All Tribunals Case Commentaries

Acknowledge Consumer Status Despite Multiple Property Holdings: Insights from ALOKE ANAND v. M/S. IREO PVT. LTD. & 2 ORS.

Date: Nov 2, 2021

Acknowledge Consumer Status Despite Multiple Property Holdings: Insights from ALOKE ANAND v. M/S. IREO PVT. LTD. & 2 ORS. Introduction The case of Aloke Anand vs. M/S. Ireo Pvt. Ltd. & 2 Ors....

Limits of Revisional Authority under Section 263: Insights from Sangram Keshari Samantaray vs. Pr. CIT-2, Bhubaneswar

Date: Oct 29, 2021

Limits of Revisional Authority under Section 263: Insights from Sangram Keshari Samantaray vs. Pr. CIT-2, Bhubaneswar Introduction The case of Sangram Keshari Samantaray vs. Principal Commissioner of...

ITAT Chandigarh Establishes Precedence on Deductibility of ESI and PF Contributions under Section 36(1)(va) Amidst Section 43B Amendments

Date: Oct 29, 2021

ITAT Chandigarh Establishes Precedence on Deductibility of ESI and PF Contributions under Section 36(1)(va) Amidst Section 43B Amendments Introduction In the landmark case of M/s Citi Centre...

CESTAT Upholds Appeal Against Central Government's Decision on Anti-Dumping Duty: A Landmark Judgment

Date: Oct 28, 2021

CESTAT Upholds Appeal Against Central Government's Decision on Anti-Dumping Duty: A Landmark Judgment Introduction The case of Jubilant Ingrevia Limited v. Designated Authority Directorate General of...

Affirmation of Consumer Rights to Refund with Interest and Compensation in Real Estate Disputes – NCDRC Upholds Consumer's Entitlement in Kuber Builders v. Reeshab Teelak Chemicals Pvt. Ltd.

Date: Oct 28, 2021

Affirmation of Consumer Rights to Refund with Interest and Compensation in Real Estate Disputes – NCDRC Upholds Consumer's Entitlement in Kuber Builders v. Reeshab Teelak Chemicals Pvt. Ltd....

Deficiency in Service: Divisional Manager & Anr. v. Sujinder Singh Judgment Analysis

Date: Oct 27, 2021

Deficiency in Service: Divisional Manager & Anr. v. Sujinder Singh Judgment Analysis Introduction The case of Divisional Manager & Anr. v. Sujinder Singh was adjudicated by the State Consumer...

Enhancing Duty of Disclosure: NCDRC’s Interpretation of Section 45 in SMT. SUNITA v. HDFC Standard Life Insurance Co. Ltd.

Date: Oct 26, 2021

Enhancing Duty of Disclosure: NCDRC’s Interpretation of Section 45 in SMT. SUNITA v. HDFC Standard Life Insurance Co. Ltd. Introduction SMT. SUNITA v. HDFC Standard Life Insurance Co. Ltd. & Anr. is...

Mandatory Carry Bag Charges as Unfair Trade Practice: Reliance Retail Ltd. v. Amarpreet Singh

Date: Oct 26, 2021

Mandatory Carry Bag Charges as Unfair Trade Practice: Reliance Retail Ltd. v. Amarpreet Singh Introduction The case of Reliance Retail Ltd. v. Amarpreet Singh adjudicated by the State Consumer...

NCLAT Reinforces Limits on Inherent Powers: Denial of Review and Recall in Insolvency Proceedings

Date: Oct 26, 2021

NCLAT Reinforces Limits on Inherent Powers: Denial of Review and Recall in Insolvency Proceedings Introduction The case of Agarwal Coal Corporation Private Limited v. Sun Paper Mill Limited & Anr....

Extension of Time Limit under Section 54 for Construction of New Residential Property: Patel vs DCIT Judgment Analysis

Date: Oct 26, 2021

Extension of Time Limit under Section 54 for Construction of New Residential Property: Patel vs DCIT Judgment Analysis Introduction The case of Shri Sangram J Patel vs D.C.I.T., International...

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Abdul Razak: Establishing Duty of Good Faith in Insurance Claims

Date: Oct 23, 2021

Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Abdul Razak: Establishing Duty of Good Faith in Insurance Claims Introduction The case of Oriental Insurance Co. Ltd. v. Abdul Razak adjudicated by the National...

Deficiency in Service and Consumer Rights: Insights from Manoj Kumar v. PUDA

Date: Oct 20, 2021

Deficiency in Service and Consumer Rights: Insights from Manoj Kumar v. PUDA Introduction The case of Manoj Kumar v. Punjab Urban Planning & Development Authority (PUDA) adjudicated by the District...

Consumer Rights Reinforced in ATUL KUMAR AGARWAL v. KRRISH SHALIMAR PROJECTS PVT. LTD.

Date: Oct 19, 2021

Consumer Rights Reinforced in Atul Kumar Agarwal v. Krrish Shalimar Projects Pvt. Ltd. Introduction The case of Atul Kumar Agarwal v. Krrish Shalimar Projects Pvt. Ltd. was adjudicated by the...

Consumer Rights Reinforced: Deficiency in Hotel Services in Bhupinder Singh Bhatia v. Make My Trip India Ltd.

Date: Oct 19, 2021

Consumer Rights Reinforced: Deficiency in Hotel Services in Bhupinder Singh Bhatia v. Make My Trip India Ltd. Introduction The case of Bhupinder Singh Bhatia v. Make My Trip India Ltd. was...

RERA Punjab Judgment: Jatinder Kaur v. ATS Estates Pvt Ltd - Establishing Rights to Possession and Interest for Delayed Delivery

Date: Oct 14, 2021

RERA Punjab Judgment: Jatinder Kaur v. ATS Estates Pvt Ltd - Establishing Rights to Possession and Interest for Delayed Delivery Introduction The case of Jatinder Kaur v. ATS Estates Pvt Ltd was...

RERA Punjab Judgment: Strengthening Buyer Rights in Real Estate Transactions

Date: Oct 14, 2021

RERA Punjab Judgment: Strengthening Buyer Rights in Real Estate Transactions Introduction The case of Baljeet Kaur v. ATS Estates Pvt Ltd adjudicated by the Real Estate Regulatory Authority (RERA) in...

Ensuring Consideration of Change in Law Events During Tariff Adoption: The Green Infra Renewable Energy v. RERC Decision

Date: Oct 13, 2021

Ensuring Consideration of Change in Law Events During Tariff Adoption: The Green Infra Renewable Energy v. RERC Decision Introduction In the landmark case of Green Infra Renewable Energy Limited v....

Deficiency in Service by Real Estate Developers: Landmark Refund Directive with Interest in Consumer Protection

Date: Oct 12, 2021

Deficiency in Service by Real Estate Developers: Landmark Refund Directive with Interest in Consumer Protection Introduction The case of Brigadier Harir Pant v. M/S. Imperia Structure Ltd....

NCLAT's Landmark Decision on Classification of Security Deposits as Financial Debt under IBC

Date: Oct 8, 2021

NCLAT's Landmark Decision on Classification of Security Deposits as Financial Debt under IBC Introduction The case of Sach Marketing Private Limited v. Resolution Professional of Mount Shivalik...

Starlog Enterprises Ltd. v. Avil Menezes: Defining Financial Debt under the IBC

Date: Oct 8, 2021

Starlog Enterprises Ltd. v. Avil Menezes: Defining Financial Debt under the IBC Introduction Starlog Enterprises Ltd. v. Avil Menezes is a landmark case adjudicated by the National Company Law...