Jammu and Kashmir High Court Case Commentaries

Mandatory Strict Compliance with Sections 251–252 CrPC for Conviction on Plea in Section 138 NI Act Cases; Appeal Bar under Section 375 CrPC

Date: Jul 18, 2026

Mandatory Strict Compliance with Sections 251–252 CrPC for Conviction on Plea in Section 138 NI Act Cases; Appeal Bar under Section 375 CrPC 1. Introduction The decision in ADIL AHMAD SOFI v. JAVID...

Pension/Gratuity Cannot Be Withheld Absent Instituted Departmental or Judicial Proceedings (CSR Articles 168-A & 168-D)

Date: Jul 16, 2026

Pension/Gratuity Cannot Be Withheld Absent Instituted Departmental or Judicial Proceedings (CSR Articles 168-A & 168-D) 1. Introduction The Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court at Srinagar (Acting...

Once Amendment is Allowed, the Unamended Leave-to-Defend Pleading Becomes Inefficacious in Order XXXVII CPC Suits

Date: Jul 14, 2026

Once Amendment is Allowed, the Unamended Leave-to-Defend Pleading Becomes Inefficacious in Order XXXVII CPC Suits AB. GANI GANAIE AND ANR v. AB. GANI BHAT (Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh High Court,...

Interim Release of NDPS-Seized Vehicles: Confiscation Risk Is Not a Bar; Release on Superdari with Inventory Safeguards under BNSS §497

Date: Jul 13, 2026

Interim Release of NDPS-Seized Vehicles: Confiscation Risk Is Not a Bar; Release on Superdari with Inventory Safeguards under BNSS §497 1) Introduction In ANJUM RAFIQ v. UT OF J AND K TH COMMISSIONER...

Quashing Drug Prosecutions for (i) Limitation Bar and (ii) Defeat of Section 25(3) Right Due to Delay

Date: Jul 11, 2026

Quashing Drug Prosecutions for (i) Limitation Bar and (ii) Defeat of Section 25(3) Right Due to Delay Case: DR. JOHNS LAB PVT LTD THROUGH ITS DIRECTOR v. STATE THROUGH DRUG INSPECTOR (FOOD AND DRUG...

Preventive Detention under the J&K Public Safety Act Requires Independent Application of Mind and Fact-Based Grounds (No “Borrowed Satisfaction” from a Police Dossier)

Date: Jun 30, 2026

Preventive Detention under the J&K Public Safety Act Requires Independent Application of Mind and Fact-Based Grounds (No “Borrowed Satisfaction” from a Police Dossier) 1. Introduction In FAYAZ AHMAD...

Interim Orders Are Executable Under Section 36 CPC (Order XXXIX Rule 2-A Not Exclusive) and Mandatory Verification of AI/Digital Citations in Judicial Orders

Date: Jun 9, 2026

Interim Orders Are Executable Under Section 36 CPC (Order XXXIX Rule 2-A Not Exclusive) and Mandatory Verification of AI/Digital Citations in Judicial Orders 1. Introduction In PRINCIPAL WOODLAND...

Suppression of Failed Bail-Cancellation Efforts Vitiates “Subjective Satisfaction” under the PIT NDPS Act

Date: Jun 8, 2026

Suppression of Failed Bail-Cancellation Efforts Vitiates “Subjective Satisfaction” under the PIT NDPS Act Case: MAKHAN DIN v. PRINCIPAL SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT HOME DEPARTMENT, JAMMU AND OTHERS...

Compensation Claims for Public Works Require Proof of Proprietary Encroachment; Individuals Cannot Claim Compensation for Kahcharai Land

Date: Jun 8, 2026

Compensation Claims for Public Works Require Proof of Proprietary Encroachment; Individuals Cannot Claim Compensation for Kahcharai Land Case: MOHAMMAD SULTAN DAR AND OTHERS v. UNION TERRITORY OF J...

PEG Godown Contracts: Estoppel by Undertaking and Validity of Cost-Saving Recoveries for Delayed Black-Topping

Date: Jun 7, 2026

PEG Godown Contracts: Estoppel by Undertaking and Validity of Cost-Saving Recoveries for Delayed Black-Topping Case: M/S ALPINE AGRO SERVICES v. UNION OF INDIA AND ORS. (CONSUMER AFFAIRS AND PUBLIC...

