Translate
Text Highlighter

Bookmark

PDF

Share

Report a problem
AMICUS AI
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 63(2) and 63(3) of the DERA, 2000 and Sections 185(2)(a) and (5) of the Electricity Act, 2003, read with Licence Condition 23.1, and Condition 22(b)
  • Section 20 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 read with Rule 57 of the Indian Electricity Rules, 1956,
  • Section 26 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 and Section 49 of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948
  • provisions of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 and the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948,
  • Rule 10(2) of the Delhi Electricity Reforms (Transfer Scheme) Rules, 2001
  • provisions of this Act, the State Electricity Regulatory Commission
  • Indian Electricity Act, 1910 and the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948.
  • reservations.39. Section 26(7) of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910
  • Section 21 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1948 and Section 63
  • Indian Electricity Act, 1910, Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948,
  • Sections 53 and 55 of the Indian Electricity Act, 2003,
  • Delhi Electricity Reforms Transfer Scheme Rules, 2001.
  • Sections 14, 15(1) and 15(2) of DERA read with Rules 3
  • Sections 26(1) and 26(7) of the Electricity Act, 1910
  • Section 42(6) of the Indian Electricity Act, 2003,
  • Section 26(1) of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910,
  • SECTION 55 ELECTRICITY ACT
  • Rule 57(i) of the Indian Electricity Rules, 1956.
  • Section 20 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910
  • Rule 57 of the Indian Electricity Rules, 1956
  • Rule 57 of the Electricity Supply Rules, 1956
  • Section 185(2)(c) of the Electricity Act, 2003.
  • Section 20 of the Indian Electricity Act,
  • Section 55(1) of the Electricity Act, 2003,
  • ELECTRICITY ACT 2003
  • Delhi Electricity Reform Act, 2000 (DERA),
  • SECTION 55 ELECTRICITY ACT 2003
  • Delhi Electricity Reforms Act, 2000.
  • SECTION 26 ELECTRICITY ACT
  • Section 63(3) of the DERA, 2000
  • Indian Electricity Rules, 1956,
Are you a practicing lawyer?
Enhance your digital presence and reach by creating a Casemine profile.
Upload pleading to use the new AI search
Cites
Cited by
Citation Codes
Equivalent Citations
citation codes
Case Number
Judges
Acts
  • Sections 63(2) and 63(3) of the DERA, 2000 and Sections 185(2)(a) and (5) of the Electricity Act, 2003, read with Licence Condition 23.1, and Condition 22(b)
  • Section 20 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 read with Rule 57 of the Indian Electricity Rules, 1956,
  • Section 26 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 and Section 49 of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948
  • provisions of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 and the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948,
  • Rule 10(2) of the Delhi Electricity Reforms (Transfer Scheme) Rules, 2001
  • provisions of this Act, the State Electricity Regulatory Commission
  • Indian Electricity Act, 1910 and the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948.
  • reservations.39. Section 26(7) of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910
  • Section 21 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1948 and Section 63
  • Indian Electricity Act, 1910, Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948,
  • Sections 53 and 55 of the Indian Electricity Act, 2003,
  • Delhi Electricity Reforms Transfer Scheme Rules, 2001.
  • Sections 14, 15(1) and 15(2) of DERA read with Rules 3
  • Sections 26(1) and 26(7) of the Electricity Act, 1910
  • Section 42(6) of the Indian Electricity Act, 2003,
  • Section 26(1) of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910,
  • SECTION 55 ELECTRICITY ACT
  • Rule 57(i) of the Indian Electricity Rules, 1956.
  • Section 20 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910
  • Rule 57 of the Indian Electricity Rules, 1956
  • Rule 57 of the Electricity Supply Rules, 1956
  • Section 185(2)(c) of the Electricity Act, 2003.
  • Section 20 of the Indian Electricity Act,
  • Section 55(1) of the Electricity Act, 2003,
  • ELECTRICITY ACT 2003
  • Delhi Electricity Reform Act, 2000 (DERA),
  • SECTION 55 ELECTRICITY ACT 2003
  • Delhi Electricity Reforms Act, 2000.
  • SECTION 26 ELECTRICITY ACT
  • Section 63(3) of the DERA, 2000
  • Indian Electricity Rules, 1956,
Smart Summary

Factual and Procedural Background

The writ appeal arises from a challenge to the judgment of the learned Single Judge dated 14.12.2005. The petitioner, a registered consumer of electricity at 134, 1st Floor, Sunder Nagar, New Delhi, sought to declare illegal and mala fide the replacement of his originally installed electro-mechanical electricity meter by a new electronic meter by the respondents. The petitioner alleged that the original meter was correct and functioning properly under Rule 57 of the Electricity Supply Rules, 1956, and that the replacement meter caused inflated electricity bills. The petitioner prayed for quashing the meter testing report dated 3.3.2005 and for a writ of mandamus directing refund of excess charges billed after the meter replacement on 26.4.2003. The respondent, BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd. (BRPL), filed counter affidavits defending the replacement as part of a policy to upgrade meters in line with power sector reforms and regulatory directives. The appeal challenges the Single Judge’s dismissal of the writ petition.

