Loading..
Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • NARCOTIC DRUGS AND PSYCHOTROPIC SUBSTANCES ACT
  • Section 2(p)(iii)
  • Section 22(b)(ii)(A) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985.
  • Section 10 of the Conservation of Foreign and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974
  • Section 173 (2) of the Cr. P.C.
  • S.27 of the Arms Act,
  • Section 3(1) of the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007
  • https://www.drugs.com/illicit/mdma.html). c) Section 21 of the NDPS Act
  • clause (f) of Section 8 read with sub-section (2) of Section 9
  • clauses (c), (e), (g), (h), (i), (l), (m), (n), (q), 1[(qb)] and (s) of Section
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • ARTICLE 226 CONSTITUTION OF INDIA
  • NARCOTIC DRUGS AND PSYCHOTROPIC SUBSTANCES ACT
  • Section 2(p)(iii)
  • Section 22(b)(ii)(A) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985.
  • Section 10 of the Conservation of Foreign and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974
  • Section 173 (2) of the Cr. P.C.
  • S.27 of the Arms Act,
  • Section 3(1) of the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007
  • https://www.drugs.com/illicit/mdma.html). c) Section 21 of the NDPS Act
  • clause (f) of Section 8 read with sub-section (2) of Section 9
  • clauses (c), (e), (g), (h), (i), (l), (m), (n), (q), 1[(qb)] and (s) of Section
Smart Summary

Judgment Summary — High Court of Kerala (Raja Vijayaraghavan, J. and G. Girish, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner in this writ petition is the wife of the detenu (Niyas @ Kolli Niyas). The detenu is subject to a detention order issued by the 2nd respondent under Section 3(1) of the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 ("KAAPA") (referred to in the record as Ext.P1), and that order was confirmed by the 1st respondent under Section 10(4) of the KAAPA (referred to as Ext.P2). Exts.P1 and P2 were challenged in the present writ petition.

Short factual sequence (as recorded in the opinion):

  • An earlier detention order dated 1.6.2022 had been passed against the detenu; he underwent detention from 4.6.2022 for six months.
  • After release, on interception, the detenu was found in possession of 2.250 gms of MDMA and 15 gms of Ganja; a crime (Crime No. 54 of 2023) was registered on 26.6.2023 under Section 22(b)(ii)(A) of the NDPS Act alleging intent to sell.
  • On 2.8.2023 the sponsoring authority submitted a report seeking prosecution under KAAPA classifying the detenu as a "known Goonda" on the premise of being a drug offender.
  • While those proceedings were pending, Crime No. 1475 of 2023 (including offences under Section 307 IPC) was registered on 14.9.2023; the detenu was arrested on 05.10.2023. An additional report on 10.10.2023 sought classification as a "Known Rowdy".
  • The Superintendent of Police forwarded a list of ten criminal cases involving the detenu during 2018–2023; the sponsoring authority asserted a live link between subsequent conduct and earlier prejudicial activity, and on that basis a detention order was passed on 21.10.2023.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the classification of the detenu as a "known rowdy" was in order?
  2. Whether Crime No. 54 of 2023 (NDPS) is liable to be excluded from consideration?
  3. Whether the acts committed by the detenu are prejudicial to the maintenance of public order?
  4. Whether the alleged non-production of relevant documents before the detaining authority is fatal to the detention?
  5. Whether there was non-application of mind by the detaining authority/Government in ordering the maximum period of detention?

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments

  • The sponsoring report requested classification as a "known goonda" but the order classified the detenu as a "known rowdy"; this change was challenged.
  • Crime No. 54 of 2023 is an NDPS matter and cannot be used to classify the detenu as a "known rowdy".
  • Relying on Luciya Francis, mere possession of a narcotic (2.225 gms of MDMA) cannot be taken as stock for sale absent material manifesting intention to sell; it could be personal consumption.
  • In Crime No. 1475 of 2023 the detenu is only the 5th accused with no direct overt acts; that case could not justify classification as a "known rowdy".
  • The detenu was in judicial custody when the detention order was passed; the detaining authority should have applied its mind to whether detention was warranted.
  • Section 12 KAAPA allows up to one year for subsequent detention but the detaining authority must apply its mind before imposing the maximum period; petitioner contends this exercise was not carried out.
  • Overall, the petitioner's cases do not involve activities that are prejudicial to the maintenance of public order.

