G. Jayachandran, J.:— Crl.O.P. No. 6322 of 2018 is filed by S. Ramesh and another against the State, the first respondent and Dr. N. Sethuraman, who is the 2 respondent praying to quash the criminal proceedings in C.C. No. 4228 of 2015 on the file of the learned XVIII Metropolitan Magistrate, Saidapet, Chennai.
2. Crl.O.P. No. 6231 of 2018 is filed by S. Arun and 5 others against the State, the first respondent and Dr. N. Sethuraman, who is the 2 respondent praying to quash the criminal proceedings in C.C. No. 1725 of 2013 on the file of the learned XVIII Metropolitan Magistrate, Saidapet, Chennai.
3. Crl.O.P. No. 6232 of 2018 is filed by Dr. S. Brathibha against the State, the first respondent and Dr. N. Sethuraman, who is the 2 respondent praying to quash the criminal proceedings in C.C. No. 6766 of 2014 (split up from C.C. No. 1725 of 2013) on the file of the learned XVIII Metropolitan Magistrate, Saidapet, Chennai.
4. All the three criminal original petitions were allowed by this Court vide order dated 01.03.2018 based on the compromise memo dated 20.02.2018. The above said orders of this Court passed by the Hon'ble Mr. Justice M.S. Ramesh on 01.03.2018 are now sought to be recalled by the second respondent Dr. N. Sethuraman, who is the petitioner in Crl.M.P. Nos. 6611, 6612 and 6613 of 2018 and also by a third party by name G. Sakthi Saravanan, who is the petitioner in Crl.M.P. Nos. 6600, 6602 and 6604 of 2018.
5. The sum and substance of the case is that, Dr. N. Sethuraman, who is the petitioner in Crl.M.P. Nos. 6611, 6612 and 6613 of 2018 and the second respondent in Crl.O.P. Nos. 6322, 6231 and 6232 of 2018, is the founded Trustee of SR Trust at Madurai. Meenakshi Mission Hospital and Research Centre is administered by the said Trust. On 11.06.2012 the said Dr. N. Sethuraman gave a complaint to J1-Saidapet Police Station alleging that Arun and 7 others by deceit got a power of attorney registered at Saidapet Sub Registrar Office on 05.12.2011. According to Dr. N. Sethuraman, he was made to believe that the power of attorney is executed in respect of SR Trustees, after his lifetime. However, he had now come to know that except the first page of power of attorney deed, the other sheets were substituted with different content contrary to his intention. Based on the fabricated power of attorney, Arun and others have filed a suit before XVII Assistant City Civil Court, Chennai in O.S. No. 9503 of 2011 and had obtained ad-interim order of injunction against the existing trustees.
6. Based on the above said complaint, the Police has investigated the case and filed final report against S. Arun, S. Ramesh, Dr. S. Brathibha, Mariappa Sairam, Ganesh, Ganeshkumar, Jeyaraj and Vinupandian for offence under Sections 420, 465, 467, 468, 471 r/w 34 IPC and the same was taken on file by the learned Magistrate in C.C. No. 1725 of 2013. Later, the case in C.C. No. 1725 of 2013 against Mariappa Sairam was split up, due to his non-appearance and C.C. No. 6766 of 2014 was assigned to the split up case.
7. In between, a complaint under Section 156(3)Cr.P.C. was filed before the Magistrate by Dr. N. Sethuraman alleging that the accused Ramesh, S. Brathibha, Mariappa Sairam have breached the condition imposed on them while granting bail and have absconded. Despite proclamation against them under Section 82 Cr.P.C., they are not appeared before the Magistrate. Therefore, for non-appearance in response to the proclamation issued under Section 82 Cr.P.C., they are liable to be punished under Section 174 A IPC.
8. Based on the direction passed by the Magistrate, Saidapet Police Station, registered a case against Ramesh, Brathibha and Mariappa Sairam under Section 174 A IPC on 06.07.2015 in J-1 Cr. No. 1815 of 2015 and took up the investigation. Later, on completion of the investigation, final report was filed and taken up on file by XVIII Metropolitan Magistrate, Saidapet, Chennain in C.C. No. 4228 of 2015.