Contractual ECHS Termination for Unsatisfactory Performance Is Not “Punitive” or “Stigmatic” So as to Require a Formal Enquiry (Article 311 Inapplicable)

Date: Jun 7, 2026

Contractual ECHS Termination for Unsatisfactory Performance Is Not “Punitive” or “Stigmatic” So as to Require a Formal Enquiry (Article 311 Inapplicable) Case: Manzoor Ahmad Bhat v. UNION OF INDIA...

Affiliation Binds: Board’s Power to “Prescribe Textbooks” Includes Mandating Exclusive Use of Board-Published Textbooks in Affiliated Schools

Date: Jun 7, 2026

Affiliation Binds: Board’s Power to “Prescribe Textbooks” Includes Mandating Exclusive Use of Board-Published Textbooks in Affiliated Schools 1. Introduction This Letters Patent Appeal (LPA No. 241...

Section 143A NI Act: Interim Compensation Must Follow Reasoned, Case-Specific Discretion

Date: Jun 7, 2026

Section 143A NI Act: Interim Compensation Must Follow Reasoned, Case-Specific Discretion (and Will Not Be Quashed if Reasons Are Discernible) 1. Introduction In MOHAMMAD ASHRAF MIR v. WAZIRA RESHI...

Second Appeal Gatekeeping under Section 100 CPC: Unregistered “Tahrirnama” Cannot Prove Transfer/Possession in Kashmir, Nor Dislodge Presumption of Revenue Entries

Date: Jun 6, 2026

Second Appeal Gatekeeping under Section 100 CPC: Unregistered “Tahrirnama” Cannot Prove Transfer/Possession in Kashmir, Nor Dislodge Presumption of Revenue Entries Case: ABDUL AZIZ MIR v. TARIQ AHMAD...

No Compassionate Regularisation or Redeployment for Post-Retirement Death; Consolidated JKCL Workers Limited to Unpaid Wages (with Interest)

Date: Jun 6, 2026

No Compassionate Regularisation or Redeployment for Post-Retirement Death; Consolidated JKCL Workers Limited to Unpaid Wages (with Interest) Case: SHAHID MEHRAJ v. UNION TERRITORY OF J AND K AND ANR....

Terminal Benefits Cannot Be Withheld on a Mere Pending Investigation: Article 168-A J&K CSR Requires Determination of Loss in Judicial/Departmental Proceedings

Date: Jun 6, 2026

Terminal Benefits Cannot Be Withheld on a Mere Pending Investigation: Article 168-A J&K CSR Requires Determination of Loss in Judicial/Departmental Proceedings 1. Introduction In VIKAR MUSTAFA...

Disclosure Statements Cannot Substitute Proof: Section 27 Evidence Act Limited to Discovery; Circumstantial Chain Must Be Complete

Date: Jun 5, 2026

Disclosure Statements Cannot Substitute Proof: Section 27 Evidence Act Limited to Discovery; Circumstantial Chain Must Be Complete Case: ALI MOHAMMAD DAR v. UNION TERRITORY THORUGH POLICE STATION...

Dispensing with Departmental Enquiry on “Security of the State” Grounds: Reasons Need Not Appear in the Dismissal Order if Contemporaneous Record Supports the Governor’s Satisfaction

Date: Jun 4, 2026

Dispensing with Departmental Enquiry on “Security of the State” Grounds: Reasons Need Not Appear in the Dismissal Order if Contemporaneous Record Supports the Governor’s Satisfaction 1) Introduction...

Vacillating Pleadings and Inordinate Delay Defeat Writ Claims for University Medals

Date: Jun 4, 2026

Vacillating Pleadings and Inordinate Delay Defeat Writ Claims for University Medals Case: IBRAR BASHIR SHIRAZI v. UNIVERSITY OF KASHMIR Court: High Court of Jammu & Kashmir and Ladakh, Srinagar...

PCDA(P) Cannot Override Review Medical Board: Presumption of Attributability for Post-Enrolment Disabilities and Rounding-Off of Disability Pension

Date: May 31, 2026

PCDA(P) Cannot Override Review Medical Board: Presumption of Attributability for Post-Enrolment Disabilities and Rounding-Off of Disability Pension Case: UNION OF INDIA TH SECRETARY TO GOVT OF INDIA...