State's Response

  • The State (Senior Public Prosecutor) contended the detaining authority had subjectively satisfied itself that the detenu's activities fell within anti-social activity as defined by KAAPA; reliance was placed on Pesala Nookaraju.
  • The State pointed to ten prior cases (nine within Section 2(t) of KAAPA) and maintained the NDPS case is also an anti-social activity; the subsequent involvement in serious offences (including one under Section 307 IPC) showed a live link with earlier prejudicial activities.
  • Records relating to the relevant crimes were forwarded to the detaining authority to enable it to satisfy itself; reliance was placed on Radhika B. (live link principle) and Vijay Kumar regarding review of the maximum detention period.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Stenny Aleyamma Saju v. State of Kerala and Ors. (Full Bench) Filing of final report under Section 173 Cr.P.C. is not a prerequisite to invoke KAAPA, but mere registration of FIR is insufficient — "something more" is necessary to record objective and subjective satisfaction. The court held that the sponsoring authority had placed records (FIR, witness statements, wound certificates, affidavit of investigating officer etc.) and that the guidelines in Stenny were complied with.
Luciya Francis v. State of Kerala Observed that mere possession of narcotic substance is not necessarily "stock" for sale unless manifested with evidence of intention to sell. The petitioner relied on it; the court distinguished the facts and held Luciya's observations were not applicable here, noting MDMA cannot be lawfully possessed and the prosecution case alleged possession for sale.
Pesala Nookaraju v. Government of Andhra Pradesh and Ors. (Supreme Court) Explains the thin line between law-and-order and public order; emphasises latent potentiality and the role of subjective satisfaction of detaining authority in preventive detention. The court relied on Pesala to analyse whether the detenu's activities could be prejudicial to public order and to underscore that subjective satisfaction based on credible material is decisive.
Radhika B. v. State of Kerala and Ors. (Full Bench) Prejudicial activities relied upon for an earlier detention can be counted for a subsequent detention order if a live link exists. The State invoked this principle; the court accepted existence of a live link (subsequent offences after earlier detention) and treated earlier activities as relevant.
Vijay Kumar (Vijayakumar) v. Union of India & Ors. (Supreme Court) Authority confirming detention is not required to give special reasons for fixing the maximum period; it may be presumed government applied its mind. The court applied Vijayakumar to reject the contention that imposition of the maximum period showed non-application of mind; the court held it was not justified to upset the period chosen by the Government on that ground.
Ashraf v. Inspector General of Police, Police, Kochi Range (Division Bench) Absence of the word "possession" in KAAPA definitions is not decisive; possession is an inseparable component of activities such as stocking, transport or sale and may attract KAAPA definitions. The court relied on Ashraf to reject the petitioner's argument that possession alone cannot make one a drug-offender for KAAPA purposes.
Ansar T.A. v. State of Kerala and Ors. Reiterated Ashraf: being found in possession of narcotics can attract the definition of "drug offender" under KAAPA. The court referred to Ansar and quoted its reasoning in support of the proposition that possession is covered by KAAPA definitions and to reject the petitioner's contention.
Dr. Ram Manohar Lohia v. State of Bihar; Pushkar Mukherjee v. State of W.B.; Dipak Bose alias Naripada v. State of W.B.; Arun Ghosh v. State of W.B.; Commissioner of Police v. C. Anita Collected in Pesala: illustrate the principle that the test for public order is the latent potentiality of the act and that law-and-order acts can, in context, become prejudicial to public order. The court relied on the Pesala exposition (which cites these cases) to explain the distinction between law-and-order and public order and to conclude the detenu's conduct had the potential to disturb public order.
Ashok Kumar v. Delhi Administration Discusses that the potentiality of an act (not merely its intrinsic nature) determines whether it affects public order. The court invoked Ashok Kumar to reinforce the test of potentiality when determining if the detenu's acts prejudiced public order.
Dattatraya Moreshwar Pangarkar v. State of Bombay; A.K. Roy v. Union of India Authority and period of detention (duration) are to be decided by the appropriate authority/government and not by the Advisory Board or courts; period is for the government to decide. The court cited these cases to support the proposition that the duration of detention is to be decided by the Government and to reject the contention that the maximum period must be justified by special reasons in every case.
Ameena Begam v. State of Telangana and Ors. (Supreme Court) Observed that when detention is continued for the maximum period, the objective should ideally bear some reflection in the order of detention; absence of such reflection was not held to automatically invalidate an otherwise valid order. The court noted Ameena Begam but distinguished its immediate effect: it did not pronounce that absence of reflection in the order would invalidate an otherwise valid detention order, and the court felt bound by Vijayakumar.
Ibrahim Bachu Bafan and Another v. State of Gujarat and Another Supports the principle that the subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority is not ordinarily justiciable except where mala fides, total absence of material, or reliance on impermissible materials is shown. The court relied on this authority to explain the limited scope of judicial review in preventive detention matters and to uphold the detention where materials exist and no mala fide is alleged.
Rema Vijayalal v. State of Kerala Referenced by the petitioner in support of the proposition that the detaining authority should apply its mind before imposing maximum detention. The court observed that Vijayakumar was not brought to the attention of the court that decided Rema Vijayalal, and held itself bound by Vijayakumar on the question of maximum detention period.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The court proceeded issue-by-issue, applying the material placed before it and the legal principles drawn from precedent (as cited in the opinion):

Classification as "Known Rowdy"

The court noted the detenu's involvement in ten criminal cases from 2018 to 2023, including a prior detention (1.6.2022). After release he was involved in the NDPS matter (Crime No. 54/2023) and subsequently in Crime No. 1475/2023 (including Section 307 IPC) where he was arrayed as the fifth accused. The court observed that the sponsoring authority forwarded prominent records showing the detenu's role, and after noting involvement in Crime No. 1475/2023, the authority submitted a subsequent report seeking classification as a "Known Rowdy" under Section 2(p)(iii) of KAAPA. The court found no procedural violation in that course and held the classification to be in order.

NDPS Crime (Crime No. 54/2023) — Exclusion Argument

The petitioner argued (relying on Luciya Francis) that the small quantity (2.225 gms MDMA) indicated personal use and could not be taken as stock for sale. The court rejected this argument for the following reasons, on the record:

  • MDMA is an illegal psychotropic substance; under the NDPS Act some substances cannot be lawfully possessed even for personal use and MDMA is not among those permitted for personal consumption.
  • The prosecution case (as per records) alleged possession for the purpose of sale; the court treated the prosecution's allegation and the submitted materials as sufficient to consider the NDPS offence in the KAAPA classification.
  • The court relied on earlier Kerala authorities (Ashraf; Ansar) holding that absence of the word "possession" in KAAPA definitions does not exclude possession from the concept of a drug-offender; possession can constitute or be part of stocking, sale, transport etc.
  • The court therefore held Luciya Francis was distinguishable on the facts and not applicable to this case.

Prejudicial to Maintenance of Public Order

The court analysed the difference between "law and order" and "public order" by reference to Pesala Nookaraju and the authorities collected therein. The court reiterated the established test that the decisive factor is the latent potentiality of the acts to disturb the even tempo of community life, not merely their intrinsic nature.

