periodic-inspection Case Commentaries

Conspiracy to Supply: When “Significantly Higher Than Category 1” Justifies Going Beyond Drug Guideline Ranges, with Class B Conspiracy as Aggravation

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Conspiracy to Supply: When “Significantly Higher Than Category 1” Justifies Going Beyond Drug Guideline Ranges, with Class B Conspiracy as Aggravation 1. Introduction In R v Worrall & Ors [2026] EWCA...

Officer Apparent Bias Can Vitiate a s.193(7) CLEUD Revocation Where Members Rely on an Unfair and Unbalanced Report

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Officer Apparent Bias Can Vitiate a s.193(7) CLEUD Revocation Where Members Rely on an Unfair and Unbalanced Report 1. Introduction Ocean One Hundred Ltd, R (On the Application Of) v New Forest...

Blackmail Guideline: “Substantial period” and “sophisticated planning” assessed per count, but totality may still justify a high overall term

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Blackmail Guideline: “Substantial period” and “sophisticated planning” assessed per count, but totality may still justify a high overall term Case: Williamson, R. v [2026] EWCA Crim 548 Court: Court...

Misuse of Corporate IT Administrator Access to Obtain Litigation Advantage Bars Equitable Relief and Engages the High Court’s Inherent Jurisdiction

Date: Apr 24, 2026

Misuse of Corporate IT Administrator Access to Obtain Litigation Advantage Bars Equitable Relief and Engages the High Court’s Inherent Jurisdiction Case: Kelly v Store All Logistics Ltd (Approved)...

R v HGF [2026] EWCA Crim 570 — Staying Proceedings Where Police Fail to Secure CCTV Central to Credibility

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Staying Proceedings as Abuse of Process Where Police Fail to Obtain CCTV Central to Credibility (and a Fair Trial Cannot Be Cured by Directions) 1. Introduction R v HGF [2026] EWCA Crim 570 is a...

IPAT must give logical, explicit reasons when rejecting PTSD/memory evidence in credibility assessments

Date: Apr 23, 2026

IPAT must give logical, explicit reasons when rejecting PTSD/memory evidence in credibility assessments 1) Introduction In G.K. (Ghana, Medical Evidence, Memory) v The International Protection...

[2026] CSIH 20 — Investor Warranties and the Limits of Determining Implied Waiver/Personal Bar at Debate

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Investor Warranties Do Not Ordinarily Prove Implied Waiver/Personal Bar at Debate: Proof Required Where Waiver Is Alleged Between Co‑Warrantors 1) Introduction In Reclaiming Motion by the Founder...

Section 50 Non-Refoulement Is Not a Standalone “Ordinary JR” Decision: Upstream International Protection Decisions Fall Within the 28-Day, Substantial-Grounds Regime

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Section 50 Non-Refoulement Is Not a Standalone “Ordinary JR” Decision: Upstream International Protection Decisions Fall Within the 28-Day, Substantial-Grounds Regime Case: TE v The International...

Late “fraud” amendments refused where vague, unexplained and potentially limitation-defeating; other clarificatory amendments allowed (Order 28 RSC)

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Late “fraud” amendments refused where vague, unexplained and potentially limitation-defeating; other clarificatory amendments allowed (Order 28 RSC) Case: Tolan v Mayo County Council [No. 1]...

Inquest Scope and “Coronial Causation”: Police Omission Cannot Be Excluded as “Speculative” Without Key Criminal-Justice Materials

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Inquest Scope and “Coronial Causation”: Police Omission Cannot Be Excluded as “Speculative” Without Key Criminal-Justice Materials Case: O'Brien, R (On the Application Of) v HM Assistant Coroner for...

Suspension is Not Presumptive: Immediate Custody May Be Required for Sustained, Extremely Dangerous Police-Evasion Driving

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Suspension is Not Presumptive: Immediate Custody May Be Required for Sustained, Extremely Dangerous Police-Evasion Driving 1) Introduction In Rex v Bristow ([2026] EWCA Crim 633), the Court of Appeal...

Arrest on an Outstanding Warrant During Jury Deliberations Does Not Automatically Require Re-Exercising the “Trial in Absence” Discretion

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Arrest on an Outstanding Warrant During Jury Deliberations Does Not Automatically Require Re-Exercising the “Trial in Absence” Discretion 1) Introduction In [2026] EWCA Crim 559, the Court of Appeal...

Tolan v Mayo County Council [No. 2] — Preliminary Issue on Limitation Where Fraud Is Not Properly Pleaded

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Directing a Preliminary Issue on the Statute of Limitations Where “Fraud” Is Not Properly Pleaded Introduction In Tolan v Mayo County Council [No. 2] (Approved) [2026] IEHC 297, the High Court...

Standing as a Jurisdictional Constraint in Planning Judicial Review: Courts May Revisit Standing Absent Cross‑Appeal and Refuse “Busybody” Representative Challenges

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Standing as a Jurisdictional Constraint in Planning Judicial Review: Courts May Revisit Standing Absent Cross‑Appeal and Refuse “Busybody” Representative Challenges Case Duff, Application for...

Stays for Refusal of Genetic Testing: Relevance-First and Heightened Materiality for Sensitive “Trio Exome” Evidence

Date: Apr 23, 2026

Stays for Refusal of Genetic Testing: Relevance-First and Heightened Materiality for Sensitive “Trio Exome” Evidence 1. Introduction C. (A Minor) v Health Service Executive (Approved) [2026] IEHC 234...

Consent Under GDPR/PECR Is an Objective “Outward Indication”: No Subjective Autonomy Inquiry (RTM v Bonne Terre Ltd & Anor)

Date: Apr 22, 2026

Consent Under GDPR/PECR Is an Objective “Outward Indication”: No Subjective Autonomy Inquiry Case: RTM v Bonne Terre Ltd & Anor (Sky Betting and Gaming) Citation: [2026] EWCA Civ 488; [2026] WLR(D)...

Schedule 10 paragraph 25 Sentencing Act 2020: Crown Court may revoke a magistrates’ community order when activating a suspended sentence imposed on committal for sentence

Date: Apr 22, 2026

Schedule 10 paragraph 25 Sentencing Act 2020: Crown Court may revoke a magistrates’ community order when activating a suspended sentence imposed on committal for sentence 1. Introduction In R v...

Section 38 Courts of Justice Act 1936 Appeals Are De Novo Where Oral Evidence Was Given (and “Re-hearing” in Supreme Court Practice Does Not Alter That)

Date: Apr 22, 2026

Section 38 Courts of Justice Act 1936 Appeals Are De Novo Where Oral Evidence Was Given (and “Re-hearing” in Supreme Court Practice Does Not Alter That) Case: O'Brien and Anor v Gill (Approved)...

Limits of Section 3 HRA: No “Reading-In” Disability Protection for Armed Forces Service Under Equality Act Schedule 9

Date: Apr 22, 2026

Limits of Section 3 HRA: No “Reading-In” Disability Protection for Armed Forces Service Under Equality Act Schedule 9 1. Introduction L & Anor v Ministry of Defence [2026] EWCA Civ 602 is a Court of...

Limits on Court-Ordered State Intervention in Foreign Hague Return Enforcement

Date: Apr 22, 2026

Limits on Court-Ordered State Intervention in Foreign Hague Return Enforcement 1) Introduction In AB v An Taoiseach and Ors (Approved) [2026] IEHC 236, the High Court (Mr Justice Conleth Bradley)...