S.C Das, J.:— By filing this writ petition, the petitioner challenged the judgment and order dated 26.07.2013 passed by the Central Administrative Tribunal, Guwahati Bench (for short, CAT, Guwahati Bench) passed in OA No. 289 of 2012 and subsequent order dated 10.07.2014 passed by the same tribunal in Review Application No. 1 of 2014 arising out of OA No. 289 of 2012 and further prayed for directing the respondents to consider the promotion of the petitioner without taking into consideration the ACR of the year 2007-08 and APAR of the year 2008-09.
2. We have heard the petitioner-in-person and learned CGC, Mr. A Roy Barman for the respondent-Union of India.
3. The petitioner, while was working as Sr. Deputy Accountant General in the Office of the Accountant General (Audit), Tripura, Agartala by filing Original Application No. 289/2012 before the CAT (Guwahati Bench) sought for the following reliefs:-
8.1 “That the Hon'ble Tribunal be pleased to set aside and quash the impugned letter No. CPF/A.Ar.G(P)/2007.Pt.II CR 851 dated 09.09.2010 (Annexure-7) and impugned order dated 02.05.2011 (Annexure-15).
8.2 The Hon'ble Tribunal be pleased to direct the respondent that the grading of ‘very good’ awarded by the reviewing officer without assigning any reason in ACR of the applicant for the year 2004-05 be ignored and further be pleased to direct the respondent that the grading of ‘outstanding’ given by the reporting officer for the said year 2004-05 be taken into consideration for the purpose of promotion of the applicant to the grade of Senior Administrative Grade.
8.3 That the Hon'ble Tribunal be pleased to declare that the ACRs/APAR for the year 2005-06, 2006-07, 2007-08 and 2008-09 are incomplete, invalid as written in violation of relevant instructions/norms/rules of DoP&T as well as of the respondent department and also in violation of the principles of natural justice and further be pleased to direct the respondent to hold the DPC meeting to consider the promotion of the applicant to grade of SAG, as per decision contained in para 5, 6(b) and 7(b) of the DPC proceedings held on 18.06.2010, ignoring the uncommunicated, unreviewed, incomplete, invalid, blank, below benchmark graded ACRS/APAR for the year 2005-06, 2006-07, 2007-08 and 2008-09 and further be pleased to direct the respondents to take into consideration the grading of the relevant ACRs of the previous years in the light of the instruction contained in the DoP&T O.M dated 20th June, 1989 read with the corrigendum dated 13 July, 1989 while considering the case of the applicant for promotion to the grade of Senior Administrative Grade with all consequential service benefits including seniority at least from the date of promotion of his batchmates/juniors to the grade of Senior Administrative Grade.”
4. The grievance of the petitioner before the Tribunal was that his ACRs of the year 2005-06 (2nd spell), 2006-07, 2007-08, and APAR of 2008-09 were recorded below the benchmark, violating the standing instructions issued by the DoPT and the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General time to time and also violating the principles enunciated by the Apex Court in numerous case laws in respect of writing of ACRs and thereby he was deprived fro due promotion with his batch mates in July, 2010.
5. The Tribunal disposed the OA No. 289 of 2012 by order dated 27.07.2013 with the following decision:
“47. In our considered view the uncommunicated adverse entry in the ACRs as well as the expunged ACRs which are blank and unreviewed (due to retirement of Reviewing Officer) and any remarks from the Reviewing Officer which are kept in blank have to be ignored.
48. In the result the O.A is disposed of with a direction to the respondents to hold the Review DPC for considering the applicant for promotion to the post of Senior Administrative Grade by ignoring the ACR for the year 2005-06 (2 spell) and 2006-07 to consider the ACRs of preceding year 2005-06(Part-I). The Review DPC shall be convened within 5 months from the date of receipt of a certified copy of this order. There will be no order as to costs.”
6. By dint of the above order the Tribunal partly allowed the prayer for the petitioner in respect of his ACR of the year 2005-06 (2 spell) and of the year 2006-07 but the Tribunal did not pass any order in respect of the ACRs of the year 2007-08 and APAR of the year 2008-09.
