7th Circuit Case Commentaries

Invalid Copyright Registration and Its Legal Consequences: Johnson v. Cypress Hill

Date: Jun 2, 2011

Invalid Copyright Registration and Its Legal Consequences: Johnson v. Cypress Hill Introduction In the landmark case of Syl Johnson, also known as Sylvester Thompson, Plaintiff-Appellant, v. Cypress...

Noerr-Pennington Immunity Affirmed in Competitive Petitioning and PR Campaigns

Date: May 27, 2011

Noerr-Pennington Immunity Affirmed in Competitive Petitioning and PR Campaigns Introduction In the case of MERCATUS GROUP, LLC v. LAKE FOREST HOSPITAL, adjudicated by the United States Court of...

Clarifying the Scope of EEOC Charges in Title VII Claims: Moore v. Vital Products

Date: May 26, 2011

Clarifying the Scope of EEOC Charges in Title VII Claims: Moore v. Vital Products Introduction Moore v. Vital Products, Incorporated is a pivotal case decided by the United States Court of Appeals...

Affirmation of District Court's Jurisdiction Over Independent Common Law Retaliatory Discharge Claims in Nereida Mendez v. Perla Dental

Date: May 25, 2011

Affirmation of District Court's Jurisdiction Over Independent Common Law Retaliatory Discharge Claims in Nereida Mendez v. Perla Dental Introduction In Nereida Mendez v. Perla Dental and Dental...

Seventh Circuit Reinforces Jurisdictional Integrity and Judicial Estoppel in Walton v. Bayer

Date: May 24, 2011

Seventh Circuit Reinforces Jurisdictional Integrity and Judicial Estoppel in Walton v. Bayer Introduction Case Citation: Cathy M. Walton v. Bayer Corporation, et al., 643 F.3d 994 (7th Cir. 2011) The...

Regarded as Disabled: Miller v. Illinois Department of Transportation - A Landmark ADA Decision

Date: May 11, 2011

Regarded as Disabled: Miller v. Illinois Department of Transportation - A Landmark ADA Decision Introduction Case Citation: Darrell Lynn Miller v. Illinois Department of Transportation, 643 F.3d 190...

Affirmation of SORNA's Constitutionality Against Ex Post Facto Challenges: United States v. Leach

Date: May 4, 2011

Affirmation of SORNA's Constitutionality Against Ex Post Facto Challenges: United States v. Leach Introduction The case of UNITED STATES of America v. Donald Leach (639 F.3d 769) presents a pivotal...

Reaffirming the Right of Citizen Suits under RCRA: Adkins v. VIM Recycling

Date: May 4, 2011

Reaffirming the Right of Citizen Suits under RCRA: Adkins v. VIM Recycling Introduction The case of Jerry Adkins, et al. v. VIM Recycling, Inc., K.C. Industries, LLC, and Kenneth R. Will, adjudicated...

Enforcement of Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies under ERISA: Strict Adherence Over Substantial Compliance

Date: Apr 30, 2011

Enforcement of Exhaustion of Administrative Remedies under ERISA: Strict Adherence Over Substantial Compliance Introduction The case of Augusta Edwards v. Briggs Stratton Retirement Plan (639 F.3d...

Termination for Policy Violations Not Pretextual Retaliation: Zellner v. Herrick

Date: Apr 30, 2011

Termination for Policy Violations Not Pretextual Retaliation: Zellner v. Herrick Introduction In the landmark case of Robert Zellner v. Daryl Herrick, the United States Court of Appeals for the...

Affirmation of Denial of Ineffective Assistance Claim in Koons v. United States

Date: Apr 29, 2011

Affirmation of Denial of Ineffective Assistance Claim in Koons v. United States Introduction Andrew C. Koons found himself entangled in a legal battle following his guilty plea to being a felon in...

Establishing Minimum Contacts for Personal Jurisdiction in Online Trademark Disputes: BE2 LLC v. Ivanov

Date: Apr 28, 2011

Establishing Minimum Contacts for Personal Jurisdiction in Online Trademark Disputes: BE2 LLC v. Ivanov Introduction The case of BE2 LLC and be2 Holding, A.G. v. Nikolay V. Ivanov (642 F.3d 555)...

Responsibilities of Appointed Counsel in Habeas Corpus Proceedings: Insights from Lavin v. Rednour

Date: Apr 27, 2011

Responsibilities of Appointed Counsel in Habeas Corpus Proceedings: Insights from Lavin v. Rednour Introduction Case: John Lavin, Petitioner-Appellant, v. Dave Rednour, Respondent-Appellee. Court:...

Refusal to Suppress Evidence in Eviction-Related Searches Upholds Under Fourth Amendment

Date: Apr 26, 2011

Refusal to Suppress Evidence in Eviction-Related Searches Upholds Under Fourth Amendment Introduction The case of United States of America v. Marcus Curlin (638 F.3d 562) adjudicated by the United...

Clarifying the 'Manifest Weight of the Evidence' Standard in Granting Motions for a New Trial

Date: Apr 23, 2011

Clarifying the 'Manifest Weight of the Evidence' Standard in Granting Motions for a New Trial Introduction In the appellate case of Michel R. Mejia v. Cook County, Illinois, et al., the United States...

Establishing Due Process Standards in Prison Disciplinary Proceedings: Jones v. Cross Appellant Court Commentary

Date: Apr 20, 2011

Establishing Due Process Standards in Prison Disciplinary Proceedings: Jones v. Cross Appellant Introduction In the case of Torrance Jones, Petitioner-Appellant v. James Cross, Jr., Warden,...

Establishing Probable Cause in Animal Neglect Seizure Cases: Mahnke v. Garrigan

Date: Apr 14, 2011

Establishing Probable Cause in Animal Neglect Seizure Cases: Mahnke v. Garrigan Introduction Mahnke v. Garrigan is a pivotal case decided by the United States Court of Appeals for the Seventh Circuit...

Rebalancing the Confrontation Clause: Sussman v. Jenkins and the Admissibility of Prior False Accusations in Criminal Defense

Date: Apr 2, 2011

Rebalancing the Confrontation Clause: Sussman v. Jenkins and the Admissibility of Prior False Accusations in Criminal Defense Introduction Gordon E. Sussman v. Larry Jenkins, 636 F.3d 329 (7th Cir....

Clarifying Federal Jurisdiction under CAFA: Insights from Back Doctors Ltd. v. Metropolitan Property and Casualty Insurance Company

Date: Apr 2, 2011

Clarifying Federal Jurisdiction under CAFA: Insights from Back Doctors Ltd. v. Metropolitan Property and Casualty Insurance Company Introduction The case of Back Doctors Ltd., individually and on...

Seventh Circuit Reinforces Confrontation Clause Protections in Jones v. Basinger

Date: Apr 1, 2011

Seventh Circuit Reinforces Confrontation Clause Protections in Jones v. Basinger Introduction Antonio D. Jones was convicted in 2004 for his involvement in a heinous robbery that resulted in four...