Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • The Land Acquisition Act, 1894
  • The Act (no specific title mentioned)
  • Section 4 of the Act on 1977
  • The Act under which the appellants are entitled to compensation and other statutory benefits
  • Section 9 of the Act
  • Section 18 of the Act
  • Section 54 of the Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 23 of the Act
  • Section 6 of the Act
  • Section [not specified], The Act
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • The Land Acquisition Act, 1894
  • The Act (no specific title mentioned)
  • Section 4 of the Act on 1977
  • The Act under which the appellants are entitled to compensation and other statutory benefits
  • Section 9 of the Act
  • Section 18 of the Act
  • Section 54 of the Act
  • Section 5, Subsection 2 of the 1983 Income Tax Act
  • Section 23 of the Act
  • Section 6 of the Act
  • Section [not specified], The Act
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The State of Haryana issued a notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 on 4 November 1977 to acquire large tracts of undeveloped agricultural land in Villages Atmadpur and Mawai, Tehsil Ballabgarh, District Faridabad, for residential development. The Land Acquisition Officer (LAO) awarded compensation at Rs 16.52 per square yard in 1982-84. Upon references under Section 18, the Reference Court enhanced the rate to Rs 22 per square yard.

The landowners appealed under Section 54. A Division Bench of the Punjab & Haryana High Court, by various orders ending on 19 October 2005, partly allowed the appeals and fixed compensation at Rs 50 per square yard with statutory additions. Dissatisfied, the landowners pursued civil appeals to the Supreme Court seeking further enhancement.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the High Court was justified in valuing the acquired land at Rs 50 per square yard or whether a higher rate should be adopted.
  2. What principles should govern the determination of fair market value for large chunks of undeveloped agricultural land acquired for residential purposes.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellants’ Arguments

  • The High Court erred in reducing the figure it itself found (Rs 63 per sq yd) to Rs 50 without any rationale.
  • Comparable acquisitions between 1980 and 1990 attracted court-approved rates of Rs 300–325 per sq yd; applying a 10% yearly backward deduction would justify Rs 100–200 per sq yd in 1977.
  • In any event, the appellants were entitled to at least Rs 63 per sq yd on the High Court’s own findings.

Respondent State’s Arguments

  • The High Court rightly awarded Rs 50 per sq yd; no further enhancement is warranted.
  • Market value under Section 23 must be based on sales or acquisitions contemporaneous with, or prior to, the Section 4 notification; rates fixed for lands acquired years later are irrelevant.
  • The appellants never sought Rs 200 per sq yd before the High Court and produced no sale deeds; at best they could claim Rs 63 per sq yd.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Brig. Sahib Singh Kalha v. Amritsar Improvement Trust, (1982) 1 SCC 419 Up to 53% deductions (20% for amenities + 20-33% for development costs) when valuing large undeveloped tracts via small developed plots. Formed part of the deduction framework adopted while assessing a reasonable rate.
Chimanlal Hargovinddas v. LAO, (1988) 3 SCC 751 Deductions of 20-50% to account for layout, roads, blocked capital, and entrepreneurial hazards on large undeveloped land. Cited to justify making appropriate deductions from exemplar values.
Kasturi v. State of Haryana, (2003) 1 SCC 354 Normal deduction of one-third for agricultural/undeveloped land having potential value. Referred for guidance on standard deductions.
Lal Chand v. Union of India, (2009) 15 SCC 769 Deductions may range from 20% to 75% when large tracts are valued through sales of small developed plots. Supported the permissible bandwidth of deductions.
A.P. Housing Board v. K. Manohar Reddy, (2010) 12 SCC 707 Confirmed deduction range of 20-75%; applied one-third deduction in that case. Cited while calibrating deductions applicable here.
Land Acquisition Officer v. M.K. Rafiq Saheb, (2011) 7 SCC 714 Where exemplar is a small developed plot, deduction may be increased to 60% for large undeveloped land. Referenced to emphasise flexibility in deduction percentages.
Chandrashekar v. LAO, (2012) 1 SCC 390 Summarised earlier jurisprudence; deductions up to 53% (or higher up to ~67%) recognised. The Court quoted the decision extensively to restate governing methodology.
Subh Ram case, (2010) 1 SCC 444 Limited deductions for two development components to 33⅓% each (≈67% total). Used as part of the survey of deduction ceilings.
Other cases cited by counsel (e.g., Haji Mohammad Ekramul Haq; State of Kerala v. Hassan Koya; Bhag Singh; Municipal Committee Bhatinda; Union of India v. Mangatu Ram; V. Hanumantha Reddy; ONGC Ltd.; Maharunnisa; Chandrashekhar (2009); Valliyammal; Salaha Begaum; Digamber) Cited generally to support enhancement of compensation and assessment of potentiality. The judgment lists these authorities but does not discuss them in detail while reaching its conclusion.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