Legal Issues Presented

  1. Whether the respondent licensee had the legal authority to replace the petitioner’s electro-mechanical meter with an electronic meter.
  2. Whether the replacement meter was accurate and functioning properly as per applicable rules and regulations.
  3. Whether the petitioner’s remedy lay in a writ petition or through statutory consumer grievance forums under the Indian Electricity Act, 2003.
  4. Whether there was any legal vacuum or procedural irregularity due to non-framing of regulations under Sections 53 and 55 of the Electricity Act, 2003.

Arguments of the Parties

Appellant's Arguments

  • The appellant contended that the respondent had no power to replace the existing electro-mechanical meter with an electronic meter.
  • The appellant alleged that the original meter was correct and working properly under Rule 57 of the Electricity Supply Rules, 1956.
  • The appellant claimed the new electronic meter caused inflated readings and excessive billing.
  • The appellant argued that regulations under Sections 53 and 55 of the Electricity Act, 2003, had not been framed, creating a legal vacuum affecting the legitimacy of the meter replacement.

Respondent's Arguments

  • The respondent justified the replacement as part of a policy to replace old, inaccurate electro-mechanical meters with more reliable, tamper-proof electronic meters pursuant to power sector reforms and regulatory directives.
  • The respondent relied on statutory provisions including Sections 20, 21, 26 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910, the Delhi Electricity Reforms Act, 2000, and the Electricity Act, 2003, to assert authority to replace meters.
  • The respondent emphasized the accuracy, reliability, and anti-tamper features of electronic meters, supported by certifications from BIS, CPRI, and DERC surveys and tests.
  • The respondent pointed out that the petitioner had alternative remedies through consumer grievance forums and ombudsman under Sections 42(5) and 42(6) of the Indian Electricity Act, 2003.
  • The respondent submitted that the absence of regulations under Sections 53 and 55 of the Electricity Act, 2003, did not create a legal vacuum and that the old legal regime continued until regulations were framed.

Table of Precedents Cited

Precedent Rule or Principle Cited For Application by the Court
Belwal Spinning Mills Ltd. v. U.P State Electricity Board, (1997) 6 SCC 740 Licensee’s power to enter premises, inspect, test, and alter meters under Section 20 of Indian Electricity Act, 1910. The Court relied on this precedent to uphold the licensee’s authority to replace the meter without adjudicating on meter correctness.
Ram Kishan v. NDPL, LPA 746/2004 Availability of alternative remedies through consumer forums and ombudsman under Sections 42(5) and 42(6) of Indian Electricity Act, 2003. The Court emphasized that writ petitions should not ordinarily be entertained where statutory grievance mechanisms exist.
Peenya Industries Association v. Karnataka State Electricity, AIR 1998 Karnataka 369 Power of electricity boards to replace meters with more sophisticated equipment. The Court agreed with this decision rejecting the petitioner’s contention against meter replacement.
Punjab State Electricity v. Bassi Cold Storage, 1994 Supp (2) SCC 125 Binding and statutory nature of Conditions of Supply. Supported the continued applicability of Conditions of Supply empowering licensees regarding meter specifications.
Bihar State Electricity Board v. Parmeshwar, (1996) 4 SCC 686 Validity of Conditions of Supply and licensee’s powers. Reinforced the binding nature of Conditions of Supply and licensee’s authority.
Hyderabad Vanaspati Ltd. v. A.P State Electricity Board, (1998) 4 SCC 470 Authority of electricity boards under Conditions of Supply. Confirmed the licensee’s powers under Conditions of Supply.
The Mysore State Road Transport Corporation v. Gopinath Gundachar Char, AIR 1968 SC 464 General principles of statutory powers and functions. The Court agreed this precedent was applicable to the case facts supporting licensee’s powers.
UPSEB v. City Board Mussoorie, (1985) 2 SCC 16 Statutory powers of licensees under electricity laws. Used to support the powers exercised by the respondent licensee.

Court's Reasoning and Analysis

The Court observed that the replacement of electro-mechanical meters by electronic meters was a policy decision driven by the need to reduce financial losses, theft, and commercial indiscipline in the electricity sector. This policy was supported by resolutions from Chief Ministers' Conferences, expert opinions, and statutory reforms including the Delhi Electricity Reform Act, 2000 and the Electricity Act, 2003.

The Court noted the technical superiority of electronic meters in terms of accuracy, durability, tamper resistance, and compliance with BIS standards. It accepted the evidence from the counter affidavits and reports from BIS, CPRI, and DERC, which confirmed the correctness and proper functioning of the electronic meters installed in the petitioner’s premises.

The Court emphasized that the licensee, as successor to Delhi Vidyut Board, inherited statutory powers under various legislations and conditions of supply, authorizing it to determine meter specifications and replace meters as necessary. It relied on Section 26(1) and 26(7) of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910, which empower the licensee to install correct meters and to alter meters.

The Court rejected the appellant’s contention of absence of power to replace meters, holding that the licensee’s choice of a “correct meter” is not subject to the consumer’s preference but guided by technological advancements and regulatory standards. It noted the regulatory directives mandating installation of electronic meters for loads exceeding 10 kW.

