periodic-inspection Case Commentaries

Invalidity of Planning Permissions for Failure to Publish Section 106 Agreements: Greenfields (IOW) Ltd v Isle of Wight Council

Date: Apr 17, 2025

Invalidity of Planning Permissions for Failure to Publish Section 106 Agreements Introduction In Greenfields (IOW) Ltd, R (On the Application Of) v Isle of Wight Council & Anor [2025] EWCA Civ 488,...

Dispositive Section Controls: Operative Orders vs. Narrative Reasoning in Arbitral Awards

Date: Apr 17, 2025

Dispositive Section Controls: Operative Orders vs. Narrative Reasoning in Arbitral Awards 1. Introduction This commentary examines the Court of Appeal’s decision in Nigeria LNG Ltd v Taleveras...

Judicial Review of Planning Enforcement Appeals: Factual Disputes Over Historic Plans Are Not Public Law Errors, and Relitigation May Be an Abuse Despite Environmental Standing

Date: Apr 17, 2025

Judicial Review of Planning Enforcement Appeals: Factual Disputes Over Historic Plans Are Not Public Law Errors, and Relitigation May Be an Abuse Despite Environmental Standing 1. Introduction Duff,...

Phase-Limited Planning Assessment in Hydrocarbon Exploration: Excluding Speculative Production Impacts

Date: Apr 17, 2025

Phase-Limited Planning Assessment in Hydrocarbon Exploration: Excluding Speculative Production Impacts Introduction Frack Free Balcombe Residents' Association v Secretary of State for Housing,...

Litigation Funding Priority in Collective Proceedings: Jurisdiction Under Section 47C(3)(b) of the Competition Act 1998

Date: Apr 17, 2025

Litigation Funding Priority in Collective Proceedings: Jurisdiction Under Section 47C(3)(b) of the Competition Act 1998 Introduction Gutmann v Apple Inc & Ors ([2025] EWCA Civ 459) is an appeal...

Non-Delegable Mandatory Duty to Arrange Updated Healthcare Plans under s.42(3) CFA 2014 and the Impact of Fresh Evidence – A R v North Central London Integrated Care Board

Date: Apr 17, 2025

Non-Delegable Mandatory Duty to Arrange Updated Healthcare Plans under s.42(3) CFA 2014 and the Impact of Fresh Evidence Introduction This case arises from a judicial review brought on behalf of “A,”...

Planning Committees’ Non-Delegable Duty Under Regulation 63(5) and the High Threshold for Refusing Remedies under Section 31(2A) SCA 1981

Date: Apr 17, 2025

Planning Committees’ Non-Delegable Duty Under Regulation 63(5) and the High Threshold for Refusing Remedies under Section 31(2A) SCA 1981 Introduction The appeal in Bradbury v Brecon Beacons National...

Limitation of Section 37/38 Orders to Children Who Are Subject of Proceedings

Date: Apr 17, 2025

Limitation of Section 37/38 Orders to Children Who Are Subject of Proceedings 1. Introduction This commentary examines the Court of Appeal’s decision in E (Section 37 Direction) [2025] EWCA Civ 470,...

Clarifying the Scope of Appeals Against Contempt Sanctions: Extensions, Fresh Evidence, and the Irrelevance of Post-Sanction Conditions

Date: Apr 17, 2025

Clarifying the Scope of Appeals Against Contempt Sanctions: Extensions, Fresh Evidence, and the Irrelevance of Post-Sanction Conditions Introduction Yaxley-Lennon v HM Solicitor General ([2025] EWCA...

Hospital Trusts’ Representative Standing to Protect Clinicians’ Article 8 Rights During the “Initial Phase”: A Commentary on Abbasi v Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust [2025] UKSC 15

Date: Apr 17, 2025

Hospital Trusts’ Representative Standing to Protect Clinicians’ Article 8 Rights During the “Initial Phase” Commentary on Abbasi v Newcastle upon Tyne Hospitals NHS Foundation Trust [2025] UKSC 15 1....

