v. PPM America, Inc., PPM Holdings, Inc., and the Amended and Restated PPM...