7th Circuit Case Commentaries

Edwards v. Snyder: Reevaluating Frivolous Dismissals in Deliberate Indifference Claims Under the Eighth Amendment

Date: Mar 8, 2007

Edwards v. Snyder: Reevaluating Frivolous Dismissals in Deliberate Indifference Claims Under the Eighth Amendment 1. Introduction Wayne Edwards v. Donald N. Snyder, Jr., Director, Michael L. Holmes,...

Confrontation Clause and Hearsay Exceptions: Insights from VARELA v. UNITED STATES

Date: Feb 27, 2007

Confrontation Clause and Hearsay Exceptions: Insights from VARELA v. UNITED STATES Introduction Salome VARELA v. UNITED STATES of America, 481 F.3d 932 (7th Cir. 2007), presents a significant...

Seventh Circuit Limits Recovery of Post-Trial Costs Under Rule 54(d) While Affirming Appellate Costs Under Rule 39(e) in Republic Tobacco Co. v. North Atlantic Trading Co.

Date: Feb 23, 2007

Seventh Circuit Limits Recovery of Post-Trial Costs Under Rule 54(d) While Affirming Appellate Costs Under Rule 39(e) in Republic Tobacco Co. v. North Atlantic Trading Co. Introduction In the...

Enhanced Pleading Requirements Under FRCP 9(b): Analysis of Borsellino v. Goldman Sachs

Date: Feb 21, 2007

Enhanced Pleading Requirements Under FRCP 9(b): Analysis of Borsellino v. Goldman Sachs Introduction The case of Lewis Borsellino and I.M. Acquisitions, LLC v. Goldman Sachs Group, Inc., adjudicated...

Affirmation of Denied Intervention in ADA Class Action: Implications for Disability Rights Representation

Date: Feb 16, 2007

Affirmation of Denied Intervention in ADA Class Action: Implications for Disability Rights Representation Introduction The case of Stanley Ligas et al. v. Barry S. Maram et al. before the United...

Preserving Defendants' Statute of Limitations Defenses: Rule 41(a)(2) Voluntary Dismissal Guidelines

Date: Feb 16, 2007

Preserving Defendants' Statute of Limitations Defenses: Rule 41(a)(2) Voluntary Dismissal Guidelines Introduction The case Bonnie M. Wojtas and Richard J. Wojtas v. Capital Guardian Trust Company...

Affirmation of Effective Counsel in Plea Bargaining: Almonacid v. United States

Date: Feb 15, 2007

Affirmation of Effective Counsel in Plea Bargaining: Almonacid v. United States Introduction Juan Almonacid appealed his conviction for conspiracy to distribute and possess with intent to distribute...

7th Circuit Affirms Termination Clause Enforcement in SOUND OF MUSIC CO. v. 3M

Date: Feb 14, 2007

7th Circuit Affirms Termination Clause Enforcement in SOUND OF MUSIC CO. v. 3M Introduction The case of SOUND OF MUSIC CO., Plaintiff-Appellant, v. MINNESOTA MINING AND MANUFACTURING CO.,...

Affirming Summary Judgment Standards under the ADEA: Hemsworth v. Quotesmith.com

Date: Feb 9, 2007

Affirming Summary Judgment Standards under the ADEA: Hemsworth v. Quotesmith.com Introduction In the case of Willard L. Hemsworth, II v. Quotesmith.com, Inc., adjudicated by the United States Court...

Qualified Immunity Upholds Fourth Amendment Compliance in Mannoia v. Farrow

Date: Feb 8, 2007

Qualified Immunity Upholds Fourth Amendment Compliance in Mannoia v. Farrow Introduction The case of Jeffrey Mannoia v. David G. Farrow, adjudicated by the United States Court of Appeals for the...

Application of Federal Sentencing Guidelines and Offense Grouping in the Post-Booker Era: Insights from United States v. Spano, Schullo, and Maltese

Date: Feb 8, 2007

Application of Federal Sentencing Guidelines and Offense Grouping in the Post-Booker Era: Insights from United States v. Spano, Schullo, and Maltese Introduction The case of United States of America...

Affirmation of Prosecutorial Immunity and Dismissal of Frivolous Section 1983 and 1985 Claims in Redwood v. Dobson

Date: Feb 8, 2007

Affirmation of Prosecutorial Immunity and Dismissal of Frivolous Section 1983 and 1985 Claims in Redwood v. Dobson Introduction The case of Erik Redwood and Jude Redwood v. Elizabeth Dobson and...

Hearsay Admissibility in Defamation Cases: Insights from Schindler v. Seiler

Date: Feb 6, 2007

Hearsay Admissibility in Defamation Cases: Insights from Schindler v. Seiler Introduction Jay J. Schindler, a renowned medical professional, filed a defamation lawsuit against Joseph C. Seiler and...

Procedural Default and the Waiver of Ineffective Assistance Claims: Analysis of Michael Daniels v. Stanley Knight

Date: Feb 6, 2007

Procedural Default and the Waiver of Ineffective Assistance Claims: Analysis of Michael Daniels v. Stanley Knight Introduction Michael Daniels v. Stanley Knight (476 F.3d 426, 2007) is a pivotal case...

Enforcement of Forum Selection Clauses in International Joint Ventures: Abbott v. Takeda

Date: Feb 3, 2007

Enforcement of Forum Selection Clauses in International Joint Ventures: Abbott v. Takeda Introduction The case of Abbott Laboratories v. Takeda Pharmaceutical Company Limited (476 F.3d 421) addresses...

Enhanced Surveillance and Fourth Amendment Protections: Insights from United States v. Garcia

Date: Feb 3, 2007

Enhanced Surveillance and Fourth Amendment Protections: Insights from United States v. Garcia Introduction In United States v. Garcia, 474 F.3d 994 (7th Cir. 2007), the United States Court of Appeals...

Interpretation of Tolling Agreements: Tolling Defenses vs. Tolling the Statute of Limitations

Date: Feb 3, 2007

Interpretation of Tolling Agreements: Tolling Defenses vs. Tolling the Statute of Limitations Introduction The case of Camico Mutual Insurance Company v. Citizens Bank ([474 F.3d...

Federal Arbitration Act Interpretation in Volkswagen v. Sud's of Peoria: A Comprehensive Analysis

Date: Jan 30, 2007

Federal Arbitration Act Interpretation in Volkswagen v. Sud's of Peoria: A Comprehensive Analysis Introduction The case Volkswagen of America, Incorporated v. Sud's of Peoria, Incorporated,...

Affirmation of Employer's Affirmative Defense in Sexual Harassment Claims under Title VII

Date: Jan 26, 2007

Affirmation of Employer's Affirmative Defense in Sexual Harassment Claims under Title VII Introduction In the case of Brenda Jackson, Sherri Lisiecki, Patricia Birchell-Sielaff, and Estate of Linda...

Seventh Circuit Affirms Finality of Conditional Settlements under Rule 68 in Default Judgment Cases

Date: Jan 25, 2007

Seventh Circuit Affirms Finality of Conditional Settlements under Rule 68 in Default Judgment Cases Introduction In the case of Daniel Sims and Andrea Sims v. EGA Products, Inc., the United States...