Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Disposition
To access the original judgment, please Sign In or Subscribe.

    KM ANITA v. GNCTD

    1

    OA No.1029/2023

    CENTRAL ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

    PRINCIPAL BENCH, NEW DELHI

    O.A. No.1029/2023

    Reserved on: 27.07.2023 Pronounced on:11.08.2023 Hon'ble Mr. R.N. Singh, Member (J) Hon'ble Mr. Sanjeeva Kumar, Member (A) K.M. Anita

    D/o Sh. Raj Kumar Singh

    W/o Sh. Arun Kumar Verma

    R/o House No.203, Aliganj, Kotla Mubarakpur, New Delhi-110003.

    Mobile 91-9818777636

    Email: arunkasana@yahoo.com …Applicant (By Advocate:Shri Amarjeet Singh Bedi) Versus

    1. Government of NCT of Delhi Through the Principal Secretary, Education, Old Secretariat, Sham Nath Marg, Delhi-110054.

    Email:secy.se@nic.in

    2. The Directorate of Education, Government of NCT of Delhi Old Secretariat, Delhi-110054. Email:diredu@nic.in

    3. The Delhi Subordinate Services Selection Board ("DSSSB") through Secretary. FC-18, Institutional Area,

    Kakardooma Delhi-110092.

    Email:chairmandsssb.delhi @nic.in …Respondents. (By Advocates: Shri Amit Yadav)

    O R D E R

    Hon'ble Mr. Sanjeeva Kumar, Member (A):

    The present OA has been preferred seeking quashing of termination order dated 27.03.2023 vide which the applicant

    2

    was terminated from the post of TGT-Sanskrit (Female). Aggrieved by the aforesaid order, the applicant has sought the following reliefs:-

    "i. To quash the termination letter dated 27.03.2023 issued by the Respondents;

    ii. Direct the Respondents to reinstate the applicant for appointment to the post of TGT, Sanskrit against Post-Code 55/21 as the case may be under

    Advertisement No.03/2021 dated 27.05.2021 under the Directorate of Education Govt. of N.C.T., Delhi along with all consequential benefits;

    iii. pass such other order/s as may be deemed fit and proper."

    2. The facts of the case, in brief, are that pursuant to the Advertisement No.03/2021 dated 27.05.2021 by Respondent No.3, the applicant applied for the post of TGT-Sanskrit (Female) under Post Code 55/21. As per the Advertisement relevant essential educational qualification for the above post code is B.A. (Honours) in one of the Modern Indian Language (MIL) concerned or B.A. with MIL concerned as one of the elective subjects from a recognized university having 45% marks in aggregate with one additional language or one school subject at degree level. The applicant took selection test and subsequent to selection she was issued an offer of appointment on 15.11.2022. Post issuance of appointment letter, her documents were

    3

    physically verified and she received her joining order for Sriniwaspuri - Government Girls Senior Secondary School as TGT (Sanskrit) on 21.12.2022. After serving for more than three months at the post of TGT (Sanskrit), she received a WhatsApp message on the evening of 27.03.2023 informing her that she has been terminated from service. The applicant verified from other similarly situated teachers who were appointed along with her but found that she has been selectively terminated from the service and no apparent reason has been cited for the same. Subsequently, the applicant filed a representation dated 29.03.2023 with Respondent No.2 but no reply was provided to the applicant. She preferred an RTI seeking copy of noting but no communication was received by the applicant either. However, she came to know verbally that since the applicant did not study Sanskrit originally while pursuing her BA, she has been terminated from the service.

    3. The applicant has claimed that she was given appointment after due verification of the documents at three different stages and once the respondents have accepted the candidature of applicant for appointment, her termination was unfair. It has been submitted that the applicant is MA in Sanskrit language which is even a much higher

    4

    qualification than required for TGT post. Besides the applicant has studied in Sanskrit language in three parts in three years from a recognized university at the graduation level. Moreover, if PGT teachers, who are teaching senior secondary classes, are only required to have M.A. degree including the same qualification for teaching lower classes is not proper.

    4. To bolster her claim, the applicant has cited a catena of judgments as follows:

    i) Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Ors. Vs. Neelam Rana of the Hon'ble Delhi High Court in WP(c) Nos.1520/2012 & 575/2013 decided on

    07.08.2013.

    ii) Baboo Lal Sharma vs. Govt. of NCT of Delhi, Rev. Pet. No.346/2015 decided on

    18.09.2015 by the Hon'ble Delhi High Court.

    iii) Rinku Singh vs. DSSSB (2018 SCC OnLine CAT 5613) decided by this Tribunal.

    iv) Parminder Kaur vs. Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Ors. in OA 1949/2015 decided on 29.04.2019 decided by this Tribunal..

    v) Jyoti K.K. vs. Kerala Public Service Commission (2010) 15 SCC 596.

    vi) Chandrakala Trivedi vs. State of Rajasthan and ors. (2012) 13 SCC 129.

    5. The import of these judgments are that higher qualification cannot be a disqualification as there is nothing to suggest that she would be less equipped to teach the

    5

    subject to students vis-à-vis a person who has obtained a lesser degree. Also if a person has acquired higher qualification in the same faculty, such qualification can certainly be stated to presuppose the acquisition of the lower qualifications prescribed for the post.

