Factual and Procedural Background
The Tehsildar, Tangi Chowdwar, Cuttack issued an auction notice on 11 July 2022 inviting sealed bids for a five-year lease to extract sand from the Mahanadi Sand Quarry under Tehsil Tangi Chowdwar, District Cuttack, Odisha. Bids were to be submitted by 18 July 2022 and opened on 19 July 2022. After verification, the lease was to be granted to the highest bidder.
Clause 5 of the tender incorporated Rule 27(4)(iv) of the Odisha Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2016 (“the Rules”), requiring bidders to submit either: (i) an income tax return (ITR) of the previous financial year showing annual income not less than the sum of the additional charge offered plus royalty for the minimum guaranteed quantity for one year; or (ii) a bank guarantee valid for 18 months for not less than the same amount.
Twenty bidders participated. The unsuccessful bidder quoted the highest rate at Rs. 2127.27 per cubic meter, while the successful bidder quoted Rs. 1250 per cubic meter. In its meeting on 19 July 2022, the Tender Committee declared the highest bidder’s (unsuccessful bidder’s) bid non-responsive for not complying with Rule 27(4)(iv), specifically for not submitting the ITR for the financial year 2021–2022. The successful bidder’s bid was found technically responsive and was declared the highest valid bid.
On 25 July 2022, the Tehsildar issued Form-F to the successful bidder, intimating his success and calling upon him to (i) accept the terms and conditions, and (ii) deposit Rs. 1,26,75,000 under Rules 27(7) and 27(9). On the same day, the successful bidder accepted the terms and deposited the amount via RTGS.
On 10 August 2022, the unsuccessful bidder filed a writ petition before the High Court of Orissa challenging the award of the tender to the successful bidder. By an ex parte interim order dated 24 August 2022, the High Court directed that no further action pursuant to the Form-F issued to the successful bidder be given effect to.
By final order dated 1 March 2022 (referred to in the judgment as 1 March 2023 in relation to the challenged decision), the High Court held that the unsuccessful bidder’s bid was rightly rejected for non-compliance with Rule 27(4)(iv) and upheld the grant of tender to the successful bidder. However, noting the large difference between the rates quoted by the unsuccessful and successful bidders and the consequent loss to the public exchequer, the High Court directed the Tehsildar to ask the successful bidder to match the rate offered by the unsuccessful bidder. The unsuccessful bidder challenged the upholding of its bid rejection, and the successful bidder challenged the direction requiring it to match the higher rate.
In the unsuccessful bidder’s special leave petition, a Bench of the Supreme Court granted an ad-interim status quo order on 29 March 2023 regarding the contract. By the time of the Supreme Court’s final decision, three years and three months of the original five-year lease period had already lapsed, and no lease deed had been executed due to the litigation.
Legal Issues Presented
- What is the correct interpretation of the expression “previous Financial Year” in Rule 27(4)(iv) of the Odisha Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2016, particularly when the tender is issued in the midst of a financial year and the statutory deadline for filing the latest income tax return has not expired?
- Whether the Tender Committee lawfully rejected the highest bidder’s (unsuccessful bidder’s) bid for not submitting the ITR for financial year 2021–2022, and whether the High Court was justified in upholding that rejection.
- What consequential relief should be granted to the parties, including whether the prior tender process should be maintained, modified, or set aside and whether a fresh auction should be ordered, given the lapse of a substantial portion of the lease period.
Arguments of the Parties
Unsuccessful Bidder’s Arguments
- The unsuccessful bidder had submitted its ITR for financial year 2020–2021 along with its bid, and also filed a provisional balance sheet for financial year 2021–2022.
- The tender was floated in the middle of the year (11 July 2022), and as a company, the bidder’s statutory last date for filing the ITR for financial year 2021–2022 was 31 October 2022. It could not therefore be compelled to file the 2021–2022 ITR by the bid submission date.
- The Tender Committee misinterpreted Rule 27(4)(iv) by insisting on the 2021–2022 ITR and failed to appreciate that submission of the 2020–2021 ITR fulfilled the Rule’s mandate.
- The High Court failed to exercise its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution in not correcting the Tender Committee’s misinterpretation.
- Given that three years and three months of the five-year lease period had already expired, the Tehsildar should now be directed to issue a fresh tender.
- In support of these submissions, reliance was placed on:
- B.S.N. Joshi & Sons Ltd. v. Nair Coal Services Ltd. & Others;
- Jagdish Mandal v. State of Orissa & Others;
- UFLEX Limited v. Government of Tamil Nadu & Others.
