Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Rule-15 of the OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962,
  • sub-rule (2) of Rule-15 of Rules, 1962,
  • Sub-rule(3) of Rule-15 of Rules, 1962
  • Rule-15 of the OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962,
  • sub-rule(5) of Rule-15. Rule-15(6)
  • Rule-15 of OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962
  • Rule-13 of OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962.
  • sub-rule 10(b)
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Attorney(S)
Judges
Acts
  • provisions contained in Rule-15 of the OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962,
  • sub-rule (2) of Rule-15 of Rules, 1962,
  • Sub-rule(3) of Rule-15 of Rules, 1962
  • Rule-15 of the OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962,
  • sub-rule(5) of Rule-15. Rule-15(6)
  • Rule-15 of OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962
  • Rule-13 of OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962.
  • sub-rule 10(b)
Smart Summary

Structured Summary of the Opinion (Dr. B.R. Sarangi, J.)

Factual and Procedural Background

The petitioner was employed as an Assistant Teacher (Level-V, Elementary Cadre) at Aptira UGME School. He challenged an office order dated 16.12.2019 (Annexure-12) which terminated his service with immediate effect under Rule-15 of the OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962, on the ground of submission of a purportedly fake C.T. pass certificate.

The factual narrative in the opinion states that the petitioner pursued the C.T. course beginning in 1999, sat for examinations in 2001, 2002 and 2003 (including compartmental examinations), and the Board of Secondary Education, Odisha issued a certificate in his favour on 30.12.2003. A provisional certificate-cum-memorandum of marks was sent to the Headmaster of the training school in 2004. Subsequent scrutiny led the Board to issue a revised mark sheet in favour of the petitioner.

After joining service as an Assistant Teacher, the petitioner was asked by the Block Education Officer (Bonth) on 05.11.2019 to produce his educational testimonials for verification. Following verification steps, an allegation was raised by one Bikash Kumar Dhal that the petitioner’s C.T. certificate was fraudulent. The District Project Coordinator, SSA, Bhadrak asked for an enquiry on 26.11.2019. The Principal of the District Institute of Education & Training, Agarpada, Bhadrak sent a memo on 28.11.2019 clarifying that the petitioner passed the C.T. examination in 2003 (compartmental) and provided the serial number and revised mark sheet.

The petitioner filed W.P.(C) No. 24972 of 2019, which was disposed of by this Court on 10.12.2019, directing the Block Education Officer to consider the petitioner’s documents and pass appropriate orders within four months. Despite submitting representations citing that order, the Block Education Officer issued Annexure-12 on 16.12.2019 terminating the petitioner’s service without conducting a formal inquiry or giving an opportunity of hearing, which prompted the present writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the termination of the petitioner's service by Annexure-12 dated 16.12.2019 under Rule-15 of the OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962 was valid when the procedural requirements of Rule-15 were not followed.
  2. Whether the authorities complied with the principles of natural justice (opportunity of hearing, fair procedure) before imposing the major penalty of termination.
  3. Whether the allegation of production of a fake C.T. certificate, relied upon by the authority, justified immediate termination without conducting the statutory disciplinary procedures.
  4. Whether the earlier order of this Court in W.P.(C) No. 24972 of 2019 (dated 10.12.2019) directing consideration of documents was complied with.

Arguments of the Parties

Petitioner's Arguments (as advanced by Mr. Bimbisar Dash)

  • The procedure prescribed under Rule-15 of the OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962 for imposing the major penalty of termination was not complied with.
  • The petitioner was not given any opportunity of hearing before the order of termination; no inquiry was conducted into the allegations.
  • Because of the foregoing procedural defects and breach of principles of natural justice, the termination order (Annexure-12) cannot be sustained in law.

