5th Circuit Case Commentaries

Helms-Burton Act Standing and Statutory Interpretation: Glen v. American Airlines

Date: Aug 3, 2021

Helms-Burton Act Standing and Statutory Interpretation: Glen v. American Airlines Introduction Robert M. Glen v. American Airlines, Incorporated is a pivotal case adjudicated by the United States...

Sovereign Immunity and Equal Protection in Transgender Inmate Healthcare: Haverkamp v. Texas

Date: Jul 31, 2021

Sovereign Immunity and Equal Protection in Transgender Inmate Healthcare: Haverkamp v. Texas Introduction Haverkamp v. Texas is a landmark case adjudicated by the United States Court of Appeals for...

Enhanced Indemnification Obligations Under FLSA: Analysis of Sanchez Oil & Gas v. Crescent Drilling & Production

Date: Jul 31, 2021

Enhanced Indemnification Obligations Under FLSA: Analysis of Sanchez Oil & Gas Corp. v. Crescent Drilling & Production, Inc. Introduction The case of Sanchez Oil & Gas Corporation v. Crescent...

Strengthening the Nexus Requirement in Asylum Claims: Vazquez-Guerra v. Garland

Date: Jul 30, 2021

Strengthening the Nexus Requirement in Asylum Claims: Vazquez-Guerra v. Garland Introduction Edith Nohemi Vazquez-Guerra and Wendy Chantal Barragan-Vazquez are Mexican nationals who sought asylum in...

Prim v. Deputy Stein: Reversing Summary Judgment on Assault Claims under Civil Rights Law

Date: Jul 28, 2021

Prim v. Deputy Stein: Reversing Summary Judgment on Assault Claims under Civil Rights Law Introduction Prim v. Deputy Stein; Lieutenant Webb; Detective Terrell; John Harshaw; Montgomery County,...

Affirmed Liability with Remittitur: Fifth Circuit Sets Precedent on Fraudulent Transfers and Res Judicata in Bankruptcy Transactions

Date: Jul 28, 2021

Affirmed Liability with Remittitur: Fifth Circuit Sets Precedent on Fraudulent Transfers and Res Judicata in Bankruptcy Transactions Introduction The case of In the Matter of: 3 Star Properties,...

Affirmation of Conviction in Child Pornography Possession Case: Legal Principles and Implications

Date: Jul 16, 2021

Affirmation of Conviction in Child Pornography Possession Case: Legal Principles and Implications Introduction The case United States of America v. Jeffrey Clinton Michalik (5 F.4th 583) adjudicated...

Establishment Clause and Judicial Conduct: Insights from Freedom From Religion Foundation v. Mack

Date: Jul 10, 2021

Establishment Clause and Judicial Conduct: Insights from Freedom From Religion Foundation v. Mack Introduction The case of Freedom From Religion Foundation, Inc. v. Wayne Mack, 4 F.4th 306 (2021),...

Application of 28 U.S.C. § 1631 in Diversity Jurisdiction Cases: Franco v. Mabe Trucking Co.

Date: Jul 9, 2021

Application of 28 U.S.C. § 1631 in Diversity Jurisdiction Cases: Franco v. Mabe Trucking Co. Introduction Case: David Franco v. Mabe Trucking Company, Incorporated; Richard Agee; National Interstate...

Reforming Qualified Immunity Standards: Insights from Terwilliger v. Reyna

Date: Jul 9, 2021

Reforming Qualified Immunity Standards: Insights from Terwilliger v. Reyna Introduction The case of Bradley Terwilliger et al. v. Abelino Reyna et al. (4 F.4th 270) adjudicated by the United States...

Establishing Judicial Oversight of Hardship Determinations in Removal Cases: Guerrero v. Garland

Date: Jul 3, 2021

Establishing Judicial Oversight of Hardship Determinations in Removal Cases: Guerrero v. Garland Introduction In the landmark case Jose Felipe Guerrero Trejo v. Merrick Garland, decided by the United...

Fifth Circuit Sets Precedent on Mandatory Bar Associations: First Amendment Rights Protect Against Non-Germane Activities

Date: Jul 3, 2021

Fifth Circuit Sets Precedent on Mandatory Bar Associations: First Amendment Rights Protect Against Non-Germane Activities Introduction In the landmark case of McDonald v. State Bar of Texas, the...

Qualified Immunity Affirmed for Jail Officers in Inmate Suicide Case

Date: Jul 3, 2021

Qualified Immunity Affirmed for Jail Officers in Inmate Suicide Case Introduction In the case of Patsy K. Cope and Alex Isbell v. Leslie W. Cogdill, Mary Jo Brixey, Jessie W. Laws, the United States...

Enforcement of Arbitration Agreements Under Texas Law Confirmed in Gallagher v. Vokey

Date: Jul 2, 2021

Enforcement of Arbitration Agreements Under Texas Law Confirmed in Gallagher v. Vokey Introduction The case of Edward Gallagher v. Colby Vokey addresses the enforceability of arbitration agreements...

Affirmation of Qualified Immunity in Excessive Force Claims: Analysis of Jackson v. Gautreaux et al. (5th Cir. 2021)

Date: Jul 1, 2021

Affirmation of Qualified Immunity in Excessive Force Claims: Analysis of Jackson v. Gautreaux et al. (5th Cir. 2021) 1. Introduction In the case of Jackson v. Gautreaux et al., the United States...

Guidry v. Lumpkin: Upholding Strict Standards for Certificates of Appealability under AEDPA

Date: Jun 24, 2021

Guidry v. Lumpkin: Upholding Strict Standards for Certificates of Appealability under AEDPA Introduction Guidry v. Lumpkin, 2 F.4th 472 (5th Cir. 2021), is a significant appellate case that addresses...

Revisiting §1983 Claims Post-Heck: Insights from Colvin v. Leblanc et al.

Date: Jun 24, 2021

Revisiting §1983 Claims Post-Heck: Insights from Colvin v. Leblanc et al. Introduction The case of James L. Colvin v. James Leblanc, Secretary of Corrections and others, adjudicated by the United...

HAYWARD DEAN v. AKAL SECURITY: Establishing the Predominant-Benefit Test for Meal Periods under the FLSA

Date: Jun 23, 2021

HAYWARD DEAN v. AKAL SECURITY: Establishing the Predominant-Benefit Test for Meal Periods under the FLSA Introduction In the landmark case of Hayward Dean, Individually and All Others Similarly...

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Thompson v. Microsoft: Clarifying ADA Accommodation Standards

Date: Jun 23, 2021

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Thompson v. Microsoft: Clarifying ADA Accommodation Standards Introduction In the landmark case of John Thompson v. Microsoft Corporation, 2 F.4th 460 (5th Cir....

Hope v. Harris et al.: Fifth Circuit Clarifies Sovereign Immunity and Prisoner Standing in Solitary Confinement Claims

Date: Jun 19, 2021

Hope v. Harris et al.: Fifth Circuit Clarifies Sovereign Immunity and Prisoner Standing in Solitary Confinement Claims Introduction In the case of Dennis Wayne Hope v. Todd Harris et al., the United...