5th Circuit Case Commentaries

Affirmation of Summary Judgment Standards in Employment Discrimination and Retaliation: Rios v. IRS

Date: Jul 19, 2001

Affirmation of Summary Judgment Standards in Employment Discrimination and Retaliation: Rios v. IRS Introduction In the landmark case of Josephine Rios v. Charles O. Rossotti, the United States Court...

Affirming IRS's Right to Set Off Prepetition Tax Overpayments Under §6402(a) and §553: In re Constance Luongo

Date: Jul 19, 2001

Affirming IRS's Right to Set Off Prepetition Tax Overpayments Under §6402(a) and §553: In re Constance Luongo Introduction The case of In re Constance Luongo involves a taxpayer, Constance Luongo...

Affirmation of Reasonable Suspicion in Roving Border Patrol Stops and Proper Application of Sentencing Guidelines

Date: Jul 18, 2001

Affirmation of Reasonable Suspicion in Roving Border Patrol Stops and Proper Application of Sentencing Guidelines Introduction In the case of United States of America v. Michael Brett Jacquinot, 258...

Enforcing Tax Deficiencies Through Deemed Admissions: Carney v. IRS

Date: Jul 17, 2001

Enforcing Tax Deficiencies Through Deemed Admissions: Carney v. IRS Introduction Carney v. Internal Revenue Service, 258 F.3d 415 (5th Cir. 2001), is a pivotal case addressing the enforceability of...

Affirmation of Judicial Standards in NAGPRA and §1983 Claims: Romero v. Becken et al.

Date: Jul 17, 2001

Affirmation of Judicial Standards in NAGPRA and §1983 Claims: Romero v. Becken et al. Introduction In Daniel Castro Romero, Jr. v. Wesley Becken et al., decided by the United States Court of Appeals...

Fifth Circuit Clarifies Rules on Attorney Disqualification and §1985(3) in Employment Retaliation Cases

Date: Jul 12, 2001

Fifth Circuit Clarifies Rules on Attorney Disqualification and §1985(3) in Employment Retaliation Cases Introduction In the landmark case of Deborah M. Horaist v. Doctor's Hospital of Opelousas et...

Servicing Companies Not Considered Agents Under Texas Insurance Code: Affirmation in Northwinds Abatement, Inc. v. Employers Insurance of Wausau

Date: Jul 12, 2001

Servicing Companies Not Considered Agents Under Texas Insurance Code: Affirmation in Northwinds Abatement, Inc. v. Employers Insurance of Wausau Introduction The appellate case NORTHWINDS ABATEMENT,...

Affirmation of 'Reasonably Anticipated Use' Standard in Products Liability: Ellis v. Nut Hustler Inc.

Date: Jul 12, 2001

Affirmation of 'Reasonably Anticipated Use' Standard in Products Liability: Ellis v. Nut Hustler Inc. Introduction Elton Fitzgerald Ellis filed a products liability lawsuit against Nut Hustler Inc.,...

Establishing Qualification as a Prerequisite in ADA, ADEA, and ERISA Claims: Insights from Holtzclaw v. DSC Communications Corporation

Date: Jul 7, 2001

Establishing Qualification as a Prerequisite in ADA, ADEA, and ERISA Claims: Insights from Holtzclaw v. DSC Communications Corporation Introduction Holtzclaw v. DSC Communications Corporation, 255...

Retaliation Claims in Employment Termination: Insights from Beattie v. Madison County School District

Date: Jul 6, 2001

Retaliation Claims in Employment Termination: Insights from Beattie v. Madison County School District Introduction The case of Joy Beattie v. Madison County School District (254 F.3d 595, 2001)...

Establishing Standards for Malicious Prosecution and Qualified Immunity in Bivens Actions

Date: Jun 30, 2001

Establishing Standards for Malicious Prosecution and Qualified Immunity in Bivens Actions Introduction The case of Joe Alfred Izen, Jr. v. Terrance Catalina (256 F.3d 324) adjudicated by the United...

Rudd v. Johnson: Upholding Strict Standards for Certificates of Appealability in Capital Cases

Date: Jun 29, 2001

Rudd v. Johnson: Upholding Strict Standards for Certificates of Appealability in Capital Cases Introduction Rudd v. Johnson, 256 F.3d 317 (5th Cir. 2001), is a pivotal case addressing the stringent...

Clarification of Double Jeopardy Standards in Conspiracy Charges: United States v. Delgado & Alburtis

Date: Jun 27, 2001

Clarification of Double Jeopardy Standards in Conspiracy Charges: United States v. Delgado & Alburtis Introduction In the seminal case of United States v. Delgado, also known as Enrique Hank...

Court Affirms RCRA Enforcement Against Municipal Contributors: Cox et al. v. City of Dallas

Date: Jun 27, 2001

Court Affirms RCRA Enforcement Against Municipal Contributors: Cox et al. v. City of Dallas Introduction The case of Cox et al. v. City of Dallas revolves around plaintiffs who are residents adjacent...

Broussard v. Johnson: Establishing Enhanced Due Process Standards in Prison Disciplinary Proceedings

Date: Jun 26, 2001

Broussard v. Johnson: Establishing Enhanced Due Process Standards in Prison Disciplinary Proceedings Introduction Morris R. Broussard v. Gary L. Johnson, 253 F.3d 874 (5th Cir. 2001), is a pivotal...

Reinforcing the 'Purposeful Availment' Standard for Personal Jurisdiction in Diversity Cases: PBC & PGH v. Potomac Electric Power Company

Date: Jun 23, 2001

Reinforcing the 'Purposeful Availment' Standard for Personal Jurisdiction in Diversity Cases: PBC & PGH v. Potomac Electric Power Company Introduction The case Panda Brandywine Corporation (PBC) and...

Reaffirmation of Procedural Bar for Ineffective Assistance of State Habeas Counsel under AEDPA: Martinez v. Johnson

Date: Jun 23, 2001

Reaffirmation of Procedural Bar for Ineffective Assistance of State Habeas Counsel under AEDPA: Martinez v. Johnson Introduction Johnny Joe Martinez, a Texas death-row inmate, challenged his...

Standing and Class Certification in Racial Discrimination Case: James & Lary v. City of Dallas and HUD

Date: Jun 19, 2001

Standing and Class Certification in Racial Discrimination Case: James & Lary v. City of Dallas and HUD Introduction The case of Irma Jean James and Terri Lary v. City of Dallas, Texas and U.S....

Affirmation of Qualified Immunity and Deliberate Indifference Standards in §1983 Claims for Pretrial Detainees’ Medical Care

Date: Jun 16, 2001

Affirmation of Qualified Immunity and Deliberate Indifference Standards in §1983 Claims for Pretrial Detainees’ Medical Care Introduction Lenard G. Gibbs v. H.M. (Mack) Grimmette, et al. is a seminal...

Expansion of Personal Jurisdiction in Securities Fraud Cases: Lewis v. Farkas et al. (5th Cir., 2001)

Date: Jun 15, 2001

Expansion of Personal Jurisdiction in Securities Fraud Cases: Lewis v. Farkas et al. (5th Cir., 2001) Introduction The case of Michael P. Lewis v. David M. Fresne et al., adjudicated by the United...