Opposite Parties' Arguments (as advanced by Mr. B. Satpathy / opposite party no.6)

  • It was contended that the petitioner produced a fake C.T. pass certificate to procure his employment, and verification revealed the certificate to be forged.
  • Given the forgery, the authorities were justified in taking action (including lodging an FIR and terminating employment) and there was no illegality or irregularity in the impugned order.
  • The respondent urged the Court not to interfere at this stage and sought dismissal of the writ petition.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Taylor v. Taylor, (1875) 1 Ch D 426 Where a power is given to do a certain thing in a certain way, the thing must be done in that way or not at all. The Court relied on this as the origin of the principle that statutory procedures prescribed for an act must be followed; used to support invalidation of action taken without compliance with Rule-15.
Nazir Ahmad v. King Emperor, 63 Ind App 372 : AIR 1936 PC 253 Reiterated the rule that when power is given to do a thing in a certain way it must be done in that way. Cited to reinforce the statutory-procedure-must-be-followed principle underpinning the Court’s view that Rule-15 must be observed in letter and spirit.
Babu Verghese & Ors. v. Bar Council of Kerala & Ors., AIR 1999 SC 1281 Affirmation of the same view regarding mandatory compliance with prescribed procedure. Used to support the conclusion that failure to follow the statutory disciplinary process vitiates the action.
Ridge v. Baldwin, (1964) AC 40 : (1963) 2 All ER 66 (HL) Description of what constitutes a fair procedure — not precisely definable, but what a reasonable person would regard as fair in the circumstances. Referenced to underscore the Court’s assessment that the termination lacked a fair procedure and thereby violated principles of natural justice.
A.K. Kraipak v. Union of India, AIR 1970 SC 150 Principle that rules of natural justice apply to domestic enquiries and administrative proceedings. Adopted to hold that procedural fairness is required in disciplinary proceedings affecting service rights.
Dr. G. Sarana v. University of Lucknow, AIR 1976 SC 2428 Support for the applicability of natural justice principles to administrative/domestic enquiries. Cited to reinforce the principle that the petitioner was entitled to fair procedure in disciplinary action.
State Bank of Patiala v. S.K. Sharma, AIR 1996 SC 1669 Definition: 'Natural Justice' means 'fair play in action'. Used to emphasize that the conduct complained of lacked fairness required by natural justice.
Union of India v. E.G. Nambudiri, (1991) 3 SCC 38 Explains the purpose and scope of natural justice: applicable when rights are affected, generally requires opportunity of hearing; reasons need not always be recorded but giving reasons is desirable. Cited to explain the need for hearing and fairness in administrative actions affecting vested rights and to justify quashing the impugned order for lack of hearing.
Suresh Chandra Nanhorya v. Rajendra Rajak, (2006) 7 SCC 800 Natural justice is the essence of fair adjudication and prevents miscarriage of justice. Relied upon to support the Court's conclusion that the disciplinary action violated fundamental fairness.
Sahara India (Firm) v. CIT, (2008) 14 SCC 151 (relying on A.K. Kraipat v. Union of India, (1969) 2 SCC 262) Observation that rules of natural justice are not rigidly defined; underlying principle is to prevent arbitrary exercise of State power and secure fair play in action. Invoked to frame the Court's approach that arbitrariness and lack of procedural fairness in administrative action are impermissible and justify judicial intervention.
A.K. Kraipat/Kraipak v. Union of India, (1969) 2 SCC 262 Referenced by Sahara India: foundational authority on natural justice principles in administrative law. Used indirectly (through Sahara India) to reinforce that natural justice aims to check arbitrary State action; supports setting aside defective disciplinary action.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court's reasoning proceeds in a series of connected findings grounded in both the facts and legal principles reproduced in the opinion:

  1. Fact-finding stage: The Court accepted that the petitioner had produced a C.T. pass certificate and had been employed as an Assistant Teacher. The Block Education Officer called for verification of documents; an outsider alleged forgery; and the District Project Coordinator sought an enquiry. Critically, the Principal of the District Institute of Education & Training issued a memo (28.11.2019) affirming that the petitioner had passed the C.T. examination in 2003 (compartmental) and provided the serial number and revised mark sheet.
  2. Procedural-law analysis: The impugned termination was effected under Rule-15 of OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962. The Court examined the text of Rule-15 (as summarized in the opinion) and noted that the rule prescribes an "elaborate procedure" for imposing major penalties like termination — including framing definite charges, communicating charges and statements of allegations in writing, permitting the government servant to submit a written defence (ordinarily within one month), supplying records on which allegations are based for preparation of defence, appointment of presenting and inquiry officers, examination of witnesses, and the availability of specified penalties under Rule-13.
  3. Application of Rule-15 to the facts: The Court found no materials on record showing that the due procedure under Rule-15 had been followed. The disciplinary procedure required by Rule-15(2), (3), (5), (6), (7) and (10)(b) was not adhered to — in particular, there was no evidence of framed charges, supply of records for preparing defence, or a proper inquiry; nor was a hearing afforded.
  4. Specific evidentiary lacunae: The Court observed that the report from the Board of Secondary Education (sought on 11.11.2019) was not placed on record and that, importantly, the very institute responsible for training had clarified authenticity of the petitioner's certificate and forwarded relevant documents. On that basis, the Court concluded that termination based merely on an outsider's allegation — without compliance with Rule-15 and without following the principles of natural justice — could not be sustained.
  5. Reliance on precedent and legal principles: The Court invoked established authorities to support two related propositions: (a) where statute prescribes a manner of doing an act, it must be done in that manner (Taylor v. Taylor; Nazir Ahmad; Babu Verghese); and (b) principles of natural justice apply to administrative and domestic enquiries affecting rights (A.K. Kraipak, Dr. G. Sarana, State Bank of Patiala, Union of India v. E.G. Nambudiri, Suresh Chandra Nanhorya, Sahara India). The Court emphasized that natural justice requires fair procedure and ordinarily an opportunity to be heard where vested rights are affected.
  6. Synthesis and conclusion: Given (i) the mandatory procedural safeguards contained in Rule-15, (ii) the absence of any record showing compliance with those safeguards, (iii) an express clarification from the training institute about the petitioner’s certificate, and (iv) the importance of natural justice, the Court concluded that Annexure-12 was passed in violation of statutory procedure and natural justice. The counter affidavit admitted the lack of adherence to Rule-15 (as the respondents acknowledged in their pleadings that FIR was lodged and termination effected immediately), reinforcing the Court's view that the disciplinary provisions were not followed.
  7. Remedy chosen: On this foundation, and having heard the parties and perused the record, the Court quashed the termination order and directed immediate reinstatement of the petitioner.

Holding and Implications

Holding: The writ petition is allowed; Annexure-12 (office order dated 16.12.2019 terminating the petitioner) is quashed and the petitioner is directed to be reinstated in service with immediate effect.

Implications:

  • Direct effect: The immediate legal consequence is that the termination order of 16.12.2019 is set aside and the opposite parties are directed to reinstate the petitioner immediately. The writ petition is allowed and there is no order as to costs.
  • Grounding principle: The decision reinforces that where a statutory disciplinary procedure (Rule-15 of OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962) prescribes specific steps before imposing a major penalty like termination, those steps must be followed; failure to do so, particularly when coupled with a denial of opportunity of hearing and an absence of proper inquiry, warrants judicial interference.
  • Broader precedent: The opinion applies established jurisprudence on the mandatory nature of statutory procedure and the application of natural justice to administrative/domestic enquiries. The Court did not purport to lay down new law; it applied settled principles to the facts at hand to set aside the defective disciplinary action.

Order on costs: The Court ordered that there shall be no order as to costs (i.e., no costs awarded).

    biswanath sethi v. state of odisha and ors

    Dr. B.R. Sarangi, J.