9. The above three criminal cases viz., C.C. No. 1725 of 2013, C.C. No. 6766 of 2014 (split up from C.C. No. 1725 of 2013) and C.C. No. 4228 of 2015 were quashed by the Hon'ble Mr. Justice M.S. Ramesh based on the compromise memo entered between the parties vide order dated 01.03.2018 passed in Crl.O.P. Nos. 6322, 6231 and 6232 of 2018.
10. These orders are now sought to be recalled by Dr. N. Sethuraman on the ground that the memo of compromise does not reflect the true state of affairs. Out of four civil suits pending between the parties, only two suits were referred in the memo of compromise. Since he was suffering from movement disorder, forget-fullness and loss of memory, he did not realize the omission in the compromise memo. Since the consent given by him in the compromise memo is not a willful consent in good state of mind, the orders passed by this Court based on the compromise memo are to be recalled.
11. As far as the contention made by the third party G. Sakthi Saravanan to recall the orders is that the order passed Criminal Original Petitions recording the presence of Dr. S. Brathibha cannot be true, since Dr. S. Brathibha is a proclaimed offender. Against her, a lookout circular has been issued. In support of his contention, he has referred a writ petition filed by Dr. S. Brathibha to quash the look out notice and other proceedings before this Court in connection with proclaiming Dr. S. Brathibha as an absconder/proclaim offender and the case pending against her under Section 174A IPC in C.C.No4228 of 2015. The said G. Sakthi Saravanan claims his locus to sustain the petition on the ground that he is one of the trustee of SR Trust and by quashing the criminal proceeding without impleading the trust and its trustees the real victims of the crime under trial in C.C. No. 1725 of 2013 etc., the parties have played fraud on the Court.
12. The learned Senior Counsel appearing for G. Sakthi Saravanan the petitioner in C.C. No. 6602 of 2018, 6604 of 2018 and 6600 of 2018 would submit that the order impugned was passed without giving an opportunity to the party concern and obtained by abuse of process of court. Hence, exercising the inherent power, the impugned order should be recalled. In facts and circumstances, like this, the provision of Section 362 Cr.P.C., which impose embargo on the Court to review will not attract.
13. In support of his submission, he refer paragraph No. 27 in the judgment rendered by the Hon'ble Supreme Court in State of Punjab v. Davinder Pal Singh Bhullar [(2010) 13 SCC 88]:
‘27. If a judgment has been pronounced without jurisdiction or in violation of principles of natural justice or where the order has been pronounced without giving an opportunity of being heard to a party affected by it or where an order was obtained by abuse of the process of court which would really amount to its being without jurisdiction, inherent powers can be exercised to recall such order for the reason that in such an eventuality the order becomes a nullity and the provisions ofSection 362Cr.P.C. would not operate. In such eventuality, the judgment is manifestly contrary to the audi alteram partem rule of natural justice. The power of recall is different from the power of altering/reviewing the judgment. However, the party seeking recall/alteration has to establish that it was not at fault. (Vide: Chitawan v. Mahboob Ilahi, 1970 Crl.L.J. 378; Deepak Thanwardas Balwani v. State of Maharashtra, 1985 Crl.L.J. 23; Habu v. The State Of Rajasthan, AIR 1987 Raj. 83 (F.B.); Swarth Mahto v. Dharmdeo Narain Singh, (1972) 2 SCC 273 : AIR 1972 SC 1300; Makkapati Nagaswara Sastri v. S.S Satyanarayan., (1981) 1 SCC 62 : AIR 1981 SC 1156; Asit Kumar Kar v. State of West Bengal, (2009) 2 SCC 703; and Vishnu Agarwal v. State of U.P., (2011) 14 SCC 813 : AIR 2011 SC 1232).’
14. Per contra, the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent would submit that the registered power of attorney deed dated 05.12.2011 which is the subject matter of the criminal prosecution, was later cancelled by Dr. N. Sethuraman on 28.12.2011. The suits, which are pending before the Sub Court, Madurai, are in respect of removal of existing trustees and appointment of new trustees through power of attorney dated 05.12.2011, which is now cancelled. The defacto complainant, who is the father of S. Ramesh, Dr. S. Brathibha and father-in-law of Mariappa Sairam, had decided to withdraw the complaint to restore peace among the family members. G. Sakthi Saravanan who is the third party and stake claim in the trust, is neither a party interested nor victim to implead himself in this case. Further, in view of Section 362 Cr.P.C., the order passed by this Court on 01.03.2018, after hearing the parties concerned and in the presence of the parties concerned, cannot be altered or recalled on the flimsy ground raised by the petitioner.