The Court also addressed the argument regarding a supposed legal vacuum due to non-framing of regulations under Sections 53 and 55 of the Electricity Act, 2003, holding that the old legal regime continued to operate until such regulations were framed, and that the licensee’s powers were not suspended.

Regarding consumer grievance redressal, the Court pointed out the existence of statutory forums and ombudsman under the Indian Electricity Act, 2003, which provide alternative remedies and interim reliefs, thus discouraging writ petitions on such matters.

Finally, the Court recognized the importance of embracing technological progress and refused to interfere with the policy and technical decisions of the electricity authorities, especially where supported by expert certification and regulatory compliance.

Holding and Implications

The writ appeal is dismissed.

The Court upheld the legality and validity of the respondent licensee’s replacement of the petitioner’s electro-mechanical meter with an electronic meter. It confirmed the licensee’s statutory authority to determine and install correct meters, consistent with technological and regulatory developments. The decision reinforces the principle that electricity distribution licensees have the power and duty to upgrade metering infrastructure in pursuit of accurate measurement, theft prevention, and efficient distribution. It also clarifies that consumers have statutory alternative remedies for grievances, limiting the scope for writ petitions in such cases. No new precedent was created beyond affirming existing statutory and regulatory frameworks and the acceptance of technological advancement in metering.

    Suresh Jindal v. Bses Rajdhani Power Ltd. & Ors.

    Markandeya Katju, C.J— This writ appeal has been filed against the impugned judgment of the learned Single Judge dated 14.12.2005

    2. Heard learned Counsel for the parties and perused the record.

    3. The facts have been set out in detail in the impugned judgment of the learned Single Judge and hence we are not repeating the same except where necessary.

    4. The prayer in the writ petition was for declaring the acts of the respondents as illegal and mala fide in replacing the correct and working meter of the petitioner by another meter in respect of electricity connection installed for 134, 1st Floor, Sunder Nagar, New Delhi and for quashing the meter testing report dated 3.3.2005 in respect of the electricity connection. The petitioner also prayed for a writ of mandamus directing the respondent to refund the excess bill recovered from the petitioner on the basis of the new meter installed in the premises on 26.4.2003

    5. The petitioner is the registered consumer in respect of electricity connection bearing K. No. 2540F320018 installed in the aforesaid premises 134, 1st Floor, Sunder Nagar, New Delhi, with the sanctioned load of 15 kw.

    6. It is alleged in paragraph 3 of the writ petition that on 26.4.2003 the agents of the respondent had replaced the existing electro-mechanical meter and had installed a new electronic meter. The copy of the meter report is Annexure P1 to the writ petition.

    7. It is alleged in paragraph 4 of the writ petition that the meter installed in the premises of the petitioner was intact and in good order and was recording the consumption as per Rule 57 of the Electricity Supply Rules, 1956 and there was no error in the same.

    8. It is alleged that soon after the installation of the new meter, the petitioner had started receiving inflated reading and bills. The petitioner made a representation on 31.8.2004 against it stating therein that the electronic meter installed in the premises was not recording the correct consumption and he had been excessively charged. He received a reply to the said representation on 25.9.2004 asking him to deposit the meter testing charges vide Annexure P2 to the writ petition. However, the petitioner was forced to make the payment of the bill.

    9. A counter affidavit was filed by the Government of NCT of Delhi and we have perused the same.

    10. Before dealing with the allegation in the petition and the counter affidavit, in our opinion it is necessary to state certain facts.

    11. It appears that a policy decision was taken to replace the old electromechanical meters by more reliable electronic meters as part of the overall power sector reforms pursuant to the resolutions passed by the Chief Ministers' Conferences of 1996 and 2001 to tackle the financial crises emerging from annual losses in electricity supply of around Rs. 30,000 crores, of which the predominant part was due to theft of electricity and commercial losses. The decision to instal electronic meters was because they have longer life and are less susceptible to human intervention by theft or tampering, are more accurate, and have inbuilt safeguards to ensure proper recording of electricity consumption. This decision was consistent with the trend and expert-opinion in India and internationally, and since 1990s electronic meters have been in vogue in the Indian Electricity industry and in Delhi since the days of Delhi Vidyut Board. Old electro-mechanical meters are progressively being replaced by the more reliable and superior electronic meters.

    12. The policy decision to replace electro-mechanical meters with electronic meters was based on global metering standards adopted by the Bureau of Indian Standards (BIS) and was endorsed by the Technical Committee of BIS and field survey of electronic meters in Delhi undertaken by BIS, and also by the Accelerating Power Development and Reforms Programme (APDRP) Committee of the Ministry of Power, Union Government. The Test Report of the meters submitted by DERC was certified by representative of BIS and the Central Power Research Institute of Ministry of Power (CPRI).

    13. It is stated in the counter affidavit of the Government of NCT of Delhi that with the enactment of Delhi Electricity Reform Act, 2000 (DERA), the Government of NCT of Delhi gave shape to the process of the Power Sector Reform in Delhi. DERA provides for setting up a Regulatory Commission for restructuring of the electricity industry, increasing avenues for participation of private sector in the electricity industry, and generally for taking measures conducive to the development and management of the electricity industry in an efficient, commercial, economic and competitive manner in Delhi.