State of Odisha’s Arguments
- The State was willing to award the tender for the remainder of the period in favour of the successful bidder, but at the rate quoted by the unsuccessful bidder.
- Alternatively, respondent nos. 1 and 2 were willing to refund, without interest, the amount deposited by the successful bidder, since the lease deed could not be executed due to the litigation.
Successful Bidder’s Arguments
- The Tender Committee correctly rejected the unsuccessful bidder’s bid because it did not comply with Rule 27(4)(iv), specifically by failing to file the ITR for financial year 2021–2022.
- The ITRs now produced by the unsuccessful bidder did not show annual income above the required threshold value.
- In the absence of arbitrariness or mala fides, the terms of a tender are not open to judicial scrutiny.
- Once a bidder is declared successful, accepts the terms and conditions, and deposits the statutory amount, a vested right is created in favour of the successful bidder, and execution of the lease deed is a ministerial act.
- The delay in execution of the lease deed was entirely due to litigation and not attributable to the successful bidder; an act of the Court should not prejudice a party (actus curiae neminem gravabit).
- Public auctions are instruments of accountability and transparency, and a concluded auction, in the absence of mala fides or breach of law, should not be cancelled.
- The successful bidder was now ready to match the rate offered by the unsuccessful bidder and requested that the Tehsildar be directed to execute a lease deed in its favour for a fresh period of five years.
- In support of these submissions, reliance was placed on:
- Afcons Infrastructure Ltd. v. Nagpur Metro Rail Corporation Ltd. & Anr.;
- Gujarat Pottery Works v. B.P. Sood, Controller of Mining Leases for India;
- Bhushan Power and Steel Ltd. v. S.L. Seal, Addl. Secretary (Steel and Mines), State of Odisha & Ors.;
- Aane Mines and Minerals, Nagarjuna Hills, Panjagutta, Hyderabad v. State of Karnataka & Another;
- Doiwala Sehkari Shram Samvida Samiti Ltd. v. State of Uttaranchal and Ors.;
- Subodh Kumar Singh Rathour v. Chief Executive Officer and Ors.;
- Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Ltd. v. Mandeepa Enterprises and Ors.
Table of Precedents Cited
| Precedent |
Rule or Principle Cited For |
Application by the Court |
| B.S.N. Joshi & Sons Ltd. v. Nair Coal Services Ltd. & Others (2006) 11 SCC 548 |
Cited by the unsuccessful bidder in support of its submissions regarding tender interpretation and judicial review in contractual matters. |
The judgment notes the citation but does not discuss or apply this precedent in its reasoning. |
| Jagdish Mandal v. State of Orissa & Others (2007) 14 SCC 517 |
Cited by the unsuccessful bidder in support of its challenge to the tender rejection and the scope of judicial review under Article 226. |
The Court does not specifically analyse or apply this case in its reasoning. |
| UFLEX Limited v. Government of Tamil Nadu & Others (2022) 1 SCC 165 |
Cited by the unsuccessful bidder in support of its submissions relating to tender conditions and their interpretation. |
Not specifically discussed or applied in the Court’s analysis. |
| Afcons Infrastructure Ltd. v. Nagpur Metro Rail Corporation Ltd. & Anr. (2016) 16 SCC 818 |
Cited by the successful bidder to emphasise that, absent arbitrariness or mala fides, tender terms are not open to judicial scrutiny. |
The Supreme Court notes the reliance but does not expressly apply this decision in its reasoning. |
| Gujarat Pottery Works v. B.P. Sood, Controller of Mining Leases for India 1966 SCC OnLine SC 126 |
Cited by the successful bidder to support the proposition that a vested right arises upon acceptance of the bid and deposit of statutory amounts, with the lease execution being a ministerial act. |
The Court does not independently analyse or apply this precedent in its reasoning. |
| Bhushan Power and Steel Ltd. v. S.L. Seal, Addl. Secretary (Steel and Mines), State of Odisha & Ors. (2017) 2 SCC 125 |
Cited by the successful bidder regarding the vesting of rights upon acceptance of the bid in mining/lease contexts. |
The judgment does not specifically rely on this case in its analysis. |
| Aane Mines and Minerals, Nagarjuna Hills, Panjagutta, Hyderabad v. State of Karnataka & Another 2019 SCC OnLine Kar 3791 |
Cited by the successful bidder in relation to rights flowing from concluded auctions and execution of mining leases. |
Not expressly discussed or applied in the Court’s reasoning. |
| Doiwala Sehkari Shram Samvida Samiti Ltd. v. State of Uttaranchal and Ors. (2007) 11 SCC 641 |
Cited by the successful bidder for the principle that an act of the Court should not prejudice a party (actus curiae neminem gravabit). |
The Court does not specifically refer back to this decision in its reasoning. |
| Subodh Kumar Singh Rathour v. Chief Executive Officer and Ors. 2024 SCC OnLine SC 1682; (2024) 15 SCC 461 |
