Loading..
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 54 LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894
  • section 4 of Act, 1894.
  • section 4(1) of Act, 1894
  • Section 6(1) of Act, 1894
  • Section 23 of Act 1894.
  • provisions of Act 1894,
  • Section 18 of Act, 1894
  • Section 4; (c)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • SECTION 54 LAND ACQUISITION ACT 1894
  • section 4 of Act, 1894.
  • section 4(1) of Act, 1894
  • Section 6(1) of Act, 1894
  • Section 23 of Act 1894.
  • provisions of Act 1894,
  • Section 18 of Act, 1894
  • Section 4; (c)

    Bulandshahar Khurja Development Authority, Through Secretary v. Shyam Sunder Kansal And Others

    Neutral Citation No. - 2015:AHC:189249-DB

    1.

    Court No. - 34

    1.Case :- FIRST APPEAL No. - 6 of 1998

    Appellant :- Bulandshahar Khurja Development Authority, Through Secretary

    Respondent :- Shyam Sunder Kansal And Others

    Counsel for Appellant :- Ashwani Kumar Srivastava,A.K.Mishra,B. Dayal

    Counsel for Respondent :-M.C. Singh

    2. Case :- FIRST APPEAL No. - 4 of 1998

    Appellant :- Buland Shahar Khurja Development Authority Through Secy.

    Respondent :- Gurdeo Singh & Others

    Counsel for Appellant :- A.K. Srivastava,A.K.Mishra,B. Dayal

    3. Case :- FIRST APPEAL No. - 5 of 1998

    Appellant :- Bulandshahar Khurja Development Authority, Through Secretary

    Respondent :- Sushil Kumar And Others

    Counsel for Appellant :- Ashwani Kumar Srivastava,A.K.Mishra,B. Dayal

    4. Case :- FIRST APPEAL No. - 7 of 1998

    Appellant :- Bulandshahar Khurja Development Authority, Through Secretary

    Respondent :- Jai Karan Singh

    Counsel for Appellant :- Ashwani Kumar Srivastava,Ajay Kumar Mishra

    Counsel for Respondent :- Atul Srivastava, Sunil Kumar

    Hon'ble Sudhir Agarwal,J. Hon'ble Brijesh Kumar Srivastava-II,J.

    1. Heard learned counsel for the parties and perused the record.

    2. At the instance of Bulandshahr Khurja Development Authority (hereinafter referred to as 'BKDA'), these four appeals under Section 54 of Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred to as "Act 1894") have arisen from award/judgement dated 16.08.1994 and decree dated 30.08.1994 passed by Sri V.K. Jain, District Judge, Bulandshahr in four Land Acquisition References (hereinafter referred to as "LAR") No. 643 of 1992, 644 of 1992, 645 of 1992 and 646 of 1992, whereby Reference Court has awarded compensation at the rate of Rs.305/- per sq. yard besides 30% solatium and interest at different rates for different period

    1

    as per the Act, 1894.

    3. At the behest of BKDA, for the purpose of construction of commercial centre and park in village Sunhera, Pargana Baran, Tehsil and District Bulandshahr, for planned development scheme, proceedings for acquisition of 2.475 acres of land in the said village were initiated by State Government by publishing notification under Section 4(1) of Act, 1894 in Gazette dated 20.01.1990. Notification under Section 6(1) of Act, 1894 was published in Gazette dated 13.03.1990 and possession of acquired land was taken on 09.07.1991 (03 Bigha 06 Biswansi 07 Kanchwansi=1.885 acres). As shown at serial no.3 of award of Special Land Acquisition Officer (hereinafter referred to as 'SLAO'), total land proposed to be acquired by respondent no.1 was 03 Bigha 19 Biswa 04 Biswansi (2.475 acres), whereas area declared for acquisition in the award of which possession was taken, was 03 Bigha 06 Biswansi 07 Kanchwansi=1.885 acres.

    4. The land acquired by State comprised Khasra No. 30, 40, 41, 42, 43 of Village Sunehra which belonged to several persons including claimant respondents in all these appeals. Details of claimant- respondents, area of their land, LAR No., Appeal No., rates of compensation awarded by SLAO and Reference Court are given in the following chart:

    First  Appeal No. LAR  No. Claimant Details of  Khasra/  Gata/Plot No.  and area  Rate of  compensati­  ­on awarded  by SLAO (in  Rs.) Rate of  compen­ ­sation  awarded by  Referen­  ­ce Court (in Rs.)
    4  of  1998 643 of 1992 Gurudeo Singh Khasra No. 43 (168.27 sq.  yard) 1,08,428.57  per Bigha  (35.844 per  sq. yard) 305/­ per sq. yard
    5 of  1998 646 of 1992 Susheel Kumar Khasra No. 40 (151 sq.  yard) ­do­ ­do­