    14. After the enactment of the DERA, the Government of NCT of Delhi notified the Delhi Electricity Reforms Transfer Scheme Rules, 2001. In terms of Sections 14, 15(1) and 15(2) of DERA read with Rules 3 and 4 of the Transfer Scheme, the Government created various successor companies of the erstwhile Delhi Vidyut Board. Delhi Vidyut Board was divided into seven companies, one Holding Company, two Generation companies and one Transmission Company and three Distribution companies. Consequently, three private distribution companies (DISCOMS) were formed, including the respondent, BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd. (BRPL).

    15. The Electricity Act, 2003 came into effect from 10.6.2003 Under the provisions of this Act, the State Electricity Regulatory Commission grants licences for distribution of electricity. It is the duty of the licensee to develop and maintain efficient, coordinate and economical distribution system in his area of supply and to supply electricity in accordance with the provisions of the Act. Under Section 57(i) of the Electricity Act, 2003, the Regulatory Commission can specify standards of performance of a licensee.

    16. In paragraph 5 of the counter affidavit filed by the Government of NCT, Delhi, it is stated that as per Section 55 of the Electricity Act, 2003, which deals with the issue of meters, detailed Regulations are to be made by Central Electricity Authority, and the issues relating to meters and their testing are to be governed in accordance with the Indian Electricity Rules, 1956, which have been saved by Section 185(2)(c) of the Electricity Act, 2003. As per Section 20 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 read with Rule 57 of the Indian Electricity Rules, 1956, it is the responsibility of the licensee to examine, test and regulate the meters. A true copy of Rule 57 of the Indian Electricity Rules, 1956 is Annexure R4 to the counter affidavit.

    17. It may be mentioned that the BRPL is a successor distribution company of the erstwhile Delhi Vidyut Board (DVB) in terms of the statutory Transfer Scheme issued by Government of NCT of Delhi vide Part V of the Delhi Electricity Reforms Act, 2000. BRPL inherited the rights, functions, powers, duties of the DVB in respect of distribution of electricity in its area under the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 and the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948. These include the right to enter any premises to inspect, test, repair or alter supply lines, meters, etc. vide Section 20 of the Indian Electricity Act, as interpreted by the Supreme Court in Belwal Spinning Mills Ltd. v. U.P State Electricity Board, (1997) 6 SCC 740 (vide paragraph 37) read with Condition 25 of the Licence. The right to determine specifications of the meters is contained in Condition 22(b) of the DESU/DVB Condition of Supply, which continues to apply to-date read with Regulation 17(ii) of the Regulation made under DERA. The consumer has to get an appropriate meter installed that conforms to the requisite specifications of the licensee in terms of Regulation 17(ii) of DERC's Metering and Billing Regulations, 2002 read with Condition 22(b) of the Conditions of Supply. The specifications requiring electronic meters were put in place, forwarded to DERC and displayed on website and offices of BRPL.

    18. A counter affidavit has also been filed by ‘BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd.’ It has been stated in paragraph 2 of the said counter affidavit filed by the BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd. that the rampant financial crisis and commercial indiscipline in the sector led to the enactment of the Electricity Act, 2003 in the wake of (a) a bail out package costing the public exchequer over Rs. 45,000/- crores of securitisation of past dues owed by various SEBs and utilities to Central Public Sector Undertakings, and (b) an admitted annual loss levels exceeding Rs. 25,000/- crores. The fundamental objectives and elements of the Electricity Act, 2003 have been set out in paragraphs 2 and 3 of the counter affidavit.

    19. Section 55 of the Electricity Act mandates that a licensee shall not supply electricity after June, 2005 except by use of ‘correct meters’. The purpose of installing an electronic meter is to ensure that the licensee is able to record accurately the energy consumed by all consumers. After all, the licensee is only distributing electricity that it purchases in bulk, and the consumers must pay for what they are actually consuming. If the licensees are prevented from replacing old/inaccurate meters, the same will perpetuate disparity and inequality inter se between consumers having accurate/electronic meters and those having old/inaccurate/electro-mechanical meters.

    20. In paragraph 5 of the counter affidavit, it is stated that the respondent No. 1 stepped into the shoes of the erstwhile Delhi Vidyut Board, and it inherited a system where distribution losses were exorbitant. On July 1, 2002, when the distribution business was inherited by the respondent No. 1, it did not receive any meter register or any fixed assets register from the erstwhile Delhi Vidyut Board. One of the principal reasons for the high level of distribution losses was that the energy consumption was not being accurately measured, billed for and recovered. This was particularly so since the existing meters were electro-mechanical which are neither as accurate nor as tamper-proof as electronic meters. Full details about the advantages of electronic meters have been set out in paragraph 9 of the counter affidavit of the respondent No. 1, and hence we are not repeating the same. It is stated in the counter affidavit that a significant number of old electro-mechanical meters have no meter terminal covers, and as such the proper sealing of the present electro-mechanical meters cannot be ensured. As a licensee, the respondent No. 1 is obliged to seal the meters in accordance with the Delhi Electricity Regulatory Commission (Performance Standards—Metering and Billings) Regulations, 2002. However, as the terminal covers are open, it is not possible for the licensee to seal them effectively.

