All Tribunals Case Commentaries

NCLAT Affirms Committee of Creditors' Discretion in Resolution Plan Approval: Next Orbit Ventures v. Print House

Date: Apr 14, 2021

NCLAT Affirms Committee of Creditors' Discretion in Resolution Plan Approval: Next Orbit Ventures v. Print House Introduction The case of Next Orbit Ventures Fund v. Print House (India) Pvt. Ltd. was...

Interplay Between IBC and Companies Act: NCLAT Reinforces Ineligibility Under Section 29A Applies to Section 230 Schemes

Date: Apr 14, 2021

Interplay Between IBC and Companies Act: NCLAT Reinforces Ineligibility Under Section 29A Applies to Section 230 Schemes Introduction The case of Ashish Mohan Gupta v. The Liquidator of M/S Hind...

IBC Supersedes PMLA in Corporate Insolvency Proceedings: NCLAT Establishes Precedence

Date: Apr 10, 2021

IBC Supersedes PMLA in Corporate Insolvency Proceedings: NCLAT Establishes Precedence Introduction The case of Directorate Of Enforcement v. Manoj Kumar Agarwal adjudicated by the National Company...

CESTAT Upholds Input Service Status for Club Membership and Insurance Services in Cenvat Credit Claims

Date: Apr 10, 2021

CESTAT Upholds Input Service Status for Club Membership and Insurance Services in Cenvat Credit Claims Introduction The case of Rajratan Global Wire Ltd. v. Commissioner, Central Goods & Service Tax,...

NCLAT Reinforces Swiss Ribbons Principles in IBC Proceedings

Date: Apr 10, 2021

NCLAT Reinforces Swiss Ribbons Principles in IBC Proceedings Introduction The case of Sree Bhadra Parks And Resorts Ltd. v. Ramani Resorts And Hotels Pvt. Ltd. adjudicated by the National Company Law...

Clarity on Section 271(1)(c): Mandating Specificity in Penalty Notices - Singh Consultancy Pvt. Ltd. v. CIT

Date: Apr 10, 2021

Clarity on Section 271(1)(c): Mandating Specificity in Penalty Notices Introduction The case of Singh Consultancy Pvt. Ltd. v. CIT adjudicated by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITAT) on April 9,...

NCLT Establishes Priority of EPF Claims over Liquidation Processes under IBC 2016

Date: Apr 9, 2021

NCLT Establishes Priority of EPF Claims over Liquidation Processes under IBC 2016 Introduction The case titled Nagalingam Muthiah (SAS Autocom Engineers India Pvt Ltd) v. Office Of The Recovery...

Approval Requirements for Security Interests in Transmission Licences: Insights from Gurgaon-Palwal Transmission Ltd. v. U.P. Power Corporation Ltd.

Date: Apr 9, 2021

Approval Requirements for Security Interests in Transmission Licences: Insights from Gurgaon-Palwal Transmission Ltd. v. U.P. Power Corporation Ltd. Introduction The case of Gurgaon-Palwal...

RERA Punjab Upholds Allottee’s Right to Interest on Delayed Possession in Satwant Boparai v. Omaxe Chandigarh Extension

Date: Apr 8, 2021

RERA Punjab Upholds Allottee’s Right to Interest on Delayed Possession Introduction The case of Satwant Boparai w/o Sh. Swaran Singh Boparai v. Omaxe Chandigarh Extension Developers Pvt. Ltd....

Necessity of 'Offence Reports' in Customs Broker Licensing Proceedings: Comprehensive Analysis of P Cawasji & Co vs. Commissioner of Customs

Date: Apr 7, 2021

Necessity of 'Offence Reports' in Customs Broker Licensing Proceedings: Comprehensive Analysis of P Cawasji & Co vs. Commissioner of Customs Introduction The case of P Cawasji & Co vs. Commissioner...

Dispensation of Shareholder and Creditor Meetings in Corporate Amalgamations: Ambuja Cements Limited Judgment Commentary

Date: Apr 7, 2021

Dispensation of Shareholder and Creditor Meetings in Corporate Amalgamations: Ambuja Cements Limited Judgment Commentary 1. Introduction The judgment in the case of Ambuja Cements Limited versus the...

Consumer Protection Against Deficient Real Estate Services: Ramandeep Singh v. Emerging India Housing Corporation Pvt. Ltd.

Date: Apr 6, 2021

Consumer Protection Against Deficient Real Estate Services: Ramandeep Singh v. M/s Emerging India Housing Corporation Pvt. Ltd. Introduction The case of Ramandeep Singh v. M/s Emerging India Housing...

Equal Ranking of Secured Creditors in Liquidation: Technology Development Board v. Anil Goel Liquidator of Gujarat Oleo Chem Ltd & Ors

Date: Apr 6, 2021

Equal Ranking of Secured Creditors in Liquidation: Technology Development Board v. Anil Goel Liquidator of Gujarat Oleo Chem Ltd & Ors Introduction The case of Technology Development Board v. Anil...

Affirmation of Medical Negligence and Compensation Standards in LASIK Surgery: Ruhela v. Sun Eye Hospital & Lasik Surgery Center

Date: Apr 2, 2021

Affirmation of Medical Negligence and Compensation Standards in LASIK Surgery: Ruhela v. Sun Eye Hospital & Lasik Surgery Center Introduction The case of Amit Kumar Ruhela v. Sun Eye Hospital & Lasik...

Strict Adherence to Statutory Time Limits in Customs Appeals: Shambhu Synthetics Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Customs

Date: Apr 2, 2021

Strict Adherence to Statutory Time Limits in Customs Appeals: Shambhu Synthetics Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner of Customs Introduction The case of Shambhu Synthetics Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner Of Customs...

Revocation of Inter-State Trading Licence: Jaiprakash Associates Ltd. v. CERC Establishes Procedural Compliance Standards

Date: Apr 2, 2021

Revocation of Inter-State Trading Licence: Jaiprakash Associates Ltd. v. CERC Establishes Procedural Compliance Standards Introduction The judicial decision in Jaiprakash Associates Limited v....

Emerging Valley Judgment: Strengthening Consumer Rights Against Unfair Real Estate Practices

Date: Apr 1, 2021

Emerging Valley Judgment: Strengthening Consumer Rights Against Unfair Real Estate Practices Introduction The case of Mr. Chandan Mehta v. M/s Emerging Valley Private Limited adjudicated by the State...

Refund Entitlement under Consumer Protection Act in Real Estate Transactions: Insights from Puja Garg v. M/s Manohar Infrastructure & Constructions Pvt.Ltd.

Date: Apr 1, 2021

Refund Entitlement under Consumer Protection Act in Real Estate Transactions: Insights from Puja Garg v. M/s Manohar Infrastructure & Constructions Pvt.Ltd. Introduction The case of Puja Garg v. M/s...

CCI Establishes Non-Dominance of IATA in India's Air Cargo Account Settlement Market

Date: Apr 1, 2021

CCI Establishes Non-Dominance of IATA in India's Air Cargo Account Settlement Market Introduction The Competition Commission of India (CCI) rendered a significant judgment regarding the appeal filed...

SEBI Order on Insider Trading in ADF Foods Limited: Strengthening Regulatory Measures

Date: Mar 31, 2021

SEBI Order on Insider Trading in ADF Foods Limited: Strengthening Regulatory Measures Introduction The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) delivered a landmark judgment on March 30, 2021...