On the facts, the court observed the detenu's criminal conduct formed a consistent course over several years, including multiple serious offences such as attempts to murder/culpable homicide and possession of prohibited narcotics. The court concluded that the length, magnitude and intensity of the offences demonstrated a potential to affect public order. The detaining authority's statement of subjective satisfaction that the detenu's activities were prejudicial to public order was drawn from credible material on record, and the court held that whether the material was sufficient was not to be re-evaluated by the court objectively; the scope of review is limited to whether subjective satisfaction was properly entertained.

Production of Documents

The court expressly found that the Superintendent of Police had placed all relevant records before the detaining authority — including FIRs, statements of informants, injured and witnesses, reports identifying accused, Mahazars, wound certificates, and the affidavit of the investigating officer — and therefore the contention that materials were not placed was rejected. The court held the guidelines in Stenny were complied with.

Maximum Period of Detention and Application of Mind

The petitioner argued the detaining authority failed to apply its mind before prescribing the maximum period (one year under Section 12 of KAAPA for a subsequent detention). The court considered binding Supreme Court authorities (Vijayakumar; Dattatraya Pangarkar; A.K. Roy) and concluded that Section 10/12 does not require the authority to give special reasons for fixing the maximum period; it may reasonably be presumed that the Government applied its mind. The court noted Ameena Begam's observation that objectivity in reflecting reasons for maximum detention would be desirable, but declined to treat absence of such reflection as fatal in the present matter. On the whole, the court found no non-application of mind that would invalidate the detention order.

Scope of Judicial Review

The court reiterated the narrow scope of judicial review in preventive detention: if the detaining authority has subjective satisfaction based on credible materials, courts will not sit in appeal over the merits of that satisfaction. Review is permissible where mala fide, total absence of material, or reliance on impermissible material is shown; none of these vitiating factors were found on the record.

Holding and Implications

HOLDING: The writ petition was dismissed. The court concluded the detenu had not made out a case for interference with the detention order.

Implications:

  • The detention order classifying the detenu as a "known rowdy" and the confirmation of detention by the Government were upheld by the High Court on the facts and materials placed before the detaining authority.
  • The court found that relevant materials (FIRs, witness statements, identification reports, wound certificates, investigating officer's affidavit etc.) had been placed before the detaining authority and that the authority had subjective satisfaction supported by those materials.
  • The court applied existing precedent to hold that (a) possession of narcotics can be treated as falling within KAAPA's definitions where attendant facts suggest acts like stocking/transport/sale, and (b) the Government may fix the maximum period of detention and is not required to state detailed reasons for doing so in every case. The court did not purport to lay down a new legal principle.
  • Direct effect: on the record provided, the challenge to Exts.P1 and P2 failed and the detention continues as previously ordered. The court did not announce any new precedent beyond applying and harmonising earlier authorities.

This summary is a faithful extraction and synthesis of matters expressly recorded in the provided judgment text. No information has been added beyond what appears in the opinion.

Result: Writ Petition dismissed.

    SALMATH E v. STATE OF KERALA

    IN THE HIGH COURT OF KERALA AT ERNAKULAM

    PRESENT

    THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE RAJA VIJAYARAGHAVAN V

    &

    THE HONOURABLE MR. JUSTICE G.GIRISH

    MONDAY, THE 22ND

    DAY OF JULY 2024 / 31ST ASHADHA, 1946

    WP(CRL.) NO. 711 OF 2024

    PETITIONER:

    SALMATH E

    AGED 23 YEARS

    W/O. NIYAS, BILAL MANZIL,

    ARATTUPUZHA NORTH, ALAPPUZHA,

    PIN - 690515

    BY ADVS.

    M.H.HANIS

    P.M.JINIMOL

    T.N.LEKSHMI SHANKAR

    NANCY MOL P.

    ANANDHU P.C.

    NEETHU.G.NADH

    CIYA E.J.

    RESPONDENTS:

    1 STATE OF KERALA

    REPRESENTED BY THE ADDITIONAL CHIEF

    SECRETARY TO GOVERNMENT, HOME AND VIGILANCE

    DEPARTMENT, GOVERNMENT SECRETARIAT,

    THIRUVANANTHAPURAM, PIN - 695001

    2 THE DISTRICT COLLECTOR & DISTRICT

    MAGISTRATE

    KOLLAM DISTRICT, PIN - 691013

    3 THE DISTRICT POLICE CHIEF

    KOLLAM RURAL, KOLLAM DISTRICT, PIN - 691001

    4 THE CHAIRMAN

    ADVISORY BOARD, KAAPA, SREENIVAS, PADAM

    ROAD, VIVEKANANDA NAGAR, ELAMAKKARA,

    ERNAKULAM DISTRICT, PIN - 682026

    1

    5 THE SUPERINTENDENT OF JAIL

    CENTRAL JAIL, VIYYUR, THRISSUR DISTRICT,

    PIN - 670004

    BY ADVS.

    ADVOCATE GENERAL OFFICE KERALA

    ADDL.DIRECTOR GENERAL OF PROSECUTION(AG-11)

    SRI ANAZ K A, PUBLIC PROSECUTOR

    THIS WRIT PETITION (CRIMINAL) HAVING COME UP FOR

    ADMISSION ON 22.07.2024, THE COURT ON THE SAME DAY

    DELIVERED THE FOLLOWING:

    2

    'CR'

    J U D G M E N T

    Raja Vijayaraghavan, J.

    The petitioner is the wife of Niyas @ Kolli Niyas, who is undergoing detention pursuant to Ext.P1 order of detention issued by the 2nd respondent under Section 3(1) of the Kerala Anti-Social Activities (Prevention) Act, 2007 ('KAAPA' for brevity). By Ext.P2 order, the 1st respondent has confirmed the order of detention under Section 10 (4) of the KAAPA, after securing the opinion of the Advisory Board. Exts.P1 and P2 orders are under challenge in this writ petition.