    6 of 645 of Kedar Nath Khasra No. -do- -do-

    1998 1992 Kansal 40 (1 Bigha 19

    2

    substituted by Biswansi 6 his sons Shyam Kachwansi= Sunder Kansal 3171 sq. yard) and 2 others

    7 of 644 of Jai Karan Singh Khasra No. -do- -do- 1998 1992 43 (300 sq.

    yard)

    5. After taking into account oral as well as documentary evidence, adduced before SLAO, vide award dated 23.12.1991, he awarded compensation determining market value of acquired land at the rate of Rs. 1,08,428.57 per Bigha (Rs. 35.844 per sq. yard). Being dissatisfied with the award of SLAO, claimant respondents in the present four appeals made applications for Reference under Section 18 of Act, 1894 to District Judge, Bulandshahar for determination of market value considering factors under Section 23 of Act 1894. It is pursuant thereto, the aforesaid LARs No. 643, 644, 645 and 646 of 1992 have been decided by Reference Court.

    6. In First Appeal No. 5 of 1998 claimant respondent has filed cross objection, claiming compensation at the rate of Rs. 500/- per sq. yard. In First Appeal No. 4 of 1998 also cross objection has been filed by claimant tenure holder claiming comepnsation at the rate of Rs. 450/- per sq. yard.

    7. The Court below formulated following four issues:

    ^^1- D;k fo'ks"k Hkwfe v/;kfIr vf/kdkjh }kjk vius vfHkfu.kZ; esa mfpr izfrdj fnyk;k x;k gS] ;fn ugha lna HkZdrk fdl nj ls izfrdj ikus d s vf/kdkjh gS\""

    "1. Whether appropriate compensation has been awarded by the Special Land Acquisition Officer in his award?, If not, at which rate claimant land holders are entitled to get compensation?"

    "2- D;k lna HkZ fooU/ku vkSj ekSu lgefr d s fo)kUr ls ckf/kr gS\ "

    "2. Whether Reference is barred by principle of estoppel and

    3

    acquiescence?"

    "3- D;k lna HkZ dky ckf/kr gS\ "

    "3. Whether Reference is barred by limitation?"

    "4- vuqrks"k] ;fn dksbZ ftl s lanHkZdrkZ ikus dk vf/kdkjh gS\**

    "4. Relief, if any, to which claimant tenure holders are entitled ?"

    (English translation by Court)

    8. All the four References were consolidated by 9thAdditional District Judge, Bulandshahr vide order dated 27.01.1993, considering the fact that land was acquired by a common notification for the same project and decided by a common award. L.A.R. No. 645 of 1992 Kedar Nath Kansal vs. State, was made leading case.

    9. Before Reference Court, claimant respondents filed 28 documents in support of their claim for awarding compensation at a higher rate of Rs. 650/- per sq. yard. Those documents included the following:

    S. No. Nature of document  Exhibit/ Paper no. Area Consideration/ Rate   per   sq. yard. (in Rupees)
    1. Sale   deed   dated 05/12/88 Ex.1 151 sq. yard 43,500/­   @ 288.08   per sq.yard
    2. Sale deed dated 06/02/89 Ex.2 100 sq. yard 30,000/­   @ 300/­   per sq.yard.
    3. Sale   deed   dated 28/12/88 Ex.3 200   sq. yard. 1,14,286/­ @ 571.43   per sq. yard.
    4. Agreement to sell dated 06/03/90 Ex.5 107.27   sq. yard. 59,000/­   @ 550/­ per sq. yard.
    5. Agreement   to   sell dated 30/03/90 Ex.6
    6. Agreement to sell dated 26/04/90 Ex.7

    7. Copy of Judgment Ex.8 dated 26/02/91 in O.S.

    421/90

    8. Copy of Judgment Ex.9 dated 30/05/90 in L.A.R.No. 41 of 1987

    9. Copy of Judgment Ex.10 dated 21/01/91 in

    L.A.R.No. 258 of 1987

    10. Besides, the Court below also obtained Commissioner's report dated 15.04.1993 along with map, according to which, Village Sunehra and land of Gurdev Singh was 100 yards away from canal bridge. From the land of Gurudev, upto the land of Kedar Nath, several constructions were in existence on both sides of road. Godowns, offices, tube-well and trees of eucalyptus were also there and the land situated adjacent to G.T. Road. Adjacent to acquired land and in front thereof, there existed Pink Hotel, petrol pump, wine shops, Garg Transport Company, Mayur Industries Corporation. Besides some Pucca constructions, in back, there was Chakor Tourist Place along with restaurant.