Cited by the successful bidder to argue that concluded public auctions, absent mala fides or illegality, should not be cancelled; later referenced by the Court for principles of public trust in auctions of natural resources. |
The Court refers to this case (along with Natural Resources Allocation, In Re) to affirm that tenders and public auctions for natural resources are exercises in public trust, obliging the State to secure best value with fairness and transparency. |
| Prakash Asphaltings and Toll Highways (India) Ltd. v. Mandeepa Enterprises and Ors. 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1959 |
Cited by the successful bidder in support of the contention that concluded auctions should not be cancelled in the absence of mala fides or breach of law. |
The Court does not specifically engage with this precedent in its reasoning. |
| Michigan Rubber (India) Ltd. v. State of Karnataka & Others (2012) 8 SCC 216 |
Articulates that judicial review in tender matters is limited to examining whether the decision-making process is arbitrary, irrational, mala fide, or contrary to public interest. |
The Court relies on this decision to define the contours of judicial review in contractual/tender matters and to emphasise that interference is warranted only where the process is vitiated by such infirmities. |
| Banshidhar Construction Pvt. Ltd. v. Bharat Coking Coal Ltd. & Others (2024) 10 SCC 273 |
Reiterates that governmental decisions in tender matters must be free from arbitrariness and guided by Article 14 of the Constitution. |
Cited by the Court to reinforce that State action in tenders must comply with the constitutional mandate of non-arbitrariness. |
| TATA Cellular v. Union of India (1994) 6 SCC 651 |
States that courts generally do not interfere in contractual matters of the State, but also that courts have a duty to intervene where the decision-making process is irrational, perverse, or against public interest. |
The Court cites this case to balance judicial restraint in tender matters with the obligation to intervene when tender conditions are misconstrued in a way that harms public interest. |
| Natural Resources Allocation, In Re, Special Reference No. 1 of 2012 (2012) 10 SCC 1 |
Affirms that tenders and public auctions, especially for natural resources, are exercises in public trust and the State, as custodian of natural wealth, is obligated to secure the best value consistent with fairness and transparency. |
The Court relies on this reference (along with Subodh Kumar Singh Rathour) to frame the relief, emphasising the State’s duty to maximise public revenue and ensure fairness and transparency in auctions of sand quarries. |
Court's Reasoning and Analysis
The Supreme Court first outlined the settled principles governing judicial review of tenders. Relying on Michigan Rubber (India) Ltd., it reiterated that in contractual matters the “heart beat of fair play” is non-arbitrariness and fairness in State action, and that judicial interference is confined to situations where the decision-making process is arbitrary, irrational, mala fide, or contrary to public interest. Referring to Banshidhar Construction Pvt. Ltd., the Court noted that governmental decisions must be free from arbitrariness and guided by Article 14. Citing TATA Cellular, it acknowledged that courts ordinarily refrain from interfering in State contracts, but must intervene if the process is irrational, perverse, or against public interest.
The Court then emphasised the nature of public tenders. A public tender is not a private bargain but “an instrument of governance” through which the State, as trustee of public wealth, must maximise public value by a fair, transparent, and competitive process. The tendering authority must interpret tender terms consistently and in a manner that advances, rather than defeats, the tender’s object. Where an interpretation narrows competition and excludes the highest bidder on a ground unsupported by law, thereby affecting public interest and State revenue, the decision-making process stands vitiated and warrants judicial intervention.
Against this backdrop, the Court addressed the central issue: the interpretation of “previous Financial Year” in Rule 27(4)(iv) of the Rules, as amended on 11 March 2022. The Rule requires submission of an ITR of the “previous Financial Year” showing annual income above a specified threshold, or an equivalent bank guarantee. Clause 5 of the auction notice substantially reproduced this requirement.
The Court noted that the unsuccessful bidder was a company and, as accepted in the State’s counter, had filed its ITR for financial year 2020–2021. The auction notice was issued on 11 July 2022, with bids due on 18 July 2022. Under Section 139(1) of the Income Tax Act, 1961, a company could file its ITR for financial year 2021–2022 up to 31 October 2022. Thus, on the bid submission date, the statutory period for filing the 2021–2022 ITR had not expired, and a bidder could not reasonably be expected to have filed and produced that ITR with its bid.