7. The petitioner, therefore, filed review application No. 01/2014 before the Tribunal seeking review of the order dated 26.07.2013 and the review application was dismissed with the following order:
“4. Examining the contentions raised in the present R.A on the touchstone of aforesaid law, we are of the considered view that the application has failed to point out any error apparent on the face of record.
5. In view of the above, we find no merit in the present R.A and the same is accordingly dismissed.”
8. Felt aggrieved, the present writ petition is filed by the petitioner.
9. At the very outset, it is submitted by the petitioner that the Tribunal interfered in respect of the ACR for the year 2005-06(2 spell) and 2006-07 whereas the Tribunal did not interfere in respect of the ACR of the year 2007-08 and APA for the year 2008-09 though those two ACR/APARs were also suffering from the same mischief as that of the ACRs of the year 2005-06 and 2006-07.
10. It is an admitted position that an entry below the benchmark in the ACR of an employee amounts to ‘adverse remark’ and according to the petitioner an adverse entry made in the ACR of 2007-08 was not at all known to the petitioner since the entry was made behind his back without informing him anything and immediately before the DPC held in the year 2010 a communication was made to him and that amounts to no communication in the eye of law. He has also submitted that the APAR of the year 2008-09 was also suffering from the same wrong as held by the Tribunal in its order dated 26.07.2013 since the adverse entries were expunged subsequently whereas after expunction no further entry was made and so that APAR was also incomplete and the Tribunal would arrive at a conclusion that the ACR of the year 2007-08 and the APAR of the year 2008-09 also were liable to be ignored while considering the promotion of the petitioner.
11. The petitioner argued that he was performing his duties with all sincerity and devotion and there was no occasion that he was advised by his superior authority to rectify his performance on any count or that he was not doing his job in a proper manner. His all ACRs prior and subsequent to those four years were consistently at par or above the required benchmark and there was no occasion that he was graded below the benchmark on any occasion prior to and after those four years. It is emphatically submitted by the petitioner that he was never made aware of his defects or shortcomings during the period of his service prior to and during those four years. The reporting authority did not make any objective assessment of the performance of the petitioner and ignoring all guidelines and communications issued by the DoPT and the Comptroller and Auditor General, recorded adverse remarks in the ACRs. At no point of time he was made aware of any shortcoming in his works, conduct or performance by any sort of official communication and therefore no opportunity was afforded to him to improve in respect of any shortcomings or defect, if any, noticed by the reporting authority. He made representation against the adverse remarks to the superior authority but his representation was simply turned down without assigning any reason. According to the petitioner, fairness and transparency has deliberately been given a good bye while recording the ACRs of the petitioner for the year 2007-08 and APAR for the year 2008-09. The Tribunal failed to exercise its jurisdiction in accordance with law and therefore the petitioner is deprived of the justice according to law and hence he prayed for allowing the writ petition.
12. Learned CGC, Mr. A Roy Barman appearing for the respondent-Union of India placed before this Court the record along with the original ACRs/APAR and submitted that there was no valid reason at all assigned by the reporting officer for grading the petitioner below the benchmark and that all the ACRs/APARs of the petitioner before and after those questioned years were excellent and brilliant. He has submitted that the respondent has nothing to oppose the prayer of the petitioner and that the Tribunal would direct that the ACR of the year 2007-08 and the APAR of the year 2008-09 were also suffering from the same mischief as that of the 2 spell ACR of 2005-06 and ACR of 2006-07. He has also submitted that there was injustice occasioned on the petitioner and so he has nothing to oppose the contention of the petitioner raised in the writ petition.
13. Assessment of performance and recording of ACR of an employee is the job of the administrative authority of the particular employee. It is expected that the superior authority would be doing the job in accordance with law keeping in mind that it is for the improvement of quality and excellence as well as efficiency in the public service. The superior officer who would be writing the ACRs is expected to show objectivity, impartiality and fair assessment of the performance of the subordinate employee with the highest sense of responsibility as well as honesty and integrity keeping in mind to improve the excellence of the individual employee. Once ACR is recorded by the superior authority in accordance with the procedure prescribed and following the objectives behind, a court of law is not required ordinarily sit over it like an appellate authority.