    21. It is stated in paragraph 6 of the counter affidavit that it is only through accurate metering that a licensee can correctly record the actual consumption of electricity. Use of electronic meters is more accurate and tamper-proof than electro-mechanical meters. For this and other reasons, BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd. initiated replacement of electro-mechanical meters by electronic meters. The electronic meters have an optical port based meter reading that reduces human intervention in recording energy consumption.

    22. In paragraph 7 of the counter affidavit, it is stated, that the respondent No. 1 recovers the tariff per unit of electricity as approved by DERC. The accuracy and reliability of the meters hence is fundamental to an efficient distribution operation. The purpose behind replacing old electro-mechanical meters with electronic meters is only to ensure that energy consumed is accurately recorded, and each consumer pays for what he actually consumes. The DERC order on Annual Revenue Requirement for the financial year 2003-2004 stipulated that, where the sanctioned load exceeds 10 K W, the licensee should instal electronic meters in their place in a time-bound manner. It is keeping these fundamental considerations in mind that BRPL commenced installation of electronic meters, and in doing so, it only gave effect to the directions of the DERC.

    23. On the facts of the case we find no merit in this appeal, nor in the writ petition. It is well known that scientific and technological advancements are taking place all over the world in every sector including the electricity sector. Hence legal proceedings cannot and should not stop this march of technology. The law must respond to the technological advancements and must develop in consonance with technology. All industrial consumers with sanction load above 10 kw, have been provided with electronic meters and it is alleged that no complaint has been received regarding the same. The electronic meters have been designed with inbuilt anti-tamper features, whereas such features are not available in electro-mechanical meters. Further, the obligation for accurate metering and billing, warrants replacement” of old/inaccurate/electro-mechanical meters even below 10 kw load.

    24. The advantages of electronic meters over electro-mechanical meters are set out in paragraph 9 of the counter affidavit of the respondent No. 1, and we are not repeating the same and they may be looked into.

    25. Since this Court does not consist of technical experts, we see no reason to disbelieve the advantages/features of the electronic meters as mentioned in paragraph 9 of the counter-affidavit and we accept the same. As stated therein, electronic meters are much more accurate than mechanical meters. They have no moving parts and have negligible effect of ageing. On the other hand, electromechanical meters have disc-revolution and gear-mechanism for recording of energy and these gears wear off with the passage of time and tend to slow down the meters.

    26. It is stated in paragraph 9(c) of the counter affidavit that the electromechanical meters in use in Delhi need replacement because a large number of electro-mechanical meters, installed in the area of the Licensee, are more than 12 years old, and are sticky/stopped or tampered. As such, they do not record the actual consumption. Several meters have suffered substantial wear and tear due to ageing and environmental factors. Most of the electro-mechanical meters do not have meter terminal covers. As such, the proper sealing of these electro-mechanical meters cannot be ensured, by the Licensee, which is a violation of the requirement of sealing of meters as stipulated in Regulation 17 of the M & B Regulations. Unsealed meters are prone to theft of electricity. In the absence of seals, unscrupulous people can take undue advantage by not allowing the meter to register the actual consumption, which is unfair to the honest paying consumers. The electromechanical meters are easy to tamper with. If these meters are tilted, wilfully or otherwise, then they have a tendency to record lower than the actual energy consumption.

    27. Suffice it to say that sufficient details has been given in paragraph 9 of the counter affidavit to show the great superiority of the electronic meter. Hence, we cannot ignore the same. This is the age of science and technology, and this Court should not obstruct these developments.

    28. Moreover, if the consumer has any grievance, he can approach the Foum under Section 42(5) and thereafter the ombudsman under Section 42(6) of the Indian Electricity Act, 2003, which have been set up. In Ram Kishan v. NDPL, LPA 746/2004, decided on 30.11.2005 a Division Bench of this Court has held that if a consumer of electricity has any grievance against his bill he has an alternative remedy to approach the Forum constituted under Section 42(5), and if he has a grievance against the order of the Forum he has a second alternative remedy under Section 42(6) to approach the ombudsman. It was held in that decision that both these authorities have powers to pass interim orders pending their final decisions. Both these authorities have been constituted, and hence a writ petition should not ordinarily be entertained. Straightaway, regarding grievances about electricity bills.

    29. To help the consumers certain information is given in each bill as stated paragraph 17 of the counter affidavit. In paragraph 18 it is stated that billing software of the Discoms is thoroughly checked, as there are internal checks and balances. Various initiatives have been undertaken to streamline consumer billing system as stated therein.

    30. Additionally, to bring about further improvements in the overall billing system, the respondent No. 1 has engaged an international consultancy firm, Accenture, to audit their billing.

    31. The Commission has engaged the service of the Standarisation Testing and Quality Certification division of the Department of Information Technology, Government of India for auditing billing software of all three Discoms starting with BRPL vide its letter dated 25.8.2005 The performance and billing standards have been evolved that are under revision. The Commission sought comments from public and stakeholders through a public notice that apeared in a leading newspaper on May 22, 2004. The respondent No. 1 submitted its response to the Commission on June 15, 2004 and the Commission is in the process of finalizing these regulations. In paragraph 22 it is stated that the complaints of the consumer reading any one demanding illegal gratification is taken very seriously, In fact, there are brochures and advertisements that have been printed out giving helpline numbers for the consumers to report such instances.