After examining the record and hearing counsel, the Supreme Court accepted the appellants’ alternative submission that compensation should be fixed at Rs 63 per square yard.

  1. The Court reviewed settled law on valuation of large undeveloped tracts, highlighting the need for deductions when extrapolating from small developed plots.
  2. It synthesised principles from leading precedents (Brig. Sahib Singh Kalha, Chimanlal, Kasturi, Lal Chand, A.P. Housing Board, M.K. Rafiq Saheb, Chandrashekar) to reaffirm permissible deduction ranges (20-75%) and the importance of land potentiality, location, and development costs.
  3. Evidence in the present case consisted mainly of oral testimony about potentiality; no contemporaneous sale deeds were produced. The LAO, Reference Court, and High Court had successively fixed Rs 16.52, Rs 22, and Rs 50 per sq yd.
  4. The High Court, however, had itself found Rs 63 per sq yd to be the proper rate before inexplicably reducing it to Rs 50. The Supreme Court deemed that reduction unjustified.
  5. The Court rejected the appellants’ primary argument seeking Rs 100–200 per sq yd derived from later acquisitions, holding that rates from 10 years after the Section 4 notification cannot be used to roll back values at a flat 10% per annum.
  6. Applying the identified precedential principles, the Court concluded that Rs 63 per sq yd represented a fair market value on 4 November 1977, balancing potentiality, lack of sale deeds, and necessary deductions.

Holding and Implications

Appeals Allowed in Part. The Court enhanced the compensation from Rs 50 to Rs 63 per square yard. The LAO must recalculate compensation, including solatium and interest, at the revised rate and pay verified amounts to the landowners within three months. No order as to costs.

Implications: The judgment affords the appellants a higher monetary award but sets no new legal precedent; it mainly re-applies and reinforces existing principles on deductions and valuation methodology in land acquisition cases.

To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    Bhupal Singh And Others v. State Of Haryana .

    Abhay Manohar Sapre, J.— Civil Appeal No. 7377 of 2008 is filed against the judgment and order dated 19-10-2005 passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana at Chandigarh in Bhupal Singh v. State of Haryana 2005 SCC OnLine P&H 947 , (2006) 143 PLR 234 which arises out of the order dated 21-11-1988 passed by the Additional District Judge, Faridabad in Land Acquisition Case No. 15 of 1988.

    2. Civil Appeals Nos. 8635-38 of 2014 are filed against the final judgment and orders dated 7-5-2010 along with modified orders dated 23-7-2010 and 27-5-2010 passed by the High Court of Punjab and Haryana in Sat Pal v. State of Haryana RFA No. 2214 of 2010, decided on 7-5-2010 (P&H) and Kirpa Devi v. State of Haryana RFA No. 2253 of 2010, decided on 27-5-2010 (P&H) respectively, whereby the High Court disposed of both the RFAs in terms of the order dated 19-10-2005 passed in Bhupal Singh v. State of Haryana 2005 SCC OnLine P&H 947 , (2006) 143 PLR 234.

    3. Civil Appeals Nos. 6184-85 of 2010 are filed against the judgment and order dated 20-10-2009 passed in Jas Ram v. State of Haryana RFA No. 3165 of 1993, decided on 20-10-2009 (P&H) and Cross-objection Petition No. 85-CL of 2009.

    4. By the impugned judgment/orders, the Division Bench of the High Court partly allowed the first appeals filed by the appellants herein (claimants/landowners) and enhanced the quantum of compensation payable to the claimants @ Rs 50 per square yard for their lands, which were acquired by the State under the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 (hereinafter referred to as “the Act”). Dissatisfied with the judgment/orders passed by the High Court, the claimants/landowners have filed these appeals for enhancement of the compensation.

