Gujarat High Court Case Commentaries

Subjective Assessment of Judicial Officer Judgments in Promotion Processes: Non‑Interference Principle

Date: Feb 28, 2025

Subjective Assessment of Judicial Officer Judgments in Promotion Processes: Non‑Interference Principle Introduction This commentary examines the landmark decision of the Gujarat High Court in...

Contempt of Court and Unauthorized Transcripts: Redefining Judicial Boundaries in Interim Orders

Date: Feb 5, 2025

Contempt of Court and Unauthorized Transcripts: Redefining Judicial Boundaries in Interim Orders Introduction The Gujarat High Court, in the case titled "Gujarat Operational Creditors Association...

Strengthening the Stringency of Bail under the NDPS Act: A Landmark Judicial Principle

Date: Feb 5, 2025

Strengthening the Stringency of Bail under the NDPS Act: A Landmark Judicial Principle Introduction The case of Pragnesh Pravinbhai Thummar v. State of Gujarat before the Gujarat High Court...

New Directions in Urban Planning: Enforcing GRUDA, 2022 for Regularisation of Unauthorised Developments

Date: Feb 4, 2025

New Directions in Urban Planning: Enforcing GRUDA, 2022 for Regularisation of Unauthorised Developments Introduction The judgment in Sharifbhai Hasambhai Sakaryani v. State of Gujarat delivered on...

Ensuring Accuracy in Petition Filings: The Imperative for Diligence and Correct Departmental Association in Contempt Proceedings

Date: Feb 4, 2025

Ensuring Accuracy in Petition Filings: The Imperative for Diligence and Correct Departmental Association in Contempt Proceedings Introduction The case of Gemarbhai Dalabhai Desai v. S.K. Patel,...

Clarifying the Pre-Existing Right Requirement under Section 33(C)(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act: Insights from Jayanti Ishwarbhai Parmar v. Sheth Shri Sabbir Mohammed Zubair

Date: Jan 14, 2025

Clarifying the Pre-Existing Right Requirement under Section 33(C)(2) of the Industrial Disputes Act: Insights from Jayanti Ishwarbhai Parmar v. Sheth Shri Sabbir Mohammed Zubair Introduction The case...

Recognition of Anganwadi Workers as Regular Employees: A Landmark Decision

Date: Aug 3, 2024

Recognition of Anganwadi Workers as Regular Employees: A Landmark Decision Introduction In the case of Adarsh Gujarat Anganwadi Union v. State of Gujarat, adjudicated by the Gujarat High Court on...

Gujarat High Court Establishes Compensation Over Reinstatement for Illegally Terminated Daily Wage Workers

Date: Feb 3, 2024

Gujarat High Court Establishes Compensation Over Reinstatement for Illegally Terminated Daily Wage Workers Introduction The case of District Rural Development Agency & 1 other(s) vs. Vipul...

Extending Compassionate Compensation to Permanent Daily Rated Employees: Insights from STATE OF GUJARAT v. Makwana

Date: Aug 11, 2023

Extending Compassionate Compensation to Permanent Daily Rated Employees: Insights from STATE OF GUJARAT v. Makwana Introduction The case of State of Gujarat v. Chhanaji Bhagaji Makwana (Decd),...

Crystallization of Increment Entitlement for Government Servants: A Comprehensive Analysis of STATE OF GUJARAT v. PRAHLADBHAI HARIBHAI PATEL

Date: Apr 20, 2023

Crystallization of Increment Entitlement for Government Servants: A Comprehensive Analysis of STATE OF GUJARAT v. PRAHLADBHAI HARIBHAI PATEL Introduction The case of State of Gujarat vs. Prahladbhai...

Appellate Court Reaffirms Principle of Upholding Acquittals in Corruption Cases Due to Insufficient Evidence

Date: Feb 14, 2023

Appellate Court Reaffirms Principle of Upholding Acquittals in Corruption Cases Due to Insufficient Evidence Introduction The case of The State of Gujarat v. Ratilal Hirji Jobanputra adjudicated by...

Establishing the Limitation Bar for Reassessment Notices Post Finance Act 2021: KeeNara Industries v. IT Officer

Date: Feb 8, 2023

Establishing the Limitation Bar for Reassessment Notices Post Finance Act 2021: KeeNara Industries v. IT Officer Introduction The case of KeeNara Industries Private Limited v. The Income Tax Officer,...

Gujarat High Court Establishes 6% Disallowance Rate for Bogus Purchases in Income Tax Assessments

Date: Jan 17, 2023

Gujarat High Court Establishes 6% Disallowance Rate for Bogus Purchases in Income Tax Assessments Introduction In the case of PR. Commissioner of Income Tax 1, Surat v. M/s Surya Impex, the Gujarat...

Gujarat High Court Affirms Entitlement to Notional Increment Upon Retirement

Date: Apr 28, 2022

Gujarat High Court Affirms Entitlement to Notional Increment Upon Retirement Introduction In the landmark case of STATE OF GUJARAT v. Takhatsinh Udesinh Songara, adjudicated by the Gujarat High Court...

Insurance Liability for Paid Drivers: Gujarat High Court Establishes Precedent

Date: Apr 22, 2022

Insurance Liability for Paid Drivers: Gujarat High Court Establishes Precedent Introduction The case of Valiben Laxmanbhai Thakore (Koli) Wd/o Late Laxmanbhai Ramsingbhai Thakore (Koli) v. Kandla...

Invalid Issuance of Section 148 Notices to Deceased Assessees: Insights from Gujarat High Court

Date: Mar 30, 2022

Invalid Issuance of Section 148 Notices to Deceased Assessees: Insights from Gujarat High Court Introduction The case of Krishnaawtar Kabra l/h of Jagannath Rampal Kabra v. The Income Tax Officer...

Gujarat High Court Declares Gujarat Cooperative Societies (Amendment) Act, 2019 as Ultra Vires Article 14 and Arbitrary

Date: Aug 28, 2021

Gujarat High Court Declares Gujarat Cooperative Societies (Amendment) Act, 2019 as Ultra Vires Article 14 and Arbitrary Introduction In the landmark case of Pravinsinh Indrasinh Mahida v. State Of...

Gujarat High Court Upholds Non-Retroactivity of CBDT Circulars in Income Tax Appeals

Date: Jun 25, 2021

Gujarat High Court Upholds Non-Retroactivity of CBDT Circulars in Income Tax Appeals Introduction In the landmark case of Principal Commissioner of Income Tax (Central) Ahmedabad vs. Anand Natwarlal...

Gujarat High Court Sets Precedent on Reopening Assessments under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act

Date: May 12, 2021

Gujarat High Court Sets Precedent on Reopening Assessments under Section 148 of the Income Tax Act Introduction The case of Divya Jyoti Diamonds Private Limited v. Income Tax Officer adjudicated by...

Dineshbhai Gamit v. Gujarat State Election Commission: Upholding Judicial Review in Panchayat Elections

Date: Feb 11, 2021

Dineshbhai Gamit v. Gujarat State Election Commission: Upholding Judicial Review in Panchayat Elections Introduction The case of Dineshbhai Chhaganbhai Gamit v. Gujarat State Election Commission was...