14. We are aware that the power of judicial review of the decision of administrative tribunal is very limited. The Supreme Court in Swapan Kumar Pal v. Achintya Kumar Nayak, reported in (2008) 1 SCC 379 has observed that for exercising the power of judicial review the Court has a limited role to play. It could interfere only if any legal error has been committed in the decision making process. It could not enter into the merit of the decision.
15. It is also a settled position that while exercising the power of judicial review the Court should not sit as an appellate authority and the Court should remain confined to see whether the decision has been taken according to the settled principles of law or not.
16. Learned CGC, Mr. Roy Barman has fairly admitted that there is nothing to show any communication made to the petitioner to improve his performance or that there was any advise, warning or shortcoming noticed by the reporting officer or reviewing officer and such shortcoming, advise or warning was communicated to the petitioner and that the petitioner failed to follow it. The petitioner alleged absence of objectivity in recording adverse remarks. He has also alleged that the Tribunal did not give any decision in respect of ACRs for the year 2007-08 and 2008-09 though those ACRs were also suffering from the same mischief as that of the other two ACRs challenged in the Original Application before the Tribunal.
17. The Supreme Court in the case of State Bank of India v. Kashinath Kher, (1996) 8 SCC 762 in para 15 has observed:
“15. ………. The object of writing the confidential report is two-fold, i. e. to give an opportunity to the officer to remove deficiencies and to inculcate discipline. Secondly, it seeks to serve improvement of quality and excellence and efficiency of public service. This Court in Delhi Transport Corporation's case (AIR 1991 SC 101) pointed out pitfalls and insidious effects on service due to lack of objectives by the controlling officer. Confidential and character reports should, therefore, be written by superior officers higher above the cadres. The officer should show objectivity, impartiality and fair assessment without any prejudices whatsoever with the highest sense of responsibility alone to inculcate devotion to duty, honesty and integrity to improve excellence of the individual officer. Lest the officers get demoralised which would be deleterious to the efficacy and efficiency of public service. Therefore, they should be written by a superior officer of high rank, who are such high rank officers is for the appellant to decide. The appellants have to prescribe the officer competent to write the confidentials. There should be another higher officer in rank above the officer who has written confidential report to review such report. The appointing authority or any equivalent officer would be competent to approve the confidential reports or character rolls. This procedure would be fair and reasonable. The reports thus written would form the basis for consideration for promotion. The procedure presently adopted is clearly illegal, unfair and unjust.”
18. In the case of UP Jal Nigam v. Prabhat Ch. Jain reported in (1996) 2 SCC 363, the Apex Court in para 3 of the judgment has observed:-
“3. ……… As we view it the extreme illustration given by the High Court may reflect an adverse element compulsorily communicable, but if the graded entry is of going a step down, like falling from ‘very good’ to ‘good’ that may not ordinarily be an adverse entry since both are a positive grading. All what is required by the Authority recording confidentials in the situation is to record reasons for such down grading on the personal file of the officer concerned, and inform him of the change in the form of an advice. If the variation warranted be not permissible, then the very purpose of writing annual confidential reports would be frustrated. Having achieved an optimum level the employee on his part may slacken in his work, relaxing secure by his one time achievement. This would be an undesirable situation. All the same the sting of adverseness must, in all events, be not reflected in such variations, as otherwise they shall be communicated as such. It may be emphasised that even a positive confidential entry in a given case can perilously be adverse and to say that an adverse entry should always be qualitatively damaging may not be true. In the instant case we have seen the service record of the first respondent. No reason for the change is mentioned. The down grading is reflected by comparison. This cannot sustain. Having explained in this manner the case of the first respondent and the system that should prevail in the Jal Nigam, we do not find any difficulty in accepting the ultimate result arrived at by the High Court.”