    5. The question that arises for consideration in these appeals is whether the High Court was justified in partly allowing the appeals filed by the claimants/landowners by awarding compensation @ Rs 50 per square yard for their lands which were acquired by the State or the rate should have been more than Rs 50 per square yard?

    6. In order to appreciate the controversy involved in these appeals, it is necessary to state the relevant facts infra.

    7. The appellants are the owners of the land described hereinbelow in relation to the appellants in the appeals:

    7.1 The appellants in CA No. 7377 of 2008 and CAs Nos. 6184-85 of 2010 are the owners of the land acquired in Village Atmadpur, Hadbast No. 127, Tehsil Ballabgarh, District Faridabad; and

    7.2 The appellants in CAs Nos. 8635-38 of 2014 are the owners of the land acquired in Village Mawai, Hadbast Nos. 126 and 4, Tehsil Ballabgarh, District Faridabad.

    8. In exercise of the powers conferred under Section 4 of the Act, the State Government issued a Notification on 4-11-1977 and acquired a large chunk of land measuring 689 kanals and 17 marlas in Village Atmadpur, Hadbast No. 127, Tehsil Ballabgarh, District Faridabad, Haryana (as mentioned in Award No. 13 of 1982-1983, filed as Annexure P-1 in CA No. 7377 of 2008), 66 kanals 15 marlas and 149 kanals and 18 marlas in Village Mawai, Hadbast Nos. 126 and 4, Tehsil Ballabgarh, District Faridabad (as mentioned in Award No. 12 of 1982-1983 and Award No. 1 of 1984-1985, filed as Annexures P-1 and P-3 respectively, in CAs Nos. 8635-38 of 2014) and 445 kanals 12 marlas in Village Atmadpur, Hadbast No. 127, Tehsil Ballabgarh, District Faridabad, Haryana (as mentioned in award dated 6-4-1989 passed by the Reference Court of Land Acquisition Collector, filed as Annexure P-1 in CAs Nos. 6184-85 of 2010) for development of residential colonies for the public at large. It was followed by the declaration published on 1-11-1980 under Section 6 of the Act. The aforementioned land belonging to the appellants was also acquired pursuant to these notifications.

    9. This led to initiation of the proceedings for determination of compensation payable to each of the landowners including that of the appellants herein by the Land Acquisition Officer (in short “the LAO”). Under Section 9 of the Act, notices were issued to the appellants calling upon them to participate in the land acquisition proceedings to enable the LAO to determine the fair market value of the lands on the date of acquisition as provided under Section 23 of the Act so that the compensation would be paid to the landowners at such determined rate. Accordingly, the LAO held an enquiry and after affording an opportunity to the appellants passed the awards dated 18-11-1982 and 2-5-1984 fixing the compensation @ Rs 16.52 per square yard being the fair market value of the acquired land payable to the appellants.

    10. Feeling aggrieved by the said awards, the appellants sought reference to the civil court under Section 18 of the Act for re-determination of the compensation made by the LAO. The Reference Court, on the basis of the evidence adduced, partly answered the reference in favour of the appellants and accordingly enhanced the rate of compensation from Rs 16.52 per square yard to Rs 22 per square yard. In other words, the Reference Court held that the appellants were entitled to get compensation for their lands @ Rs 22 per square yard being the fair market value of their lands on the date of notification issued under Section 4 of the Act.

    11. Dissatisfied with the determination made by the Reference Court, the appellants filed appeals under Section 54 of the Act before the High Court and challenged the legality and correctness of the award of the Reference Court out of which these appeals arise.

    12. The Division Bench of the High Court, by the impugned judgment/orders, partly allowed the appeals filed by the appellants and accordingly enhanced the compensation payable to the appellants. The High Court held that the fair market value/rate of the acquired lands on the date of acquisition for the appellants' land was Rs 50 per square yard and hence the appellants were entitled to get the compensation for their acquired lands @ Rs 50 per square yard along with other statutory benefits payable under the Act. It is against these judgment/orders, the claimants/landowners have filed these appeals by way of special leave before this Court.

