Gujarat High Court Case Commentaries

Statutory DRP Remedy Cannot Be Defeated by Misfiling Objections: Fresh Limitation from Refiling Before the Faceless Assessing Officer

Date: Dec 23, 2025

Statutory DRP Remedy Cannot Be Defeated by Misfiling Objections: Fresh Limitation from Refiling Before the Faceless Assessing Officer 1. Introduction In MILACRON INDIA PRIVATE LIMITED v. THE...

Mutual Consent Divorce: Family Court Should Not Reject Section 13B Petition for Want of Waiver Application Without Granting Opportunity; Cooling-off Period is Directory

Date: Dec 23, 2025

Mutual Consent Divorce: Family Court Should Not Reject Section 13B Petition for Want of Waiver Application Without Granting Opportunity; Cooling-off Period is Directory 1) Introduction The Gujarat...

Financial Crisis/Closure Is Not “Sufficient Cause” for Long-Lapsed Restoration: Vigilance Required in CESTAT Appeals

Date: Dec 12, 2025

Financial Crisis/Closure Is Not “Sufficient Cause” for Long-Lapsed Restoration: Vigilance Required in CESTAT Appeals Case: SHREE UKAI PRADESH SAHAKARI KHAND UDYOG MANDALI LTD v. UNION OF INDIA & ORS....

Knowledge-Based Culpable Homicide in High-Speed Road Accidents: Commentary on Tathya Pragneshbhai Patel v. State of Gujarat (Gujarat High Court, 03.12.2025)

Date: Dec 10, 2025

Knowledge-Based Culpable Homicide in High-Speed Road Accidents: Commentary on Tathya Pragneshbhai Patel v. State of Gujarat, Gujarat High Court (03 December 2025) 1. Introduction This judgment of the...

Withdrawal on Redressal After Caste Validation: Liberty to Re-approach for Unadjudicated Prayers and Non-Operation of Prior Order

Date: Dec 10, 2025

Withdrawal on Redressal After Caste Validation: Liberty to Re-approach for Unadjudicated Prayers and Non-Operation of Prior Order Case: DEVIBEN BHIKHABHAI VASH v. STATE OF GUJARAT Court: Gujarat High...

Business Tenancy Succession Under Section 5(11)(c)(ii): “Carrying On With the Tenant at Death” Is Mandatory; Revision Under Section 29(2) Cannot Reappreciate Evidence

Date: Dec 10, 2025

Business Tenancy Succession Under Section 5(11)(c)(ii): “Carrying On With the Tenant at Death” Is Mandatory; Revision Under Section 29(2) Cannot Reappreciate Evidence 1) Introduction The Gujarat High...

Rolling Prohibitory Orders, Publicity Mandate and Safeguards under Section 144 CrPC / Section 163 BNSS and Section 37 Gujarat Police Act: Commentary on Navdeep Mathur v. State of Gujarat

Date: Dec 9, 2025

Rolling Prohibitory Orders, Publicity Mandate and Safeguards under Section 144 CrPC / Section 163 BNSS and Section 37 Gujarat Police Act: Commentary on Navdeep Mathur v. State of Gujarat 1....

No Ownership from Long Possession or Tax Payments: Standing of Encroachers to Challenge Housing Board Eviction – Commentary on Ranjana Mulchandbhai Shitlani v. Gujarat Housing Board

Date: Dec 9, 2025

No Ownership from Long Possession or Tax Payments: Standing of Encroachers to Challenge Housing Board Eviction Commentary on Ranjana Mulchandbhai Shitlani v. Gujarat Housing Board & Ors. Gujarat High...

Bail under Section 483 BNSS and Cyber Hoax Bomb Threats: Commentary on Rene Joshilda Goldwin Joseph v. State of Gujarat

Date: Dec 3, 2025

Bail under Section 483 BNSS and Cyber Hoax Bomb Threats: A Commentary on Rene Joshilda Goldwin Joseph v. State of Gujarat I. Introduction The order in Rene Joshilda Goldwin Joseph v. State of...

Passport Renewal Despite Minor Pending Criminal Case for Overseas Resident: Commentary on Mohasin Sabbir Ahmed Surati v. Union of India

Date: Nov 27, 2025

Balancing Minor Pending Criminal Proceedings with Passport Renewal for Overseas Workers: A Commentary on Mohasin Sabbir Ahmed Surati v. Union of India Court: High Court of Gujarat at Ahmedabad Case...