    32. In paragraph 23 of the counter affidavit, it is stated that pursuant to the orders of the High Court dated August 10, 2005, the CPRI officials visited the premises of the petitioner and conducted an accuracy test of the electronic meter. The test report revealed that the meter is functioning properly and the percentage of error was only 0.01 % which is a negligible error and well within the permissible limits of error as laid out in Rule 57(i) of the Indian Electricity Rules, 1956. True copy of the report is Annexure R9 to the counter affidavit.

    33. After the accuracy test the consumer wanted to know as to why his recorded consumption was more. In response, the respondent No. 1 decided to study the parameters of the load and time for which the loads were run at the premises. The various parameters being downloaded through the Common Meter Reading Instrument (CMRI). The Advocate for the petitioner wanted another test to be carried out on lower loads. For the satisfaction of the petitioner, this was agreed to. During this parallel activity, the optical scanner user for count of pulses got disturbed which resulted in an erroneous reading of +3.86 during the accuracy check. This discrepancy was brought to the knowledge of the Advocate of the petitioner by the officials of the CPRI. The petitioner's Advocate wanted the same test to be done by another CPRI team using a different instrument. The respondents agreed to him and have been trying to get in touch with the petitioner with a view to finalise the date for the test. A letter was addressed to the petitioner in this regard but the response of the petitioner is still awaited.

    34. Subsequently, an affidavit was filed by one Shri Rakesh Aggarwal, Member of the Executive Committee of the respondent No. 1. At the relevant time, he was serving as Chief Executive Officer of BSES. He has stated in paragraph 4 of his affidavit that he has read the affidavit of the Chief Executive Officer and affirmed that they are correct.

    35. The argument of the learned Counsel for the appellant is that there was no power in the respondent No. 1 to change the electro-mechanical meter to electronic meter. We do not agree with this submission.

    36. In this connection, we may refer Section 26(1) of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910, where it is stated that—

    “in the absence of an agreement to the contrary, the amount of energy supplied to a consumer or the electrical quantity contained in the supply shall be ascertained by means of a correct meter, and the licensee shall, if required by the consumer, cause the consumer to be supplied with such a meter.”

    37. The words “correct meter” in Section 26(1) are significant. As noted in paragraph 9 of the counter affidavit of respondent No. 1, electro-mechanical meters have several defects, details of which have been given in paragraph 9, whereas the electronic meter is much more accurate. When the authorities prefer the electronic meter for its accurate reading, surely it is not for this Court to sit in appeal over the decision of the authorities, particularly when the opinion of the authority is based on modern advances in technology. It is not for the petitioner/appellant himself to decide what should be the correct meter.

    38. It may be mentioned that Section 63(3) of the DERA, 2000 clearly continues the provisions of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 and the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948, save insofar as they are not inconsistent with the provisions of DERA, subject to certain modifications and reservations.

    39. Section 26(7) of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 also empowers the licensee to place a meter which will ascertain the amount of energy supplied to the consumer.

    40. In Belwal Spinning Mills Ltd. v. U.P State Electricity Board (supra), (vide paragraph 37) the Supreme Court observed:

    “7/76 Licensee, therefore, cannot only enter in the premises of the consumer for inspecting, testing, etc., but the licensee can also alter the meter whenever such alternative is needed.”

    41. In our opinion, the powers under Sections 26(1) and 26(7) of the Electricity Act, 1910 do not depend on the adjudication of the correctness of the meter.

    42. A licensee is authorised under Section 26(7) to place in addition to any meter installed at the premises of a consumer, other meter or apparatus as the licensee deems fit for the purpose of ascertaining or regulating the amount of energy supplied to the consumer. Such power does not depend on the existence of any dispute as to the correctness of the meter installed, as observed by the Supreme Court in the above decision.

    43. It may be noted that APDRP required information technology and computer aided tools for revenue increase. Paragraph 13 specifically noted that commercial losses have to be recovered for metering, meter reading, billing collection and outage reduction. Electronic meters had entered in the territory of India in 1992.

    44. Paragraph 9 of the APDRP states that it is switching over to the electronic meter.

    45. Apart from the above, Regulations 17(i) and 17(ii) of the Delhi Electricity Regulatory Commission (Performance Standards—Metering and Billing) Regulations, 2002 permits installation of an accurate meter. Regulation 17(ii) states as under:

    “(ii) In case of new connection/replacement of meter, the consumer, in accordance with Section 26 of the Electricity Act, may himself procure the meter either from the vendors certified by the licensee, or conforming to licensee's technical specifications. The licensee shall calibrate such meter at consumer's cost and seal the meter. Alternatively, consumer may choose to pay the full cost of the meter provided by the licensee. No meter rent shall be chargeable in such cases.”

    46. Thus, under Regulation 17(ii), the meter must be of the licensee's specification, and not the consumer's specification.