    2. Short facts:

    a) By an order dated 1.6.2022, a detention order under Section 3(1) of the KAAPA had earlier been passed against the detenu and he was detained in custody from 4.6.2022 for six months. After release from detention, the car in which the detenu was travelling was intercepted and on search, he was found in possession of 2.250 gms of MDMA and 15 gms of Ganja. On the allegation that it was intended for sale, the Kollam Excise Enforcement and Anti-Narcotic Squad registered Crime No. 54 of 2023 on 26.6.2023 under Section 22(b)(ii)(A) of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act, 1985. Immediately

    3

    thereafter, the sponsoring authority submitted a report on 2.8.2023 seeking to initiate proceedings under the KAAPA against the detenu by classifying him as a 'known Goonda', on the premise that he is a drug offender. While the proceedings were pending, the detenu got involved in Crime No. 1475/2023 for offences punishable inter alia under Section 307 of the IPC. The Crime was registered on 14.09.2023 and the detenu was arrested on 05.10.2023. Immediately thereafter, the sponsoring authority submitted an additional report on 10.10.2023 pointing out the involvement of the detenu in an offence falling under Chapter XVI of the IPC and requested for classification of the detenu as a 'Known Rowdy'. In the report, the Superintendent of Police forwarded the list of cases in which the detenu was involved during the past 7 years. It is stated in the report that the subsequent conduct of the detenu in getting himself involved in crimes after the earlier order of detention will trigger and maintain a live link with the earlier prejudicial activity. It is also stated that unless action is taken under the KAAPA, the detenu shall continue to indulge in anti-social activities. The details of the crimes in which the detenu got himself which was used for categorizing the detenu as a 'known rowdy' are as under:

    4

    Sl. Crime No.andstatus of Police Station Crime Date Sections involved Status of No. accused case

    143, 147, 148, 294 (b), Final report is 1 582/18 ( A1) Kilikolloor 24/08/18 323, 324, 326, 341,342, laid and 308, 149 of IPC. pending as SC1475/21

    1645/19 (A2) 294(b), 323, 324,2 Kundara 28/07/19 SC 506(ii), 307 & 34 of IPC. 1055/21,

    294(b), 324, 506(ii), SC

    3 2035/19 (A1) Kundara 13/09/19 939/21,

    307 & 34 of IPC

    4 1507/20 (A1)

    CC

    Kilikolloor 11/08/20 294(b), 394 of IPC 3426/20 143, 147, 148, 294(b), SC 1314/22, 5 462/21 (A1) Kannanalloor 22/07/21 323, 324, 341, 308,149 of

    IPC

    6 1136/21 ( A1) Kundara 13/07/21 294 (b), 341, 323, 324, CC 2/22,34 of IPC 7 197/22 ( A1) 341, 294 (b), 323, 324,

    CC 427/22,

    Kilikolloor 1/03/22 506, 34 of IPC

    294(b), 324, 326, 307,

    8 188/22 (A4) Kollam East 5/03/22 143, 147, 148, 149 of IPC SC 111/23, & Sec 27 of Arms Act

    22(b)& 20(b)(ii)A Under

    9 54/23 (A1) Kollam Excise 26/06/23 Investigation

    of NDPS Act

    341, 294(b), 506, 324,

    10 1475/23 ( A5) Kottiyam Under14/09/23 326, 307, 212, 34 of IPC Investigation Sl. Nos. 9 and 10 are the cases in which the detenu got himself involved after being released from detention.

    b) It is further stated that out of the ten crimes, nine of the crimes are

    5

    cases falling within the purview of Section 2(t) of the KAAPA. It was mentioned in the report that the detenu after being released in Crime No.54/2023 by the bail order dated 22.8.2023, had got himself involved in the last crime on 14.9.2023. As the cases falling under Sl. Nos. 9 and 10 were under investigation, the records of the case including the FIR, Statement of witnesses, report of identification of accused, the role attributed to various accused, the statement of injured, the wound certificate, the remand application, and also the affidavit of the investigating officer were submitted. As the accused was under judicial custody, the awareness of the detaining authority of the same and the likelihood of the detenu being released were also apprised. The detaining authority on the basis of the above report has passed the order of detention on 21.10.2023.

    3. The contention of the petitioner:

    a) Sri.M.H.Hanis, the learned counsel appearing for the petitioner submitted that though in the report of sponsorship, the request was for classifying the detenu as a 'known goonda', the order was passed classifying the detenu as a 'known rowdy'. Crime No.54 of 2023 is for violation of the provisions of the NDPS Act and the said crime cannot be used to classify the detenu as a 'known rowdy'.

    b) Crime No. 54 of 2023 and Crime No. 1475 of 2023 are under

    6

    investigation. Though in Stenny Aleyamma Saju v. State Of Kerala and Ors.1, a Full Bench has held that the filing of a final report under Section 173 (2) of the Cr. P.C. is not a prerequisite to invoke the power under Section 3 of the KAAPA, it has been clarified that mere registration of the FIR is not enough, and something more is necessary to meet the requirements under the statute, to record the objective as well as subjective satisfaction. In the case on hand, no such materials were brought to the notice of the detaining authority. The police have not yet obtained the report from the scientific lab to conclusively establish that the contraband seized was MDMA or Ganja.

    c) Relying on the law laid down in Luciya Francis v. State of Kerala2, it is submitted that the mere possession of a narcotic substance cannot be construed as part of stock unless it is manifested with evidence of intention to sell. Mere possession of narcotic drugs, according to the learned counsel, cannot be classified as acts affecting public order.

    d) In Crime No. 1475 of 2023, the detenu has no direct involvement and he has been roped in as the 5th accused. The overt acts are all against accused Nos. 1 to 4 and 7. The only allegation is that it is at

    1

    [2017 (3) KHC 517]

    [2023 (5) KHC 255]

    2

    the instance of the detenu that the other accused had attacked the victim. The said case could not have been reckoned for classifying the detenu as a 'known rowdy'.

    e) When the detention order was passed, the detenu was in judicial custody in Crime No. 1475 of 2023. If that be the case, the detaining authority ought to have applied its mind to determine whether an order of detention was warranted in the detenu's case.

    f) Under Section 12 of the KAAPA, a person may be detained for a period that may extend up to a maximum of one year in the case of a subsequent detention order. However, the detaining authority is required to apply its mind before ordering detention for the maximum period. In the case on hand, no such exercise has been carried out.

    g) Finally, it is submitted that the cases in which the detenu is involved do not involve activities that are prejudicial to the maintenance of public order.