    13. Heard the learned counsel for the parties.

    14. Shri Nidhesh Gupta, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants, placing reliance on the decisions in Haji Mohd. Ekramul Haq v. State of W.B AIR 1959 SC 488 , 1959 Supp (1) SCR 922, State of Kerala v. P.P Hassan Koya AIR 1968 SC 1201 , (1968) 3 SCR 459, Bhag Singh v. UT of Chandigarh (1985) 3 SCC 737, Municipal Committee, Bhatinda v. Balwant Singh (1995) 5 SCC 433, Union of India v. Mangatu Ram (1997) 6 SCC 59, V. Hanumantha Reddy v. Land Acquisition Officer (2003) 12 SCC 642, ONGC Ltd. v. Rameshbhai Jivanbhai Patel (2008) 14 SCC 745, Maharunnisa v. Commr. & LAO (2009) 9 SCC 750 , (2009) 3 SCC (Civ) 850, Chandrashekhar v. Land Acquisition Officer (2009) 14 SCC 441 , (2009) 5 SCC (Civ) 392, Valliyammal v. Tahsildar (LA) (2011) 8 SCC 91 , (2011) 4 SCC (Civ) 49, Chandrashekar v. Land Acquisition Officer (2012) 1 SCC 390 , (2012) 1 SCC (Civ) 259, Salaha Begaum v. Land Acquisition Officer (2013) 11 SCC 426 , (2014) 1 SCC (Civ) 563 and Digamber v. State of Maharashtra (2013) 14 SCC 406 , (2014) 2 SCC (Civ) 763, contended that the High Court having rightly held in the appellants' favour that a case for enhancement in payment of compensation for the acquired land is made out, erred in enhancing the compensation only @ Rs 50 per square yard. According to the learned Senior Counsel, having regard to the nature of the potentiality of the use of the lands which was duly proved by the appellants by adducing evidence and rightly recognised by the Courts in the appellants' favour by returning finding on this issue, the appellants were entitled to claim enhancement in the compensation at the rate ranging between Rs 100 per square yard to Rs 200 per square yard in place of Rs 50 per square yard.

    15. The learned Senior Counsel pointed out that several acres of lands situated near the acquired lands in question were acquired by the State Government between the years 1980 to 1989-1990 and for acquisition of these lands, the State Government paid compensation to their landowners @ Rs 300 to Rs 325 per square yard pursuant to orders of the Courts. The learned Senior Counsel, therefore, contended that if Rs 300 to Rs 325 is taken to be the rate of the similarly situated lands in the year 1989-1990 and if 10% is reduced retrospectively on yearly basis of Rs 300 to Rs 325, then in such event, the fair market value of the lands in question prevailing in the year 1977 i.e the year of acquisition, could safely be determined between Rs 100 to Rs 200 per square yard. Lastly and in the alternative, the learned Senior Counsel contended that in any event, the High Court having rightly held that the appellants were entitled to claim compensation at the enhanced rate of Rs 63 per square yard erred in eventually awarding compensation @ Rs 50 per square yard without there being any basis. According to him, the appellants therefore were entitled to get the compensation at the enhanced rate of Rs 63 per square yard instead of Rs 50 per square yard on the basis of finding of the High Court.

    16. Per contra, the learned counsel for the respondent State supported the impugned judgment 2005 SCC OnLine P&H 947 , (2006) 143 PLR 234 and contended that no case is made out on facts or/and in law to call for any interference in the impugned judgment 2005 SCC OnLine P&H 947 , (2006) 143 PLR 234 of the High Court. The learned counsel while refuting the contention of Mr Nidhesh Gupta, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the appellants, contended that the fair market value of the lands in question cannot be determined in the manner suggested by Mr Gupta. According to him, firstly in order to determine the fair market value of the acquired land, as provided under Section 23 of the Act, one is required to take into account the prevailing market rate of the similarly situated lands in nearby area of the acquired land on the date of the issuance of notification under Section 4 of the Act but in no case the rate of the lands either sold or acquired subsequent to the date of issuance of the notification in question can be taken into consideration. The learned counsel pointed out that the appellants never claimed compensation @ Rs 200 per square yard as was urged before this Court for the first time and hence at best the appellants could be considered for award of compensation @ Rs 63 per square yard but not beyond this rate.

