All Tribunals Case Commentaries

Threshold Compliance under Section 7 Amid Section 10A Provisions: Narayan Mangal v. Vatsalya Builders

Date: Aug 19, 2023

Threshold Compliance under Section 7 Amid Section 10A Provisions: Narayan Mangal v. Vatsalya Builders Introduction The case of Narayan Mangal v. Vatsalya Builders & Developers Pvt. Ltd. adjudicated...

Establishing the Necessity of a Pre-Existing Dispute in Operational Debt Claims: Feng Ji v. Giesecke & Devrient MS India Pvt. Ltd. & Anr.

Date: Aug 12, 2023

Establishing the Necessity of a Pre-Existing Dispute in Operational Debt Claims Introduction The case of Feng Ji v. GIESECKE & DEVRIENT MS INDIA PVT. LTD. & Anr. adjudicated by the National Company...

Precedent on Limitation and Pre-existing Disputes in Corporate Insolvency

Date: Aug 11, 2023

Clarification on Limitation and Pre-existing Disputes in Corporate Insolvency Resolution: TIMEX BOND INDUSTRIES Pvt. Ltd. v. DEIST INDUSTRIES Pvt. Ltd. Introduction The case of Timex Bond Industries...

CESTAT Sets Precedent for Specific Classification of Snow Goggles Under Customs Tariff

Date: Aug 10, 2023

CESTAT Sets Precedent for Specific Classification of Snow Goggles Under Customs Tariff Introduction The case of Aureole Inspecs India Pvt. Ltd. v. Principal Commissioner, Customs-New Delhi...

Section 10A of IBC: Suspension of CIRP Applications Post Default Amid COVID-19 Pandemic

Date: Aug 9, 2023

Section 10A of IBC: Suspension of CIRP Applications Post Default Amid COVID-19 Pandemic 1. Introduction The case of Carissa Investments LLC v. Indu Techzone Private Limited adjudicated by the...

Comprehensive Commentary on Dr. Santosh Gaydhankar v. Mr. Sandeep Kumar Advocate

Date: Aug 9, 2023

Establishing New Precedents in Consumer Disputes: Insights from Dr. Santosh Gaydhankar v. Mr. Sandeep Kumar Advocate Introduction The case of Dr. Santosh Gaydhankar v. Mr. Sandeep Kumar Advocate...

Establishing Consumer Rights in Cooperative Societies: Insights from Mahender Singh v. Sahara Credit Co-operative Society

Date: Aug 5, 2023

Establishing Consumer Rights in Cooperative Societies: Insights from Mahender Singh v. Sahara Credit Co-operative Society Introduction The case of Mahender Singh v. Sahara Credit Co-operative Society...

NCLAT Upholds Non-Arbitrability of Oppression and Mismanagement Claims under the Companies Act

Date: Aug 1, 2023

NCLAT Upholds Non-Arbitrability of Oppression and Mismanagement Claims under the Companies Act Introduction The case of Indus Motor Company Private Limited & Ors v. T.P Anilkumar & Ors adjudicated by...

Insurers' Burden of Proof in Medi-Claim Policy Disputes Affirmed: UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. v. SUKHBIR SINGH

Date: Jul 27, 2023

Insurers' Burden of Proof in Medi-Claim Policy Disputes Affirmed: UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. v. SUKHBIR SINGH Introduction The case of UNITED INDIA INSURANCE CO. v. SUKHBIR SINGH adjudicated by the...

Comprehensive Legal Commentary: Noordeen Ahmed Amina vs. ITO – Reassessment of Penalty under Section 269SS

Date: Jul 27, 2023

Reassessment of Penalty under Section 269SS: Noordeen Ahmed Amina vs. ITO Introduction The case of Noordeen Ahmed Amina vs. ITO, NFAC New Delhi adjudicated by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal (ITA)...

ITAT Judgment Clarifies Applicability of Section 69/69A and Section 115BBE in Surrendered Business Income

Date: Jul 25, 2023

ITAT Judgment Clarifies Applicability of Section 69/69A and Section 115BBE in Surrendered Business Income Introduction The case of Shri Parmod Singla, Patiala v. The ACIT, Circle, Patiala adjudicated...

Yester Investment Pvt Ltd v. Manish Motilal Jaju: Affirming Class-Wide Voting in IBC Resolution Plans

Date: Jul 20, 2023

Yester Investment Pvt Ltd v. Manish Motilal Jaju: Affirming Class-Wide Voting in IBC Resolution Plans Introduction The case of Yester Investment Private Limited v. Manish Motilal Jaju was adjudicated...

National Green Tribunal Upholds Closure of Red Category Industry Operating Without Consent: Khurshid Ahmed v. WB Pollution Control Board

Date: Jul 20, 2023

National Green Tribunal Upholds Closure of Red Category Industry Operating Without Consent: Khurshid Ahmed v. West Bengal Pollution Control Board Introduction The case of Khurshid Ahmed v. West...

Enhanced Limitation Period Recognition in Insolvency Proceedings: Asset Reconstruction Company India Limited v. Uniworth Textiles Limited

Date: Jul 11, 2023

Enhanced Limitation Period Recognition in Insolvency Proceedings: Asset Reconstruction Company India Limited v. Uniworth Textiles Limited 1. Introduction The case of Asset Reconstruction Company...

Maa Kalika Transport Pvt Ltd v. Commissioner of CGST & Central Excise: Upholding the Composite Nature of Transportation Services Under GST

Date: Jul 11, 2023

Maa Kalika Transport Pvt Ltd v. Commissioner of CGST & Central Excise: Upholding the Composite Nature of Transportation Services Under GST Introduction The case of Maa Kalika Transport Private...

Establishing Precedent for Automatic Recovery Certificates in DRB Tribunals

Date: Jul 6, 2023

Establishing Precedent for Automatic Recovery Certificates in DRB Tribunals Introduction The case of Union Bank of India v. M/s Swastik Enterprises adjudicated by the Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRB) in...

Acceptance of Late Form 10B Filing for Section 11 Exemption: ITAT Ahmedabad's Landmark Judgment in Shree Charitable Trust v. ITO

Date: Jul 6, 2023

Acceptance of Late Form 10B Filing for Section 11 Exemption: ITAT Ahmedabad's Landmark Judgment in Shree Charitable Trust v. ITO Introduction The case of Shree Charitable Trust, Vadodara v. The ITO...

Defining Financial Debt under IBC 2016: Insights from Globe Capital Market Ltd. v. Narayan Securities Ltd. Judgment

Date: Jul 4, 2023

Defining Financial Debt under IBC 2016: Insights from Globe Capital Market Ltd. v. Narayan Securities Ltd. Judgment Introduction The legal landscape of corporate insolvency in India has been...

Ex-Parte Adjudication in Debt Recovery Under the RODB Act: Insights from HDFC Bank v. M/S Sai Ram Traders

Date: Jul 1, 2023

Ex-Parte Adjudication in Debt Recovery Under the RODB Act: Insights from HDFC Bank Ltd. v. M/S Sai Ram Traders and Others Introduction The case of HDFC Bank Ltd. v. M/S Sai Ram Traders and Others...

Misrepresentation in Real Estate: Landmark Judgment in Jagruk Nagrik & Anr. v. Shreeniwass Cotton Mills Ltd. & Anr.

Date: Jun 27, 2023

Misrepresentation in Real Estate: Landmark Judgment in Jagruk Nagrik & Anr. v. Shreeniwass Cotton Mills Ltd. & Anr. Introduction The case of Jagruk Nagrik & Anr. v. Shreeniwass Cotton Mills Ltd. &...