The Court held that Rule 27(4)(iv) must be read harmoniously with the Income Tax Act. A “reasonable understanding” of “previous Financial Year” in this context must treat it as the financial year immediately preceding the current financial year for which the return has actually become due and been filed—here, 2020–2021. Accordingly, for the unsuccessful bidder, “previous Financial Year” had to be taken as 2020–2021, not 2021–2022, and its submission of the 2020–2021 ITR met the Rule’s requirement.
The Tender Committee, however, adopted a “narrow and erroneous” interpretation by insisting on the 2021–2022 ITR and rejecting the highest bid for non-filing of that return. This interpretation both excluded the highest bidder and defeated the tender’s purpose of maximising State revenue from a natural resource. The Court held that such a misconstruction diminished competition and deprived the State of legitimate revenue, thereby undermining the principle that the State must act to enhance, not diminish, the public exchequer when dealing with natural resources. In these circumstances, the Court’s constitutional duty to interfere was “beyond question”. The High Court, in upholding the Tender Committee’s view, failed to consider this aspect, rendering its judgment unsustainable.
Having found the rejection of the unsuccessful bidder’s bid to be legally flawed, the Court considered appropriate relief. Drawing on Natural Resources Allocation, In Re and Subodh Kumar Singh Rathour, it reiterated that tenders and public auctions, especially for natural resources, are exercises in public trust. The State, as custodian of natural wealth, must secure the best value while maintaining fairness and transparency.
The Court noted that the auction notice was issued on 11 July 2022, the Form-F was issued on 25 July 2022, and the bid was accepted for a five-year period, of which three years and three months had already elapsed without execution of a lease deed. There was no material on record regarding the current market rate of sand, but the Court observed that an upward trend in sand prices could be safely inferred, noting in particular that the successful bidder, at the appellate stage, had expressed willingness to match the unsuccessful bidder’s higher rate. At the same time, the Court recognised that the successful bidder was entitled, on the principle of restitution, to a refund of the amount earlier deposited, together with interest.
In view of its conclusion on the interpretation of Rule 27(4)(iv), the Court found it unnecessary to decide the parties’ other contentions. It instead fashioned relief aimed at restoring fairness and protecting the public interest and exchequer through a fresh, competitive auction process.
Holding and Implications
Holding: The Supreme Court held that, in the circumstances of this case, the expression “previous Financial Year” in Rule 27(4)(iv) of the Odisha Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2016, referred to financial year 2020–2021, not 2021–2022, because the statutory deadline for filing the 2021–2022 ITR had not expired on the bid submission date. The Tender Committee’s rejection of the unsuccessful bidder’s highest bid for non-filing of the 2021–2022 ITR was therefore based on an erroneous interpretation that unjustifiably restricted competition and diminished public revenue.
Consequently, the Court:
- Quashed and set aside the High Court’s impugned judgment dated 1 March 2023 in Writ Petition (C) No. 20402 of 2022.
- Directed the Tehsildar, Tangi Chowdwar, Cuttack, to issue a fresh auction notice for grant of a sand extraction lease for the Mahanadi Sand Quarry in accordance with the Odisha Minor Mineral Concession Rules, 2016.
- Directed that both the unsuccessful and successful bidders, as well as all other concerned parties, shall be entitled to participate and submit bids in the fresh auction.
- Directed that the contract for extraction of sand from the Mahanadi Sand Quarry be awarded strictly in accordance with the Rules.
- Ordered the State to refund to the successful bidder the amount it had deposited, within 30 days, together with interest at 6% per annum from the date of deposit until payment, on the principle of restitution.
- With these directions, the appeals were DISPOSED OF.
Implications: The immediate effect is that the earlier tender process and the High Court’s directions regarding the existing bids and rates are set aside, and the sand quarry lease must now be re-auctioned under the governing Rules, with all interested parties free to compete afresh. The successful bidder is made financially whole for the period during which its deposit remained blocked due to litigation.
The judgment clarifies how the term “previous Financial Year” in Rule 27(4)(iv) should be understood when tenders are issued mid-year and the statutory time to file the latest ITR has not expired, and it reinforces that tender conditions must be interpreted in a way that preserves competition and maximises public revenue in dealings with natural resources, within the established limits of judicial review in tender matters.
Show full summary ...