2d Circuit Case Commentaries

“Ensuring” Is Not “Compelling”: Second Circuit Clarifies Standing and APA §706(1) Constraints under the No Surprises Act

Date: Jul 23, 2025

“Ensuring” Is Not “Compelling”: Second Circuit Clarifies Standing and APA §706(1) Constraints under the No Surprises Act Commentary on Neurological Surgery Practice of Long Island, PLLC v. U.S. Dep’t...

Probable Cause Unshaken by Unreviewed Video Evidence: The Alberty v. Hunter Doctrine

Date: Jul 22, 2025

Probable Cause Unshaken by Unreviewed Video Evidence: The Alberty v. Hunter Doctrine Alberty v. Hunter, No. 23-7564-cv, United States Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit (decided 21 July 2025)...

Cementing Admissions: Second Circuit Confirms Rule 36 Requests May Address the “Application of Law to Fact” and Upholds Strict Consequences for Non-Response

Date: Jul 22, 2025

Cementing Admissions: Second Circuit Confirms Rule 36 Requests May Address the “Application of Law to Fact” and Upholds Strict Consequences for Non-Response 1. Introduction In Cement and Concrete...

Hernandez v. McIntosh: Seibert-Compliant Jury Instructions and the Limits of AEDPA Harmless-Error Deference

Date: Jul 22, 2025

Hernandez v. McIntosh: Seibert-Compliant Jury Instructions and the Limits of AEDPA Harmless-Error Deference 1. Introduction Pedro Hernandez was convicted in New York State court of the 1979...

United States v. Adamu: Automated Forensic Reports Held Non-Testimonial and §959’s Extraterritorial Reach Reaffirmed

Date: Jul 22, 2025

United States v. Adamu: Automated Forensic Reports Held Non-Testimonial and §959’s Extraterritorial Reach Reaffirmed Introduction United States v. Adamu, Nos. 23-6561 & 23-6696 (2d Cir. July 21,...

“Culpable-Nexus” Doctrine Under JASTA – A Commentary on Wildman v. Deutsche Bank

Date: Jul 22, 2025

Wildman v. Deutsche Bank – The Second Circuit Crystallises a “Culpable-Nexus” Requirement for Bank Liability under JASTA 1. Introduction In Wildman v. Deutsche Bank, Docket No. 23-132 (2d Cir....

Cable First v. Lepetiuk Engineering: The Second Circuit’s Clear Warning on Frivolous Appeals, Misrepresented Ownership, and Rule 38 Sanctions

Date: Jul 22, 2025

Cable First v. Lepetiuk Engineering: The Second Circuit’s Clear Warning on Frivolous Appeals, Misrepresented Ownership, and Rule 38 Sanctions Introduction Cable First Construction, Inc. (“Cable...

Clarifying Warrant-Exception Boundaries During Police “Wellness Checks” – A Commentary on Alicea v. City of Bridgeport

Date: Jul 22, 2025

Clarifying Warrant-Exception Boundaries During Police “Wellness Checks” – A Commentary on Alicea v. City of Bridgeport 1. Introduction Jurisdiction & Panel: Second Circuit Court of Appeals (Judges...

Perpetuating Diversity Jurisdiction after Partial Dismissal: The Second Circuit’s Clarification in Banga v. Lustig (2025)

Date: Jul 22, 2025

Perpetuating Diversity Jurisdiction after Partial Dismissal: The Second Circuit’s Clarification in Banga v. Lustig (2025) Introduction Banga v. Lustig, 24-140-cv, is a Second Circuit summary order...

Clarifying Section 29(b) Rescission: Convertible Notes Not Voidable Absent Contractual Broker-Dealer Obligations – Commentary on EMA Financial, LLC v. Vystar Corp. (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Jul 22, 2025

Clarifying Section 29(b) Rescission: Convertible Notes Not Voidable Absent Contractual Broker-Dealer Obligations – Commentary on EMA Financial, LLC v. Vystar Corp. (2d Cir. 2025) Introduction The...

