1st Circuit Case Commentaries

Rehabilitation Act Mandates Reasonable Accommodation: Syl v. Calero-Cerezo

Date: Jan 15, 2004

Rehabilitation Act Mandates Reasonable Accommodation: Syl v. Calero-Cerezo Introduction The case of Sylvia I. Calero-Cerezo v. United States Department of Justice explores the obligations of federal...

Reevaluation of Statute of Limitations Tolling: Rodríguez-García v. Municipality of Caguas

Date: Jan 8, 2004

Reevaluation of Statute of Limitations Tolling: Rodríguez-García v. Municipality of Caguas Introduction Rodríguez-García v. Municipality of Caguas, 354 F.3d 91 (1st Cir. 2004), represents a...

Establishing the 'Willful' Standard for FMLA Violations: A Comprehensive Analysis of Hillstrom v. Best Western TLC Hotel

Date: Jan 1, 2004

Establishing the 'Willful' Standard for FMLA Violations: A Comprehensive Analysis of Hillstrom v. Best Western TLC Hotel Introduction Hillstrom v. Best Western TLC Hotel, 354 F.3d 27 (1st Cir. 2003),...

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Employment Discrimination: Employer Liability Requires Tangible Employment Action or Severe and Pervasive Harassment

Date: Jan 1, 2004

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Employment Discrimination: Employer Liability Requires Tangible Employment Action or Severe and Pervasive Harassment Introduction In the case of Alice Mercedes...

Waiver of Eleventh Amendment Immunity in Special Education Cases: Nieves-Márquez v. Commonwealth of Puerto Rico

Date: Dec 25, 2003

Waiver of Eleventh Amendment Immunity in Special Education Cases: Nieves-Márquez v. Commonwealth of Puerto Rico Introduction In Nieves-Márquez; Jesús Nieves; Leonor Márquez v. The Commonwealth of...

Excessive Force and Attorney's Fees: Phaly POY v. John Boutselis et al. - A Comprehensive Analysis

Date: Dec 20, 2003

Excessive Force and Attorney's Fees: Phaly POY v. John Boutselis et al. - A Comprehensive Analysis Introduction The case of Phaly Poy v. John Boutselis, et al. (352 F.3d 479) adjudicated by the...

APPRENDI v. NEW JERSEY Applied: Sentencing Error in United States v. Julio Perez-Ruiz

Date: Dec 20, 2003

APPRENDI v. NEW JERSEY Applied: Sentencing Error in United States v. Julio Perez-Ruiz Introduction The case of United States of America v. Julio Perez-Ruiz (353 F.3d 1) presents a pivotal application...

Retaliation Claims under the ADA: Pretextual Discharge Recognized in Wright v. CompUSA

Date: Dec 20, 2003

Retaliation Claims under the ADA: Pretextual Discharge Recognized in Wright v. CompUSA Introduction The case Stephen D. Wright v. CompUSA, Inc. (352 F.3d 472, 1st Cir. 2003) serves as a significant...

A Comprehensive Commentary on Acevedo-García v. Monroig: Establishing Precedents in Political Discrimination Jurisprudence

Date: Dec 6, 2003

Establishing Boundaries: The Precedential Impact of Acevedo-García v. Monroig on Political Discrimination and Collateral Estoppel Introduction Acevedo-García v. Monroig, adjudicated by the United...

First Circuit's Landmark Ruling on FLSA Overtime Applicability to Municipal Police Officers

Date: Dec 3, 2003

First Circuit's Landmark Ruling on FLSA Overtime Applicability to Municipal Police Officers Introduction In the case of Gary O'BRIEN et al. v. Town of Agawam et al., the United States Court of...

Rosario-Urdaz v. Rivera-Hernandez: Establishing Enhanced Standards for Preliminary Injunctions in §1983 Political Discrimination Claims

Date: Nov 26, 2003

Rosario-Urdaz v. Rivera-Hernandez: Establishing Enhanced Standards for Preliminary Injunctions in §1983 Political Discrimination Claims Introduction Rosario-Urdaz v. Rivera-Hernandez, 350 F.3d 219...

Enhancing Brady Compliance: First Circuit Upholds Habeas Relief in Norton v. Spencer

Date: Oct 31, 2003

Enhancing Brady Compliance: First Circuit Upholds Habeas Relief in Norton v. Spencer Introduction In Roger Norton v. Luis Spencer, 351 F.3d 1 (1st Cir. 2003), the United States Court of Appeals for...

Implied Waiver of Attorney-Client Privilege: XYZ Corporation v. United States

Date: Oct 23, 2003

Implied Waiver of Attorney-Client Privilege: XYZ Corporation v. United States Introduction Case: In re KEEPER OF THE RECORDS (GRAND JURY SUBPOENA ADDRESSED TO XYZ CORPORATION). XYZ Corporation,...

Strict Service Requirements and the Limited Scope of Rule 60(b): Analysis of CAISSE v. DUBOIS

Date: Oct 7, 2003

Strict Service Requirements and the Limited Scope of Rule 60(b): Analysis of CAISSE v. DUBOIS Introduction CAISSE v. DUBOIS, 346 F.3d 213 (1st Cir. 2003), is a significant appellate decision...

Corporations Excluded from Section 362(h) Damages for Automatic Stay Violations: In re Spookyworld, Inc.

Date: Sep 26, 2003

Corporations Excluded from Section 362(h) Damages for Automatic Stay Violations: In re Spookyworld, Inc. Introduction The case of In re: Spookyworld, Inc. (346 F.3d 1) revolves around the Town of...

First Circuit Upholds Non-Arbitration for Nonsignatory Parties under FAA Chapter 2

Date: Sep 23, 2003

First Circuit Upholds Non-Arbitration for Nonsignatory Parties under FAA Chapter 2 Introduction In the landmark case of InterGen N.V. v. Eric F. Grina, Alstom (Switzerland) Limited, and Alstom Power...

Clarifying Property Interests in Transitory Public Employment under Law 52: Maria E. Gomez Candelaria v. Jose A. Rivera Rodriguez

Date: Sep 19, 2003

Clarifying Property Interests in Transitory Public Employment under Law 52: Maria E. Gomez Candelaria v. Jose A. Rivera Rodriguez Introduction The case of Maria E. Gomez Candelaria, et al. v. Jose A....

Expansion of the Discovery Rule in Federal Tort Claims Act: Comprehensive Analysis of Statia A. Skwira v. United States

Date: Sep 16, 2003

Expansion of the Discovery Rule in Federal Tort Claims Act: Comprehensive Analysis of Statia A. Skwira v. United States Introduction In the landmark case Statia A. Skwira, as Administratrix of the...

Remand of Vega-Encarnación's Civil Rights Claim for Further Proceedings

Date: Sep 13, 2003

Remand of Vega-Encarnación's Civil Rights Claim for Further Proceedings Introduction The case of Víctor Vega-Encarnación v. Eustaquio Babilonia et al. involves a civil rights complaint filed by...

Arevalo v. Ashcroft: Standard for Stays of Removal and Retroactive Application of IIRIRA's Reinstatement Provision

Date: Aug 30, 2003

Arevalo v. Ashcroft: Standard for Stays of Removal and Retroactive Application of IIRIRA's Reinstatement Provision Introduction Gloria Arevalo, the petitioner, challenged the United States...