    47. The learned Single Judge has referred to the judgment in Peenya Industries Association v. Karnataka State Electricity, AIR 1998 Karnataka 369, which has rejected the contention of the petitioner that the Board does not have power to replace the meter once provided to the consumer by a more sophisticated equipment than what was installed earlier. We agree with the view taken therein.

    48. Apart from that, in June, 2003, the Delhi Electricity Regulatory Commission issued a directive (called the “Order on Annual Revenue Requirement for July, 2002 to March, 2003 and financial year 2003-2004 and determination of retail supply tariffs for BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd.” Similar orders were issued for the other two distribution companies in the National Capital Territory of Delhi. In paragraph 7.2.5 of the said order, dealing with metering it was noted by the Commission that metering is another area of concern. In view of high level of AT&C losses in the Discoms areas, the order noted that 3 phase LT meters were proposed to be replaced by electronic meters by December, 2003. By paragraph 4.9.2.14 of the said order, the commission directed the petitioner to complete installation of electronic meters for all consumers, except those up to 10 kw. The respondent No. 1 was, therefore, under an obligation under the aforesaid directive of the Delhi Electricity Regulatory Commission to change over to electronic meters where the supply was over 10 kw.

    49. In our opinion, the shifting over to electronic meters and the power with the licensee to opt for electronic meter is not violative of the law. BSES Rajdhani Power Ltd. has to conform to the standardization which under the BIS Standards are statutorily notified under the BIS Act, 1986. These circumscribe the power of the licensee to opt for a particular electronic meter. The respondent has alleged that the meters procured by it from the vendors conform to ISI certification.

    50. Thus, the power to replace the existing meter by the electronic meter is in accordance with law for the following reasons:

    (a) This power is specifically contained in Section 20 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 as interpreted by the Supreme Court in Belwal Spinning Mills case (supra).

    (b) It is also contained in Regulation 17(ii) of the DERC (Performance Standards—Metering and Billing) Regulations, 2002.

    (c) It is in accordance with Tariff Order issued by DERC for the period July, 2002 to March, 2004 including direction to complete installation of electronic meters for all consumers above 10 kw by 31.3.2004 The petitioner has, admittedly, load of 15 kw.

    (d) The power of BRPL to determine specification and type of meter to be installed arises out of Section 21 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1948 and Section 63 of the DERA.

    (e) This power also arises out of DESU/DVB Conditions of Supply, which continue to hold field in terms of Sections 63(2) and 63(3) of the DERA, 2000 and Sections 185(2)(a) and (5) of the Electricity Act, 2003, read with Licence Condition 23.1, and Condition 22(b) vests the power in the licensee to determine meter-specifications. Condition 23 casts an obligation on the consumer to ‘adhere to the specifications’ and to keep the meter correct.

    51. It may be mentioned that the binding and statutory nature of the Conditions of Supply has been upheld by the Supreme Court in Punjab State Electricity v. Bassi Cold Storage, 1994 Supp (2) SCC 125, Bihar State Electricity Board v. Parmeshwar, (1996) 4 SCC 686 (vide paragraph 16) and Hyderabad Vanaspati Ltd. v. A.P State Electricity Board, (1998) 4 SCC 470 : AIR 1998 SC 1715 (paragraph 22), etc.

    52. The continued operation of the Conditions has also been upheld by this Court in several decisions such as, Gulab Rai v. MCD, 42 (1990) DLT 121 (DB); MCD v. H.D Shourie, 53 (1994) DLT 1 (DB); Satish Sharma v. DVB, 2002 (64) DRJ 666; Haryana Ice Factory v. MCD, AIR 1986 Delhi 78, etc.

    53. It may also be mentioned that the Licence Condition 25.1 vests power in the licensee to take appropriate action for—

    (a) metering at the point of supply;

    (b) revenue realization;

    (c) prevention of meter tampering; and

    (d) prevention of unauthorised use of electricity.

    54. It may be mentioned that the Discoms purchase the electricity from the transmission companies and the electricity is then distributed to the consumers. The electricity so purchased is thus the property of the Discoms such as BRPL, and hence BRPL has a right to prevent its theft and unauthorised use. One way of doing the same is by providing the anti-theft features in the meters being installed by the Discoms. Hence BRPL has a right to provide specifications of the meters, which are installed at the premises of the consumers to protect the electricity from being stolen or being used unauthorisedly.

    55. It is further on record that independent expert agencies like DERC, BIS and CPRI undertook surveys and audit of the electronic meters being installed in Delhi by BRPL at various stages, viz. (a) the meter manufacturers, who supply the meters to BRPL in Delhi have obtained and maintained the licence issued by BIS permitting them to manufacture such meters and mark them as complaint with BIS specification. BIS undertakes audit of the manufacturing facilities and processes, random sample test and batch testing of the meters manufactured pursuant to such licence; (b) all electronic meters installed by BRPL in Delhi bear the ISI/BIS mark, (c) DERC undertook a compaign of verifying complaints against electronic meters involving officials of CPRI and BIS and have found the meters installed in Delhi as proper; (d) in September, 2005, after conducting an extensive field survey of meters installed in Delhi, BIS has confirmed that the electronic meters are as per BIS specifications and proper. In addition, being the expert technical body requested by the Ministry of Power and DERC, it also gave its findings about the basic reasons for metering problems in Delhi as related to wiring defects, changed consumption and loads patterns and other consumer related issues.

