1st Circuit Case Commentaries

First Circuit Affirms AEDPA’s One-Year Limitation and Restricts Equitable Tolling in Delaney v. Matesanz

Date: Sep 6, 2001

First Circuit Affirms AEDPA’s One-Year Limitation and Restricts Equitable Tolling in Delaney v. Matesanz Introduction In Charles C. Delaney III v. James Matesanz et al., the United States Court of...

Zimmerman v. Direct Federal Credit Union: Establishing Precedents on Workplace Retaliation and Punitive Damages

Date: Sep 5, 2001

Zimmerman v. Direct Federal Credit Union: Establishing Precedents on Workplace Retaliation and Punitive Damages Introduction Zimmerman v. Direct Federal Credit Union and David Breslin is a landmark...

Standing in Bankruptcy Appeals Under § 363(m): In re Spenlinhauer

Date: Aug 21, 2001

Standing in Bankruptcy Appeals Under § 363(m): In re Spenlinhauer Introduction The case Robert J. Spenlinhauer v. Joseph V. O'Donnell, Trustee in Bankruptcy delves into the intricacies of bankruptcy...

Interpretation and Tolling of AEDPA’s One-Year Limitation: Neverson v. Bissonnette

Date: Aug 21, 2001

Interpretation and Tolling of AEDPA’s One-Year Limitation: Neverson v. Bissonnette Introduction In the landmark appellate case of Neverson v. Bissonnette, the United States Court of Appeals for the...

Redefining Disability Under the FMLA: First Circuit Sets New Precedent

Date: Aug 21, 2001

Redefining Disability Under the FMLA: First Circuit Sets New Precedent Introduction The case of Gladys Navarro-Pomares v. Pfizer Corporation represents a pivotal moment in the interpretation of the...

United States v. Davis et al.: Affirming Standards for CERCLA Consent Decrees and Contribution Allocations

Date: Aug 18, 2001

United States v. Davis et al.: Affirming Standards for CERCLA Consent Decrees and Contribution Allocations Introduction United States of America, Plaintiff, Appellee, v. William M. Davis, et al.,...

Affirmation of Dischargeability under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(2)(A) in Bankruptcy Proceedings

Date: Aug 14, 2001

Affirmation of Dischargeability under 11 U.S.C. § 523(a)(2)(A) in Bankruptcy Proceedings Introduction The case of In re: Robert T. Spigel, Debtor explores the intricate relationship between...

Excusable Neglect and Attorneys’ Duty of Diligence under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b)(1): Dávila-Álvarez v. Central Universidad

Date: Aug 7, 2001

Excusable Neglect and Attorneys’ Duty of Diligence under Federal Rule of Civil Procedure 60(b)(1): Dávila-Álvarez v. Central Universidad Introduction The case of Dávila-Álvarez; Fernández-Ramírez;...

Trade Dress and Merger Doctrine in Appellate Review: Insights from Yankee Candle Co. v. Bridgewater Candle Co.

Date: Aug 7, 2001

Trade Dress and Merger Doctrine in Appellate Review: Insights from Yankee Candle Co. v. Bridgewater Candle Co. Introduction In the appellate case The YANKEE CANDLE COMPANY, INC., Plaintiff, Appellant...

Fortini v. Murphy: Federal Habeas Corpus and the Exhaustion of State Remedies

Date: Jul 28, 2001

Fortini v. Murphy: Federal Habeas Corpus and the Exhaustion of State Remedies Introduction Fortini v. Murphy, 257 F.3d 39 (1st Cir. 2001), is a pivotal case that delves into the intricacies of...

Validity of Presentence Waivers of Appellate Rights in Plea Agreements: United States v. Teeter

Date: Jul 24, 2001

Validity of Presentence Waivers of Appellate Rights in Plea Agreements: United States v. Teeter Introduction United States of America v. Patricia A. Teeter is a pivotal case adjudicated by the United...

First Circuit Reaffirms Due Process in Administrative Forfeiture: Gonzalez-Gonzalez v. United States

Date: Jul 24, 2001

First Circuit Reaffirms Due Process in Administrative Forfeiture: Gonzalez-Gonzalez v. United States Introduction Manuel Gonzalez-Gonzalez v. United States is a pivotal case adjudicated by the United...

United States v. Brunette: Redefining Probable Cause and Good Faith in Child Pornography Investigations

Date: Jul 13, 2001

United States v. Brunette: Redefining Probable Cause and Good Faith in Child Pornography Investigations Introduction The case of United States v. Brunette addresses critical issues surrounding the...

Reaffirming the Clear Error Standard in Subject-Matter Jurisdiction: The Valentin v. Hospital Bella Vista Decision

Date: Jun 28, 2001

Reaffirming the Clear Error Standard in Subject-Matter Jurisdiction: The Valentin v. Hospital Bella Vista Decision Introduction The case of Helga E. Valentin v. Hospital Bella Vista, decided by the...

Mootness in Class Action Litigation: Insights from Cruz v. Farquharson

Date: Jun 13, 2001

Mootness in Class Action Litigation: Insights from Cruz v. Farquharson Introduction The landmark case of Maria Antonia Cruz, et al. v. Steven J. Farquharson, decided by the United States Court of...

Essential Job Functions and Reasonable Accommodations under the ADA: A Comprehensive Commentary on Phelps v. Optima Health, Inc.

Date: May 31, 2001

Essential Job Functions and Reasonable Accommodations under the ADA: A Comprehensive Commentary on Phelps v. Optima Health, Inc. Introduction In the case of Simonne Phelps, Plaintiff, Appellant v....

Enforcement of Amount in Controversy Requirement in Class Actions under 28 U.S.C. §1332: Spielman v. Genzyme

Date: May 25, 2001

Enforcement of Amount in Controversy Requirement in Class Actions under 28 U.S.C. §1332: Spielman v. Genzyme Introduction Spielman v. Genzyme Corp. is a landmark decision by the United States Court...

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Straughn v. Delta Air Lines: No Discrimination Found in Employment Termination

Date: May 18, 2001

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Straughn v. Delta Air Lines: No Discrimination Found in Employment Termination Introduction Case: Claire A. Straughn v. Delta Air Lines, Inc. Court: United States...

Wilson v. Union Underwear Company: Establishing Limits on Failure to Warn Claims Under the Flammable Fabrics Act

Date: May 18, 2001

Wilson v. Union Underwear Company: Establishing Limits on Failure to Warn Claims Under the Flammable Fabrics Act Introduction In Wilson v. Union Underwear Company, Inc., the United States Court of...

First Circuit Upholds Maine Rx Program: Implications for Preemption and Dormant Commerce Clause

Date: May 17, 2001

First Circuit Upholds Maine Rx Program: Implications for Preemption and Dormant Commerce Clause Introduction The case of Pharmaceutical Research and Manufacturers of America (PhRMA) v. Ke (249 F.3d...