    11. Claimants' oral evidence comprised of statement of Shyam Sunder Kansal PW-1, Gurudev Singh PW-2, Jai Karan Singh PW 3, Chandra Kant Saxena PW 4, Sushil Kumar PW 5, Ravindra Pal Singh PW 6 and Pravin Yadav Advocate PW 7. Sri Pravin Yadav PW 7 was the Advocate Commissioner who visited acquired land and submitted report.

    12. On behalf of defendant appellant two witnesses were examined i.e. Manoj Kumar, Amin in the office of SLAO as DW-1 and Dhara Singh, Lekhpal in the office of appellant as DW-2.

    13. The Court below has observed that SLAO himself recommended compensation at the rate of Rs.9,20,000/- per Pucca Bigha vide letter (Paper no. 88 of original file). With regard to potentiality of land, it was mentioned by SLAO that all the land is Abadi having Rasta etc. and there is no big plot which is more suitable for the scheme. There is no family on this land belonging to Scheduled Caste and Scheduled Tribe. There is no residential building over the proposed land, which may affect any family. The land is situated on G.T. Road in front of Chakor Cafeteria. The land is suitable for residential purpose. There is no high voltage line

    5

    over the land in question and it is more suitable for development of commercial structures and park. In view thereof, the Court has observed that defendant appellant itself admitted that acquired land is situated at a place where commercial development was fast and a large number of hotels, shops, wine shops, transport companies etc., were already existing. Exhibit-1 (paper no.14C-2) is sale deed executed by Shyam Sunder Kansal in favour of Smt. Sushil Kumar, transferring by sale 151 sq. yard of land of plot no.40, for a consideration of Rs. 43,500/- on 05.12.1988. Similarly, Exhibit-2 (paper no.16C-2) is sale deed dated 06.02.1989 executed by Krishna Singh in favour of Asha Singh, transferring 100 sq. yard for Rs. 30,000/-. Exhibit-3 (paper no. 17C-2) is sale deed whereby 200 sq. yard of land was transferred by sale for a consideration of Rs. 1,14,286/- on 29.12.1989. The Court below found that SLAO relied on sale deed of 17.08.1987 of Gata No.40, executed by one Kedar Nath Kansal in favour of Chhaju, in order to determine rate of compensation at Rs. 1,08,428.57 per pucca Bigha, while acquisition has commenced after about three years, hence the said exemplar was not valid, when many exemplars of corresponding period were available, showing that land in plot is worth much higher in view of subsequent fast development in the area in question. In these circumstances, Reference Court determined market value at Rs. 305/- per sq. yard.

    14. The only question up for consideration in these appeals is,

    "whether market value determined by Court below for the purpose of compensation is excessive, unreasonable and unjust, so as to be reduced by upholding market value determined by SLAO".

    15. Counsel for appellant contended that on behalf of appellant one Manoj Kumar, Amin in the office of SLAO, adduced oral evidence as DW1, stating that land of claimant respondents was acquired for BKDA for the purpose of construction of park and commercial centre. SLAO selected sale deed at serial no.5, for the purpose of assessing compensation, which was dated 17.08.1987, executed by Chhaju and Smt. Kamla in respect of 210 sq. meter out of plot no.40, transferred for consideration of Rs. 9,000/- i.e. at the rate of Rs. 1,08,428.57 of one

    6

    pucca Bigha. It is said that there was no reason for Court below to discard the said evidence and enhance market value, multifold.

    16. Per contra, learned Counsel appearing for claimant respondents contended that the land has high potential, situated in a well developed area where larger plots were not available and acquired land belonging to claimants is also in smaller pieces of land, yet exemplars providing higher rates have not been followed and therefore, rate determined by Court below needs be enhanced and there is no question of reduction thereof.

    17. Before examining the question, "whether market value determined by Court below is just, valid and shows true market value on the date of notification under Section 4(1) of Act, 1894 i.e. 20.01.1990", it would be appropriate to consider legal principles laid down in last several decades on the question, how market value of land, acquired forcibly under the provisions of Act 1894, should be determined. These principles have been settled in a catena of decisions of Apex Court as well as this Court, and some of such decisions may be referred hereinbelow.