    1. Dr. B.R. Sarangi, J. The petitioner, who was working as an Assistant Teacher (Level-V, Elementary Cadre) in Aptira UGME School, has filed this writ petition challenging the office order dated 16.12.2019 under Annexure-12 terminating his service with immediate effect under Rule-15 of OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962 on the ground of submission of fake C.T. pass certificate

    2. The factual matrix of the case, in hand, is that after completion of H.S.C. examination conducted by the Board of Secondary Education, the petitioner took admission in Secondary Teachers Training School, Agarpada for prosecuting C.T. course in the year 1999. In July, 2001, he appeared in all the subjects but could not clear some papers. In 2002, the petitioner again appeared and cleared all but eight papers. In October, 2003, the petitioner appeared in those eight papers and having not come out successful, he appeared in the compartmental examination and cleared all the papers. After clearing the Secondary Teachers' Training Certificate examination, Board of Secondary Education, Odisha issued necessary certificate in favour of the petitioner on 30.12.2003. The Secretary, Board of Secondary Education, Odisha vide letter no. 3142 (4781) dated 17.09.2004 sent the provisional certificate-cum-memorandum of marks of the petitioner to the Headmaster, S.T. School, Agarpada, Bhadrak. Though there were some wrong recording of marks by the Board of Secondary Education, Odisha, after scrutiny, Board of Secondary Education, Odisha issued revised mark sheet in favour of the petitioner.

    2.1. Thereafter, the petitioner joined as an Asst. Teacher (Level-V of Elementary Education Cadre) in Aptira UGME School, Agarpada. While the petitioner continuing as such, the Block Education Officer, Bonth vide letter dated 05.11.2019 called upon the petitioner to produce all the testimonials regarding educational qualification by 06.11.2019. In response to the same, the petitioner submitted all the documents before the Block Education Officer, Bonth for verification. On 11.11.2019, Block Education Officer, Bonth requested the Secretary, Board of Secondary Education, Odisha to verify copy of the C.T. certificate produced by the petitioner and to confirm about its genuineness.

    2.2. At that point of time, one Bikash Kumar Dhal alleged that the petitioner submitted fraudulent and forged C.T. certificate and, as such, the petitioner never passed C.T. examination from the Board of Secondary Education, Odisha. Basing upon such allegations, the District Project Coordinator, SSA, Bhadrak vide letter dated 26.11.2019 requested the Block Education Officer, Bonth to conduct an enquiry into the aforesaid allegations and to take appropriate action and submit compliance report thereof. On 27.11.2019, Block Education Officer, Bonth claimed that the certificate submitted by the petitioner is forged one and sought explanation from the petitioner to be submitted within a period of seven days, failing which the higher authority will be requested to initiate disciplinary action against him. The Principal, District Institute of Education and Training, Agarpara, Bhadrak vide memo dated 28.11.2019 clarified the position that the petitioner has passed C.T. examination in the year 2003 as a compartmental candidate and the serial number of such certificate was 030858. As such, the revised mark sheet issued by Board of Secondary Education, Odisha and other relevant documents were also forwarded by the District Institute of Education and Training, Agarpara, Bhadrak. Accordingly, on 02.12.2019 the petitioner submitted his explanation before the Block Education Officer, Bonth clarifying that the C.T. certificate received from District Institute of Education and Training, Agarpada, Bhadrak is genuine and original. Though the petitioner submitted such explanation and clarification was given by the Principal, District Institute of Education and Training, but without considering the same, the Block Education Officer, Bonth proceeded with the matter by initiating proceeding against the petitioner.