    6. The respondents in their counter have refuted the claim of the applicant. Though they have admitted that after due documents verification, the applicant was issued an appointment letter but asserted that at a later stage it came to notice of the answering respondents that the applicant had completed B.A. without Sanskrit Subject for the session 2000-2002 though she passed her graduation with Sanskrit subject as an additional/single subject during the period 2017-2019. As per the RR of the said post code, the candidate should have studied the subject concerned for at least two years during the graduation course. The elective word may also include main subject as practiced in different universities. In 2002, the applicant had obtained B.A. degree from Ch. Charan University, Meerut but had not studied Sanskrit as a subject. After completing the graduation course in the year 2002, she cleared Sanskrit language in BA (Single Subject) in the examination conducted by the same university for three consecutive years i.e. 2017, 2018 and

    6

    2019 which was not a degree. The respondents have also alluded to the judgment in the case of Ms. Snehlata for the post of TGT (Sanskrit) in W.P. (C) No.2514/2012 in the matter of GNCTD & Ors. Vs. Snehlata in support of their contention.

    7. Relying on the above judgment, the respondents have argued that since the degree which she had in graduation did not pertain to Sanskrit, the respondents were right in terminating her services.

    8. We have perused the pleadings on record and also heard Shri Amarjeet Singh Bedi, learned counsel for the applicant and Shri Amit Yadav, learned counsel for the respondents.

    9. It is not in dispute that the applicant though did not possess a degree in Sanskrit but she had studied Sanskrit for three years subsequently and more importantly obtained a Master degree in the subject later. The respondents have failed to consider that the applicant is eligible for appointment to the post of TGT (Sanskrit) on the basis of the higher educational qualification in the same discipline. The issue as raised by the applicant herein is fully covered by the judgment of the Hon'ble High Court of Patna in the case of Mohd. Asif Hussain vs. Bihar State Power and

    7

    Hon'ble Delhi High Court judgment in the Shrishti vs. Govt. of NCT of Delhi dated 23.05.2017. We also note that in similar circumstances and on identical facts when the respondents denied appointment to the candidates possessing higher qualification, the applicant had approached this Tribunal in the past through various OAs. Such OAs filed by the applicants were allowed by the Tribunal with a direction to the respondents to give them appointment by treating them as eligible. Such orders of the Tribunal were challenged before the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi in WP(C) Nos.1520/2012, 575/2013, 4483/2012 and 4301/2012 which were dismissed by the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi vide judgment dated 07.08.2013. It is evident from the decision of the Hon'ble High Court of Delhi that a candidate possessing higher educational qualification is eligible for appointment to the post concerned. We are also persuaded by the recent decision of the Tribunal in Intequam Ali vs. Govt. of NCT of Delhi & Ors decided on 27.06.2023 vide OA No.2514/2012 with OA No.2515 in which the Tribunal held as under:

    "9.1 In view of the above, both the OAs (OA No2514/2022 and OA No.2515) are allowed and the impugned orders are quashed and set aside."

    8

    9. The only difference between the aforementioned case and the present OA that in the case, the applicant did not deny appointment on the ground of not possessing requisite qualification whereas in the instant case the applicant has already been appointed but has been terminated subsequently. In both the cases, the applicants possessed higher qualification than the prescribed in the Advertisement for the post, though in different subjects. We also find that the case cited by the respondents in GNCTD vs. Snehlata (supra) is being distinguishable and the facts of the said case cannot be applied to the facts of the present case as the applicant holds a BA degree in the stipulated subject in the instant case as held by the Tribunal in its order dated 19.04.2023 in OA No.983/2020 (Pooja Devi vs. Govt. of NCTD and Another) which reads as follows:

    "7.1 In the present case, the respondents have misapplied and misquoted the decision rendered in the case of GNCT VS Snehlata in facts of the present case. The facts of Snehlata (supra) are quite distinguishable, as already quoted in detail herein above, it is only Snehlata case the order passed in the OA was set aside. The respondents ought to have considered the ratio of the case of Neelam Rana in W.P.(C) No.575/2013, which is squarely applicable in the case of the present applicant. Therefore, the defiency

    9

    memo dated 31.10.2019 and Office Order dated 19.8.2020 are quashed and set aside."

    10. Moreover, we find force in the arguments, supported by a catena of judgments that possession of higher qualification makes the applicant better equipped to teach that subject vis-à-vis a person with lesser qualification and acquisition of higher qualification in the same subject by a person implies acquisition of the lower qualifications prescribed.

    11. In view of the above, the OA is partly allowed and impugned termination order No.F.No.DE-3(42)/DRC/E- III\TGT Sanskrit/Female/2022/27529-35 dated 27.05.2023 is quashed. We also direct the competent authority among the respondents to reinstate the applicant with the post she was holding with all consequential benefits in accordance with law. This exercise can be completed within two months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order. No order as to costs.

    (Sanjeeva Kumar) (R.N.Singh)

    Member (A) Member(J)

    /kdr/

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    KM ANITA v. GNCTD
    (Aug 11, 2023)