15. According to the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondents, the judgment cited by the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the petitioner is factually different from the facts of the present case. In an another case, the Hon'ble Supreme Court had held that, when the parties to the criminal proceedings are related to each other and no public interest is involved, even in case of noncompoundable offences, the criminal proceedings may be quashed to meet the ends of justice.
16. Therefore, it is contended by the learned Senior Counsel appearing for the respondent that the order passed by this Court on 01.03.2018 cannot be recalled or altered. The present petitions are filed to grab the property of Dr. N. Sethuraman, who is not keeping good health. By filing these petitions to recall the order, the petitioner G. Sakthi Saravanan and his associates are pressurizing and intimidating the son and daughter of Dr. N. Sethuraman to keep away from the affairs of S.R. Trust founded by their father.
17. Though the order to quash the criminal proceeding was passed by My Brother Judge Mr. M.S. Ramesh, J. on 01.03.2018, these petitions to recall the orders have been posted before me by the Hon'ble the Chief Justice, in view of the fact that the Brother Judge, who has passed the order, is now sitting in the Madurai Bench of Madras High Court.
18. This case has to dealt taking into consideration the factual background scenario which on perusing the records filed by the parties, this Court could see that the genesis of the litigation has commenced on 05.12.2011, when the power of attorney executed by Dr. N. Sethuraman got registered at Sub Registrar Office, Chennai. The said power of attorney deed had been cancelled by Dr. N. Sethuraman by the subsequent deed of cancellation on 28.12.2011. Only thereafter, he has lodged a complaint against Arun and others, which has culminated in C.C. No. 1725 of 2013, C.C. No. 6766 of 2014 (split up from C.C. No. 1725 of 2013) and C.C. No. 4228 of 2015. Prior to the power of attorney deed executed by Dr. N. Sethuraman, his daughter S. Barathibha and son in law Mariappa Sairam has filed O.S. No. 224 of 2010 before the Principal District Court, Madurai to pass a decree in respect of settlement of the selection of trustees and functioning of the SR Trust and also to declare the plaintiff as one of the trustee in the SR Trust. After execution of the power of attorney by Dr. N. Sethuraman, removing some of the existing trustees and nominating new trustees, the same has been challenged by S. Ramesh and P. Chinnaiyan in O.S. No. 14 of 2011 before the Principal District Judge, Madurai to declare Clause Nos. 7 and 8 of the Trust Deed providing to remove or appoint trustees by the founded trustee or his nominee is void and illegal.
19. Thereafter, O.S. No. 320 of 2011 is filed by S. Ramesh before the Sub Court, Madurai challenging the Board Resolution of SR Trust held on 17.02.2011, which removed him from the trusteeship. Dr. S. Brathibha as a lifetime Managing Trustee of SR Trust and others filed a suit O.S. No. 9503 of 2011 before the VII Assistant City Civil Court, Chennai seeking injunction restraining Dr. Gurushankar, Kamini Gurushankar, Sakthi Saravanan and Raghunathan from interfering and preventing the plaintiffs from discharging their official functions, day to day affairs and other official activities in connection with SR Trust and allied Institutions.
20. Dr. S. Gurushankar had filed a suit in O.S. No. 23 of 2012 in the capacity of Managing Trustee of SR Trust before the Sub Court, Madurai against Dr. N. Sethuraman and 12 others to declare the deed of appointment in execution of power of attorney dated 05.12.2011 executed by Dr. N. Sethuraman is null and void. In which Dr. N. Sethuraman has filed a memo submitting to decree.
21. Further facts submitted by Mr. K. Subramanian, learned Senior Counsel appearing for the third party implead petitioner is that from interim orders passed in the suits pending between the parties, two revision petitions were preferred by the aggrieved parties and against the order passed by the Hon'ble High Court in the Revision Petition, the matter was taken up to the Hon'ble Supreme Court in S.L.P. No. 9831 of 2013 and 9447 of 2012. The Hon'ble Supreme Court on 23.09.2013, appointed the Hon'ble Mr. Justice R.V. Raveendran, (Retired Judge of the Hon'ble Supreme Court) to mediate the dispute between the parties. Pursuant to this, the Hon'ble Mr. Justice R.V. Raveendran, Mediated the dispute between the parties arrived at a settlement in respect of the personal properties. Whereas, the dispute regarding the trust was left open to be decided by the Court, where the suits are pending. While disposing the Special Leave Petition, the Hon'ble Supreme Court transferred the suit pending before the VII Additional City Civil court, Chennai in O.S. No. 9503 of 2011 filed by Dr. S. Brathibha as lifetime managing trustee of SR Trust and others, to District Court, Madurai to be tried along with the other suits O.S. Nos. 14 of 2011 and 224 of 2010 pending in the District Court, Madurai. Accordingly, the suit O.S. No. 9503 of 2011 on the file of VII Assistant City Civil Court, Chennai was transferred to Madurai District Court and re-numbered as O.S. No. 60 of 2015.