    2.3. Challenging the above action of the opposite parties, the petitioner approached this Court by filing W.P.(C) No. 24972 of 2019, which was disposed of vide order dated 10.12.2019 directing the Block Education Officer, Bonth to consider the documents submitted by the petitioner and pass appropriate orders in presence of the petitioner within a period of four months from the date of communication/production of the order. In compliance thereof, the petitioner submitted representation on 16.12.2019 before the District Education, Officer, Bhadrak and Block Education Officer, Bonth enclosing the order dated 10.12.2019 passed in W.P.(C) No. 24972 of 2019. But, without considering the documents submitted by the petitioner and without giving any opportunity of hearing to him, the Block Education Officer, Bonth vide office order dated 16.12.2019 terminated the services of the petitioner with immediate effect under Rule-15 of the OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962 on the ground of production of fake C.T. pass certificate. Hence this application.

    3. Mr. Bimbisar Dash, learned counsel for the petitioner contended that while imposing harsh penalty of termination of service, the procedure as envisaged under OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962 has not been complied with nor the petitioner has been given opportunity of hearing while passing the order of punishment and, more so, no inquiry has been conducted on the allegations, thereby, the order so passed in Annexure-12 dated 16.12.2019 terminating the services of the petitioner cannot sustain in the eye of law.

    4. Mr. B. Satpathy, learned Standing Counsel for School and Mass Education Department referring to the counter affidavit filed by opposite party no. 6 vehemently contended that since the petitioner has produced fake C.T. pass certificate to get an employment as an Asst. Teacher and on verification of documents the same was found to be forged, action as deemed fit has been taken against the petitioner. Thereby, the authorities have not committed any illegality or irregularity in passing the order impugned. It is further contended that once the petitioner has got employment by producing fake certificate, if it is detected that the same is forged one, the authority has got every right to take action against the petitioner. Therefore, it is contended that this Court should not interfere with the same at this stage and, as such, he seeks for dismissal of the writ petition.

    5. This Court heard Mr. Bimbisar Dash, learned counsel for the petitioner and Mr. B. Satpathy, learned Standing Counsel for School and Mass Education Department by virtual mode, and perused the records. Pleadings having been exchanged, with the consent of learned counsel for the parties, this writ petition is being disposed of finally at the stage of admission.

    6. There is no dispute with regard to the fact that the petitioner was continuing as an Asst. Teacher by producing a C.T. pass certificate. But, the Block Education Officer, Bonth, pursuant to letter dated 05.11.2019 called upon the petitioner to produce relevant documents on 06.11.2019 and on that basis the Block Education Officer requested the Secretary, Board of Secondary Education, Odisha to verify the genuineness of the C.T. certificate produced by the petitioner. When such process was continuing, on the basis of the allegations made by one Bikash Kumar Dhal, the District Project Coordinator, SSA, Bhadrak, vide letter dated 26.11.2019, requested the Block Education Officer, Bonth to conduct an enquiry into the aforesaid allegation and to take appropriate action. But the Principal, District Institute of Education and Training, Agarpara, Bhadrak vide memo dated 28.11.2019 clarified the position that the petitioner has passed the C.T. examination 2003 as a compartmental candidate and serial number of such certificate is 030858 and, as such, the revised mark sheet issued by Board of Secondary Education, Odisha and other relevant documents were also forwarded by the District Institute of Education and Training, Agarpara, Bhadrak.

    7. The impugned order indicates that the service of the petitioner has been terminated with immediate effect as per Rule-15 of OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962. On perusal of the provisions contained in Rule-15 of the OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962, it appears that elaborate procedure has been prescribed for imposing penalties of termination from service. As per sub-rule (2) of Rule-15 of Rules, 1962, the disciplinary authority shall frame definite charges on the basis of the allegations on which the inquiry is to be held. Such charges together with a statement of the allegations on which they are based, shall be communicated in writing to the government servant and he shall be required to submit, within such time as may be specified by the disciplinary authority but not ordinarily exceeding one month, a written statement of his defence and also to state whether he desires to be heard in person. Sub-rule(3) of Rule-15 of Rules, 1962 prescribes that the government servant shall, for the purpose of preparing his defence, be supplied with all the records on which the allegations are based. He shall also be permitted to inspect and take extracts from such other official records as he may specify, provided that such permission may be refused if, for reasons to be recorded in writing in the opinion of the disciplinary authority such records are not relevant for the purpose or it is against interest of the public to allow him access thereto. Similarly, for causing inquiry, presenting officer and inquiry officer are to be appointed by the disciplinary authority as per sub-rule(5) of Rule-15. Rule-15(6) and (7) provides examination of witnesses. As per sub-rule 10(b) of the Rule-15, the disciplinary authority is to impose any of the penalties as specified in clauses (vi) to (ix) of Rule-13 of OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962. If such elaborate procedure has been prescribed under law, while imposing major penalty of termination from service vide order impugned in Annexure-12 dated 16.12.2019, the aforesaid procedures have not been followed and more so there is non-compliance of principles of natural justice. Nothing has been placed on record to elucidate that due procedure has been followed to award the punishment of termination from service.

