2d Circuit Case Commentaries

Official Rhetorical Hyperbole as Non-Actionable Opinion: Standing and Defamation Limits in Miller v. James

Date: Apr 10, 2025

Official Rhetorical Hyperbole as Non-Actionable Opinion: Standing and Defamation Limits in Miller v. James Introduction In Miller et al. v. James, 24-2785 (2d Cir. Apr. 9, 2025), the U.S. Court of...

Nonmovant’s Sworn Statements Sufficient to Defeat Summary Judgment: Knox v. CRC Management Co.

Date: Apr 10, 2025

Nonmovant’s Sworn Statements Sufficient to Defeat Summary Judgment: Knox v. CRC Management Co. Introduction Knox v. CRC Management Co., decided April 9, 2025 by the United States Court of Appeals for...

Edwards v. Destefano: Transfer-Related “Dead End” Excuses PLRA Exhaustion Requirement

Date: Apr 10, 2025

Edwards v. Destefano: Transfer-Related “Dead End” Excuses PLRA Exhaustion Requirement Introduction In Edwards v. Destefano, 23-7515 (2d Cir. Apr. 9, 2025), the Second Circuit addressed whether an...

Non-Designated “Terrorist” Label as Protected Opinion: Miller v. James

Date: Apr 10, 2025

Non-Designated “Terrorist” Label as Protected Opinion: Miller v. James 1. Introduction Miller v. James (2d Cir. Apr. 9, 2025) is a summary order affirming the dismissal of a civil rights and...

United States v. Young: Concrete Factual Showing Requirement for Evidentiary Hearings in Fourth Amendment Cyber Searches

Date: Apr 10, 2025

United States v. Young: Concrete Factual Showing Requirement for Evidentiary Hearings in Fourth Amendment Cyber Searches Introduction In United States v. Young, 23-6461-cr (2d Cir. Apr. 9, 2025), the...

Dead-End Exception in PLRA Exhaustion: Edwards v. Destefano

Date: Apr 10, 2025

Dead-End Exception in PLRA Exhaustion: Edwards v. Destefano Introduction Edwards v. Destefano (2d Cir. Apr. 9, 2025) clarifies when a prisoner’s transfer can render prison grievance procedures...

Edwards v. Destefano: Transfer-Induced Dead-End Tolling Under the PLRA

Date: Apr 10, 2025

Edwards v. Destefano: Transfer-Induced Dead-End Tolling Under the PLRA Introduction This case arises under 42 U.S.C. § 1983 and the administrative exhaustion requirement of the Prison Litigation...

Harmless-Deficiency Doctrine for Anders Briefs in Appeal-Waiver Cases

Date: Apr 10, 2025

Harmless-Deficiency Doctrine for Anders Briefs in Appeal-Waiver Cases Introduction This commentary examines the Second Circuit’s decision in United States v. Arguedas, 22-1355-cr (2d Cir. Apr. 9,...

United States v. Arguedas: Harmless Deficiency Doctrine for Incomplete Anders Briefs under Appeal Waivers

Date: Apr 10, 2025

United States v. Arguedas: Harmless Deficiency Doctrine for Incomplete Anders Briefs under Appeal Waivers Introduction United States v. Arguedas, decided April 9, 2025 by the Second Circuit,...

Credible Evidence and Pretext at Summary Judgment: Knox v. CRC Management Co.

Date: Apr 10, 2025

Credible Evidence and Pretext at Summary Judgment: Knox v. CRC Management Co. Introduction Knox v. CRC Management Co., decided April 9, 2025 by the Second Circuit (No. 23-121), addresses the proper...

Clarifying Summary Judgment Standards in Workplace Discrimination and Retaliation: Knox v. CRC Management Co.

Date: Apr 10, 2025

Clarifying Summary Judgment Standards in Workplace Discrimination and Retaliation: Knox v. CRC Management Co. Introduction Case: Natasha Knox v. CRC Management Co., LLC et al. Court: United States...

Opinion and Hyperbole Not Defamation: Standing and § 1983 Chilling Claims in Miller v. James

Date: Apr 10, 2025

Opinion and Hyperbole Not Defamation: Standing and § 1983 Chilling Claims in Miller v. James Introduction Miller et al. v. James, No. 24-2785 (2d Cir. Apr. 9, 2025), arose when two anti-abortion...

Khazin v. City of New York: Clarifying the Awareness and But-For Causation Standards in Title VII Retaliation Claims

Date: Apr 9, 2025

Khazin v. City of New York: Clarifying the Awareness and But-For Causation Standards in Title VII Retaliation Claims Introduction The Second Circuit’s summary order in Khazin v. City of New York...

United States v. Love: Necessity of Particularized Justification for Internet and Employment‐Related Conditions on Supervised Release

Date: Apr 9, 2025

United States v. Love: Necessity of Particularized Justification for Internet and Employment-Related Conditions on Supervised Release Introduction United States v. Love, 24‐1706‐cr (2d Cir. Apr. 8,...

United States v. Harris: Permissible Disclosure of PSR and Medical Records to Treatment Providers under Supervised Release

Date: Apr 9, 2025

United States v. Harris: Permissible Disclosure of PSR and Medical Records to Treatment Providers under Supervised Release Introduction United States v. Harris, 24-1099-cr (2d Cir. Apr. 8, 2025),...

Clarifying Eighth Amendment Deliberate Indifference: Medical Judgment and Diagnostic Imaging

Date: Apr 9, 2025

Clarifying Eighth Amendment Deliberate Indifference: Medical Judgment and Diagnostic Imaging Introduction Wright v. Martin, decided April 8, 2025 by the United States Court of Appeals for the Second...

Clarifying Summary Judgment Standards: Extraordinary Circumstances for New Evidence and Rule 56’s Affidavit Requirements

Date: Apr 9, 2025

Clarifying Summary Judgment Standards: Extraordinary Circumstances for New Evidence and Rule 56’s Affidavit Requirements 1. Introduction This commentary examines the Second Circuit’s summary order in...

Authorizing Disclosure of PSR and Mental-Health Records to Treatment Providers: Limits on Delegation in Supervised Release Conditions

Date: Apr 9, 2025

Authorizing Disclosure of PSR and Mental-Health Records to Treatment Providers: Limits on Delegation in Supervised Release Conditions Introduction This commentary analyzes the Second Circuit’s...

Applicability of the International Parental Kidnapping Crime Act to Void Foreign Marriages and Custody Contexts

Date: Apr 9, 2025

Applicability of the International Parental Kidnapping Crime Act to Void Foreign Marriages and Custody Contexts Introduction United States v. Helbrans, 22-1680-cr(L) (2d Cir. Apr. 8, 2025), presents...

Affirmation of SRO Deference and FAPE Adequacy in IDEA Appeals

Date: Apr 9, 2025

Affirmation of SRO Deference and FAPE Adequacy in IDEA Appeals Introduction Zayas v. Banks, 24-1076-cv (2d Cir. Apr. 8, 2025), addresses a challenge under the Individuals with Disabilities Education...