    4. Response of the State:

    Sri. K.A. Anaz, the learned Senior Public Prosecutor, submitted that the assertions made by the learned counsel cannot be accepted. Relying on the law laid down in Pesala Nookaraju v. Govt. of

    8

    Andra Pradesh and Ors.3, it is submitted that the detaining authority has subjectively satisfied that the prejudicial activity committed by the detenu falls within the ambit of anti-social activity as defined under section 2(a) of the KAAPA. Reliance was placed on ten cases, out of which 9 cases fall within the ambit of cases falling within Section 2(t) of the KAAPA. One of the cases involved a drug offence which is also an anti-social activity. Reliance is placed on the observations made by a Full Bench of this Court in Radhika B. v. State of Kerala and Ors.4, where it is submitted that the prejudicial activities that were reckoned for an earlier detention order can be counted, provided the live link to issue another order of detention exists. Insofar as Crime No. 1475 of 2023 is concerned, the investigation revealed that the detenu had enmity towards the injured in the said case as he believed that he was caught by the Excise Squad in the earlier crime based on information furnished by the injured. The investigation revealed the involvement of the detenu. All the records relating to the said crime were also forwarded to the detaining authority to enable the said authority to satisfy itself as to whether the detention was warranted. Placing reliance on the law laid down in Vijay Kumar v Union of India & Ors.5, it is submitted

    3

    [(2023) SCC OnLine SC 1003]

    4

    [2015 (2) KHC 183]

    [(1988) 2 SCC 57]

    5

    that this Court will not be justified in deciding whether the maximum period of detention could have been imposed against the detenu.

    5. We have considered the submissions advanced.

    6. Whether the classification of the detenu as a 'known rowdy' is in order?

    From the materials before us, we find that the detenu has got himself involved in ten criminal cases during the period from 2018 to 2023. An earlier order of detention was passed against him on 1.6.2022 and he had undergone detention for six months. It was after his release from detention that he got himself involved in CR.No. 54 of 2023 for dealing with MDMA and Ganja. It was at that stage that the report of sponsorship was submitted by the Superintendent of Police seeking to classify the detenu as a 'known goonda'. However, before the detention order was passed, the detenu got involved in Crime No. 1475 of 2023 registered inter alia under Section 307 of the IPC. Of course, the detenu is arrayed as the 5th accused. We find from the detention order that all the records in connection with the crime were forwarded to the detaining authority by the sponsoring authority showing the prominent role of the detenu in the aforesaid crime. It was after noting his involvement in the said crime, that a subsequent report was submitted before the authority seeking to classify him as a

    10

    'Known Rowdy' as defined under Section 2(p)(iii) of the KAAPA. In the facts and circumstances, we do not think that there is any violation of procedure in adopting such a course.

    7. Whether Crime No. 54 of 2023 registered under the NDPS Act liable to be excluded?

    a) The first contention raised by the petitioner is that in view of the law laid down in Luciya Francis (supra), mere possession of a narcotic substance cannot be construed as part of stock unless it is manifested with an intention to sell. He contends that what has been seized from his possession is 2.225 gms of MDMA. It is his contention that the possession of such a small quantity cannot be reckoned as for sale and can only be for personal consumption. Profuse reliance is placed on the observation in Luciya (supra), wherein this Court had observed that the word "stocks" occurring in Section 2(i) of the KAAPA must be in such a nature that the same is kept in possession for sale and not for personal use.

    b) We are unable to accept the contention of the learned counsel that the MDMA kept in his possession has to be regarded for personal consumption and not for sale. The detenu was found in possession of 2.2250 gms of MDMA. MDMA (3-4 methylenedioxy-N- methamphetamine) is a synthetic, psychoactive drug with a

    11

    chemical structure similar to the stimulant methamphetamine and the hallucinogen mescaline. MDMA is an illegal drug that acts as both a stimulant and psychedelic, producing an energizing effect, as well as distortions in time and perception and enhanced enjoyment from tactile experiences (See:

    https://www.drugs.com/illicit/mdma.html).

    c) Section 21 of the NDPS Act provides for punishment for contravention in relation to manufactured drugs and preparations. Under Section 27 of the Act, the punishment is provided for the consumption of any narcotic drug or psychotropic substance. The said provision provides that where the narcotic drug or psychotropic substance consumed is cocaine, morphine, diacetylmorphine, or any other narcotic drug or any psychotropic substance as may be specified on this behalf by the Central Government by notification in the Official Gazette, it is punishable with rigorous imprisonment for a term which may extend to one year, or with fine which may extend to twenty thousand rupees, or with both. However, where the narcotic drug or psychotropic substance is other than those specified under Section 27, the possessor can be sentenced to imprisonment for a term which may extend to six months or with a fine which may extend to

    12

    Rs.10,000/- or with both. In other words, MDMA cannot be legally possessed by a person for his personal use as well.

    d) The specific contention of the petitioner is that the word 'possession' is not included while defining drug offenders under Section 2(i) of the KAAPA. This question was considered by a Division Bench of this Court in Ashraf v. Inspector General Of Police of Police, Kochi Range6, wherein the same contention was raised and the same was repelled by holding as under:

    2.…………….The allegations against the petitioner in those cases, as rightly noted by the Advisory Board, fall squarely under S.2(i), S.2(j) and consequently under S.2(o)(ii) of KAAPA. Noticing the substance of the allegations of those cases, the plea of the petitioner that mere possession would not attract those provisions was rightly repelled by the Advisory Board. 'Possession' is necessarily an inseparable component of any or all of the activities of stocking, transportation, sale or distribution. Hence, the mere absence of the word 'possession' in the definition of the term 'drug - offender' in KAAPA is not decisive to exclude a person found to be in possession of any drug in contravention of the Narcotic Drugs and Psychotropic Substances Act or in contravention of any other law for the time being in force, from the ambit of 'drug - offender' as defined in S.2(i) of KAAPA and therefore from the purview of the terms 'goonda' and 'known - goonda' defined respectively in Clauses (j) and

    (o) of S.2 of KAAPA. This is the law. The petitioner's plea that in the absence of the word 'possession' in those definition clauses, he cannot be covered by a restraint order under

    [2014 (3) KHC 695]

    6

    KAAPA has, therefore, been rightly repelled by the Advisory Board.

    e) The very same issue had cropped up for consideration before this Court in Ansar T.A. V. State of Kerala and Ors.7, and after noticing the observations in Ashraf (supra) had observed as follows in paragraph No. 8 of the judgment:

    "8. ……………….In the solitary case registered under S.27 of the Arms Act, the allegation is that he was found consuming ganja in the open. We are unable to accept the contention of the counsel that the aforesaid crimes cannot be taken into account to characterize the petitioner as a "known goonda". The contention appears to be that possession of ganja is not included in S.2(i) of the KAAPA which defines a drug offender and in that view of the matter, he cannot be termed as a goonda. We are unable to agree. S.2(i) of the KAAPA clearly defines a "drug offender" as one who illegally cultivates, manufactures, stocks, transports, sells or distributes any drug in contravention of the NDPS Act, 1985 or in contravention of any other law for the time being in force, or who knowingly does anything by abetting or facilitating such activity. Being found in possession of a narcotic drug would definitely attract the vice of S.2(i) of the KAAPA, as the definition is couched in such wide language. Even a person who acts in contravention of any other law relating to Narcotic Drug or a person who abets or facilitates activity in drugs will fall within the ambit of the term "drug offender" as defined. Further, each of the activity in S.2(i) of the KAAPA would take in possession of the Narcotic Substance as well. As held by this Court in Ashraf v. Inspector General Of Police of Police, 2014 (3) KHC 695, the mere absence of the

    [2017 (2) KHC 413]

    7

    word "possession" in the definition of the term "drug offender" in KAAPA is not decisive to exclude a person found to be in possession of any drug in contravention of the NDPS Act, 1985 or any other law for the time being in force. We are therefore not impressed with the said contention and the same is rejected."

    f) Under the NDPS Act, a small quantity of MDMA is 0.5 gms and the commercial quantity is 10 gms. The specific case of the prosecution as per the case records is that the detenu had kept in his possession MDMA and Ganja for the purpose of sale. In that view of the matter, the contention of the learned counsel that the petitioner was possessing MDMA for his own use and the same cannot be reckoned for initiating proceedings against him cannot be accepted. Luciya

    (supra) was rendered in the facts of the said case and the observations therein cannot be made applicable to the instant case.

    8. Whether acts committed by the detenu are prejudicial to the maintenance of public order?

    a) We do not think that the contention of the detenu that the crimes involve only law and order violations and cannot be categorized as acts that are prejudicial to public order deserves to be accepted. The Apex Court in Pesala Nookaraju (supra), after adverting to all the past precedents, including Dr. Ram Manohar Lohia v. State

    15

    of Bihar,8. Pushkar Mukherjee v. The State of West Bengal9,

    Dipak Bose alias Naripada v. State of West Bengal10, Arun Ghosh v. State of West Bengal11, Commissioner of Police v. C. Anita (Smt.)12, held as under:

    "65. Thus, from the various decisions referred to above, it is evident that there is a very thin line between the question of law and order situation and a public order situation, and some times, the acts of a person relating to law and order situation can turn into a question of public order situation. What is decisive for determining the connection of ground of detention with the maintenance of public order, the object of detention, is not an intrinsic quality of the act but rather its latent potentiality. Therefore, for determining whether the ground of detention is relevant for the purposes of public order or not, merely an objective test based on the intrinsic quality of an act would not be a safe guide. The potentiality of the act has to be examined in the light of the surrounding circumstances, posterior and anterior for the offences under the Prohibition Act.

    66. Just because four cases have been registered against the appellant detenu under the Prohibition Act, by itself, may not have any bearing on the maintenance of public order. The detenu may be punished for the offences which have been registered against him. To put it in other words,

    8

    [(1966) 1 SCR 709]

    9

    [(1969) 1 SCC 10]

    10

    [(1973) 4 SCC 43]

    11

    [(1970) 1 SCC 98]

    [(2004) 7 SCC 467]

    12

    if the detention is on the ground that the detenu is indulging in manufacture or transport or sale of liquor then that by itself would not become an activity prejudicial to the maintenance of public order because the same can be effectively dealt with under the provisions of the Prohibition Act but if the liquor sold by the detenu is dangerous to public health then under the Act, 1986, it becomes an activity prejudicial to the maintenance of public order, therefore, it becomes necessary for the detaining authority to be satisfied on material available to it that the liquor dealt with by the detenu is liquor which is dangerous to public health to attract the provisions of the 1986 Act and if the detaining authority is satisfied that such material exists either in the form of report of the Chemical Examiner or otherwise, copy of such material should also be given to the detenu to afford him an opportunity to make an effective representation. xxxx xxxxx xxxx

