5th Circuit Case Commentaries

Fifth Circuit Reaffirms 'Any Amount of Jail Time' as Prejudice Standard in Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claims

Date: Jul 2, 2004

Fifth Circuit Reaffirms 'Any Amount of Jail Time' as Prejudice Standard in Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Claims Introduction In United States of America v. Gus Peter Grammas, 376 F.3d 433 (5th...

Affirmation of Detrimental Reliance and Unjust Enrichment Dismissal in Insurance Policy Dispute

Date: Jul 1, 2004

Affirmation of Detrimental Reliance and Unjust Enrichment Dismissal in Insurance Policy Dispute Introduction The case of DRS BETHEA, MOUSTOUKAS AND WEAVER LLC; MORRISON C BETHEA, MD, A Professional...

Summary Judgment Upholds Anti-Discrimination Protections in Employment Retaliation Case

Date: Jul 1, 2004

Summary Judgment Upholds Anti-Discrimination Protections in Employment Retaliation Case Introduction In the appellate case Louis C. Roberson v. Alltel Information Services (373 F.3d 647, 5th Cir....

Interstate Fibernet Inc. v. Defendants: Appellate Jurisdiction and Finality of District Court Orders

Date: Jun 29, 2004

Interstate Fibernet Inc. v. Defendants: Appellate Jurisdiction and Finality of District Court Orders 1. Introduction The case of Interstate Fibernet Inc. v. Mississippi Power Company et al. (No....

Establishing Eighth Amendment Standards: Affirmation of Prison Conditions Protections on Death Row

Date: Jun 29, 2004

Establishing Eighth Amendment Standards: Affirmation of Prison Conditions Protections on Death Row Introduction In the landmark case of GATES v. COOK, heard by the United States Court of Appeals for...

Fifth Circuit Clarifies Grounds for Vacating FAA Arbitration Awards: Arbitrary and Capricious Not Independent Ground

Date: Jun 29, 2004

Fifth Circuit Clarifies Grounds for Vacating FAA Arbitration Awards: Arbitrary and Capricious Not Independent Ground Introduction In the appellate case Thomas McDowell Brabham, Individually and as...

Establishing Mixed-Motives Analysis in ADEA Claims: Rachid v. Jack In The Box, Inc.

Date: Jun 26, 2004

Establishing Mixed-Motives Analysis in ADEA Claims: Rachid v. Jack In The Box, Inc. Introduction The case of Ahmed P. Rachid v. Jack In The Box, Inc. (376 F.3d 305) addresses significant aspects of...

FDCPA Enforcement and Judicial Authority in FTC v. Namer: A Comprehensive Analysis

Date: Jun 26, 2004

FDCPA Enforcement and Judicial Authority in FTC v. Namer: A Comprehensive Analysis Introduction The case Federal Trade Commission v. National Business Consultants, Inc.; Robert Namer; Voice of...

Interpretation of 'Pending' in AEDPA: Fifth Circuit's Grillette Decision on Tolling Limitations Period

Date: Jun 23, 2004

Interpretation of 'Pending' in AEDPA: Fifth Circuit's Grillette Decision on Tolling Limitations Period Introduction The case of Da v. Grillette, decided by the United States Court of Appeals for the...

Judicial Estoppel Upholds Integrity in Bankruptcy Proceedings: In re Superior Crewboats, Inc.

Date: Jun 19, 2004

Judicial Estoppel Upholds Integrity in Bankruptcy Proceedings: In re Superior Crewboats, Inc. Introduction The case of In re Superior Crewboats, Inc. involves Superior Crewboats, Inc., the owner of...

Non-Signatory's Right to Stay Litigation Under FAA § 3: Analysis of Waste Management, Inc. v. Residuos Industriales Multiquim, S.A. de C.V.

Date: Jun 12, 2004

Non-Signatory's Right to Stay Litigation Under FAA § 3: Analysis of Waste Management, Inc. v. Residuos Industriales Multiquim, S.A. de C.V. Introduction The case of Waste Management, Inc. (WM) v....

Thuri v. Ashcroft: Establishing the Substantial-Evidence Standard for Asylum Eligibility

Date: Jun 8, 2004

Thuri v. Ashcroft: Establishing the Substantial-Evidence Standard for Asylum Eligibility Introduction In Thuri v. Ashcroft, 380 F.3d 788 (5th Cir. 2004), the United States Court of Appeals for the...

Certificate of Appealability Denied in Bagwell v. Dretke: Upholding Judicial Restraints and Procedural Standards

Date: Jun 8, 2004

Certificate of Appealability Denied in Bagwell v. Dretke: Upholding Judicial Restraints and Procedural Standards Introduction The case of Dennis Wayne Bagwell v. Douglas Dretke addressed significant...

Jurisdictional Boundaries in Rule 60(b) Motions: Shepherd v. International Paper Co.

Date: May 29, 2004

Jurisdictional Boundaries in Rule 60(b) Motions: Shepherd v. International Paper Co. Introduction The case of Shepherd, Grisby, et al. v. International Paper Co. (372 F.3d 326, 5th Cir. 2004)...

Southland Securities v. Inspire Insurance Solutions Inc.: Reinforcing PSLRA's Particularity in Securities Fraud Litigation

Date: May 26, 2004

Southland Securities Corporation v. Inspire Insurance Solutions Inc.: Reinforcing PSLRA's Particularity in Securities Fraud Litigation Introduction In the landmark case of Southland Securities...

Strict Application of AEDPA Standards in Denial of Certificate of Appealability: Medellin v. Dretke

Date: May 21, 2004

Strict Application of AEDPA Standards in Denial of Certificate of Appealability: Medellin v. Dretke Introduction Medellin v. Dretke is a pivotal case decided by the United States Court of Appeals for...

Comprehensive Venue Transfer Standards Established in In re Volkswagen AG

Date: May 19, 2004

Comprehensive Venue Transfer Standards Established in In re Volkswagen AG Introduction The case of In re Volkswagen AG; Volkswagen of America, Inc., decided by the United States Court of Appeals for...

Affirmation of Deferential Standards in Prisoners' Religious Rights: Freeman v. Texas Department of Criminal Justice

Date: May 8, 2004

Affirmation of Deferential Standards in Prisoners' Religious Rights: Freeman v. Texas Department of Criminal Justice Introduction Freeman v. Texas Department of Criminal Justice, 369 F.3d 854 (5th...

Defining 'Firm Offer of Credit' Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act: Insights from Kennedy v. Chase Manhattan Bank USA

Date: May 7, 2004

Defining 'Firm Offer of Credit' Under the Fair Credit Reporting Act: Insights from Kennedy v. Chase Manhattan Bank USA Introduction The case of Richard D. Kennedy and Sally S. Kennedy v. Chase...

Courts Uphold Prison Policies Requiring Judicial Authorization for Inmate Elective Medical Procedures

Date: May 1, 2004

Courts Uphold Prison Policies Requiring Judicial Authorization for Inmate Elective Medical Procedures Introduction The case of Victoria W. v. Jerry J. Larpenter, et al. addresses the delicate balance...