    17. Having heard the learned counsel for the parties and on perusal of the record of the case, we find force in the alternative submission of the learned Senior Counsel for the appellants mentioned above and hence are inclined to allow these appeals in part and accordingly modify the impugned award in favour of the appellants to the extent indicated below by enhancing the rate of the land per square yard for re-determining the payment of the compensation and other statutory benefits payable under the Act to the appellants.

    18. Law on the question as to how the court is required to determine the fair market value of the acquired land is fairly well settled by several decisions of this Court and remains no more res integra. This Court has, inter alia, held that when the acquired land is a large chunk of undeveloped land having potential and was acquired for residential purpose then while determining the fair market value of the lands on the date of acquisition, the appropriate deductions are also required to be made.

    19. It is apposite to take note of some of the decisions of this Court on the issue relevant for the disposal of these appeals:

    19.1 In Brig. Sahib Singh Kalha v. Amritsar Improvement Trust (1982) 1 SCC 419, this Court opined that where a large area of undeveloped land is acquired, provision has to be made for providing minimum amenities of town life. Accordingly, it was held that a deduction of 20% of the total acquired land should be made for land over which infrastructure has to be raised (space for roads, etc.). Apart from the aforesaid, it was also held that the cost of raising infrastructure itself (like roads, electricity, water, underground drainage, etc.) needs also to be taken into consideration. To cover the cost component for raising infrastructure, the Court held that the deduction to be applied would range between 20% to 33%. Commutatively viewed, it was held, that deductions would range between 40% and 53%.

    19.2 In Chimanlal Hargovinddas v. Land Acquisition Officer (1988) 3 SCC 751 while referring to the factors which ought to be taken into consideration while determining the market value of the acquired land, it was observed that a smaller plot was within the reach of many whereas for a larger block of land there were implicit disadvantages. As a matter of illustration, it was mentioned that a large block of land would first have to be developed by preparing its layout plan. Thereafter, it would require carving out roads, leaving open spaces, plotting out smaller plots, waiting for purchasers (during which the invested money would remain blocked). Likewise, it was pointed out that there would be other known hazards of an entrepreneur. Based on the aforesaid likely disadvantages it was held that these factors could be discounted by making deductions by way of allowance at an appropriate rate ranging from 20% to 50%. These deductions, according to the Court, would account for land required to be set apart for developmental activities. It was also sought to be clarified that the applied deduction would depend on, whether the acquired land was rural or urban, whether building activity was picking up or was stagnant, whether the waiting period during which the capital would remain locked would be short or long; and other like entrepreneurial hazards.

    19.3 In Kasturi v. State of Haryana (2003) 1 SCC 354, this Court opined that in respect of agricultural land or undeveloped land which has potential value for housing or commercial purposes, normally 1/3rd amount of compensation should be deducted depending upon the location, extent of expenditure involved for development, the area required for roads and other civic amenities, etc. It was also opined that appropriate deductions could be made for making plots for residential and commercial purposes. It was sought to be explained that the acquired land may be plain or uneven, the soil of the acquired land may be soft or hard, the acquired land may have a hillock or may be low-lying or may have deep ditches. Accordingly, it was pointed out that expenses involved for development would vary keeping in mind the facts and circumstances of each case. In Kasturi case (2003) 1 SCC 354, it was held that normal deductions on account of development would be 1/3rd of the amount of compensation. It was, however, clarified that in some cases the deduction could be more than 1/3rd in other cases even less than 1/3rd.

    19.4 In Lal Chand v. Union of India (2009) 15 SCC 769 , (2009) 5 SCC (Civ) 766, it was held that to determine the market value of a large tract of undeveloped agricultural land (with potential for development), with reference to sale price of small developed plot(s), deductions varying between 20% to 75% of the price of such developed plot(s) could be made.

    19.5 In A.P Housing Board v. K. Manohar Reddy (2010) 12 SCC 707 , (2010) 4 SCC (Civ) 711, having examined the existing case law on the point it was concluded that deductions on account of development could vary between 20% to 75%. In the peculiar facts of the case, a deduction of 1/3rd towards development charges was made from the awarded amount to determine the compensation payable.