    73. In the case on hand, the detaining authority has specifically stated in the grounds of detention that selling liquor by the appellant detenu and the consumption by the people of that locality was harmful to their health. Such statement is an expression of his subjective satisfaction that the activities of the detenu appellant is prejudicial to the maintenance of public order. Not only that, the detaining authority has also recorded his satisfaction that it is necessary to prevent the detenu appellant from indulging further in such activities and this satisfaction has been drawn on the basis of the credible material on record. It is also well settled that whether the material was sufficient or not is not for the Courts to decide by applying

    17

    the objective basis as it is matter of subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority."

    b) The true distinction between the areas of "public order" and "law and order" lies not in the nature or quality of the act, but in the degree and extent of its reach upon society. The distinction between the two concepts of "law and order" and "public order" is a fine one but this does not mean that there can be no overlapping. Acts similar in nature but committed in different contexts and circumstances might cause different reactions. In one case it might affect specific individuals only and therefore touch the problem of law and order, while in another it might affect public order. The act by itself, therefore, is not determinant of its own gravity. It is the potentiality of the act to disturb the even tempo of the life of the community which makes it prejudicial to the maintenance of public order (See:

    Ashok Kumar v Delhi Administration and others13

    )

    c) The prejudicial activities of the detenu leading to public disorder, as revealed in the grounds of detention, consist of a consistent course of criminal conduct. Although the criminal activities of the detenu in the past pertained mostly to breaches of law and order, they have now taken a turn for the worse. This is not a case of a single activity directed against a single individual. There have been a series of

    [AIR 1982 SC 1143]

    13

    criminal activities on the part of the detenu and his associates during a span of five years. It is the length, magnitude and intensity of the terror wave unleashed by a particular act of violence creating disorder that distinguishes it as an act affecting public order from that concerning law and order. Some offences primarily injure specific individuals and only secondarily the public interest, while others directly injure the public interest and affect individuals only remotely. The particular acts enumerated in the grounds of detention clearly show that the activities of the detenu cover a wide field and fall within the contours of the concept of public order. [See: Ashok Kumar (supra)].

    d) In the instant case, the detaining authority, based on the involvement of the detenu for offenses which include at least three cases of attempt to murder, attempt to commit culpable homicide not amounting to murder, and possession of prohibited narcotic drugs and substances, was subjectively satisfied itself that his actions are prejudicial to the maintenance of public order and it is necessary to invoke provisions under the Act to prevent the detenu from indulging further in such anti-social activities. "Anti-social activity" has been defined under the KAAPA to mean acting in such manner as to cause or is likely to cause, directly or indirectly, any feeling of insecurity, danger, or fear among the general public or any section thereof, or

    19

    any danger to the safety of individuals, the safety of the public, public health or the ecological system or any loss or damage to public exchequer or to any public or private property or indulges in any activities referred in clauses (c), (e), (g), (h), (i), (l), (m), (n), (q), 1[(qb)] and (s) of Section 2. The detaining authority has specifically stated in the grounds of detention that the detenu is indulging in serious anti-social activities and such a statement is an expression of its subjective satisfaction that the activities of the detenu are prejudicial to the maintenance of public order. The detaining authority has also recorded its satisfaction that it is necessary to prevent the detenu from indulging further in such activities and this satisfaction has been drawn on the basis of the credible material on record. Whether the materials are sufficient or not is not for the Courts to decide by applying the objective basis as it is a matter of subjective satisfaction of the detaining authority.

    9. Alleged non-production of the relevant documents, if fatal:

    The contention that except for the registration of the crime, the materials showing the involvement of the detenu were not placed before the detaining authority cannot be accepted. The records clearly disclose that the Superintendent of Police had placed all the records including the FIS, FIR, statement of the informant, injured

    20

    and witnesses, report identifying each accused, Mahazars, wound certificates, and the affidavit of the investigating officer to show the involvement of the detenu. In that view of the matter, the guidelines issued by the Full Bench in Stenny (supra) have been complied with.

    10. Whether there is non-application of mind in ordering the maximum period of detention?

    a) The contention of the petitioner is that while issuing the subsequent detention order, the detaining authority ought to have applied its mind and considered whether the maximum period of detention ought to have been imposed. Much reliance is placed on the observations made by this Court in Rema Vijayalal v. State of Kerala14

    to substantiate his contention.

    b) In Dattatraya Moreshwar Pangarkar v. State of Bombay15, the Apex Court has held that the duration for which a detenu is to be kept in detention is for the detaining authority to decide and not the Advisory Board. The said opinion finds approval in the decision of the Constitution Bench of the Apex Court in A.K. Roy v. Union of India16. The period of detention and the terminal point has,

    14

    [2024 (2) KHC 118]

    15

    [(1952) 1 SCC 372]

    [(1982) 1 SCC 271]

    16

    therefore, to be decided by the Government.

    c) Section 12 of the KAAPA deals with the maximum period of detention. The said provision reads as under:

    "In pursuance of the first detention order made against any person under this Act and confirmed under Section 10, he may be detained for a period which may extend up to six months from the date of the detention and in pursuance of such subsequent detention order made against such person, he may be detained for a period which may extend up to a maximum of one year."

    d) Section 10 of the Conservation of Foreign and Prevention of Smuggling Activities Act, 1974 has identical provisions, which read as under:

    "Section 10: Maximum period of detention.—The maximum period for which any person may be detained in pursuance of any detention order to which the provisions of Section 9 do not apply and which has been confirmed under clause

    (f) of Section 8 shall be a period of one year from the date of detention or the specified period, whichever period expires later and the maximum period for which any person may be detained in pursuance of any detention order to which the provisions of Section 9 apply and which has been confirmed under clause (f) of Section 8 read with sub-section (2) of Section 9 shall be a period of two years from the date of detention or the specified period, whichever period expires later:

    22

    Provided that nothing contained in this section shall affect the power of the appropriate Government in either case to revoke or modify the detention order at any earlier time."

