All Tribunals Case Commentaries

Ravi Foods Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner Of C.Ex. Hyderabad: Clarification on MRP Valuation and Admissibility of Income Tax Evidence in Central Excise Duty Assessment

Date: Dec 23, 2010

Ravi Foods Pvt. Ltd. v. Commissioner Of C.Ex. Hyderabad: Clarification on MRP Valuation and Admissibility of Income Tax Evidence in Central Excise Duty Assessment Introduction The case of Ravi Foods...

Recognition of Revenue and Accounting Methods in Real Estate: Cit v. Manish Buildwell P. Ltd.

Date: Dec 23, 2010

Recognition of Revenue and Accounting Methods in Real Estate: Cit v. Manish Buildwell P. Ltd. Introduction The case of Cit v. Manish Buildwell P. Ltd. adjudicated by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal...

Presumption of Unreliable Accounts and Suppressed Production: Insights from Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax v. SRJ Peety Steels (P.) Ltd.

Date: Dec 1, 2010

Presumption of Unreliable Accounts and Suppressed Production: Insights from Assistant Commissioner of Income-tax v. SRJ Peety Steels (P.) Ltd. Introduction The case of Assistant Commissioner of...

Ahura Holdings v. DCIT: Landmark Decision on On-Money Receipts and Business Loss Disallowance

Date: Nov 27, 2010

Ahura Holdings v. DCIT: Landmark Decision on On-Money Receipts and Business Loss Disallowance Introduction The case of Shri Gopal Lal Badruka, Hyderabad v. DCIT, Central Circle-2, Hyderabad,...

Enhancing Regulatory Compliance: CERC's Directive on Power Exchange India Ltd.

Date: Nov 20, 2010

Enhancing Regulatory Compliance: CERC's Directive on Power Exchange India Ltd. Introduction The case of Power Exchange India Ltd. (PXIL) v. Central Electricity Regulatory Commission (CERC),...

Right to Interest on Delayed Refunds Under Section 244A Confirmed

Date: Nov 20, 2010

Right to Interest on Delayed Refunds Under Section 244A Confirmed Introduction The case of M/S Multiscreen Media Pvt. Ltd. vs. The Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax is a pivotal judgment delivered...

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal Upholds Use of Internal Comparables and Limits Transfer Pricing Adjustments to International Transactions

Date: Nov 13, 2010

Income Tax Appellate Tribunal Upholds Use of Internal Comparables and Limits Transfer Pricing Adjustments to International Transactions Introduction This comprehensive commentary examines the...

Edelweiss Capital Ltd. v. Income Tax Officer: Landmark Rulings on Revenue and Capital Expenditures

Date: Nov 11, 2010

Edelweiss Capital Ltd. v. Income Tax Officer: Landmark Rulings on Revenue and Capital Expenditures Introduction The case of Edelweiss Capital Ltd., Mumbai v. Income Tax Officer is a pivotal judgment...

Validation of Dealer Advances in Income Assessment: Saumya Sales Corporation vs. Income Tax Officer

Date: Nov 5, 2010

Validation of Dealer Advances in Income Assessment: Saumya Sales Corporation vs. Income Tax Officer Introduction The case of M/S. Saumya Sales Corporation, Khalilabad, Distt: Sant Kabir Nagar v....

Burden of Proof in Capital Gains Disputes: Insights from A.C.I.T 3, Mathura v. Smt. Kela Devi Agarwal

Date: Oct 30, 2010

Burden of Proof in Capital Gains Disputes: Insights from A.C.I.T 3, Mathura v. Smt. Kela Devi Agarwal Introduction The case of A.C.I.T 3, Mathura v. Smt. Kela Devi Agarwal, adjudicated on October 29,...

Limits of Section 263 in Modifying Final Assessments: Insights from Commissioner of Income-tax v. Murli Agro Products Ltd.

Date: Oct 30, 2010

Limits of Section 263 in Modifying Final Assessments: Insights from Commissioner of Income-tax v. Murli Agro Products Ltd. Introduction The case of Commissioner of Income-tax (Central), Nagpur v....

Recognition of Advance Fees as Income under the Mercantile Method of Accounting

Date: Oct 30, 2010

Recognition of Advance Fees as Income under the Mercantile Method of Accounting Introduction The case of Commissioner of Income-tax v. Dinesh Kumar Goel decided by the Income Tax Appellate Tribunal...

Clarification on TDS Obligations Under Sections 194C, 194D, and 194J: Insights from Tata Aig General Insurance Company Ltd. v. Ito (Osd) 3(2)

Date: Oct 30, 2010

Clarification on TDS Obligations Under Sections 194C, 194D, and 194J: Insights from Tata Aig General Insurance Company Ltd. v. Ito (Osd) 3(2) 1. Introduction The case of Tata Aig General Insurance...

Redemption of Confiscated Goods and Proof of Ownership: Insights from Yakub Ibrahim Yusuf v. Commissioner of Customs

Date: Oct 29, 2010

Redemption of Confiscated Goods and Proof of Ownership: Insights from Yakub Ibrahim Yusuf v. Commissioner of Customs Introduction The case of Yakub Ibrahim Yusuf v. Commissioner Of Customs, Mumbai...

Taxation of Software Licensing Royalties: Gracemac Corporation v. Asstt. Director Of Income-Tax

Date: Oct 27, 2010

Taxation of Software Licensing Royalties: Gracemac Corporation v. Asstt. Director Of Income-Tax Introduction The case of Gracemac Corporation v. Assistant Director of Income-Tax, International Tax...

Reinforcing Business Income Classification and Interest Deductibility: Asst. Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Delite Enterprises Pvt. Ltd.

Date: Oct 21, 2010

Reinforcing Business Income Classification and Interest Deductibility: Asst. Commissioner Of Income-Tax v. Delite Enterprises Pvt. Ltd. Introduction The case of Asst. Commissioner Of Income-Tax...

Salman Khan v. Dy. Commissioner Of Income Tax Central: Re-examination of Deductions under Sections 80RR and 37(1)

Date: Oct 14, 2010

Salman Khan v. Dy. Commissioner Of Income Tax Central: Re-examination of Deductions under Sections 80RR and 37(1) 1. Introduction The case of Dy. Commissioner Of Income Tax Central, Cir-24, Mumbai v....

Consistency in Revenue Expenditure Classification and Interpretation of Section 80-IA: Poonawalla Estate Stud & Agro Farm v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax

Date: Sep 30, 2010

Consistency in Revenue Expenditure Classification and Interpretation of Section 80-IA: Poonawalla Estate Stud & Agro Farm v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax Introduction The case of Poonawalla...

Enhanced Compensation for Medical Negligence: NCDRC's Ruling in Surendra Kumar Tyagi v. Jagat Nursing Home & Hospital

Date: Sep 29, 2010

Enhanced Compensation for Medical Negligence: NCDRC's Ruling in Surendra Kumar Tyagi v. Jagat Nursing Home & Hospital Introduction The case of Surendra Kumar Tyagi v. Jagat Nursing Home & Hospital...

Ajit Education Trust v. Commissioner of Income Tax-III Baroda: Non-Retrospective Cancellation of Trust Registration under Section 12AA(3)

Date: Sep 25, 2010

Ajit Education Trust v. Commissioner of Income Tax-III Baroda: Non-Retrospective Cancellation of Trust Registration under Section 12AA(3) 1. Introduction The case of Ajit Education Trust Shravan...