    19.6 In Land Acquisition Officer v. M.K Rafiq Saheb (2011) 7 SCC 714 , (2011) 3 SCC (Civ) 950, this Court after having concluded that the land which was the subject-matter of acquisition was not agricultural land for all practical purposes and no agricultural activities could be carried out on it, concluded that in order to determine fair compensation, based on a sale transaction of a small piece of developed land (though the acquired land was a large chunk), the deduction made by the High Court at 50%, ought to be increased to 60%.

    20. After taking note of the aforesaid cases and placing reliance upon the principles laid down therein, this Court in Chandrashekar (2012) 1 SCC 390 , (2012) 1 SCC (Civ) 259 observed as under:

    “20. It is essential to earmark appropriate deductions out of the market value of an exemplar land, for each of the two components referred to above. This would be the first step towards balancing the differential factors. This would pave the way for determining the market value of the undeveloped acquired land on the basis of market value of the developed exemplar land.
    21. As far back as in 1982, this Court in Brig. Sahib Singh Kalha case (1982) 1 SCC 419 held, that the permissible deduction could be up to 53%. This deduction was divided by the Court into two components. For the ‘first component’ referred to in the foregoing paragraph, it was held that a deduction of 20% should be made. For the ‘second component’, it was held that the deduction could range between 20% to 33%. It is therefore apparent that a deduction of up to 53% was the norm laid down by the Court as far back as in 1982. The aforesaid norm remained unchanged for a long duration of time, even though, keeping in mind the peculiar facts and circumstances emerging from case to case, different deductions were applied by this Court to balance the differential factors between the exemplar land and the acquired land. Recently however, this Court has approved a higher component of deduction.
    22. In 2009 in Lal Chand case (2009) 15 SCC 769 , (2009) 5 SCC (Civ) 766 and in 2010 in A.P Housing Board case (2010) 12 SCC 707 , (2010) 4 SCC (Civ) 711 it has been held that while applying the sale consideration of a small piece of developed land, to determine the market value of a large tract of undeveloped acquired land, deductions between 20% to 75% could be made. But in 2009 in Subh Ram case (2010) 1 SCC 444 , (2010) 1 SCC (Civ) 138, this Court restricted deductions on account of the ‘first component’ of development, as also, on account of the ‘second component’ of development to 33⅓% each. The aforesaid deductions would roughly amount to 67% of the component of the sale consideration of the exemplar sale transaction(s).”

    21. Keeping the aforesaid principles in mind, we have perused the evidence in these cases. It is not in dispute that the acquisition of land in question was made in the year 1977 and it was for a large chunk of undeveloped agricultural land. It is also not in dispute that it was for construction of “residential purpose”. It is further not in dispute that the appellants did not file any sale deed in evidence in support of their case to prove the fair market value of the acquired land. All that they adduced was an oral evidence of some witnesses to prove the potentiality of the lands by showing its location, proximity to the main road which was passing in the area and named some industries and hospitals operating in the nearby areas of the acquired lands, etc.

    22. Taking all these factors in mind and on appreciation of this oral evidence, the LAO, Reference Court and the High Court fixed their respective rates as mentioned above, namely, Rs 16.52, Rs 22 and Rs 50 per square yard.

    23. As rightly argued by the learned Senior Counsel for the appellants, it is not in dispute that the High Court did hold in the appellants' favour that they were entitled to claim compensation @ Rs 63 per square yard in the concluding paragraph of the impugned judgment basing its finding after taking into consideration the potentialities of land and rate of one adjacent land of the acquired land which was also found to have been acquired at the same time as determined by the courts.

    24. In the light of this finding, we fail to appreciate as to why the High Court then assessed the rate at Rs 50 per square yard in place of Rs 63 per square yard. In other words, having rightly come to a conclusion that the fair market value of the land in question on the date of acquisition (4-11-1977) was Rs 63 per square yard, there was no justification on the part of the High Court to have then reduced it to any rate less than Rs 63 much less to Rs 50 per square yard. In our considered view, it should have been fixed at Rs 63 per square yard only.

