4th Circuit Case Commentaries

Fourth Circuit Upholds Disparate Impact and Treatment Claims in USPS Racial Discrimination Class Action

Date: Nov 26, 1981

Fourth Circuit Upholds Disparate Impact and Treatment Claims in USPS Racial Discrimination Class Action Introduction Napoleon Chisholm et al. v. United States Postal Service is a landmark class...

Strict Adherence to Rule 609(b) in Admitting Prior Convictions: Analysis of United States v. Beahm

Date: Nov 19, 1981

Strict Adherence to Rule 609(b) in Admitting Prior Convictions: Analysis of United States v. Beahm Introduction United States of America v. Luther Amos Beahm, 664 F.2d 414 (4th Cir. 1981), serves as...

Fraud Exception to Opinion Work Product Doctrine: In Re John Doe

Date: Oct 27, 1981

Fraud Exception to Opinion Work Product Doctrine: In Re John Doe Introduction The case of In Re John Doe, et al. v. United States of America (662 F.2d 1073, 4th Cir. 1981) marks a significant...

Fourth Circuit Establishes Strict Standards for Detention Strip Searches under BELL v. WOLFISH

Date: Oct 8, 1981

Fourth Circuit Establishes Strict Standards for Detention Strip Searches under BELL v. WOLFISH Introduction The case of Lucy N. Logan v. Arlington County et al. addresses significant questions...

Indemnity Claims in Asbestos Litigation: Glover v. Johns-Manville Corporation

Date: Oct 6, 1981

Indemnity Claims in Asbestos Litigation: Glover v. Johns-Manville Corporation Introduction Glover v. Johns-Manville Corporation, 662 F.2d 225 (4th Cir. 1981), represents a significant judicial...

Establishing Local Government Liability under Section 1983: Insights from Avery v. County of Burke

Date: Oct 3, 1981

Establishing Local Government Liability under Section 1983: Insights from Avery v. County of Burke Introduction The case of Virginia Ann Avery v. County of Burke addresses significant issues related...

Affirming Union Standing and Reversing Class Certification Denial in Employment Discrimination Case

Date: Sep 18, 1981

Affirming Union Standing and Reversing Class Certification Denial in Employment Discrimination Case Introduction In the landmark case of International Woodworkers of America, AFL-CIO, CLC; Local...

Hall v. Harris: Fourth Circuit Reinforces Standards for Residual Functional Capacity and Vocational Evaluation in Disability Claims

Date: Sep 5, 1981

Hall v. Harris: Fourth Circuit Reinforces Standards for Residual Functional Capacity and Vocational Evaluation in Disability Claims Introduction Hall v. Harris, 658 F.2d 260 (4th Cir. 1981), is a...

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Hummer v. Commonwealth of Virginia Establishes Standards for Prison Conditions Claims under Section 1983

Date: Aug 27, 1981

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Hummer v. Commonwealth of Virginia Establishes Standards for Prison Conditions Claims under Section 1983 Introduction The case of L. Lee Hummer v. Commonwealth of...

Disclosure Obligations in Contract Reprocurement: Square Construction Co. v. WMATA

Date: Aug 18, 1981

Disclosure Obligations in Contract Reprocurement: Square Construction Co. v. WMATA Introduction In the landmark case Square Construction Company and La Fera Contracting Company v. Washington...

Mercury Construction Co. v. Moses H. Cone Memorial Hospital: Upholding Federal Arbitration Rights

Date: Aug 13, 1981

Mercury Construction Co. v. Moses H. Cone Memorial Hospital: Upholding Federal Arbitration Rights Introduction Mercury Construction Company (hereafter "Mercury"), a Delaware corporation, entered into...

Cheeseman v. Nachman: Expanded Interpretation of 'Householder' in Homestead Exemption Eligibility

Date: Jul 31, 1981

Cheeseman v. Nachman: Expanded Interpretation of 'Householder' in Homestead Exemption Eligibility Introduction The case Oliver Reginald Cheeseman and Isabelle Cheeseman v. Erwin B. Nachman, heard by...

Expanding EEOC's Jurisdiction in Discrimination Suits: EEOC v. American National Bank

Date: Jun 27, 1981

Expanding EEOC's Jurisdiction in Discrimination Suits: EEOC v. American National Bank Introduction In the landmark case of Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) v. American National Bank,...

Fourth Circuit Upholds Cost Assessment for In Forma Pauperis Plaintiffs in §1983 Cases

Date: Jun 20, 1981

Fourth Circuit Upholds Cost Assessment for In Forma Pauperis Plaintiffs in §1983 Cases Introduction The case of Chester F. Flint, Jr., Rodney Allen Stover, and Richard Earl Marks versus various...

Good Faith in Contract Termination Affirmed; Limitations on Treble Damages under N.C.G.S. §75-1.1 Established

Date: May 19, 1981

Good Faith in Contract Termination Affirmed; Limitations on Treble Damages under N.C.G.S. §75-1.1 Established Introduction The case of United Roasters, Inc. v. Colgate-Palmolive Company decided by...

Index Journal Company Segregation Under Scrutiny: Fourth Circuit Clarifies Title VII Standards

Date: Apr 29, 1981

Index Journal Company Segregation Under Scrutiny: Fourth Circuit Clarifies Title VII Standards Introduction In the landmark case of Martha Armstrong v. Index Journal Company, adjudicated by the...

Affirmation of Disability Determination Based on Sedentary Work Capability: Frady v. Harris

Date: Apr 10, 1981

Affirmation of Disability Determination Based on Sedentary Work Capability: Frady v. Harris Introduction The case Thomas F. Frady, Appellant v. Patricia Roberts Harris, Secretary of Health and Human...

Fourth Circuit Reaffirms McDonnell Douglas Framework in Racial Discrimination Case against U.S. Postal Service

Date: Apr 3, 1981

Fourth Circuit Reaffirms McDonnell Douglas Framework in Racial Discrimination Case against U.S. Postal Service Introduction In the landmark case Carl F. Page v. William J. Bolger, adjudicated by the...

Jurisdictional Threshold and the Exclusion of Punitive Damages in Pure Contract Actions: Wiggins v. North American Equitable Life Assurance Co.

Date: Apr 3, 1981

Jurisdictional Threshold and the Exclusion of Punitive Damages in Pure Contract Actions: Wiggins v. North American Equitable Life Assurance Co. Introduction The case of Annie Wiggins v. North...

Protecting Prisoner Privacy Rights: Insights from Lee v. Downs, 4th Cir. 1981

Date: Mar 6, 1981

Protecting Prisoner Privacy Rights: Insights from Lee v. Downs, 4th Cir. 1981 Introduction Lee v. Downs, 641 F.2d 1117 (4th Cir. 1981), is a pivotal case addressing the balance between maintaining...