    8. Furthermore, when report was called for from the Board of Secondary Education, Odisha on 11.11.2019 under Annexure-6, whether such report has been received from the Board or not, that has not been placed on record. Therefore, on the basis of mere allegation of an outsider, the action so taken for termination of service of the petitioner without following due procedure, cannot sustain in the eye of law.

    9. It is the basic principles of law long settled that if the manner of doing a particular act is prescribed under any Statute, the act must be done in that manner or not at all. The origin of this rule is traceable to the decision in Taylor v. Taylor, (1875) 1 Ch D 426, which was followed by LORD ROCHE in Nazir Ahmad v. King Emperor,  63 Ind App 372: AIR 1936 PC 253 who stated as under:-

    -"where a power is given to do a certain thing in a certain way, the thing must be done in that way or not at all."

    The same view has also been taken by the apex Court in Babu Verghese and others v. Bar Council of Kerala & Ors.,  AIR 1999 SC 1281 at page 1288.

    In view of detailed procedure envisaged under Rule-15 of the OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962, if the same has not been followed in letter and spirit as to the law discussed above, any action taken in violation of such rules cannot sustain in the eye of law.

    10. Apart from the above, the Principal, District Institute of Education and Training, Agarpara, Bhadrak vide memo dated 28.11.2019 addressed to the Block Education Officer, Bonth with regard to genuineness of the secondary teachers training certificate issued to the petitioner, has specifically clarified that the petitioner having Roll No. 02CP002 has passed the C.T. examination, 2003 (Compartmental) and serial no. of certificate is 030858. Consequentially, a revised mark sheet was also issued by the Board of Secondary Education, Odisha. Therefore, there should not have been any doubt about the certificate produced by the petitioner to get into the job as an Asst. Teacher. In such view of the matter, this Court is of the considered opinion that without making any proper inquiry and without ascertaining the correctness of the certificate and also without giving opportunity of hearing to the petitioner, the order so passed in Annexure-12 dated 16.12.2019, is contrary to the provisions of law and violates the principles of natural justice.

    11. Lord Reid in Ridge v. Baldwin, (1964) AC 40 : (1963) 2 All ER 66 (HL) very succinctly described it as not being capable of exact definition but what a reasonable man would regard as a fair procedure in particular circumstances.

    12. In A.K. Kraipak v. Union of India,  AIR 1970 SC 150, the apex Court held that the principles of natural justice which are meant to prevent miscarriage of justice are also applicable to domestic enquiries and administrative proceedings.

    The same view has also been taken by the apex Court in Dr. G. Sarana v. University of Lucknow,  AIR 1976 SC 2428.

    13. In State Bank of Patiala v. S.K. Sharma,  AIR 1996 SC 1669, the apex Court held that 'Natural Justice' means 'fair play in action'.