Loss of Matrimonial Prospects and Empathetic Assessment of Non‑Pecuniary Damages in Motor Accident Claims: Commentary on Jigishaben Maheshbhai Patel v. Sipai Mohammadkhan Rasulkhan

Date: Nov 27, 2025

Loss of Matrimonial Prospects and Empathetic Assessment of Non‑Pecuniary Damages in Motor Accident Claims: A Commentary on Jigishaben Maheshbhai Patel v. Sipai Mohammadkhan Rasulkhan & Ors. 1....

Independent and Reasoned Findings by ICAI Council under Section 21: Commentary on Council of ICAI v. S.N. Valera

Date: Nov 25, 2025

Independent and Reasoned Findings by ICAI Council under Section 21: Commentary on Council of Institute of Chartered Accountants of India v. S.N. Valera 1. Introduction The decision of the Gujarat...

“Immediate” Satisfaction under Section 153C: Gujarat High Court on Time‑Bound Recording Post‑Search in Parag Rameshbhai Gathani v. ITO

Date: Nov 25, 2025

“Immediate” Satisfaction under Section 153C: Gujarat High Court on Time‑Bound Recording Post‑Search in Parag Rameshbhai Gathani v. Income Tax Officer 1. Introduction The Gujarat High Court in Parag...

“Live Link” Requirement under Amended Section 153C: Commentary on Sandhya Maulik Patel v. ACIT, Gujarat High Court (2025)

Date: Nov 25, 2025

“Live Link” Requirement under Amended Section 153C of the Income-tax Act: A Detailed Commentary on Sandhya Maulik Patel v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Gujarat High Court (24 November 2025)...

Judicial Power to Correct Bona Fide Clerical Errors in NEET‑PG Applications: Commentary on Ronil Umeshkumar Modi v. State of Gujarat

Date: Nov 21, 2025

Judicial Power to Correct Bona Fide Clerical Errors in NEET‑PG Applications under Article 226: Commentary on Ronil Umeshkumar Modi v. State of Gujarat 1. Introduction The decision in Ronil Umeshkumar...

Presumption Under Section 113A Evidence Act Contingent on Proved Cruelty Under Section 498A IPC – Commentary on State of Gujarat v. Rajeshbhai Pitamberbhai Parmar

Date: Nov 20, 2025

Presumption Under Section 113A Evidence Act Contingent on Proved Cruelty Under Section 498A IPC – Commentary on State of Gujarat v. Rajeshbhai Pitamberbhai Parmar 1. Introduction The Gujarat High...

Zero-Rated Exports vs Deemed Exports under GST: Scope of ITC Refunds and Circular 172/2022 – Commentary on Shah Paperplast Industries Ltd. v. Union of India (Gujarat High Court, 13 November 2025)

Date: Nov 14, 2025

Zero-Rated Exports vs Deemed Exports under GST: Scope of ITC Refunds and Circular 172/2022 – Commentary on Shah Paperplast Industries Ltd. v. Union of India (Gujarat High Court, 13 November 2025) I....

Minimum Four‑Hour Threshold for Fixed Pay of Part‑Time Gujarat Government Employees: Commentary on Deputy Director, Animal Husbandry v. State of Gujarat (Gujarat High Court, 03.11.2025)

Date: Nov 4, 2025

Minimum Four‑Hour Threshold for Fixed Pay of Part‑Time Gujarat Government Employees under the 16.07.2019 Circular Case: Deputy Director, Animal Husbandry & Anr. v. State of Gujarat & Anr. Court: High...

Blood-Alcohol Statutory Presumption Sustains Conviction under Section 66(1)(b) Despite Acquittal under Section 85(1)(3): Minor Chain Delays Within 7 Days Not Fatal

Date: Oct 2, 2025

Blood-Alcohol Statutory Presumption Sustains Conviction under Section 66(1)(b) Despite Acquittal under Section 85(1)(3): Minor Chain Delays Within 7 Days Not Fatal 1. Introduction The Gujarat High...

Premature Retirement of Judicial Officers under Rule 21: Article 166(2) Authentication Validates “Governor’s Order” and Judicial Review Remains Narrow

Date: Oct 1, 2025

Premature Retirement of Judicial Officers under Rule 21: Article 166(2) Authentication Validates “Governor’s Order” and Judicial Review Remains Narrow 1) Introduction Case: JAYESHKUMAR KRISHNAKANT...