    18. In Chimanlal Hargovinddas vs. Special Land Acquisition Officer, (1988) 3 S.C.C 751, the Court has said that a reference is like a suit which is to be treated as an original proceeding. The claimants is in the position of a plaintiff who has to show that the price offered for his land in the Award is inadequate. However, for the said purpose the Court would not consider the material, relied upon by Land Acquisition Officer in Award, unless the same material is produced and proved before the Court. The Reference Court does not sit in appeal over the Award of Land Acquisition Officer. The material used by Land Acquisition Officer is not open to be used by the Court suo motu unless such material is produced by the parties and proved independently before the Reference Court. Determination of market value has to be made as per market rate prevailing on the date of publication of notification under section 4 of Act, 1894. The basic principle which has to be followed by Reference Court for determining market value of land, as if, the valuer i.e. the

    7

    Court is a hypothetical purchaser, willing to purchase land from the open market and is prepared to pay a reasonable price, as on the crucial day, i.e., date of publication of notification under section 4 of the Act, 1894. The willingness of vendor to sale land on reasonable price shall be presumed. The Court, therefore, would co-relate market value reflated in the most comparable instance which provides the index of market value. Only genuine instances would be taken into account. Sometimes even post-notification instances may be taken into account if they are very proximate, genuine and acquisition itself has not motivated the purchaser to pay a higher price on account of the resultant improvement in development prospects. Proximity from time angle and from situation angle would be relevant considerations to find out most comparable instances out of the genuine instances. From identified instances which would provide index of market value, price reflected therein may be taken as norm and thereafter to arrive at the true market value of land under acquisition, suitable adjustment by plus and minus factors has to be made. In other words a balance sheet of plus and minus factors may be drawn and the relevant factors may be valuated in terms of price variation as a prudent purchaser would do. The market value of land under acquisition has to be deduced by loading the price reflected in the instances taken for plus factors and unloading for minus factors.

    19. The size of the land, therefore, would constitute an important factor to determine market value. It cannot be doubted that small size plot may attract a large number of persons being within their reach which will not be possible in respect of large block of land wherein incumbent will have to incur extra liability in preparing a lay out and carving out roads, leaving open space, plotting out smaller plots, waiting for purchasers etc. The Court said that in such matters, the factors can be discounted by making deduction by way of an allowance at an appropriate rate ranging between 20% to 50%, to account for land, required to be set apart for carving out road etc. and for plotting out small plots.

    20. The concept of smaller and larger plots should be looked into not

    8

    only from the angle as to what area has been acquired, but also the number of land holders and size of their plots. When we talk of concept of prudent seller and prudent buyer, we cannot ignore the fact that in the category of prudent seller the individual land holder will come. It is the area of his holding which will be relevant for him and not that of actual total and collective large area which is sought to be acquired.

    21. In V.M. Salgoacar & brother Ltd. vs. Union of India (1995) 2 S.C.C 302 the land acquired by notification dated 06.07.1970 in village Chicalim near Goa Airport belonged to a single owner. The Court observed when land is sold out in smaller plots, there may be a rising trend in the market, of fetching higher price in comparison to the plot which are much higher in size. Having said so the Court further said "

    though the small plots ipso facto may not form the basis per se to determine the compensation, they would provide foundation for determining the market value. On its basis, giving proper deduction, the market value ought to be determined".

    22. Again in Shakuntalabai (Smt.) and others vs. State of Maharashtra, 1996 (2) S.C.C 152, 20 acres of land in Akola town was sought to be acquired by notification published on 11.08.1965 under section 4(1) of Act, 1894 which was also owned by a single person. It is in this context the Court said "the Reference Court committed manifest error in determining compensation on the basis of sq. ft. When land of an extent of 20 acres is offered for sale in an open market, no willing and prudent purchaser would come forward to purchase that vast extent of land on sq. ft. basis. Therefore, the Reference Court has to consider valuation sitting on the armchair of a willing prudent hypothetical vendee and to put a question to itself whether in given circumstances, he would agree to purchase the land on sq. ft. basis. No feat of imagination is necessary to reach the conclusion. The answer is obviously "no".

    23. We may also notice at this stage that deduction for development is different than deduction permissible in respect of largeness of area vis-a- vis exemplar of small piece of land. Many times, land owners relied on

    9

    the rates on which development authorities used to offer allotment of developed plots cropped out by them in residential or industrial area. Such rates apparently cannot form basis for compensation for acquisition of undeveloped lands for reasons more than one. The market value in respect of large tract of undeveloped agricultural land in a rural area has to be determined in the context of a land similarly situated whereas allotment rates of development authorities are with reference to small plots and in a developed lay out falling within urban or semi-urban area. The statutory authorities including development authorities used to offer rates with reference to economic capacity of the buyer like economic weaker sections, low income group, middle income group, higher income group etc. Therefore, rates determined by such authorities are not uniform. The market value of acquired land cannot depend upon economic status of land loser and conversely on the economic status of the body at whose instance the land is acquired. Further, normally, land acquired is a freehold land whereas allotment rates determined by development authorities etc. constitute initial premium payable on allotment of plots on leasehold basis.

