All Tribunals Case Commentaries

Deficiency in Service by Real Estate Developers: BPTP Ltd. Judgment Analysis

Date: Oct 22, 2019

Deficiency in Service by Real Estate Developers: BPTP Ltd. Judgment Analysis Introduction The case Jasjot Singh Dang v. M/s BPTP Ltd. was adjudicated by the State Consumer Disputes Redressal...

Rei Agro Limited SEBI Judgment Commentary: Upholding Procedural Compliance in Preferential Allotments

Date: Oct 18, 2019

Upholding Procedural Compliance in Preferential Allotments: The SEBI Judgment in Rei Agro Limited Case Introduction On October 17, 2019, the Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) rendered a...

Group Insolvency Resolution under I&B Code: NCLAT's Precedent in Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company Limited v. Sachet Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd.

Date: Sep 21, 2019

Group Insolvency Resolution under I&B Code: NCLAT's Precedent in Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction Company Limited v. Sachet Infrastructure Pvt. Ltd. Introduction The case Edelweiss Asset Reconstruction...

New Precedent on Change in Law Compensation in Power Purchase Agreements: Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd. v. Rajasthan Electricity Regulatory Commission

Date: Sep 15, 2019

New Precedent on Change in Law Compensation in Power Purchase Agreements: Jaipur Vidyut Vitran Nigam Ltd. v. Rajasthan Electricity Regulatory Commission Introduction The case of Jaipur Vidyut Vitran...

Establishing Liability Through Tripartite Agreements: Insights from UCO Bank v. Deepak Sharma

Date: Sep 12, 2019

Establishing Liability Through Tripartite Agreements: Insights from UCO Bank v. Deepak Sharma Introduction The case of UCO Bank v. Deepak Sharma adjudicated by the Debts Recovery Tribunal (DRT) on...

Tribunal Affirms SEBI Must Establish Mens Rea to Debar Chartered Accountants: Price Waterhouse v. SEBI

Date: Sep 10, 2019

Tribunal Affirms SEBI Must Establish Mens Rea to Debar Chartered Accountants: Price Waterhouse v. SEBI Introduction The case of Price Waterhouse & Co. Bangalore LLP and Others v. Securities and...

Refund of Property Investment: Alok Kumar v. Golden Peacock Residency Establishes New Standards for Developer Accountability

Date: Sep 7, 2019

Refund of Property Investment: Alok Kumar v. Golden Peacock Residency Establishes New Standards for Developer Accountability Introduction The case of Alok Kumar versus Golden Peacock Residency...

Consumer Fora's Jurisdiction Over Flat Pricing: Insights from Harinderpal Singh v. Housefed

Date: Aug 28, 2019

Consumer Fora's Jurisdiction Over Flat Pricing: Insights from Harinderpal Singh v. Housefed Introduction The case of Harinderpal Singh v. The Punjab State Federation of Cooperative House Building...

Enhanced Consumer Protection in Real Estate: Landmark Ruling on Compensation for Delayed Possession

Date: Aug 20, 2019

Enhanced Consumer Protection in Real Estate: Landmark Ruling on Compensation for Delayed Possession Introduction The case of Vinamra Shyamji Sharma vs. Three C Shelters Pvt. Ltd. and Orris...

Director Liability Clarified: Insights from Sayanti Sen v. SEBI Tribunal

Date: Aug 10, 2019

Director Liability Clarified: Insights from Sayanti Sen v. SEBI Tribunal Introduction The case of Sayanti Sen v. Securities And Exchange Board Of India (SEBI) addressed critical issues regarding the...

Scope of Scrutiny in Limited Assessments: R. & H. Property Developer Pvt. Ltd. v. PCIT-11, Mumbai

Date: Jul 31, 2019

Scope of Scrutiny in Limited Assessments: R. & H. Property Developer Pvt. Ltd. v. Principal Commissioner Of Income Tax-11, Mumbai Introduction The case of R. & H. Property Developer Pvt. Ltd. v....

Deduction under Section 36(1)(va) Denied for Late PF & ESI Contributions: Eagle Trans Shipping Case Analysis

Date: Jul 26, 2019

Deduction under Section 36(1)(va) Denied for Late PF & ESI Contributions: Eagle Trans Shipping Case Analysis Introduction The case of Eagle Trans Shipping & Logistics (India) Private Ltd. v....

ITA Decision in Suman Poddar v. ITO: Scrutinizing the Genuineness of Long-Term Capital Gains

Date: Jul 26, 2019

ITA Decision in Suman Poddar v. ITO: Scrutinizing the Genuineness of Long-Term Capital Gains Introduction The case of Suman Poddar, New Delhi v. ITO, Ward-39(5), New Delhi adjudicated by the Income...

GST Classification of Food Supplies at Members' Club Events: Insights from Bengal Rowing Club v. WBAAR

Date: Jul 9, 2019

GST Classification of Food Supplies at Members' Club Events: Insights from Bengal Rowing Club v. WBAAR Introduction The case of Bengal Rowing Club v. Appellate Authority for Advance Ruling, GST...

Ensuring Equitable Distribution of Claims in Corporate Insolvency Resolution: Insights from Standard Chartered Bank v. Essar Steel

Date: Jul 5, 2019

Ensuring Equitable Distribution of Claims in Corporate Insolvency Resolution: Insights from Standard Chartered Bank v. Essar Steel Introduction The case of Standard Chartered Bank v. Satish Kumar...

DLF Ltd. vs. Rasheed Ahmad Usmani and Others: Invalidity of Class Action Due to Individual Settlements and Conveyance Deeds

Date: Jul 3, 2019

DLF Ltd. vs. Rasheed Ahmad Usmani and Others: Invalidity of Class Action Due to Individual Settlements and Conveyance Deeds Introduction The case of Rasheed Ahmad Usmani And Others vs. DLF Ltd....

Contributions as Consideration for Supply of Services Under GST: NIBM Ruling

Date: Jun 26, 2019

Contributions as Consideration for Supply of Services Under GST: National Institute of Bank Management Ruling Introduction The case of the National Institute of Bank Management (NIBM) versus the...

Defining Interest Rates and Reinforcing Consumer Rights in Real Estate Transactions: The Jalandhar Improvement Trust v. Archit Gupta Judgment

Date: Jun 15, 2019

Defining Interest Rates and Reinforcing Consumer Rights in Real Estate Transactions: The Jalandhar Improvement Trust v. Archit Gupta Judgment Introduction The case of Jalandhar Improvement Trust &...

EBR Enterprises v. Union of India: Affirmation of Subsection (5) of Section 80A in Restricting Retrospective Deductions

Date: Jun 5, 2019

EBR Enterprises v. Union of India: Affirmation of Subsection (5) of Section 80A in Restricting Retrospective Deductions Introduction The case of EBR Enterprises v. Union of India adjudicated by the...

SEBI's Enforcement on Registrar Compliance: The Sharex Dynamic Precedent

Date: May 25, 2019

SEBI's Enforcement on Registrar Compliance: The Sharex Dynamic Precedent Introduction The Securities and Exchange Board of India (SEBI) plays a pivotal role in regulating and overseeing...