19. In the case of Sukhdeo v. Commissioner, Amaravati Division, reported in (1996) 5 SCC 103, the Supreme Court in para 6 of the judgment observed:
6. It is settled law that when the government resorts to compulsorily retire a government servant, the entire record of service, particularly, in the last period of service is required to be closely scrutinised and the power would be reasonably exercised. In State Bank of India v. Kashinath Kher (para 15), this court had held that the controlling officer while writing confidential and character roll report, should be a superior officer higher above the cadres of the officer whose confidential reports are written. Such officer should show objectivity, impartiality and fair assessment without any prejudice whatsoever with highest sense of responsibility to inculcate in the officer's devotion to duty, honesty and integrity so as to improve excellence of the individual officer, lest the officers get demoralised which would be deleterious to the efficacy and efficiency of public service. In that case it was pointed out that confidential reports written and submitted by the officer of the same cadre and adopted without any independent scrutiny and assessment by the committee was held to be illegal. In this case, the power exercised is illegal and it is not expected of from that high responsible officer who made the remarks. When an officer makes the remarks he must eschew making vague remarks causing jeopardy to the service of the subordinate officer. He must bestow careful attention to collect all correct and truthful information and give necessary particulars when he seeks to make adverse remarks against the subordinate officer whose career prospect and service were in jeopardy. In this case, the controlling officer has not used due diligence in making remarks. It would be salutary that the controlling officer before writing adverse remarks would give prior sufficient opportunity in writing by informing him of the deficiency he noticed for improvement. In spite of the opportunity given if the officer/employee does not improve then it would be an obvious fact and would form material basis in support of the adverse remarks. It should also be mentioned that he had given prior opportunity in writing for improvement and yet was not availed of so that it would form part of the record.”
20. The petitioner specifically referred to the Comptroller and Auditor General's Manual of Standing Orders (Administrative), Page-124, Clause-d which reads as follows:
“(d) The officer should be made aware of the defects to which attention is drawn in the report, and no attempt should be made to differentiate between a remediable and an irremediable defect. Any report containing adverse remarks which the Comptroller and Auditor General accepts as material or where the Comptroller and Auditor General finds a report to be indicative of a material fall in the standard of work and conduct of the officer, will be sent to the Head of the office with instructions that it is to be shown to the officer concerned, his signature obtained upon it and the report returned to the Assistant Comptroller and Auditor General (Personnel) by name. Any remarks on an officer's report which show that he has taken steps to remedy defects to which his attention had been drawn in a previous year should be communicated to him so that he may know that his efforts to improve have not passed unnoticed: such communications will be made by the Comptroller and Auditor General.”
21. The petitioner referred to Government of India, DoPT's instruction wherein it is clearly stated -
“It is necessary that every Government servant should know what his defects are and how he could remove them. Every reporting officer should realise that it is his duty not only to make an objective assessment of his subordinate's work and qualities but also to give him at all times the necessary advice, guidance and assistance to correct his faults and deficiencies. If this part of the Reporting Officer's duty is properly performed, there should be no difficulty about recording adverse entries, which would only refer to defects which had persisted despite the Reporting Officer's efforts to have them corrected.”
22. The petitioner further referred to the letter dated 18.07.2007 issued by the Assistant Comptroller and Auditor General from the Office of the Comptroller and Auditor General of India addressed to the Principal Accountant General and copy of that letter was annexed as Annexure-5 to the Original Application. The contents of that letter read as follows:
“OFFICE OF THE COMPTROLLER & AUDITOR GENERAL OF INDIA
NEW DELHI-110 002
Confidential
No. 59-A, Ar.G(P)/89
Dated: 18.7.2007
Shri. Niranjan Pant
Pr. Accountant General (C&RA)
Gujarat,
Audit bhavan, Near Commerce Six Rd.
Navrangpura,
Ahmedabad-380 009
Subject: Bench mark for promotion: Advice to Group Officers to improve their performance.
Sir/Madam,
Kindly refer to this office letter of even no. dated 16.7.2002 (copy enclosed) regarding DOP&T's instructions on promotions by Selection in Group ‘A’. According to these instructions, the bench mark for promotion to the level of Senior Deputy Accountant General (Rs. 12000-16500) and Senior Administrative Grade of IA&AS (Rs. 18400-22400) is ‘Very Good’.