    24. However, where an exemplar of small piece of land is relied, in absence of any other relevant material, Court may determine market value in the light of evidence relating to sale price of small developed plots. In such cases, deduction varying from 20% to 75% is liable to apply depending upon nature of development of lay out in which exemplar plot is situated.

    25. In Lal Chand Vs. Union of India and another, (2009) 15 SCC 769, Court noticed that this deduction for development constitutes two components- one is with reference to area required to be utilized for development work and second is the cost of development work. It further held that deduction for development in respect of residential plot may be higher while not so where it is an industrial plot. Similarly, if acquired land is in a semi-developed urban area or in any undeveloped rural area, then deduction for development may be much less and vary from 25 to

    10

    40 percent since some basic infrastructure will already be available. The percentage is only indicative and vary depending upon relevant factors. With reference to exemplars of transfer of land between private parties, Court would also look into the intrinsic evidence, i.e., the exemplar sale deed where the sale deed recites financial difficulties of vendor and urgent need to find money as a reason for sale or other similar factors, like litigation or existence of some other dispute. These are all the factors constituting intrinsic evidence of a distress sale.

    26. In Lal Chand Vs. Union of India (supra), the Court also observed, if acquisition is in regard to a large area of agricultural land in a village and exemplar sale deed is also in respect of an agricultural land in the same village, it may be possible to rely upon the sale deed as prima facie evidence of prevailing market value even if such land is at the other end of village, at a distance of one or two kilometers. But, the same may not be the position where acquisition relates to plots in a town or city where every locality or road has a different value. A distance of about a kilometer may not make a difference for the purpose of market value in a rural area but even a distance of 50 meters may make a huge difference in market value in urban properties. Thus, distance between two properties, the nature and situation of property, proximity to the village or a road and several other factors may all be relevant in determining market value.

    27. Normally, the Courts have held that exemplars should be such which are before the date of notification under Section 4(1) of Act, 1894 but an exemplar sale deed of a subsequent period of date of acquisition notification is not completely ruled out to be relevant document provided circumstances to justify the same are available.

    28. In State of U.P. Vs. Major Jitendra Kumar and others, AIR 1982 SC 876, notification under Section 4 was published on 6.1.1948. The Court determined rate of compensation relying on sale deed dated 11.7.1959, i.e., a document executed after almost three and half years after the date of acquisition notification. Supreme Court upheld reliance

    11

    of such document observing that if there is no material to show that there was any fluctuation in market rate between the date of acquisition and the date of concerned sale deed, such document may be considered as a relevant material in absence of any other apt evidence. This view was followed in a subsequent decision, i.e., Administrator General of West Bengal Vs. Collector, Varanasi, AIR 1998 SC 943, where the Court said as under:-

    "Such subsequent transactions which are not proximate in point of time to the acquisition can be taken into account for purposes of determining whether as on the date of acquisition there was an upward trend in the prices of land in the area. Further under certain circumstances where it is shown that the market was stable and there were no fluctuations in the prices between the date of the preliminary notification and the date of such subsequent transaction, the transaction could also be relied upon to ascertain the market value."

    29. We need not go into a catena of other decisions rendered in the last several decades since we have benefit of a recent Division Bench decision of this Court in First Appeal No. 454/2003 and other connected matters, Meerut Development Authority through Its Secretary vs. Basheshwar Dayal (since deceased) Through His L.Rs and another

    decided on 01.08.2013 wherein the legal principles settled by Apex Court in various judgments, relevant for determination of market value have been crystallized as under:

    (i) Function of the Court in awarding compensation under the Act is to ascertain the market value of the land on the date of the notification under Section 4(1),

    (ii) The method for determination of market value may be :

    (a) Opinion of experts,

    (b) the price paid within a reasonable time in bona fide

    12

    transactions of purchase of the lands acquired or the lands adjacent to the lands acquired and possessing similar advantages,

    (c) a number of years purchase of the actual or immediately prospective profits of the land acquired. (Ref. (1994) 4 SCC 595 para 5 Jawajee Nagnatham Vs. Revenue Divisional Officer & others)

    (iii) While fixing the market value of the acquired land, comparable sales method of valuation is preferred than other methods of valuation of land such as capitalisation of net income method or expert opinion method. Comparable sales method of valuation is preferred because it furnishes the evidence for determination of the market value of the acquired land at which a willing purchaser would pay for the acquired land if it had been sold in the open market at the time of issue of notification under Section 4 of the Act. However, comparable sales method of valuation of land for fixing the market value of the acquired land is not always conclusive but subject to the following factors:-

    (a) Sale must be a genuine transaction,

    (b) the sale deed must have been executed at the time proximate to the date of issue of notification under Section 4 of the Act,

    (c) the land covered by the sale must be in the vicinity of the acquired land,

    (d) the land covered by the sales must be similar to the acquired land

    (e) the size of plot of the land covered by the sales be comparable to the land acquired.