Biological Definition of “Sex” under the Equality Act 2010 – Commentary on For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers [2025] UKSC 16

Date: Apr 17, 2025

Biological Definition of “Sex” under the Equality Act 2010 Commentary on For Women Scotland Ltd v The Scottish Ministers ([2025] UKSC 16) 1 | Introduction The Supreme Court’s decision in For Women...

Preserving the Status Quo Pending FOO Hearing: Adequacy of Damages in Interim Injunctions in AstraZeneca AB & Anor v Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Europe Ltd

Date: Apr 17, 2025

Preserving the Status Quo Pending FOO Hearing: Adequacy of Damages in Interim Injunctions in AstraZeneca AB & Anor v Glenmark Pharmaceuticals Europe Ltd 1. Introduction AstraZeneca AB & Anor...

Clarifying “Necessarily” in Conspiracy to Cause Public Nuisance: Maxey & Anor v R [2025] EWCA Crim 472

Date: Apr 17, 2025

Clarifying “Necessarily” in Conspiracy to Cause Public Nuisance: Maxey & Anor v R [2025] EWCA Crim 472 Introduction In Maxey & Anor v R ([2025] EWCA Crim 472), the England and Wales Court of Appeal...

Quantifying Material Increase in Mesothelioma Risk: Direct Risk Assessment in Johnstone v Fawcett’s Garage

Date: Apr 16, 2025

Quantifying Material Increase in Mesothelioma Risk: Direct Risk Assessment in Johnstone v Fawcett’s Garage 1. Introduction The Court of Appeal’s decision in Johnstone v Fawcett’s Garage (Newbury) Ltd...

Disapplication of Bright-Line “Relevant Person” Status in Children’s Hearings to Protect Article 8 Rights

Date: Apr 16, 2025

Disapplication of Bright-Line “Relevant Person” Status in Children’s Hearings to Protect Article 8 Rights 1. Introduction This commentary discusses the Inner House decision in Reclaiming Motion by A...

R v Mingo & Neale: The Court of Appeal Affirms Flexible Jury Directions on the “Sure / 100 % Certainty” Dichotomy

Date: Apr 16, 2025

R v Mingo & Neale: The Court of Appeal Affirms Flexible Jury Directions on the “Sure / 100 % Certainty” Dichotomy Introduction The Court of Appeal (Criminal Division) in Mingo & Anor, R. v ([2025]...

Post-Offence Conduct as a Mitigation-Nullifier – A Commentary on R v Ali [2025] EWCA Crim 870

Date: Apr 16, 2025

Post-Offence Conduct as a Mitigation-Nullifier – A Commentary on R v Ali [2025] EWCA Crim 870 Introduction R v Ali [2025] EWCA Crim 870 is a reference by the Solicitor General under s.36 Criminal...

Clarifying Youth Sentencing and the Principle of Totality: R v Cunningham [2025] EWCA Crim 513

Date: Apr 16, 2025

Clarifying Youth Sentencing and the Principle of Totality: R v Cunningham [2025] EWCA Crim 513 1. Introduction R v Cunningham ([2025] EWCA Crim 513) is a decision of the England and Wales Court of...

R v BPK (2025): Clarifying the Singular “Starting Point” in Sentencing Guidelines and the Need to Recognise Separate Criminality

Date: Apr 16, 2025

R v BPK (2025): Clarifying the Singular “Starting Point” in Sentencing Guidelines and the Need to Recognise Separate Criminality Introduction In R v BPK ([2025] EWCA Crim 711) the Court of Appeal...

Clarifying the Requirement for Dangerousness Findings under Section 280 of the Sentencing Act 2020

Date: Apr 16, 2025

Clarifying the Requirement for Dangerousness Findings under Section 280 of the Sentencing Act 2020 Introduction This commentary examines the Court of Appeal’s decision in R v Fowler [2025] EWCA Crim...