Gluck v. Hecla Mining Co.: The Second Circuit’s Reinforcement of Strict PSLRA Pleading—Puffery, Scienter, and Safe-Harbor in Securities Fraud

Date: Jul 22, 2025

Gluck v. Hecla Mining Co.: The Second Circuit’s Reinforcement of Strict PSLRA Pleading—Puffery, Scienter, and Safe-Harbor in Securities Fraud Introduction In Gluck v. Hecla Mining Co. (24-2947-cv),...

Standard Account Terms as a Global Waiver of Sovereign Immunity & The Civil Nature of Large Coercive Fines ― A Commentary on JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. v. VTB Bank, P.J.S.C. (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Jul 22, 2025

Standard Account Terms as a Global Waiver of Sovereign Immunity & The Civil Nature of Large Coercive Fines Comprehensive Commentary on JPMorgan Chase Bank, N.A. v. VTB Bank, P.J.S.C. United States...

The Illusion of APA Work-Arounds: Quezada Palacios v. Bondi and the Second Circuit’s Re-affirmation of § 1252(a)(2)(B)’s Jurisdictional Bar

Date: Jul 22, 2025

The Illusion of APA Work-Arounds: Quezada Palacios v. Bondi and the Second Circuit’s Re-affirmation of § 1252(a)(2)(B)’s Jurisdictional Bar 1. Introduction Kevin Donely Quezada Palacios (“Quezada”),...

“Hostile Appropriation by a Co-Owner” and “Active Concealment” as Dual Triggers: Commentary on Su v. Yeh (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Jul 22, 2025

“Hostile Appropriation by a Co-Owner” and “Active Concealment” as Dual Triggers for Conversion & Equitable Estoppel: An In-Depth Commentary on Su v. Yeh, 24-0653 (2d Cir. 2025) 1. Introduction...

Second Circuit Endorses “One-Facility / One-Remediation” Rule: Statute of Limitations Under CERCLA Runs from the First Physical Cleanup

Date: Jul 22, 2025

Second Circuit Endorses “One-Facility / One-Remediation” Rule: Statute of Limitations Under CERCLA Runs from the First Physical Cleanup I. Introduction On 17 July 2025, the United States Court of...

“Grave Doubt” in Coram Nobis: Johnson v. United States and the Second Circuit’s Refined Harmless-Error Framework after Ciminelli

Date: Jul 22, 2025

“Grave Doubt” in Coram Nobis: Johnson v. United States and the Second Circuit’s Refined Harmless-Error Framework after Ciminelli Introduction Johnson v. United States, No. 24-1221 (2d Cir. July 17,...

Qualified Immunity for Indirect Regulatory Coercion of Non-Expressive Conduct: A Commentary on Nat’l Rifle Ass’n of Am. v. Vullo (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Jul 22, 2025

Qualified Immunity for Indirect Regulatory Coercion of Non-Expressive Conduct: A Commentary on Nat’l Rifle Ass’n of Am. v. Vullo (2d Cir. 2025) 1. Introduction On 17 July 2025 the United States Court...

“Contingent GDP-Linked Payments Are Not ‘Principal or Interest’” – Commentary on Argentine GDP-Linked Securities Litigation (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Jul 22, 2025

“Contingent GDP-Linked Payments Are Not ‘Principal or Interest’” Commentary on the Second Circuit’s Argentine GDP-Linked Securities Litigation Summary Order (2025) 1. Introduction The Second...

Re-affirming the “Central Reason” Nexus Standard in Mixed-Motive Asylum Cases: A Commentary on Figueroa-Serrano v. Bondi (2d Cir. 2025)

Date: Jul 22, 2025

Re-affirming the “Central Reason” Nexus Standard in Mixed-Motive Asylum Cases: A Commentary on Figueroa-Serrano v. Bondi (2d Cir. 2025) 1. Introduction In Figueroa-Serrano v. Bondi, the United States...

Fredricks v. Shaheen: The Second Circuit Re-emphasizes the Courts’ Dual Duty to Furnish Rule 56 Notice and Verify Service on Pro Se Litigants

Date: Jul 22, 2025

Fredricks v. Shaheen: The Second Circuit Re-emphasizes the Courts’ Dual Duty to Furnish Rule 56 Notice and Verify Service on Pro Se Litigants Introduction Fredricks v. Shaheen, No. 22-2480 (2d Cir....