    13

    (f) if there is dissimilarity in regard to locality, shape, site or nature of land between land covered by sales and land acquired, it is open to the Court to proportionately reduce the compensation for acquired land.

    (iv) The amount of compensation cannot be ascertained with mathematical accuracy. A comparable instance has to be identified having regard to the proximity from time angle as well as proximity from situation angle. For determining the market value of the land under acquisition, suitable adjustment has to be made having regard to various positive and negative factors vis-a-vis the land under acquisition which are as under :

    -

    Positive factors Negative factors
    (i) Smallness of size (i) Largeness of area
    (ii) Proximity to a road. (ii) Situation in the interior at a distance from the road.
    (iii) Frontage on a road. (iii) Narrow strip of land with very small frontage compared to depth.
    (iv)   Nearness   to   developed area. (iv) Lower level requiring the depressed portion to be filled up.
    (v) Regular shape. (v)  Lower   level   requiring   the depressed portion to be filled up.
    (vi) Level vis­a­vis land under acquisition.   (vi)   Some   special disadvantageous   factor   which would deter a purchaser. 

    (vii) Special value for an owner of an adjoining property to whom it may have some very special advantage.

    (v) For ascertaining the market value of the land, the

    14

    potentiality of the acquired land should also be taken into consideration. Potentiality means capacity or possibility for changing or developing into state of actuality.

    (vi) Deduction not to be done when land holders have been deprived of their holding 15 to 20 years back and have not been paid any amount.

    (vii) In fixing market value of the acquired land, which is undeveloped or under-developed, the Courts have generally approved deduction of 1/3rd of the market value towards development cost except when no development is required to be made for implementation of the public purpose for which land is acquired. ( Ref. (2011) 8 SCC page 9, Valliyammal and another Vs. Special Tahsildar Land Acquisition and another , paras 13, 14, 15, 16, 17, 18 and 19).

    (viii) When there are several exemplars with Reference to similar lands, it is the general rule that the highest of the exemplars, if it is satisfied, that it is a bona fide transaction has to be considered and accepted. When the land is being compulsorily taken away from a person, he is entitled to the highest value which similar land in the locality shown to have fetched in a bona fide transaction entered into between a willing purchaser and a willing seller near about the time of the acquisition.(Ref. (2012) 5 SCC 432, Mehrawal Khewaji Trust (Registered), Faridkot and others Vs. State of Punjab and others).

    (ix) In view of Section 51A of the Act certified copy of sale deed is admissible in evidence, even the vendor or vendee thereof is not required to examine themselves for proving the contents thereof. This, however, would not mean that contents of the transaction as evidenced by the registered sale deed would automatically be accepted. The legislature advisedly has

    15

    used the word 'may'. A discretion, therefore, has been conferred upon a Court to be exercised judicially, i.e., upon taking into consideration the relevant factors. Only because a document is admissible in evidence, the same by itself would not mean that the contents thereof stand proved. Having regard to the other materials brought on record, the Court may not accept the evidence contained in a deed of sale. (Ref. (2004) 8 SCC 270 para 28 and 38, Cement Corpn. Of India Ltd. Vs. Purya and others).

    (x) While fixing the market value of the acquired land, the Land Acquisition Collector is required to keep in mind the following factors : -

    (a) Existing geographical situation of the land.

    (b) Existing use of the land.

    (c) Already available advantages, like proximity to National or State Highway or road and/ or developed area,

    (d) Market value of other land situated in the same locality/ village/ area or adjacent or very near the acquired land.

    (xi) Section 23(1) of the Act lays down what the Court has to take into consideration while Section 24 lays down what the Court shall not take into consideration and have to be neglected. The main object of the enquiry before the Court is to determine the market value of the land acquired. The market value is the price that a willing purchaser would pay to a willing seller for the property having due regard to its existing condition with all its existing advantages and its potential possibilities when led out in most advantageous manner excluding any advantage due to carrying out of the scheme for which the property is compulsorily acquired. The

    16

    determination of market value is the prediction of an economic event viz. a price outcome of hypothetical sale expressed in terms of probabilities. For ascertaining the market value of the land, the potentiality of the acquired land should also be taken into consideration. Potentiality means capacity or possibility for changing or developing into state of actuality.

    (xii) The question whether a land has potential value or not, is primarily one of fact depending upon its condition, situation, user to which it is put or is reasonably capable of being put and proximity to residential, commercial or industrial areas or institutions. The existing amenities like water, electricity, possibility of their further extension, whether near about town is developing.