    56. The learned Single Judge in paragraph 73 of his impugned judgment described in detail the various features showing the superiority of the electronic meters, which are as follows:

    S.No Item Electronic Meters Conventional Electromechanical meters 1. Life Sustainable accuracy life-over 10.15 years Limited life 2. Accuracy Class 0.5 Class-2 3. Calibration One time factory calibrated Requires calibration in SEB's Labs 4. Current range Long Range: 400% to 800% of basic Current Limited Range 400% generally 5. Voltage Range (-) 40% to (+) 150% 75% to 110% of rated voltage 6. Wear & tear No wear & tear, solid state technology Wear & tear, meter becomes slow with time 7. Hanging of meter Measures accurately in any weather even when placed flat Accuracy is affected with change in angle of repose 8. Stability Highly stable no drift over a long time Drifts with time 9. Shock vibration Being solid state technology immune to shock and vibration Affected by vibrations 10. Protection Fully protected in case of wrong connection Gets damaged with wrong connections 11. Tampered Measures accurately in various tampered conditions—Reverse Tamper—Earth tamper—Immune to DC influenced disturbed phase sequence Meters either do not record in tamper condition even start running reverse direction 12. Technology Latest digital technology/surface mount technology Traditional Ferrari type meters 13. Testing & service cost Saves lot of cost in terms of manpower at SEB's labs and replacement cost Service costs are large 14. Starting current Records Energy even below 0.4% of 1 Starts at comparatively much higher current 15. Power loss in voltage circuit is continous Loss in voltage circuit of electronic meter is low. Loss in voltage circuit of conventional meters is high.

    57. No doubt, the licence was granted by the Delhi Electricity Regulatory Commission on 11.3.2004 However, the respondent had applied for the licence under Rule 10(2) of the Delhi Electricity Reforms (Transfer Scheme) Rules, 2001 within 60 days of 1.7.2002 which was the notified date of transfer. Hence the respondents were duly licensed to supply electronic meters in the area of their distribution and was vested with the powers of the licensee under the Indian Electricity Act, 1910, Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948, and the rules framed thereunder. The powers under Section 26 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 and Section 49 of the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948 were available with the respondent No. 1 as also the power under the conditions of supply which were notified when Delhi Vidyut Board was in existence.

    58. As pointed in paragraph 78 of the impugned judgment, in certain areas of Delhi extent of theft of electricity was having alarming proportions of upto 30 to 35%. Cases arose where while conducting checks at the premises of consumers even under police protection, the enforcement team had to retreat due to lawlessness created by the residents of certain localities where ultimately huge theft of electricity was found.

    59. The learned Counsel for the appellant relied on Section 55(1) of the Electricity Act, 2003, which stated:

    “(1) No licensee shall supply electricity, after the expiry of two years from the appointed date, except through installation of a correct meter in accordance with the regulations to be made in this behalf by the authority.”

    60. The learned Counsel has submitted that the regulations have not yet been framed by the authority.

    61. Be that as it may, we are of the opinion that until the regulations are framed under Section 55(1), the old regime continues and the licensee can insist on having a correct meter. The Delhi Electricity Reforms Act, 2000 as well as the Indian Electricity Act, 1910 and the Electricity (Supply) Act, 1948 continue to be in force except where the same are inconsistent with the provisions of the Electricity Act, 2003. In our opinion, there is no inconsistency.

    62. The submission of the learned Counsel for the appellant that there is a legal vacuum on account of non-framing of Regulations under Sections 53 and 55 of the Indian Electricity Act, 2003, has no merits. In our opinion, framing of Regulations under Sections 53 and 55 is not a condition precedent to a Discom's function and power to determine what is a correct meter and of changing meters. No doubt, once regulations have been framed the BRPL has to comply with the same. The BRPL entered into the shoes of the erstwhile DVB in pursuance to a statutory scheme promulgated under the provisions of DERA. BRPL as such had all the power with regard to the metering specifications, power to replace meters, etc. In addition, BRPL has the power to instal correct meter under Sections 20, 21, 22-24 and 26 of the Indian Electricity Act, 1910, Sections 14 to 16, 60 and 63 of DERA, Rule 10(2) of the Transfer Scheme, Sections 26 and 49 of the Electricity (Supply), 1948, Condition 22 and 23 of DRSU, Condition of Supply and Sections 14, 55, 163 and 185 of the Electricity Act, 2003.

    63. Hence in our opinion, there is no legal vacuum. The learned Counsel for the respondent has relied on the judgments of the Supreme Court in The Mysore State Road Transport Corporation v. Gopinath Gundachar Char, AIR 1968 SC 464 (vide paragraph 3) and UPSEB v. City Board Mussoorie, (1985) 2 SCC 16 : AIR 1985 SC 883 (at paras 7 and 9), and we agree that these decisions apply to the facts of this case.

    64. There is no force in this appeal, and hence it is dismissed.

    Appeal dismissed.
    Use AI to get other relevant cases.

    Comments

    Suresh Jindal v. Bses Rajdhani Power Ltd. & Ors.
    (Feb 20, 2006)