    14. In Union of India v. E.G. Nambudiri,  (1991) 3 SCC 38, the apex Court held as follows:

    "The purpose of the rules of 'natural justice' is to prevent miscarriage of justice and it is no more in doubt that the principles of natural justice are applicable to administrative orders if such orders affect the rights of a citizen. Arriving at the just decision in the aim of both quasi-judicial as well as administrative enquiry; an unjust decision in administrative enquiry may have more far reaching effect than decision in a quasi-judicial enquiry. Now, there is no doubt that the principles of natural justice are applicable even to administrative enquiries. The question is whether principles of natural justice require an administrative authority to record reasons. Generally, principles of natural justice require that opportunity of hearing should be given to the person against whom an administrative order is passed. The application of principles of natural justice, and its sweep depend upon the nature of the rights involved, having regard to the setting and context of the statutory provisions. Where a vested right is adversely affected by an administrative order, or where civil consequences ensue, principles of natural justice apply even if the statutory provisions to do not make any express provision for the same, and the person concerned must be afforded opportunity of hearing before the order is passed. But principles of natural justice do not require the administrative authority to record reasons for the decision, as there is no general rule that reasons must be given for administrative decision. Order of an administrative authority, which has no statutory or implied duty to state reasons of the grounds of its decision, is not rendered illegal merely on account of absence of reasons. It has never been a principle of natural justice that reason should be given for decision. Though the principles of natural justice do not require reasons for decision, there is necessity for giving reasons in view to enable the citizens to discover the reasonings behind the decision. Right to reasons is an indispensable part of a sound system of judicial review. Under our Constitution an administrative decision is subject to the right of a citizen, it is therefore desirable that reasons should be stated."

    15. In Suresh Chandra Nanhorya v. Rajendra Rajak,  (2006) 7 SCC 800, the apex Court held that 'Natural justice' is the essence of fair adjudication, deeply rooted in tradition and conscience, to be ranked fundamental. The purpose of following the principles of natural justice is the prevention of miscarriage of justice.

    16. In Sahara India (Firm) v. CIT,  (2008) 14 SCC 151 relying upon A.K. Kraipat v. Union of India,  (1969) 2 SCC 262, the apex Court held as follows:

    "Rules of 'natural justice' are not embodied rules. The phrase 'natural juice' is also not capable of a precise definition. The underlying principle of 'natural justice', evolved under the common law, is to check arbitrary exercise of power by the State or its functionaries, it implies a duty to act fairly i.e., fair play in action. The aim of rules of natural justice is to secure justice or to put it negatively to prevent miscarriage of justice."

    In view of the law laid down by the apex Court, as discussed above, while passing the order impugned, there is non-compliance of the principles of natural justice and the entire action has been taken in gross violation of the provisions of law and, thereby, the order impugned cannot sustain.

    17. In the counter affidavit filed by opposite party no. 6, the contention raised in paragraph-17(b) of the writ petition has remained uncontroverted, inasmuch as, no specific reply has been given with regard to conduct of inquiry. Rather, reply has been given in paragraph-11 of the counter affidavit that when the C.T. certificate produced by the petitioner was proved as fake one, opposite party no. 6 took immediate steps by lodging FIR against the petitioner and at the same time terminated him from service with immediate effect vide office order no. 2290 dated 16.12.2019. Thereby, it is specifically admitted that the provisions contained under Rule-15 of OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962 with regard to conduct of inquiry have not been followed in the present case. More so, compliance of the order dated 10.12.2019 passed by this Court in W.P. (C) No. 24972 of 2019 has not been done in letter and spirit.

    18. In view of the facts and circumstances, as well as proposition of law, as discussed above, since the impugned order dated 16.12.2019 in Annexure-12 has been passed without following due procedure of law, i.e. Rule-15 of OCS (CCA) Rules, 1962 and without complying the principles of natural justice, inasmuch as no opportunity of hearing was given to the petitioner, the same cannot sustain in the eye of law and is hereby quashed. The opposite parties are directed to reinstate the petitioner in service with immediate effect.

    19. The writ petition is thus allowed. There shall be no order as to costs.

    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    biswanath sethi v. state of odisha and ors
    (Jan 28, 2021)