2. At the beginning of the financial year (by April 15), the Group Officers must be given quantifiable personal targets, which they are expected to achieve during the year. In order that the officers whose performance is not satisfactory and below the bench-mark get an opportunity to improve, you are requested to advise such officers in writing during the course of the year, preferably before September, about their shortcomings and what they must do to improve.
3. Receipt of the letter and the enclosure may kindly be acknowledged.
Yours faithfully,
Sd/- Illegible
(Deepak Narain)
Assistant Comptroller &
Auditor General (Personnel).”
23. The petitioner has also referred to the manual of Standing Orders, Volume-I and submitted that there was instruction of the Comptroller and Auditory General which was as follows:
“Before comments which are likely to be considered as adverse are recorded, the reporting officer should be advised to ensure that the officer reported upon was warned of the defects and exerted to improve his work and conduct. Such warnings may be given in writing but if they are administered orally a suitable record of it should be kept by the reporting officer and similar warnings might be issued also in cases where a noticeable fall in standard of work and conduct of the officer reported upon occurs.”
24. The Supreme Court in the case of State of UP v. Yamuna Shanker Mishra, reported in (1997) 4 SCC 7, in paragraph 7 has observed:
“7. It would, thus, be clear that the object of writing the confidential reports and making entries in the character rolls is to give an opportunity to a public servant to improve excellence. Article 51-A(j) enjoins upon every citizen the primary duty to constantly endeavour to prove excellence, individually and collectively, as a member of the group. Given an opportunity, the individual employee strives to improve excellence and thereby efficiency of administration would be augmented. The officer entrusted with the duty to write confidential reports, has a public responsibility and trust to write the confidential reports objectively, fairly and dispassionately while giving, as accurately as possible, the statement of facts on an overall assessment of the performance of the subordinate officer. It should be founded upon the facts or circumstances. Though sometimes, it may not be part of the record, but the conduct, reputation and character acquire public knowledge or notoriety and may be within his knowledge. Before forming an opinion to be adverse, the reporting officers writing confidentials should share the information which is not a part of the record with the officer concerned, have the information confronted by the officer and then make it part of the record. This amounts to an opportunity given to the erring/corrupt officer to correct the errors of the judgment, conduct, behaviour, integrity or conduct/corrupt proclivity. If, despite being given such an opportunity, the officer fails to perform the duty, correct his conduct or improve himself, necessarily, the same may be recorded in the confidential reports and a copy thereof supplied to the affected officer so that he will have an opportunity to know the remarks made against him. If he feels aggrieved, it would be open to him to have it corrected by appropriate representation to the higher authorities or any appropriate judicial forum for redressal. Thereby, honesty, integrity, good conduct and efficiency get improved in the performance of public duties and standard of excellence in services constantly rises to higher levels and it becomes successful tool to manage the services with officers of integrity, honesty, efficiency and devotion.”
25. In the case of MA Rajshekhar v. State of Karnataka reported in (1996) 10 SCC 369, the Apex Court in para 5 of the judgment observed:
“5. It was found that his integrity was not doubted and his work also in all those respects was found to be satisfactory. Under those circumstances, the remark that he “does not act dispassionately when faced with dilemma” must be pointed out with reference to specific instances in which he did not perform that duty satisfactorily so that he would have an opportunity to correct himself of the mistake. He should be given an opportunity in the cases where he did not work objectively or satisfactorily. Admittedly, no such opportunity was given. Even when he acted in a dilemma and lacked objectivity, in such circumstances, he must be guided by the authority as to the manner in which he acted upon. Since this exercise has not been done by the respondents, it would be obvious that the above adverse remark was not consistent with law.”
26. The petitioner also referred to the decision of the Jammu & Kashmir High Court as well as the decision of the Gujarat High Court wherein also similar observations have been made by the Hon'ble High Courts of Jammu & Kashmir and Gujarat and since there are Supreme Court decisions on this point, we do not like to quote here the observations of those Hon'ble High Courts on the issue.
