1st Circuit Case Commentaries

Qualified Immunity for Contracted State Actors in Parental Rights Interference: Frazier v. Bailey

Date: Feb 25, 1992

Qualified Immunity for Contracted State Actors in Parental Rights Interference: Frazier v. Bailey Introduction Frazier v. Bailey is a significant case decided by the United States Court of Appeals...

Appellate Review of Counterclaims and Fraudulent Concealment Standards: Insights from Putnam Resources v. Pateman

Date: Feb 21, 1992

Appellate Review of Counterclaims and Fraudulent Concealment Standards: Insights from Putnam Resources v. Pateman Introduction Putnam Resources, Ltd., a Connecticut-based precious metals vendor,...

Estoppel and Statutory Penalties under ERISA: Analysis of Donald Law v. Ernst Young

Date: Feb 13, 1992

Estoppel and Statutory Penalties under ERISA: Analysis of Donald Law v. Ernst Young Introduction Donald Law v. Ernst Young, etc., 956 F.2d 364 (1st Cir. 1992) is a pivotal case in the realm of...

Clarifying Scope of Employment and Discretionary Function Exceptions in FTCA Claims: Attallah v. United States

Date: Feb 6, 1992

Clarifying Scope of Employment and Discretionary Function Exceptions in FTCA Claims: Attallah v. United States Introduction The case of Elias Attallah, Violeta Lajam de Attallah, and the Conjugal...

Reaffirming the Burdens of Proof in Bankruptcy Discharge Proceedings: In Re Philip N. Burgess, Jr.

Date: Feb 1, 1992

Reaffirming the Burdens of Proof in Bankruptcy Discharge Proceedings: In Re Philip N. Burgess, Jr. Introduction The case of In Re Philip N. Burgess, Jr. involves complex bankruptcy proceedings in...

Woburn Associates v. Herbert C. Kahn: Clarifying the Scope of Administrative Expense Priority for Prepetition Indemnification Claims in Chapter 7 Liquidations

Date: Jan 17, 1992

Woburn Associates v. Herbert C. Kahn: Clarifying the Scope of Administrative Expense Priority for Prepetition Indemnification Claims in Chapter 7 Liquidations Introduction The case of Woburn...

Protected Expressions of Opinion in Defamation: Phantom Touring, Inc. v. Affiliated Publications

Date: Jan 11, 1992

Protected Expressions of Opinion in Defamation: Phantom Touring, Inc. v. Affiliated Publications Introduction In Phantom Touring, Inc. v. Affiliated Publications, et al., the United States Court of...

Affirmation of the Requirement for a Meritorious Claim in Rule 60(b)(6) Motions: Teamsters v. Superline Transportation Co.

Date: Jan 8, 1992

Affirmation of the Requirement for a Meritorious Claim in Rule 60(b)(6) Motions: Teamsters v. Superline Transportation Co. Introduction The case of Teamsters, Chauffeurs, Warehousemen and Helpers...

Affirmation of ALJ’s Residual Functional Capacity Assessment in Social Security Disability Determination

Date: Dec 31, 1991

Affirmation of ALJ’s Residual Functional Capacity Assessment in Social Security Disability Determination Introduction In the landmark case of Ramonita Cintron Perez v. Secretary of Health and Human...

Clarifying the Boundaries of "Sufficient Excuse" in Bail-Jumping Statutes: Insights from Love v. Butler

Date: Dec 20, 1991

Clarifying the Boundaries of "Sufficient Excuse" in Bail-Jumping Statutes: Insights from Love v. Butler Introduction Alvin Love v. Norman Butler is a pivotal case decided by the United States Court...

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in MESNICK v. GENERAL ELECTRIC CO.: Clarifying the Burden-Shifting Framework under ADEA and Rule 56

Date: Dec 17, 1991

Affirmation of Summary Judgment in MESNICK v. GENERAL ELECTRIC CO.: Clarifying the Burden-Shifting Framework under ADEA and Rule 56 Introduction In MESNICK v. GENERAL ELECTRIC COmpany, 950 F.2d 816...

Affirming Non-Testifying Physicians' Reports in Residual Functional Capacity Assessments: Berrios Lopez v. HHS

Date: Dec 13, 1991

Affirming Non-Testifying Physicians' Reports in Residual Functional Capacity Assessments: Berrios Lopez v. HHS Introduction In the case of Paulina Berrios Lopez v. Secretary of Health and Human...

Substantial Evidence Standard and Impairment Assessment in Disability Benefits: Ortiz v. Secretary of Health and Human Services

Date: Dec 10, 1991

Substantial Evidence Standard and Impairment Assessment in Disability Benefits Ortiz v. Secretary of Health and Human Services, 955 F.2d 765 (1st Cir. 1991) Introduction Ortiz v. Secretary of Health...

Strict Enforcement of Appeal Timelines and Limits on Excusable Neglect in Bankruptcy Contempt: Eck v. Dodge Chemical Co.

Date: Nov 28, 1991

Strict Enforcement of Appeal Timelines and Limits on Excusable Neglect in Bankruptcy Contempt: Eck v. Dodge Chemical Co. Introduction The case of David W. Eck v. Dodge Chemical Company presents a...

Clarifying Organizational Leadership and Extensiveness Under U.S.S.G. § 3B1.1(a): Commentary on United States v. William A. Dietz

Date: Nov 28, 1991

Clarifying Organizational Leadership and Extensiveness Under U.S.S.G. § 3B1.1(a): Commentary on United States v. William A. Dietz Introduction United States of America v. William A. Dietz, 950 F.2d...

ERISA’s Supremacy over State Mechanics' Lien Laws Affirmed in McCoy v. MIT

Date: Nov 20, 1991

ERISA’s Supremacy over State Mechanics' Lien Laws Affirmed in McCoy v. MIT Introduction The case of James L. McCoy, Administrator of the Electrical Workers Trust Funds, etc., Plaintiff, Appellant, v....

Exhaustion of State Remedies and Preemption in Federal Habeas Corpus: An Analysis of Tart v. Commonwealth of Massachusetts

Date: Nov 16, 1991

Exhaustion of State Remedies and Preemption in Federal Habeas Corpus: An Analysis of Tart v. Commonwealth of Massachusetts Introduction The case of Wesley P. Tart v. Commonwealth of Massachusetts...

Affirmation of Deliberate Indifference Standard in Eighth Amendment Prisoner Medical Care Claims: DesRosiers v. Moran

Date: Nov 16, 1991

Affirmation of Deliberate Indifference Standard in Eighth Amendment Prisoner Medical Care Claims: DesRosiers v. Moran Introduction In the landmark case Steven M. DesRosiers v. John J. Moran et al....

Clarissa Miranda v. Ponce Federal Bank: Defining the Boundaries of Civil RICO Claims

Date: Oct 30, 1991

Clarissa Miranda v. Ponce Federal Bank: Defining the Boundaries of Civil RICO Claims Introduction Clarissa Miranda et al. v. Ponce Federal Bank et al., 948 F.2d 41 (1st Cir. 1991), presents a pivotal...

Independent Review and Individualized Analysis in Pretrial Detention: Insights from United States v. Patriarca

Date: Oct 29, 1991

Independent Review and Individualized Analysis in Pretrial Detention: Insights from United States v. Patriarca Introduction United States v. Raymond J. Patriarca, 948 F.2d 789 (1st Cir. 1991), is a...