5th Circuit Case Commentaries

Equitable Lien Doctrine Applied to Assigned Mortgages: U.S. Bank v. Safeguard Insurance Co.

Date: Jan 5, 2006

Equitable Lien Doctrine Applied to Assigned Mortgages: U.S. Bank v. Safeguard Insurance Co. Introduction The case of U.S. Bank National Association (Successor in Interest to State Street Bank Trust...

Denial of Certificate of Appealability in Pippin v. Dretke: A Comprehensive Commentary

Date: Dec 29, 2005

Denial of Certificate of Appealability in Pippin v. Dretke: A Comprehensive Commentary Introduction Pippin v. Dretke is a pivotal case adjudicated by the United States Court of Appeals for the Fifth...

Booker Revisited: Impact of Sentencing Guideline Amendments on Conspiracy Charges

Date: Dec 24, 2005

Booker Revisited: Impact of Sentencing Guideline Amendments on Conspiracy Charges Introduction The appellate case of United States of America v. Jerry W. Freeman (434 F.3d 369) serves as a pivotal...

Mixed-Motive Framework Affirmed in FMLA Retaliation Case: Richardson v. Monitronics

Date: Dec 22, 2005

Mixed-Motive Framework Affirmed in FMLA Retaliation Case: Richardson v. Monitronics Introduction The case of Pamela Richardson v. Monitronics International, Inc. (434 F.3d 327) adjudicated by the...

Imputed Fraud and Agency Relationships in Bankruptcy Discharge: Analysis of In re Quinlivan

Date: Dec 21, 2005

Imputed Fraud and Agency Relationships in Bankruptcy Discharge: Analysis of In re Quinlivan Introduction The case In re Quinlivan (434 F.3d 314, 5th Cir. 2005) addresses the complexities surrounding...

Diversity Jurisdiction and Improper Joinder: Comprehensive Analysis of Guillory v. PPG Industries

Date: Dec 21, 2005

Diversity Jurisdiction and Improper Joinder: Comprehensive Analysis of Guillory v. PPG Industries Introduction The case of Louis Britt Guillory and Stanley Milton Gims v. PPG Industries, Inc. (434...

Reaffirming the "Severe or Pervasive" Standard in Sexual Harassment Claims: Harvill v. Westward Communications

Date: Dec 14, 2005

Reaffirming the "Severe or Pervasive" Standard in Sexual Harassment Claims: Harvill v. Westward Communications Introduction In Molly Harvill v. Westward Communications, LLC, 433 F.3d 428 (5th Cir....

Non-Retroactive Application of Booker on Initial § 2255 Motions: Analysis of United States v. Gentry

Date: Dec 9, 2005

Non-Retroactive Application of Booker on Initial § 2255 Motions: Analysis of United States v. Gentry Introduction United States v. Kenesha Gentry, 432 F.3d 600 (5th Cir. 2005), addresses a pivotal...

Establishing Statute of Limitations Parameters for Section 1983 Prosecution Claims: Price v. City of San Antonio

Date: Dec 6, 2005

Establishing Statute of Limitations Parameters for Section 1983 Prosecution Claims: Price v. City of San Antonio Introduction The case of Scott Price v. City of San Antonio, Texas; John Anthony...

Affirmation of AEDPA Standards in Habeas Corpus Denial: Summers v. Dretke

Date: Dec 3, 2005

Affirmation of AEDPA Standards in Habeas Corpus Denial: Summers v. Dretke Introduction Gregory Lynn Summers, the petitioner-appellant, appeals the denial of his habeas corpus petition and application...

United States v. Patterson: Upholding §922(g)(3) and Clarifying 'Unlawful User' Standards

Date: Dec 2, 2005

United States v. Patterson: Upholding §922(g)(3) and Clarifying 'Unlawful User' Standards Introduction In the landmark case United States v. Patterson, the United States Court of Appeals for the...

Affirmation of Substantial Evidence Standard in Asylum Credibility Determinations: Yi Wu Zhang v. Gonzales

Date: Dec 2, 2005

Affirmation of Substantial Evidence Standard in Asylum Credibility Determinations: Yi Wu Zhang v. Gonzales Introduction Yi Wu Zhang v. Alberto R. Gonzales, 432 F.3d 339 (5th Cir. 2005), is a pivotal...

Waiver of Sovereign Immunity in ADA and Rehabilitation Act Claims: Bennett-Nelson & Boykin v. Louisiana Board of Regents

Date: Nov 29, 2005

Waiver of Sovereign Immunity in ADA and Rehabilitation Act Claims: Bennett-Nelson & Boykin v. Louisiana Board of Regents Introduction The case of Bennett-Nelson & Boykin v. Louisiana Board of Regents...

Reversing ERISA-Estoppel: Fifth Circuit Dismisses Mello vs. Sara Lee Corporation

Date: Nov 23, 2005

Reversing ERISA-Estoppel: Fifth Circuit Dismisses Mello vs. Sara Lee Corporation Introduction In the pivotal case of Frank C. Mello v. Sara Lee Corporation, the United States Court of Appeals for the...

Exhaustion of Administrative Procedures Required Before Involuntary Medication: U.S. v. White

Date: Nov 22, 2005

Exhaustion of Administrative Procedures Required Before Involuntary Medication: United States v. Dedrick Reginald White Introduction In the landmark case United States v. Dedrick Reginald White,...

Enforcement of Statute of Frauds and Summary Judgment Affirmed in Harrell Equipment Co. v. SunTrust Bank

Date: Nov 11, 2005

Enforcement of Statute of Frauds and Summary Judgment Affirmed in Harrell Equipment Co. v. SunTrust Bank Introduction In Harrell Equipment Company, Inc. v. SunTrust Bank of Georgia, et al., 431 F.3d...

Reinforcing the Burden-Shifting Framework in Age Discrimination Cases: American Airlines v. Baker

Date: Nov 10, 2005

Reinforcing the Burden-Shifting Framework in Age Discrimination Cases: American Airlines v. Baker Introduction The case of Christine A. Baker v. American Airlines, Inc. (430 F.3d 750) adjudicates key...

Fifth Circuit Affirms: Fair Housing Act §3604(a) Does Not Cover Discrimination Affecting Property Values

Date: Nov 10, 2005

Fifth Circuit Affirms: Fair Housing Act §3604(a) Does Not Cover Discrimination Affecting Property Values Introduction In the case of Harold Cox; Shirley Davidson; Robert Stubblefield; Cynthia...

Supervisory Liability and Qualified Immunity Under §1983: Insights from Selden ATTEBERRY v. NOCONA GENERAL HOSPITAL

Date: Nov 4, 2005

Supervisory Liability and Qualified Immunity Under §1983: Insights from Selden ATTEBERRY v. NOCONA GENERAL HOSPITAL Introduction The case of Selden Atteberry, Indi v. Nocona General Hospital (430...

Condrey v. SunTrust: Enforcing Integration Clauses and Limiting Parol Evidence in Licensing Disputes

Date: Nov 2, 2005

Condrey v. SunTrust: Enforcing Integration Clauses and Limiting Parol Evidence in Licensing Disputes Introduction In Condrey v. SunTrust Bank of Georgia, the United States Court of Appeals for the...