27. It is an admitted position that the petitioner was never informed about his deficiencies, shortcomings, etc., in respect of his performance. There is no material placed to show that the petitioner was warned or advised about his any shortcomings or his conduct or that the reporting authority communicated its displeasure regarding any act or omission on the part of the petitioner. Under such circumstances, what actually prompted the reporting authority or reviewing authority to record an adverse entry in the ACR of those years has not been placed before us. We are, therefore, of the view that the adverse remarks in the ACRs of 2007-08 and the APAR of 2008-09 were recorded without any objectivity.
28. It is the admitted position that adverse entry in the ACR of the 2007-08 was communicated in the year 2010 before the DPC meeting. The Tribunal in para 42 of the judgment has referred O.M dated 11.05.1990 We are inclined to quote here para 42 of the judgment of the Tribunal which reads as follows:
“42. The O.M No. 22011/3/88-Estt.(D), dated the 11 May, 1990 stipulate here under:
“Where the Departmental Promotion Committee find that the adverse remarks in the Confidential Report of an officer have not been communicated to him but the adverse remarks are sufficient gravity to influence their assessment of the officer concerned, then the Committee shall defer consideration of the case of the officer, provided these remarks have been recorded in any of the CRs pertaining to three immediately preceding years prior to the year in which the DPC is held and direct the cadre controlling authority concerned to communicate the averse remarks to the officer concerned so that he may have an opportunity to make a representation against the same. Where the uncommunicated adverse remarks pertain to a period earlier than the above or where the remarks are not considered of sufficient gravity to influence the assessment of the officer concerned, the DPC may proceed with the consideration of the case but may ignore the remarks while making the assessment.”
29. The Supreme Court in the case of Deb Dutta v. Union of India, (2008) 8 SCC 725 in para 17 and 18 of the judgment observed:
“17. In our opinion, every entry in the A.C.R, of a public servant must be communicated to him within a reasonable period, whether it is a poor, fair, average, good or very good entry. This is because noncommunication of such an entry may adversely affect the employee in two ways: (1) Had the entry been communicated to him he would know about the assessment of his work and conduct by his superiors, which would enable him to improve his work in future (2) He would have an opportunity of making a representation against the entry if he feels it is unjustified, and pray for its upgradation. Hence noncommunication of an entry is arbitrary, and it has been held by the Constitution Bench decision of this Court in Maneka Gandhi v. Union of India (supra) that arbitrariness violates Article 14 of the Constitution.
18. Thus it is not only when there is a bench-mark but in all cases that an entry (whether it is poor, fair, average, good or very good) must be communicated to a public servant, otherwise there is violation of the principle of fairness, which is the soul of natural justice. Even an outstanding entry should be communicated since that would boost the morale of the employee and make him work harder.”
30. In the case of Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar v. Union of India, reported in (2009) 16 SCC 146 the Supreme Court in para 4 of the judgment observed:
“4) It is not in dispute that the CAT, Patna Bench passed an order recommending the authority not to rely on the order of caution dated 22.09.1997 and the order of adverse remarks dated 09.06.1998 In view of the said order, one obstacle relating to his promotion goes. Coming to the second aspect, that though the benchmark “very good” is required for being considered for promotion admittedly the entry of “good” was not communicated to the appellant. The entry of ‘good’ should have been communicated to him as he was having “very good” in the previous year. In those circumstances, in our opinion, non-communication of entries in the ACR of a public servant whether he is in civil, judicial, police or any other service (other than the armed forces), it has civil consequences because it may affect his chances for promotion or get other benefits. Hence, such non-communication would be arbitrary and as such violative of Article 14 of the Constitution. The same view has been reiterated in the above referred decision relied on by the appellant. Therefore, the entries “good” if at all granted to the appellant, the same should not have been taken into consideration for being considered for promotion to the higher grade. The respondent has no case that the appellant had ever been informed of the nature of the grading given to him.”
