2d Circuit Case Commentaries

Accrual of Discrimination Claims Upon Communicated Termination Decisions Unaffected by Appeals: Ikedilo v. Statter

Date: Apr 3, 2025

Accrual of Discrimination Claims Upon Communicated Termination Decisions Unaffected by Appeals: Ikedilo v. Statter Introduction In Ikedilo v. Statter, the Second Circuit considered an appeal by Dr....

Caballero v. Miller: Setting the Prejudice Threshold for Ineffective-Assistance Claims Under AEDPA

Date: Apr 3, 2025

Caballero v. Miller: Setting the Prejudice Threshold for Ineffective-Assistance Claims Under AEDPA Introduction Caballero v. Miller, 24-2602-pr (2d Cir. Apr. 2, 2025), addresses the intersection of...

Clarifying Accrual of Employment Discrimination Claims and Reasonable Accommodation Standards in Medical Residency: Ikedilo v. Statter

Date: Apr 3, 2025

Clarifying Accrual of Employment Discrimination Claims and Reasonable Accommodation Standards in Medical Residency: Ikedilo v. Statter Introduction In Ikedilo v. Statter, et al., No. 23-7947 (2d Cir....

The Unreasonableness Standard under AEDPA and Strickland: Federal Deference to State Court Findings on Ineffective Assistance of Counsel

Date: Apr 3, 2025

The Unreasonableness Standard under AEDPA and Strickland: Federal Deference to State Court Findings on Ineffective Assistance of Counsel Introduction This case arises from Andrew Caballero’s habeas...

Direct Evidence of Retaliation Under Section 1981: Bypassing Burden-Shifting Requirements

Date: Apr 3, 2025

Direct Evidence of Retaliation Under Section 1981: Bypassing Burden-Shifting Requirements Introduction El Chaar v. NYU College of Dentistry is a 2025 decision of the U.S. Court of Appeals for the...

Caballero v. Miller: Reaffirmation of AEDPA Deference and Strickland Prejudice Requirement in Habeas Corpus Review

Date: Apr 3, 2025

Caballero v. Miller: Reaffirmation of AEDPA Deference and Strickland Prejudice Requirement in Habeas Corpus Review Introduction The Second Circuit’s summary order in Caballero v. Miller (No....

El Chaar v. NYU College of Dentistry: Direct Evidence Standard in §1981 Retaliation Claims

Date: Apr 3, 2025

El Chaar v. NYU College of Dentistry: Direct Evidence Standard in §1981 Retaliation Claims Introduction El Chaar v. NYU College of Dentistry (2nd Cir. Apr. 2, 2025) addresses two related but distinct...

But-For Causation in §1981 Retaliation: Direct Evidence Suffices – El Chaar v. NYU

Date: Apr 3, 2025

But-For Causation in §1981 Retaliation: Direct Evidence Suffices – El Chaar v. NYU Introduction El Chaar v. NYU College of Dentistry is a Second Circuit summary order issued on April 2, 2025. Dr....

Communication of Adverse Employment Decision as Accrual Date in Discrimination Claims

Date: Apr 3, 2025

Communication of Adverse Employment Decision as Accrual Date in Discrimination Claims Introduction In Ikedilo v. Statter, the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit considered when the...

Reaffirming Prejudice Requirement in §2254 Ineffective Assistance Claims: Caballero v. Miller

Date: Apr 3, 2025

Reaffirming Prejudice Requirement in §2254 Ineffective Assistance Claims: Caballero v. Miller Introduction Caballero v. Miller is a Second Circuit summary order, decided April 2, 2025, which...

Direct Evidence of Retaliatory Animus Bypassing the Burden-Shifting Framework in Section 1981 Claims

Date: Apr 3, 2025

Direct Evidence of Retaliatory Animus Bypassing the Burden-Shifting Framework in Section 1981 Claims Introduction This commentary examines the United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit’s...

AEDPA Deference and Strickland Review: Caballero v. Miller Clarifies Ineffective Assistance Standards

Date: Apr 3, 2025

AEDPA Deference and Strickland Review: Caballero v. Miller Clarifies Ineffective Assistance Standards Introduction The Second Circuit’s summary order in Caballero v. Miller (No. 24-2602-pr, decided...

Admissions Establishing But-For Retaliation Under §1981: El Chaar v. NYU College of Dentistry

Date: Apr 3, 2025

Admissions Establishing But-For Retaliation Under §1981: El Chaar v. NYU College of Dentistry 1. Introduction In El Chaar v. NYU College of Dentistry, 24-1169 (2d Cir. Apr. 2, 2025), the Second...

Caballero v. Miller: Reinforcing the Prejudice Requirement for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel under AEDPA

Date: Apr 3, 2025

Caballero v. Miller: Reinforcing the Prejudice Requirement for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel under AEDPA Introduction This commentary examines the Second Circuit’s April 2, 2025 decision in...

Termination Notice as Trigger for Statute of Limitations in Discrimination Claims: Ikedilo v. Statter

Date: Apr 3, 2025

Termination Notice as Trigger for Statute of Limitations in Discrimination Claims: Ikedilo v. Statter Introduction In Ikedilo v. Statter, No. 23-7947 (2d Cir. Apr. 2, 2025), the United States Court...

Concrete Evidence Requirement in Establishing Prejudice for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel on Federal Habeas Review

Date: Apr 3, 2025

Concrete Evidence Requirement in Establishing Prejudice for Ineffective Assistance of Counsel on Federal Habeas Review Introduction Caballero v. Miller is a Second Circuit summary order reversing a...

Direct Evidence of Retaliation Displaces Burden-Shifting under §1981 & Time-Barred Hostile Work Environment Claims: El Chaar v. NYU College of Dentistry

Date: Apr 3, 2025

Direct Evidence of Retaliation Displaces Burden-Shifting under §1981 & Time-Barred Hostile Work Environment Claims: El Chaar v. NYU College of Dentistry Introduction In El Chaar v. NYU College of...

Termination‐Based Discrimination Claims Accrue at Decision Communication, Not Grievance Resolution

Date: Apr 3, 2025

Termination‐Based Discrimination Claims Accrue at Decision Communication, Not Grievance Resolution Introduction In Ikedilo v. Statter, 23‐7947 (2d Cir. Apr. 2, 2025), the United States Court of...

Notification Trigger for Statute of Limitations in Discrimination Claims: Grievance Procedures Do Not Toll

Date: Apr 3, 2025

Notification Trigger for Statute of Limitations in Discrimination Claims: Grievance Procedures Do Not Toll Introduction Ikedilo v. Statter, decided by the United States Court of Appeals for the...

El Chaar v. NYU Dentistry: Direct-Evidence Standard in §1981 Retaliation Claims

Date: Apr 3, 2025

El Chaar v. NYU College of Dentistry: Direct-Evidence Standard in §1981 Retaliation Claims Introduction In El Chaar v. NYU College of Dentistry, 24-1169 (2d Cir. Apr. 2, 2025), the Second Circuit...