1st Circuit Case Commentaries

Halsey v. Fedcap Rehabilitation Services: Affirming Administrative Remedy Requirements under Maine Law

Date: Mar 5, 2024

Halsey v. Fedcap Rehabilitation Services: Affirming Administrative Remedy Requirements under Maine Law Introduction The case of Sara Halsey and Susan Kiralis-Vernon v. Fedcap Rehabilitation Services,...

Esteban-Garcia v. Garland: Strengthening the Nexus Requirement in Asylum Claims

Date: Mar 1, 2024

Esteban-Garcia v. Garland: Strengthening the Nexus Requirement in Asylum Claims Introduction Esteban-Garcia v. Garland, a decision by the United States Court of Appeals for the First Circuit,...

Affirmation of 'Now Settled' Defense Criteria under the Hague Convention: Da Costa v. de Lima

Date: Feb 29, 2024

Affirmation of 'Now Settled' Defense Criteria under the Hague Convention: Da Costa v. de Lima Introduction Da Costa v. de Lima (94 F.4th 174) is a landmark decision by the United States Court of...

Affirmation of Maximum Revocation Sentence in Supervised Release Violation Cases

Date: Feb 24, 2024

Affirmation of Maximum Revocation Sentence in Supervised Release Violation Cases Introduction UNITED STATES OF AMERICA v. MICHAEL RAND is a pivotal case adjudicated by the United States Court of...

Affirmation of Compulsory Process Limitations and Daubert Standards in Cryptocurrency Fraud Convictions

Date: Feb 24, 2024

Affirmation of Compulsory Process Limitations and Daubert Standards in Cryptocurrency Fraud Convictions Introduction In the landmark case of United States of America v. Randall Crater, 93 F.4th 581...

Procedural Reasonableness and Plea Agreement Compliance in U.S. v. Sierra-Jimenez

Date: Feb 24, 2024

Procedural Reasonableness and Plea Agreement Compliance in U.S. v. Sierra-Jimenez Introduction In the case of United States of America v. Juan Daniel Sierra-Jimenez, 93 F.4th 565 (1st Cir. 2024), the...

United States v. Katana: Affirmation of Conspiracy to Rob under the Hobbs Act and Clarification on Constructive Amendments

Date: Feb 23, 2024

United States v. Katana: Affirmation of Conspiracy to Rob under the Hobbs Act and Clarification on Constructive Amendments Introduction In United States v. Katana, the United States Court of Appeals...

Strict Criteria for Insurance Reimbursement Claims Established in Berkley National Insurance Co. v. Atlantic-Newport Realty LLC

Date: Feb 23, 2024

Strict Criteria for Insurance Reimbursement Claims Established in Berkley National Insurance Co. v. Atlantic-Newport Realty LLC Introduction In the landmark case of Berkley National Insurance Company...

McBreairty v. Miller: Affirming the Necessity of Intent for Standing in First Amendment Injunctions

Date: Feb 22, 2024

McBreairty v. Miller: Affirming the Necessity of Intent for Standing in First Amendment Injunctions Introduction In the case of Shawn McBreairty v. Heath Miller, decided by the United States Court of...

Public Policy and Enforceability of Concealed Agreements in Gaming Licenses: Gattineri v. Wynn MA, LLC

Date: Feb 21, 2024

Public Policy and Enforceability of Concealed Agreements in Gaming Licenses: Gattineri v. Wynn MA, LLC Introduction In Gattineri v. Wynn MA, LLC; Wynn Resorts Limited, Defendants, Appellees, 93 F.4th...

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Employment Discrimination Case: Boykin v. Genzyme Therapeutic Products

Date: Feb 17, 2024

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in Employment Discrimination Case: Boykin v. Genzyme Therapeutic Products Introduction The case of Charles Boykin v. Genzyme Therapeutic Products, LP and Paul...

Reaffirmation of Strict Issue Preclusion Standards: Overruling Virtual Representation in Santiago-Martínez v. Fundacion Damas

Date: Feb 17, 2024

Reaffirmation of Strict Issue Preclusion Standards: Overruling Virtual Representation in Santiago-Martínez v. Fundacion Damas Introduction In the landmark case of Santiago-Martínez v. Fundacion...

Establishing Firm Fiduciary Responsibilities in ERISA-Regulated Insurance Premium Adjustments

Date: Feb 15, 2024

Establishing Firm Fiduciary Responsibilities in ERISA-Regulated Insurance Premium Adjustments Introduction The appellate case of Barbara M. Parmenter v. The Prudential Insurance Company of America;...

Ensuring Due Process: First-Time Counsel Non-Appearance Insufficient for Dismissal

Date: Feb 15, 2024

Ensuring Due Process: First-Time Counsel Non-Appearance Insufficient for Dismissal Introduction The case of VIVALDI SERVICIOS DE SEGURIDAD, INC. v. MAISO GROUP, CORP. presents a pivotal moment in the...

Affirmation of Qualified Immunity in State-Created Danger Doctrine: Johnson v. City of Biddeford

Date: Feb 14, 2024

Affirmation of Qualified Immunity in State-Created Danger Doctrine: Johnson v. City of Biddeford Introduction Johnson v. City of Biddeford is a significant appellate decision from the United States...

Extraterritorial Application of State Dealer Law and Subject-Matter Jurisdiction: RITC v. Daimler Trucks

Date: Feb 10, 2024

Extraterritorial Application of State Dealer Law and Subject-Matter Jurisdiction: RITC v. Daimler Trucks North America, LLC Introduction The case of Rhode Island Truck Center, LLC (RITC) versus...

Limits on Imputation of Personal Jurisdiction in Securities Fraud Cases: SEC v. Gastauer

Date: Feb 10, 2024

Limits on Imputation of Personal Jurisdiction in Securities Fraud Cases: SEC v. Gastauer Introduction In the landmark case, SEC v. Raimund Gastauer, the United States Court of Appeals for the First...

Martins v. Vermont Mutual Insurance Co.: Affirming the Necessity of a Final Judgment for Breach of Contract Claims Against Insurers

Date: Feb 7, 2024

Martins v. Vermont Mutual Insurance Co.: Affirming the Necessity of a Final Judgment for Breach of Contract Claims Against Insurers Introduction In the case of Jonathan Martins, individually and on...

Expansion of NVRA's Public Disclosure Requirements: Preemption of Maine's Voter File Restrictions

Date: Feb 3, 2024

Expansion of NVRA's Public Disclosure Requirements: Preemption of Maine's Voter File Restrictions Introduction In the case of Public Interest Legal Foundation, Inc. v. Shenna Bellows, the United...

First Circuit Clarifies Rule 608(b) and Corroborative Testimony Requirements in Eighth Amendment Deliberate Indifference Cases: Lech v. Goeler

Date: Feb 3, 2024

First Circuit Clarifies Rule 608(b) and Corroborative Testimony Requirements in Eighth Amendment Deliberate Indifference Cases: Lech v. Goeler Introduction In the landmark case of Lidia Lech v....