    (xiii) In fixing market value of the acquired land, which is undeveloped or under-developed, the Courts have generally approved deduction of 1/3rd of the market value towards development cost except when no development is required to be made for implementation of the public purpose for which land is acquired. Deduction of "development cost" is the concept used to derive the "wholesale price" of a large undeveloped land with Reference to the "retail price" of a small developed plot. The difference between the value of a small developed plot and the value of a large undeveloped land is the "development cost". (Ref. (2012) 7 SCC 595 paras 16, 17, 18, 21 and 22, Sabhia Mohammed Yusuf Abdul Hamid Mulla (dead) and others).

    30. In Valliyammal and another v. Special Tahsildar (Land Acquisition) and another, (2011) 8 SCC 91 the Court has looked into various earlier judgments laying down guiding principles for determination of market value of acquired land. The Court has observed that comparable sales method of valuation is preferred since it furnishes the evidence for determination of market value of acquired land at which

    17

    a willing purchaser would pay for acquired land if it had been sold in open market at the time of acquisition. However, this method is not always conclusive and there are certain factors, which are required to be fulfilled and on fulfillment of those factors, compensation can be determined. Such factors are (a) sale must be a genuine transaction; (b) sale deed must have been executed at the time proximate to the date of issue of notification under Section 4; (c) land covered by the sale must be in the vicinity of acquired land; (d) land covered by the sales must be similar to acquired land; and (e) size of plot of the land covered by the sales be comparable to the land acquired. If there is dissimilarity in regard to locality, shape and size or nature of land, court can proportionately reduce compensation depending upon disadvantages attached with the acquired land. Further, for determining market value, potentiality of acquired land should also be taken into consideration. The potentiality means, capacity or possibility for changing or developing into state of actuality. It is well settled that market value of property has to be determined having due regard to its existing condition, with all its existing advantages and its potential possibility when led out in its most advantageous manner. The Court stated that when undeveloped or underdeveloped land is acquired the exemplar is in respect to developed land, detection towards deduction can be made. Normally, such deduction is 1/3, but it is not a hard and fast rule.

    31. In Bhule Ram v. Union of India and another, JT 2014 (5) SC 110 the Court in para 7 has observed that valuation of immovable property is not an exact science, nor it can be determined like algebraic problem, as it bounds in uncertainties and no strait-jacket formula can be laid down for arriving at exact market value of the land. There is always a room for conjecture, and thus the court must act reluctantly to venture too far in this direction. The factors such as the nature and position of the land to be acquired, adaptability and advantages, the purpose for which the land can be used in the most lucrative way, injurious affect resulting in damages to other properties, its potential value, the locality, situation and size and shape of the land, the rise of depression in the

    18

    value of the land in the locality consequent to the acquisition etc., are relevant factors to be considered. It further said that value, which has to be assessed, is the value to the owner, who parts with his property, and not the value to the new owner, who takes it over. Fair and reasonable compensation means the price of a willing buyer, which is to be paid to the willing seller. Though the Act does not provide for "just terms" or

    "just compensation", but the market value is to be assessed taking into consideration the use to which it is being put on acquisition and whether the land has unusual or unique features or potentialities.. The Court then also considered as to what is the concept of guess work and observed that it is not unknown to various fields of law as it applies in the cases relating to insurance, taxation, compensation under the Motor Vehicle Act as well as under the Labour Laws. Having said so, the Court further said: -

    "The court has a discretion applying the guess work to the facts of the given case but is is not unfettered and has to be reasonable having connection to the facts on record adduced by the parties by way of evidence. The court further held as under: -

    "'Guess' as understood in its common parlance is an estimate without any specific information while "calculations" are always made with reference to specific data. "Guesstimate" is an estimate based on a mixture of guesswork and calculations and it is a process in itself. At the same time "guess" cannot be treated synonymous to "conjecture". "Guess" by itself may be a statement or result based on unknown factors while

    "conjecture" is made with a very slight amount of knowledge, which is just sufficient to incline the scale of probability.

    "Guesstimate" is with higher certainty than more "guess" or a

    "conjecture" per se." (para 8)

    32. In Bhupal Singh and others v. State of Haryana, (2015) 5 SCC 801 while the above principles laid down in various cases were reiterated, the Court in para 18 of the judgment said: -

    19

    "Law on the question as to how the court is required to determined the fair market value of the acquired land is fairly well settled by several decisions of this Court and remains no more res integra. This Court has, inter alia, held that when the acquired land is a large chunk of undeveloped land having potential and was acquired for residential purpose then while determining the fair market value of the lands on the date of acquisition, the appropriate deductions are also required to be made."