22. The main contention of the petitioner counsel is that, when there is a long drawn legal battle between the parties and several litigations pending touching upon the management of trust, the power of attorney deed, which change the composition of trust by deceit and fraud and the criminal case arising out of the execution of power of attorney, born-out of deceit and fraud cannot be quashed, without hearing the victim of fraud. Hence, the order passed by this Court on 01.03.2018 is null and void and to be recalled.
23. Having gone through the details of litigations between the parties and the submissions made by the counsels, in the light of Sections 362 and 482 Cr.P.C., this Court is of the opinion that the Courts have been taken for ride by all the parties concerned by suppressing facts and suggesting falsehood. This Court records the above observation without hesitation because Dr. N. Sethuraman, who is the person, who has set the criminal law in motion, had turned topsy-turvy time and again, to suit his convenience. The other petitioners have fallen into his hands either as his supporters or adversaries. No litigant can take courts for granted and make the Court to pass some orders and later, turn around to question the same on the ground of mental illness or physical incapacity.
24. It is also to be pointed out at this juncture that the learned Senior Counsel, who represented Dr. N. Sethuraman up to the Hon'ble Supreme Court, now representing the third party before this Court and make allegation against Dr. N. Sethuraman, questioning his conduct. This Court is able to see through why Sakthi Saravanan claiming himself as a trustee question the decision of the defacto complainant to withdraw his complaint lodged against his own son and daughter.
25. So far as Dr. N. Sethuraman, who is the petitioner in other set of petitions retracting his own affidavit filed before this Court and taking umbrage under illness cannot be countenance because of his periodical swing in his stand. Initially, he had executed a power of attorney on 05.12.2011 later disowned the same cancelled it on 28.12.2011 thereafter, gave a complaint against his son, daughter and son-inlaw and few others. When his daughter and son-in-law failed to appear before the trial court, he had initiated prosecution for their abscondence. Later, he had appeared before this Court and has reported compromise entered between him and his family members. Now, he claims that the memo of compromise does not reflect the true state of affairs.
26. Be that as it may. The final report, which has culminated in C.C. No. 1725 of 2013 and C.C. No. 6766 of 2014 (split up from C.C. No. 1725 of 2013) and C.C. No. 4228 of 2015 is not the real offence against any individual. A criminal case alleging fraudulent registration of power of attorney touching upon the administration of public trust cannot be compromised between the individuals, since the beneficiaries of the public trust are the real victims of the crime. Likewise, abscondence from the clutches of law cannot be a private dispute. The parties to criminal proceedings in Crl.O.P. Nos. 6231, 6232 and 6322 of 2018 are not legally entitled to upset the criminal proceedings by way of compromise memo even assuming it to be true and genuine.
27. SR Trust is a public trust running hospital and rendering service to the people in and around Madurai City. The beneficiaries of the Trust are the public. An attempt to undermining the administration of the trust by creating fraudulent document cannot be considered as a private dispute or a crime compoundable or a crime, which could be quashed at the instance of the individuals.
28. Crime against the State and general public should be viewed differently from the crime against the individual. In this case, due to suppression of facts by the parties concerned, this Court has been mislead to quash the criminal proceedings vide its order dated 01.03.2018. Therefore, this Court recalls the order passed in Crl.O.P. Nos. 6231, 6232 and 6322 of 2015 as void and non est in the eye of law.
29. For the reasons stated above, the order in Crl.O.P. Nos. 6231 of 2018, 6232 of 2018 and 6322 of 2018 passed on 01.03.2018 is recalled and the Criminal Original Petitions are dismissed as devoid of merits. Consequently, all other connected Miscellaneous Petitions are closed.