    e) In Vijayakumar v. Union of India17, a contention was taken before the Supreme Court that while passing an order of detention, the Government had not applied its mind, while confirming the detention of the detenu for the maximum period of one year from the date of detention, as prescribed in Section 10 of the Act. It was also contended that some reason ought to have been given, as to why the maximum period of detention is imposed. While repelling the said contention, the Apex Court in Paragraph 29 of the judgment had observed as under:

    "29. The last point that has been urged on behalf of the appellant is that the Government has not applied its mind while confirming the detention of the appellant for the maximum period of one year from the date of detention as prescribed in Section 10 of the Act. It is submitted that some reason should have been given why the maximum period of detention is imposed on the appellant. This contention, in our opinion, is devoid of any merit. Section 10 of the Act provides, inter alia, that the maximum period for which any person may be detained in pursuance of any detention order shall be a period of one year from the date of detention or the specified period. Section 10 does not provide that in imposing the maximum period of detention,

    [(1988 KHC 924)]

    17

    any reason has to be given. In confirming the order of detention, it may be reasonably presumed that the government has applied its mind to all the relevant facts and, thereafter, if it imposes the maximum period of detention, it cannot be said that the Government has not applied its mind as to the period of detention. In any event, under Section 11 of the Act, a detention order may, at any time, be revoked or modified by the Government. In the circumstances, we do not think that the detenu was in the least prejudiced or that there has been non-application of mind by the Government to the question of period of detention of the detenu. This contention of the appellant also fails. No other point has been urged in this appeal."

    In the concurring opinion, it was observed in paragraph no.38 as under:

    "38. If the Advisory Board reports that there is in its opinion sufficient cause for the detention of the person, the concerned authority may confirm and continue the detention of the person for such period as it thinks fit. The expression "as it thinks fit" in Section 8(f) of the Act indicates that the concerned authority after considering the report of the Advisory Board may fix any period for detention. The authority is not required to give any special reason either for fixing a shorter period or for fixing the maximum period prescribed under Section 10. The opinion of the Advisory Board and the grounds of detention are the only basis for confirming and continuing the detention, for any period, even up to the maximum period prescribed. Section 11 provides for revocation of detention order. The detention order may at any time be revoked or modified.

    24

    When the power to revoke the order of detention could be exercised at any time, it is not necessary for the authority to articulate special reasons for continuing the detention for any period much less for the maximum period prescribed under the Act."

    It was held that the authority is not required to give any special reason either for fixing a shorter period or for fixing the maximum period prescribed under the statute. The opinion of the Advisory Board and the grounds of detention are the only basis for confirming and continuing the detention, for any period, even up to the maximum period prescribed. The Act also provides for revocation of the detention order and says that the detention order may at any time be revoked or modified. When the power to revoke the order of detention could be exercised at any time, it is not necessary for the authority to articulate special reasons for continuing the detention for any period much less for the maximum period prescribed under the Act.

    f) Recently, in Ameena Begam v. State of Telangana and Ors.18, the Apex Court after referring to the law laid down in

    Vijayakumar (supra), held that the objective sought to be fulfilled in each case, whether sub-served by continuing detention for the maximum period, ought to bear some reflection in the

    [(2023) 9 SCC 587]

    18

    order of detention. However, the Apex Court refrained from pronouncing that an order of detention, otherwise held legal and valid, could be invalidated only on the ground of absence of any indication therein as to why the detention has been continued for a maximum period. It was observed in paragraph 79 of the judgment as under:

    "79. Viewed reasonably, the period of detention ought to necessarily vary depending upon the facts and circumstances of each case and cannot be uniform in all cases. The objective sought to be fulfilled in each case, whether is subserved by continuing detention for the maximum period, ought to bear some reflection in the order of detention; or else, the Government could be accused of unreasonableness and unfairness. Detention being a restriction on the invaluable right to personal liberty of an individual and if the same were to be continued for the maximum period, it would be eminently just and desirable that such restriction on personal liberty, in the least, reflects an approach that meets the test of Article 14. We, however, refrain from pronouncing here that an order of detention, otherwise held legal and valid, could be invalidated only on the ground of absence of any indication therein as to why the detention has been continued for the maximum period. That situation does not arise here and is left for a decision in an appropriate case."

    g) In Ameena Begum (supra), though Vijay Kumar (supra) was noticed, the question of whether in the absence of any indication

    26

    therein as to why the detention has been continued for the maximum period of 12 months was not decided. While rendering

    Rema Vijayalal (supra), Vijay Kumar (supra) was not brought to the notice of their Lordships. We are bound by the observations of the Apex Court in Vijay Kumar (supra).

    h) It is well settled that subjective satisfaction entertained by the detaining authority is not justiciable. This Court does not sit in appeal in proceedings under Article 226 of the Constitution of India over the decisions taken by the detaining authority on the basis of the materials placed before the detaining authority as to whether preventive detention is necessary or warranted. The short area of jurisdiction is to ascertain whether subjective satisfaction is entertained properly on the basis of materials placed before the detaining authority. If the entertainment of the latter subjective satisfaction is vitiated by mala fides or by total absence of materials or by reference to and reliance on materials which cannot legally be taken note of, certainly the powers of judicial review vested in this Court can be invoked and the order of detention on the basis of such alleged subjective satisfaction can be set aside. But, certainly, if there are materials, it is not open to this Court to sit in appeal over the subjective satisfaction entertained by the detaining authority. (See: Ibrahim Bachu

    27

    Bafan and Another v. State of Gujarat and Another19). Having considered the entire facts, we are of the view that the detenu has not made out any case for interference. This Writ Petition is dismissed.

    Sd/-

    RAJA VIJAYARAGHAVAN V

    JUDGE Sd/- GIRISH.G IAP JUDGE

    [1985 (2) SCC 24)]

    19

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    SALMATH E v. STATE OF KERALA
    (Jul 22, 2024)