    33. It is also reaffirmed that where an exemplar relates to small piece of developed land and is sought to be relied to determine market value on large tract of undeveloped acquired land, deduction can be applied ranging between 20% to 75%. The Court in para 20 of the judgment relied upon its decision in Chandrashekar v. Land Acquisition Officer, (2012) 1 SCC 390 stating that the deduction has two components, one is development and another with respect to the size of the area. The earlier percentage of deduction was restricted in Subh Ram v. State of Haryana, (2010) 1 SCC 444 stating that deduction of both components should be around 1/3 each in its entirety, which would roughly come to 67% of component of sale consideration of exemplar sale transaction. Thus, with respect to escalation of price where exemplar is much earlier in point of time, the Court in K. Devakimma and others v. Tirumala Tirupati Devasthanam and another, 2015 (111) ALR 241 said that recourse can be taken in appropriate cases to the mode of determining market value by providing appropriate escalation over the proved market value of nearby land in previous years where there is no evidence of any contemporaneous sale transaction or acquisition of comparable lands in neighbourhood. The percentage of escalation may vary from case to case so also the extent of years to determine the rates.

    34. In the light of above general guidelines and also considering the fact that claimants have to be considered as plaintiffs before Reference Court, therefore, onus initially lay upon them to prove what is the appropriate market rate, we proceed to consider first whether in the present case such onus has been discharged by plaintiffs or not.

    20

    35. Considering the entire matter in the light of exposition of law discussed above, we find that notification for acquisition under Section 4, was published on 20.01.1990. SLAO relied on sale deed of 1987, to determine market value for the purpose of awarding compensation, whereas acquisition proceedings commenced after 2½ years. Apparently, sale deed of 1987 cannot be said to be a valid exemplar when recent exemplars were available of the period corresponding to period of acquisition.

    36. Notification under Section 4(1) of Act 1894 is dated 20 thJanuary 1990. Sale deed of 5.12.1988 (Exhibit-1) of just about 13 months back, was available, which shows the rate of land transferred therein as Rs.

    288.08 per sq, yard. Another sale deed dated 28.12.1988 (Exhibit-3) was available wherein rate of transferred land was Rs. 571.43 per square yard. Third sale deed dated 6.2.1989 which is of within one year from the date of notification was available, wherein rate of land transferred was shown Rs. 300/- per sq. yard. The Courts have held, where exemplar is an year or more older, an appreciation of 5 to 7% in rural area and 10 to 15% in urban or semi-urban area could have been applied. These sale deeds relate to smaller pieces of land i.e. 151 sq. yard, 100 sq. yard, 200 sq. yard. Area of claimants' land is also quite smaller i.e. 168.27 Sq. Yard, 151 Sq. yard and 300 sq. yard, except of one claimant, whose land is 1 Bigha 19 Biswansi 6 Kachwansi. Therefore, there was no justification for applying even deduction on account of largeness of area as well. The Court below instead of following exemplar of highest rate and then applying appreciation thereon, has endevoured to adjust interest of the parties and has determined market rate at the rate of Rs. 305/ per sq. yard.

    37. So far as agreements to sell relied upon by the claimant respondents are concerned, we find that the same ought not have been followed being subsequent to lthe date of acquisition notification and, therefore, it was not safe to rely thereon when other valid exemplars were already available.

    21

    38. In our view, looking to the interest of both the parties, other relevant factors and also that area was already well developed, large piece of land was not available and simultaneously the factum that rate of sale deeds varied substantially, we find no justification to interfere with the determination of market value by the Court below. In our view the rate determined by Court below, is quite reasonable, just and valid. It has looked into various relevant aspects of the matter and therefore, none of the parties deserves any relief. We are satisfied that the impugned award of the Reference Court deserves to be affirmed.

    39. The question formulated above, therefore, is answered in favour of claimant respondents and it is held that rate determined by the Court below is just, valid and reasonable.

    40. The appeals and cross appeals are hereby dismissed without there being any order as to costs.

    Order Date :- 01.07.2015

    pp/Akn

    22

    Court No.34. Case :- FIRST APPEAL No. - 6 of 1998

    Appellant :- Bulandshahar Khurja Development Authority, Through Secretary

    Respondent :- Shyam Sunder Kansal And Others

    Counsel for Appellant :- Ashwani Kumar Srivastava,A.K.Mishra,B. Dayal

    Counsel for Respondent :-M.C. Singh

    Hon'ble Sudhir Agarwal,J. Hon'ble Brijesh Kumar Srivastava-II,J.

    Dismissed. For details see our judgment of date passed on separate sheets of paper.

    Order Date :- 01.07.2015

    pp/Akn

    23

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bulandshahar Khurja Development Authority, Through Secretary v. Shyam Sunder Kansal And Others
    (Jul 1, 2015)