Supreme Court Of India Case Commentaries

Primogeniture Stops at the Gaddi: Former Rulers’ Private Properties Devolve by Personal Law

Date: May 28, 2026

Primogeniture Stops at the Gaddi: Former Rulers’ Private Properties Devolve by Personal Law 1. Introduction In TIKKA SHATRUJIT SINGH v. SUKJIT SINGH, the Supreme Court of India decided a long-running...

Central Government’s Final Say on All India Service VRS Must Be Reasoned: Mere Complaints Do Not Amount to Contemplated Disciplinary Proceedings

Date: May 28, 2026

Central Government’s Final Say on All India Service VRS Must Be Reasoned: Mere Complaints Do Not Amount to Contemplated Disciplinary Proceedings Introduction In Abdur Rahman v. Union of India, the...

CoC-Approved Resolution Plan Is Binding: Successful Resolution Applicant Cannot Renege by Labeling Agreed LoI Terms as Conditional

Date: May 28, 2026

CoC-Approved Resolution Plan Is Binding: Successful Resolution Applicant Cannot Renege by Labeling Agreed LoI Terms as Conditional 1. Introduction In SANJAY DAVE v. ANDHRA BANK LTD., the Supreme...

No Criminal Negligence Presumed Against Bus Driver Acting on Conductor’s Signal

Date: May 28, 2026

No Criminal Negligence Presumed Against Bus Driver Acting on Conductor’s Signal 1. Introduction In MAHAMMAD HANIF JAINUM KHALIFA v. THE STATE OF KARNATAKA, the Supreme Court of India considered...

Railway Servants Remain Central Government Servants Despite Separate Service Rules

Date: May 28, 2026

Railway Servants Remain Central Government Servants Despite Separate Service Rules Introduction In BENCY JOHN v. KERALA STATE ELECTRICITY BOARD LIMITED, the Supreme Court of India considered whether...

Proactive Environmental Governance Mandated Against Illegal Sand Mining in National Chambal Sanctuary

Date: May 28, 2026

Proactive Environmental Governance Mandated Against Illegal Sand Mining in National Chambal Sanctuary 1. Introduction In IN RE: ILLEGAL SAND MINING IN THE NATIONAL CHAMBAL SANCTUARY AND THREAT TO...

Compassionate Assistance Set-Off Cannot Defeat a Dependent Parent’s Independent MACT Compensation Entitlement

Date: May 28, 2026

Compassionate Assistance Set-Off Cannot Defeat a Dependent Parent’s Independent MACT Compensation Entitlement Introduction In Sarla Devi v. Reliance General Insurance Company Limited, 2026 INSC 575,...

High Courts Retain Plenary Powers in Testamentary Proceedings to Order Criminal Investigation for Protecting Estate in Custodia Legis

Date: May 28, 2026

High Courts Retain Plenary Powers in Testamentary Proceedings to Order Criminal Investigation for Protecting Estate in Custodia Legis 1. Introduction In BAI AVABAI HORMUSJI TATA TRUST v. SHERNAZ...

Staked Online Skill Games, Fantasy Sports and Casinos Generate Taxable Actionable Claims under GST

Date: May 28, 2026

Staked Online Skill Games, Fantasy Sports and Casinos Generate Taxable Actionable Claims under GST: Rules 31A–31C Upheld and 2023 Valuation Amendments Treated as Retrospective 1. Introduction In...

Betting on Games of Skill Falls Within State Power under Entry 34

Date: May 28, 2026

Betting on Games of Skill Falls Within State Power: Online Money Gaming May Be Prohibited under Entry 34 and Public Order 1. Introduction In THE STATE OF TAMIL NADU v. JUNGLEE GAMES INDIA PRIVATE...

Delay in Externment Appeals under Section 9 of the Chhattisgarh Rajya Suraksha Adhiniyam Is Condonable under Section 5 of the Limitation Act

Date: May 28, 2026

Delay in Externment Appeals under Section 9 of the Chhattisgarh Rajya Suraksha Adhiniyam Is Condonable under Section 5 of the Limitation Act Introduction In JITTU YADAV v. STATE OF CHHATTISGARH, the...

Final Judicial Directions Must Be Obeyed as Framed: “Preference” in Service Appointments Cannot Be Reduced to Mere Consideration

Date: May 28, 2026

Final Judicial Directions Must Be Obeyed as Framed: “Preference” in Service Appointments Cannot Be Reduced to Mere Consideration Introduction In REENA KUMARI v. PRAVEER KUMAR, 2026 INSC 642, the...

Appellate Court Reversing Acquittal Must Itself Hear the Convict on Sentence and Cannot Delegate Sentencing to Trial Court

Date: May 27, 2026

Appellate Court Reversing Acquittal Must Itself Hear the Convict on Sentence and Cannot Delegate Sentencing to Trial Court Introduction In Mukesh Kumar Yadav v. The State, 2026 INSC 559, the Supreme...

Majority Trustee Authorisation and Valid E-Voting: Chronology Cannot Substitute Lawful Authority

Date: May 27, 2026

Majority Trustee Authorisation and Valid E-Voting: Chronology Cannot Substitute Lawful Authority 1. Introduction In HINDUSTAN MEDICAL INSTITUTION v. BIRLA CORPORATION LIMITED, the Supreme Court of...

Section 149 IPC Liability Reaffirmed in Mass Violence: Members of an Armed Unlawful Assembly Cannot Escape as “Mere Spectators”

Date: May 27, 2026

Section 149 IPC Liability Reaffirmed in Mass Violence: Members of an Armed Unlawful Assembly Cannot Escape as “Mere Spectators” Introduction In Mahendra Rai @ Harendra Narain Singh and Ors. etc. v....

Life Sentence May Be Reduced to Period Already Undergone by Constitutional Courts Without Amounting to Enhancement

Date: May 27, 2026

Life Sentence May Be Reduced to Period Already Undergone by Constitutional Courts Without Amounting to Enhancement 1. Introduction In Munna Moyuddin Shaikh v. State of Gujarat, 2026 INSC 558, the...

Tacit Consent Can Sustain a Contractual Arbitral Mandate, but Section 33 Cannot Convert Simple Interest into Compound Interest

Date: May 27, 2026

Tacit Consent Can Sustain a Contractual Arbitral Mandate, but Section 33 Cannot Convert Simple Interest into Compound Interest 1. Introduction In GUJARAT WATER SUPPLY AND SEWERAGE BOARD v. SARYU...

Anticipatory Bail in Economic Fraud: Civil Remedies or Unregistered Agreements Do Not Dilute Prima Facie Criminality

Date: May 27, 2026

Anticipatory Bail in Economic Fraud: Civil Remedies or Unregistered Agreements Do Not Dilute Prima Facie Criminality 1. Introduction In Saurabh Agrawal v. State of Uttar Pradesh, 2026 INSC 548, the...

Commercially Pure n-Hexane with Manufacturing Impurities Classified as Organic Chemical under Chapter 29, Not Petroleum/Motor Spirit under Chapter 27

Date: May 27, 2026

Commercially Pure n-Hexane with Manufacturing Impurities Classified as Organic Chemical under Chapter 29, Not Petroleum/Motor Spirit under Chapter 27 1. Introduction In COMMR.OF CUSTOMS KANDLA v. M/S...

Proportionality over Demolition: Irregular Public Land Allotments May Be Regularised on Full Market-Value Restitution

Date: May 27, 2026

Proportionality over Demolition: Irregular Public Land Allotments May Be Regularised on Full Market-Value Restitution 1. Introduction In K. RAHEJA CORP. PRIVATE LIMITED v. THE STATE OF MAHARASHTRA,...