    25. We have also given our anxious consideration to the whole issue keeping in view the peculiar facts, evidence adduced and the law quoted above for determining the fair market value of the land on the date of notification (4-11-1977). Having regard to the total scenario emerging from the record of the case and the findings recorded by the courts below on the issues such as location of land, its potentiality, surroundings, the rate of the adjacent land determined by the courts, the condition of the acquired underdeveloped lands, the expenditure required to develop the acquired land to start the activities, percentage of deductions to be made, its proximity to the various places in the nearby town (Faridabad), and lastly, the fact that the appellants failed to file any sale deed of any parcel of land (be that of small piece of land or big) sold in the near proximity of the acquired land, the fair market value of the lands in question as on 4-11-1977 (date of acquisition) can reasonably be worked out to “Rs 63 per square yard”. In other words, in our considered opinion, the High Court was not right in determining the fair market rate of the acquired land at Rs 50 per square yard and instead it should have determined the fair market rate of the acquired land in question at “Rs 63 per square yard”. We accordingly now fix it.

    26. We are not impressed by the submission of the learned Senior Counsel for the appellant when he submitted that we should take into consideration the fair market value of the adjacent land determined by the court which was acquired 10 years subsequent to the acquisition in question in 1989-1990 and then go on reducing its value by 10% every year to determine the fair market value of the land in question. To say the least, this submission is wholly misconceived being against the settled principle of law relating to land acquisition cases.

    27. As rightly argued by the learned counsel for the respondent, the fair market value of the acquired land is required to be determined under Section 23 of the Act on the basis of the market rate of the adjacent lands similarly situated to the acquired lands prevailing on the date of acquisition or/and prior to acquisition but not subsequent to the date of acquisition. In appropriate cases, addition of 10% per annum escalation in the prices specified in the sale deeds (if filed and relied on) in relation to adjacent similarly situated lands for fixing the market value of the acquired land may be permitted. Such is, however, not the case in hand. Here is the case where firstly, no sale deeds were filed by the appellants to prove the fair market value of the acquired land and secondly, what they now want this Court to do is to take into consideration the rate of those lands which were acquired ten years after the date of acquisition in question and then reduce the value of such land by 10% every year so as to determine the fair market value of the acquired land in question. In our view, such procedure for determination is not provided in the Act.

    28. We also cannot accept the submission of the learned counsel for the appellants when he contended that the appellants are entitled to claim compensation at the rate ranging between Rs 100 to Rs 200 per square yard. As observed supra, since the appellants failed to file any sale deed of the lands to prove the price of the lands prevailing at the relevant time (4-11-1977), we fail to appreciate as to on what basis, the appellants can claim the compensation @ Rs 100 per square yard or more. In our view it was necessary for the appellants to have filed copies of the sale deed to prove the fair market rate prevailing on the date of acquisition (4-11-1977). Since the only evidence which was adduced was to prove the potentialities of the acquired land, the courts below took into account the potentialities and the rate of adjacent land fixed by the courts and accordingly fixed the rate. We do not find any illegality in such approach of the courts below.

    29. We have arrived at the figure of “Rs 63 per square yard” after applying all relevant factors, which we have mentioned above. In our view, the rate determined by this Court is just, reasonable and represents fair market value of the lands in question on the date of acquisition. Indeed, in such cases, one can never come to any exact figure of price of lands because in the very nature of things, the prices are bound to vary from land to land and further they also depend upon the individual buyer-to-buyer, seller-to-seller and the reasons which led to such sale and purchase. However, courts in such cases always exercise their discretion within the permissible parameters after appreciating the entire evidence brought on record and applying the relevant legal principles. We have kept these factors in mind.

    30. In view of the foregoing discussion, the appeals filed by the appellant landowners deserve to be allowed and are accordingly allowed in part. The impugned judgment and orders are accordingly modified to the extent indicated above.

    31. The LAO concerned is directed to calculate the compensation payable to the appellants (landowners) for their acquired lands pursuant to the Notification issued under Section 4 of the Act on 4-11-1977 “@ Rs 63 per square yard” and accordingly calculate all statutory compensation such as solatium, interest, etc. payable under the Act to every landowner.

    32. Let this calculation be made, as directed above, by the LAO and the amount so calculated and worked out be paid to the appellants (landowners) after making proper verification of their claim cases within three months from the date of receipt of this judgment. No costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Bhupal Singh And Others v. State Of Haryana .
    (Apr 1, 2015)