31. Referring to the case of Dev Dutt and Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar (Supra) the Hon'ble Delhi High court in judgment dated 31.05.2012 in WP(C) 5042 of 2002 in para 14 has observed that the communication at the time of consideration by the DPC shall not serve any purpose. In para 14 of the judgment the Delhi High Court observed:
“14. However, the Supreme Court in Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar (supra) went further and observed categorically that, therefore, the entries “good”, if at all granted to the appellant, ought not to have been taken into consideration for being considered for promotion to the higher grade. What this meant was that the below benchmark ACRs, which had not been communicated to an employee, ought not to be taken into consideration for the purposes of considering the promotion of that employee to a higher grade. We must also distinguish between the stage when ACRs are written and the stage when they are considered by the DPC. What Dev Dutt (supra) and, indeed, Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar (supra) hold in unison is that the ACRs must be communicated to the concerned employee/officer soon after it is written. Because, its noncommunication is contrary to the provisions of Article 14 of the Constitution. But, this is at the stage when the ACRs are recorded or shortly thereafter. The objective of communicating the ACRs is two-fold. In the first place, as an element of natural justice, the officer concerned gets an opportunity of representing against the ACR before it is too late. Secondly, it also informs and warns the officer concerned that his performance is not upto the mark so that he may improve himself in the next year. However, at the stage of the DPC, the ACRs already stand crystallized and their communication then may not serve any fruitful purpose apart from informing the concerned employee/officer and, perhaps, enabling him to represent against it. But, the second aspect of improvement is lost. Consequently, at the stage of the DPC meeting the practical approach would be to not consider the uncommunicated ACRs as held Abhijit Ghosh Dastidar (supra).”
32. Since, it is the admitted position that the ACR of the year 2007-08 was communicated only before the DPC held in the year 2010, it amounts to no communication in the eye of law.
33. It is also an admitted position that the original remarks made in the APAR of the year 2008-09 were expunged and it was left blank. The Tribunal in para 45 of the judgment observed:
“45. The D.G, P&T, letter No. 27-2/83-Vig.II, dated the 9 January, 1984 is stipulated here under:
“26. Column of report should not be kept blank after expunction of adverse remarks. It has been observed that in a few cases, after the expunction of the adverse remarks, the relevant column(s) was/were left blank, i.e without any remarks, thus making the report incomplete.
It may be appreciated that an incomplete report cannot be relied upon for a fair and objective assessment of the officer concerned for his confirmation, promotion, etc. It is essential that the annual confidential reports are complete in all respects. In the circumstances, where on consideration of a representation against new adverse remarks, the competent authority comes to the conclusion that the remarks deserve to be expunged, it should see whether total expunction of the remarks will leave the relevant columns(s) blank; and if it finds the position to be so, it should order modification of the relevant remarks in a suitable manner so that the column(s) in question does/do not remain blank.”
34. While it is the admitted position that the columns in APAR of the year 2008-09 was left blank, the Tribunal would apply the same principle while deciding the Original Application in the same manner as that of the ACR of the year 2005-06 and 2006-07.
35. We are of the considered opinion that there is no material placed before us to show that there was objectivity in the recording of adverse remark in the ACR of the year 2007-08 and APAR of the year 2008-09 and there was no communication made to the petitioner before recording those ACRs that the petitioner was guilty of any shortcomings in his performance and/or conduct or character and while there is no such material we are of the considered opinion that the adverse entries were made without any objectivity and further the adverse entry in the ACR of the year 2007-08 were not communicated to the petitioner immediately after the entries to enable him to make representation as well as to improve his performance and in respect of APAR of 2008-09 we find that the columns were kept blank after expunction of remarks which was not permissible and therefore, we direct that the ACR of 2007-08 and APAR of 2008-09 shall be ignored and shall not be taken into consideration for the purpose of considering promotion of the petitioner which was due to him and the respondents pursuant to the order of the CAT while would be holding review DPC should ignore the ACR of the year 2007-08 and APAR of the year 2008-09.
36. The writ petition is accordingly allowed and disposed of. Parties to bear their own costs.
37. Return the records submitted by learned CGC.